Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask for your ideas about what research needs doing in midwifery?

133 replies

UpUpUpU · 16/02/2024 09:56

Sorry, posting for traffic!

I am a third year student midwife about to embark on a research project but I am struggling to decide on a topic.

As many of you are parents, is there anything in your experiences of maternity care that you think could have been done better or that you wondered why something was done or suggested? Anything you would have wanted more research on?

Any suggestions would be much appreciated.

Thanks in advance.

OP posts:
sleepandcoffee · 16/02/2024 10:30

Oh I have another one - the lack of infomation on how to care for yourself after a c-section .

I wasn't told anything on how to look after the scar and what to expect in the coming months to do with recovery from an operation

UpUpUpU · 16/02/2024 10:29

leafinthewind · 16/02/2024 10:26

As a former academic, please, please, please pick a small research question. The aim here is for you to become a midwife. You won't actually find out anything new, and you shouldn't try.

Pick an interesting question, sure, but pick something which lets you showcase what you can do so you get the best mark you can. Pick something for which the information already exists - secondary data like this is much quicker to use than collecting your own through interviews etc. Look at the last five years of the Maternity Survey. Compare what it shows about Black women (who say that they have good experiences of maternity care) with what we know about maternal and infant deaths (more common in Black women). Write something about why that might be, and then suggest some further research.

For the love of god, just pass your degree. You don't need to do original research.

Thank you, I appreciate this.

I did a lot of research in my former role and plan to carry over my topic into a Masters and PhD so something with scope is what I am looking for.

OP posts:
MidnightPatrol · 16/02/2024 10:27

The huge increase in inductions and the impact that has on birth outcomes.

About a third of women are induced now. If. you are induced it is more likely to result in an instrumental delivery, more likely to end in a c-section etc.

The births are more painful because the body isn't ready. Recovery longer due to the likelihood of intervention.

I was a healthy mother, with a healthy pregnancy that went overdue. I was forced to have an induction which took days and ended up in a very traumatic forceps birth (and months long recovery). No other option was presented to me, and in retrospect I think that I was forced into this awful situation when there wasn't really good reason.

Bushmillsbabe · 16/02/2024 10:27

Whydosomanywomensleepwithsuchlosers · 16/02/2024 10:23

Sodding forceps use. My hospital has 9% forceps delivery- I wonder how many of those women have significant pelvic floor issues.

Midwives seem to have limited knowledge of effective pelvic floor exercises, and only make passing references to it antenatally ( my NCT friend literally didn't know what they are until 8 week PP GP appointment- we had the same midwife). It wasn't until I started going to physio that I learnt I hadn't been doing them properly the while pregnancy. I wonder how much suffering you could alleviate if physios ran training for trainee midwives.

When I was a junior physio 15 years ago we went round every women on postnatal ward and talked to them about pelvic exercises, back care post baby, what activities to encourage and what to avoid, and tgey were given a phone number to call to request an outpatient review with a physio if any continence issues. But this, as with many things, has been cut

UpUpUpU · 16/02/2024 10:27

Bushmillsbabe · 16/02/2024 10:22

I think

  • more research on how to better support mums with SPD to labour more comfortably and with fewer complications

How to encourage better uptake of early antenatal care. I work in paediatrics and there seems to be a correlation between children with complex developmental needs and mums not accessing early antenatal care, not knowing to take folic acid, having a child with a cousin or other relative, so definitely a need for more education

In my early student days I saw terrible treatment of a woman in labour with SPD. The midwife in question no longer practices but I admit I need more knowledge in how to help these women, so this is definitely something I will look into. Thank you.

OP posts:
leafinthewind · 16/02/2024 10:26

As a former academic, please, please, please pick a small research question. The aim here is for you to become a midwife. You won't actually find out anything new, and you shouldn't try.

Pick an interesting question, sure, but pick something which lets you showcase what you can do so you get the best mark you can. Pick something for which the information already exists - secondary data like this is much quicker to use than collecting your own through interviews etc. Look at the last five years of the Maternity Survey. Compare what it shows about Black women (who say that they have good experiences of maternity care) with what we know about maternal and infant deaths (more common in Black women). Write something about why that might be, and then suggest some further research.

For the love of god, just pass your degree. You don't need to do original research.

ViciousCurrentBun · 16/02/2024 10:26

I agree with @PermanentTemporary I hated the maternity ward as there were people everywhere and noisy as anything. I am noise sensitive so my reaction is probably worse than most but some other women agreed it was hard to sleep.

Sparklybutold · 16/02/2024 10:25

Why some midwives lose the ability to actually care - compassion fatigue.

UpUpUpU · 16/02/2024 10:24

angelpie33 · 16/02/2024 10:21

Maybe a bit specific, but I wish there was better research out there for women like me with congenital uterine abnormalities (CUAs) and the best approach in terms of maternity care. It seems like different health boards have very different approaches in terms of offering cervical length scanning and foetal fibronectin testing (or not), offering regular growth scans in the third trimester and whether women with known CUAs should be under consultant care or not.

There is overall a very poor level of understanding about the risks facing women with this condition and the outcomes with different approaches to maternity care.

I like this. We do not have anything much at uni to cover this, other than a lecture on different uterus shapes. I have only come across CUA's in the PN ward so a bit too late to learn. It would be beneficial for me to learn this as well as try and come up with some more clear pathways. Thank you.

OP posts:
sleepandcoffee · 16/02/2024 10:24

@Bushmillsbabe
Having a quick scan of some studies it looks like they are more focused on preventing it getting to a stage where forceps is needed but otherwise it's ventouse/caesarean

Whydosomanywomensleepwithsuchlosers · 16/02/2024 10:23

Sodding forceps use. My hospital has 9% forceps delivery- I wonder how many of those women have significant pelvic floor issues.

Midwives seem to have limited knowledge of effective pelvic floor exercises, and only make passing references to it antenatally ( my NCT friend literally didn't know what they are until 8 week PP GP appointment- we had the same midwife). It wasn't until I started going to physio that I learnt I hadn't been doing them properly the while pregnancy. I wonder how much suffering you could alleviate if physios ran training for trainee midwives.

Bushmillsbabe · 16/02/2024 10:22

I think

  • more research on how to better support mums with SPD to labour more comfortably and with fewer complications

How to encourage better uptake of early antenatal care. I work in paediatrics and there seems to be a correlation between children with complex developmental needs and mums not accessing early antenatal care, not knowing to take folic acid, having a child with a cousin or other relative, so definitely a need for more education

angelpie33 · 16/02/2024 10:21

Maybe a bit specific, but I wish there was better research out there for women like me with congenital uterine abnormalities (CUAs) and the best approach in terms of maternity care. It seems like different health boards have very different approaches in terms of offering cervical length scanning and foetal fibronectin testing (or not), offering regular growth scans in the third trimester and whether women with known CUAs should be under consultant care or not.

There is overall a very poor level of understanding about the risks facing women with this condition and the outcomes with different approaches to maternity care.

UpUpUpU · 16/02/2024 10:21

PermanentTemporary · 16/02/2024 10:19

The impact of 'quiet night' policies on postnatal and children's wards on maternal wellbeing.

When I had ds, the sister and the team on the postnatal ward made it very clear that after 9pm all TVs were switched off, all visitors out, and it was a quiet ward. My sister's experience in a different hospital could not have been more different- groups of visitors, phones and screens going late into the night. Can't be ideal. (Tbf she was the one who went on to bf successfully, I didn't. But she never set foot in that hospital again).

The PN wards in my trust are not conducive to rest and relaxation so I hear you on this one. It would be interesting to see what the effects of time on a PN ward have on maternal mental health. Thank you.

OP posts:
Bellsra · 16/02/2024 10:20

Phineyj · 16/02/2024 10:11

I'd like to see if antenatal care can be improved. Most pregnant women are working - many in professional jobs. The practice of making everyone rock up for the same clinic at the same time and then making the clients hang around for several hours before you see them is really inefficient and stressful. I had to get my classes covered for a whole afternoon each time and was never ever seen till after school had finished!

If GPs can offer timed appointments, why can't midwifery?

In most areas it should be timed appointments but I think the problem is the minimum amount of time an appointment could potentially be completed in is allocated and so clinics inevitably over runs as it only takes a problem to be identified, a procedure to take a little bit longer to complete, a woman to ask a question or feel unwell, a referral that needs making etc which are all common and inevitable in every clinic and before you know it the clinic is running hours late. Staff are inevitably run off their feet and missing breaks etc to try not to keep women waiting any longer than necessary but given limited resources the priority is ensuring everyone gets good clinical care. Is difficult to know how to overcome this without more funding, if people happy to pay the taxes necessary for the equivalent of a private level of convenience but then if it’s a choice between paying that extra tax or having enough of your pay for swimming lessons for your child your likely to not want to pay more tax

PermanentTemporary · 16/02/2024 10:19

The impact of 'quiet night' policies on postnatal and children's wards on maternal wellbeing.

When I had ds, the sister and the team on the postnatal ward made it very clear that after 9pm all TVs were switched off, all visitors out, and it was a quiet ward. My sister's experience in a different hospital could not have been more different- groups of visitors, phones and screens going late into the night. Can't be ideal. (Tbf she was the one who went on to bf successfully, I didn't. But she never set foot in that hospital again).

Bushmillsbabe · 16/02/2024 10:19

sleepandcoffee · 16/02/2024 10:00

The use of forceps in this country , I believe they are no longer used in many countries ( and for good reason !)

Just interested what other options countries use rather than forceps? Both mine were forceps deliveries for different reasons. I was told ventouse wouldn't work due to babies head position, c section was an option but the 5-10 mins it would have taken to get me to theatre and under general anaesthetic could have been the difference between my baby being fine and them being dead or severely disabled due to hypoxia. The 2nd was done without any anaesthetic due to the urgency, was bloody painful but I chose a few minutes of pain over my child having a lifelong disability or worse

Istheworldmadorisitme · 16/02/2024 10:18

I developed intrahepatic cholestasis of pregnancy (ICP) during my second pregnancy and none of the midwifes I encountered seemed to know anything about it. I wonder why that was as the internet knows about it as does the NHS website. There also seems to be very little scientific research on the subject and no solution other than get the baby out as soon as possible.

Kosenrufugirl · 16/02/2024 10:17

UpUpUpU · 16/02/2024 10:05

I completely agree with this. Thank you.

I disagree. I am a midwife working on the labour ward. Forceps is a safe and versatile instrument in experienced hands. I did however raise the question of informed consent at a joint doctors and midwives meeting on our unit some years ago. If the doctors have time to properly consent for a Caesarean in a dire emergency, they have time to consent for an instrumental delivery. I am pleased report that our unit practice has changed and doctors do now take time to explain. This makes a huge difference in an otherwise scary situation. I wouldn't ban forceps, they are often a much better choice than a Caesarean at full dilatation when ventouse isn't possible

CoalCraft · 16/02/2024 10:14

Irritable uterus! My first pregnancy was affected by constant (every 3-5 mins all day, every day) mild Braxton-Hicks contractions from 20-ish weeks. They were dismissed, shrugged at and generally ignored right up until I gave birth at 33 weeks.

Or how about how to recognise labour. Seems a pretty basic one but in my first pregnancy I got to 10 cm dilated with strong urge to push before anyone acknowledged I was in labour, and with my second I was sent home from hospital an hour before baby was born, having been refused an examination, because "you can walk and talk through your contractions; you're days away yet."

(It was kinda satisfying that the same midwife was present for the very-much-not-days-away birth...)

Orangebadger · 16/02/2024 10:12

2 broad things. Post natal care. Currently a very underfunded Cinderella service, I am a HCP and my experience professionally and personally has been very varied with regard to the access of post natal care/ support.

Secondly women from South Asia who have limited English. How can we improve maternity care for these women to reduce the significantly higher risk of complications/ still birth that they have.

UpUpUpU · 16/02/2024 10:12

Mummatron3000 · 16/02/2024 10:10

I had a retained placenta with my 1st pregnancy, had to be removed in theatre w spinal anaesthetic (when I’d managed to give birth without epidural) plus large blood loss. It was traumatic and I believe it contributed to my PND plus struggling to breastfeed. So possibly some research into how having to undergo this type of procedure and/or blood loss affects women postnatally (both mentally and physically) would be good.

Really like this, thank you.

OP posts:
UpUpUpU · 16/02/2024 10:11

Kosenrufugirl · 16/02/2024 10:07

Hi there I am a midwife working on a labour ward. I see so many women putting more than recommended amount of weight in pregnancy going for an emergency Caesarean section. There is plenty of research worldwide that excessive weight gain in pregnancy increases the risk. However in the UK we generally don't talk about BMI or pregnancy weight gain. I would really like to know whether talking to women about optimal weight gain early in pregnancy would be acceptable to them.

thank you. I agree it is a really taboo subject isn't it.

When I was pregnant 4 years ago I put on a lot of weight and I was told it was normal and I was never weighed or spoken to about it. I went from 9 stone pre pregnancy to over 14 after delivery!

In community I do try and push the subject of healthy weight with my women but other than a consultant or anaesthetic review later in pregnancy, nothing much more happens. this is also on the list.

OP posts:
Phineyj · 16/02/2024 10:11

I'd like to see if antenatal care can be improved. Most pregnant women are working - many in professional jobs. The practice of making everyone rock up for the same clinic at the same time and then making the clients hang around for several hours before you see them is really inefficient and stressful. I had to get my classes covered for a whole afternoon each time and was never ever seen till after school had finished!

If GPs can offer timed appointments, why can't midwifery?

Mummatron3000 · 16/02/2024 10:10

I had a retained placenta with my 1st pregnancy, had to be removed in theatre w spinal anaesthetic (when I’d managed to give birth without epidural) plus large blood loss. It was traumatic and I believe it contributed to my PND plus struggling to breastfeed. So possibly some research into how having to undergo this type of procedure and/or blood loss affects women postnatally (both mentally and physically) would be good.