Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to not want to subsidise friends’ children?

201 replies

MeanAsBeans · 16/02/2024 14:09

A friend seems to think that only adults count per head when paying in restaurants. Her 2 are soon to be 9 and 11 and eat more than I do from the adult menu. AIBU to think that the split doesn’t only include adults?

And while we’re on the subject as Spring is getting closer we’ve been discussing trips/outings. A friend of a friend has joined us a few times and more than once has expected others to cover admission fees for her children because “They’re only children”

I don’t have children yet and I’m happy to buy the odd treat for kids l, an ice cream or sweets or similar but I draw the line at regularly covering costs.

AIBU?

OP posts:
Abeona · 17/02/2024 15:27

WomanOfSteel · 17/02/2024 07:43

I have a friend who is in a similar situation to you. I asked her what would happen if you just said no. She just looked at me like I was daft. 😂

I know I sound like a sop but it's genuinely difficult to negotiate and I feel for your friend. The first time one of these 20-somethings landed at Heathrow and needed collecting and orientating I wasn't long back from New Zealand where I'd met her and stayed for three days with her parents in their large house with swimming pool. So initially I thought it was a fair exchange — until it turned out that she expected to spend at least a fortnight with me and didn't plan to spend any money if she could help it. Which I sort of understood because when I was 21 and penny-pinching the senior members of the family were kind to me and would pick up the tab if we had a meal out or treat me to the theatre or a day trip. But I'd never have expected to land on them for a fortnight.

So she stayed (three weeks in the end), I took her out and about, we went to Westminster Abbey and the Tower of London and Buckingham Palace and Hampton Court (kerrching, kerrching!) and a West End show because where she lives in New Zealand she doesn't get the opportunity. And then I took her to National Trust places locally and sent her for a couple of days on the train to stay with a brilliant friend in Edinburgh who knew I was under stress (I had to pick up the cost of the train fare and send my friend money to cover the visitor's costs while she was there because I didn't want my friend ending up out of pocket)... And at the end of it all my bank balance was at least £1000 down, she's posted the pictures and one of her cousins has spotted the opportunity and is in touch to ask if they can come and stay in a few months... It's hard saying no when you've just put yourself out for one of their cousins.

I now lay down much tighter rules. They can stay for a week but no longer. I don't put myself out nearly as much. I'll try and take them out for a day or two to somewhere they'll enjoy, but I don't do the full tour guide number. I take them to the station (not easily accessible on public transport) and collect them when they get back, but I expect them to be a bit more proactive. Some of them are, some find that the UK is a bit of a culture shock after a small town in New Zealand or Canada.

But my advice to the OP is not to get into the habit of doing any of this because if you do people will expect it. It's really not an honour to be expected to pay for others' children because you don't have your own.

fitzwilliamdarcy · 17/02/2024 14:00

@SweetBirdsong THIS. My friends and family are all “kids only” at Xmas, so I’ve not had a gift in years and it costs me a fortune to buy for all of theirs.

It’s the same with adult celebrations - get married and have kids and you can get other people to buy you stuff, but remain single and you get nada. Except on your birthday but everyone gets that.

fitzwilliamdarcy · 17/02/2024 13:42

I had a friend who pulled this once - when I said “no, let’s just pay for what we ate” she did a tinkly little laugh and said, “oh I thought we’d be ok to split as you have more money than me.”

I was puzzled because she was a SAHM with a wealthy husband and I was renting at the time so money was pretty tight each month, and I said “what do you mean I do?”

She gestured to her children with an huge smile and said “well you don’t have any of these!”

Oddly enough we stopped seeing each other as much after that.

YANBU and people will do this shit. Like couples buying one round between them but everyone else having to buy them a drink each. You have to get good at saying no.

NotAgainWilson · 17/02/2024 13:19

Shinyandnew1 · 17/02/2024 13:03

then spend the whole time there trying to ignore bitchy comments about how tight I am not to agree to spend £100 per child on gifts for my siblings’ kids!

Seriously?!

Is that what your siblings spend on each other’s kids?!

Oh no, they spend more, the £100 was their sweet consideration to make it “affordable to me” without disadvantaging their kids… too much 🤯

Shinyandnew1 · 17/02/2024 13:03

then spend the whole time there trying to ignore bitchy comments about how tight I am not to agree to spend £100 per child on gifts for my siblings’ kids!

Seriously?!

Is that what your siblings spend on each other’s kids?!

NotAgainWilson · 17/02/2024 12:32

It's like a single woman being expected to buy Christmas gifts for her 3 sisters/3 BILs, and 11 combined nieces and nephews (17 gifts!) But only getting 3 gifts back.

Ah @SweetBirdsong , you would be surprised! That is more common than you imagine and absolutely draining for the single parent.

I guess some people simply assume that if everybody spends the same, things are fair.

(Says the woman who needs to spend a fortune in flights just to see them in Christmas and then spend the whole time there trying to ignore bitchy comments about how tight I am not to agree to spend £100 per child on gifts for my siblings’ kids!

Having said that, they have never asked me to pay for meals at restaurants or the entry fees to attractions).

SweetBirdsong · 17/02/2024 11:31

I can't imagine why anyone would disagree tbh. It's like a single woman being expected to buy Christmas gifts for her 3 sisters/3 BILs, and 11 combined nieces and nephews (17 gifts!) But only getting 3 gifts back.

Life does NOT favour single people/people without children. And to some degree people with very few children - 1 or 2. (Especially if you know people/are related to people with lots of children.)

I had to rein in the gift buying in my extended family about 15 years ago (when mine were mid teens.) My 4 'first' cousins had 14 kids between them! My brother had 2. So SIXTEEN children to buy for. And we only had 2.

I know some might say 'well why are you buying for your cousins children?' and that's a good question, but we just did in our family.

Was OK when it was just buying cousins and there were only 4, but then all their children started to come along! Confused

tl;dr, we put a stop to it when the cousins children started having babies! Just no! A couple of them were a bit sniffy when we said we are only buying gifts for our parents and our children now..., but IDGAF tbh!

kcchiefette · 17/02/2024 08:35

I would never expect others to pay for my child.

Next time it comes to paying, there doesnt even need to be a prior discussion, you just pay for your own and say:

"OK, so here is the money to cover my food and drink."

If they question anything afterwards, you just need to say:
"Sorry, I don't have the means at the moment to pay for your childrens meals."

They are taking advantage of the fact you havent stuck up for yourself yet.

Onelifeonly · 17/02/2024 08:31

The only person I can recall doing this with was my brother who is single with no kids and often came on outings with my children. We'd pay half each - sometimes he'd offer to pay more on the grounds he didn't normally need to pay for children when he went out and had more disposable income. Now we go out just the two of us, we just divide the total bill or pay separately.

Baldieheid · 17/02/2024 08:30

We pretty much always just pay for our own food and drink. I don't drink, and no, I'm not happy to pay for my friend to consume a glass or 2 of wine at £8 a glass whilst I drink tap water by choice.

She wants wine, she pays for it.

Same with kids. You wanted kids, you pay for them.

SpongeBob2022 · 17/02/2024 08:21

I've been out with in laws a few times in the past where weve split it despite us having DS but that's because even adding a kids meal to mine it still doesn't add up to the amount of alcohol they've had per person.

Any other situation I wouldn't expect to split and have never been out with someone who would expect this.

WomanOfSteel · 17/02/2024 07:43

Abeona · 17/02/2024 00:06

I feel your pain, OP. I think there does often seem to be an expectation that if you're single and don't have children you'll get some kind of warm and fuzzy buzz from 'treating' others' children. I was in your position 25 years ago. Now, I have to warn you, I have a grown-up version of the problem.

I have a large extended family, many of them living abroad. All the kids, once they've been to university, come to Europe for a few months and I seem to be expected to put them up for weeks at a time and take them out and about and give the full UK experience. It's cost me thousands. I think the assumption is that as I don't have children I've got money to spare. I don't. So don't be a mug like me, never agree to it if it's suggested.

I have a friend who is in a similar situation to you. I asked her what would happen if you just said no. She just looked at me like I was daft. 😂

chiwwy · 17/02/2024 00:08

MillyMoot · 16/02/2024 21:27

My DB and SIL have form for this, constantly. I especially resent it because their DC are quite overweight so in addition to a doormat I feel like I'm enabling some negative behaviours and damaging them for life. But how do you say "your children don't belong at buffets"?

Just ask for a separate bill for yourself/your family!

Abeona · 17/02/2024 00:06

MeanAsBeans · 16/02/2024 14:09

A friend seems to think that only adults count per head when paying in restaurants. Her 2 are soon to be 9 and 11 and eat more than I do from the adult menu. AIBU to think that the split doesn’t only include adults?

And while we’re on the subject as Spring is getting closer we’ve been discussing trips/outings. A friend of a friend has joined us a few times and more than once has expected others to cover admission fees for her children because “They’re only children”

I don’t have children yet and I’m happy to buy the odd treat for kids l, an ice cream or sweets or similar but I draw the line at regularly covering costs.

AIBU?

I feel your pain, OP. I think there does often seem to be an expectation that if you're single and don't have children you'll get some kind of warm and fuzzy buzz from 'treating' others' children. I was in your position 25 years ago. Now, I have to warn you, I have a grown-up version of the problem.

I have a large extended family, many of them living abroad. All the kids, once they've been to university, come to Europe for a few months and I seem to be expected to put them up for weeks at a time and take them out and about and give the full UK experience. It's cost me thousands. I think the assumption is that as I don't have children I've got money to spare. I don't. So don't be a mug like me, never agree to it if it's suggested.

NotAgainWilson · 16/02/2024 23:55

WTAF? You may not have children but when you have, you will know what shameless freeloader you are paying for.

NOBODY expects other people to pay for their food or attractions when you are out. Seriously, NOBODY.

Lavenderandbrown · 16/02/2024 23:40

And I wish mnhq would delete
that name also.

jimmyjammy001 · 16/02/2024 23:01

Just don't go with her if she brings her kids, say we can only meet up child free same for days out, I hate it when friends bring they're kids along, it's bloody annoying, completely changes the vibe

Isitreallythough · 16/02/2024 22:47

Yanbu at all

Whoopaday · 16/02/2024 22:46

Thank you for being super quick MNHQ in deleting the above poster 🙂

FatHairyCunt · 16/02/2024 22:37

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

chiwwy · 16/02/2024 22:31

MuchuseasaChocolateTeapot · 16/02/2024 20:15

Madness. If she was a bit squiffy and worked it out wrong that would be one thing but to calculate it and then actively decide that others should subsidise her family blows my mind!

A similar thing happened once with my BIL and his wife. Went out for a meal with them and DH (first time meeting them). Their share of the bill was around £55 and ours £25. I would have happily split the bill in half but SIL took £25 out of her purse and put it in the table, silence ensued. BIL said I think our share was more than that. She quickly replied ‘no it wasn’t’ but after prompting from BIL she parsimoniously slid an extra £5 from her purse, then closed it and put it back in her bag. Other family members were on a table adjacent and when I looked over they were just grinning at us. Then I realised BIL/SIL had form for doing this which is why the others sat separately and wouldn’t split the bill with them. Wish I’d questioned it more at the time but I was genuinely flummoxed!

Why didn’t knobhead family members warn you? The whole family sound crap.

justasmalltownmum · 16/02/2024 22:27

They're can't really be friends like this?

momonpurpose · 16/02/2024 22:22

GeniusLevelJaffaCake · 16/02/2024 14:11

You haven't enabled voting but I think that YANBU. My kids are my responsibility to pay for.

Agreed. She's totally nuts to have the nerve to expect it much less say it. Separate bills or don't go

Saz12 · 16/02/2024 22:13

The absolute only time this is ok is... they eat from cheap kids menu, their parent has tap water, you have expensive wine, so it comes out even.

Otherwise, you pay for your own family group.

IMustDoMoreExercise · 16/02/2024 21:56

MeanAsBeans · 16/02/2024 14:22

*Where are these people in RL?

I can't imagine ever having these kinds of issues

You’re very lucky if you’ve never encountered a freeloader/cheeky fucker. There’s plenty of them out there.

But why are you still friends with them?

Swipe left for the next trending thread