Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask for your ideas about what research needs doing in midwifery?

133 replies

UpUpUpU · 16/02/2024 09:56

Sorry, posting for traffic!

I am a third year student midwife about to embark on a research project but I am struggling to decide on a topic.

As many of you are parents, is there anything in your experiences of maternity care that you think could have been done better or that you wondered why something was done or suggested? Anything you would have wanted more research on?

Any suggestions would be much appreciated.

Thanks in advance.

OP posts:
Bellsra · 16/02/2024 11:10

leafinthewind · 16/02/2024 10:26

As a former academic, please, please, please pick a small research question. The aim here is for you to become a midwife. You won't actually find out anything new, and you shouldn't try.

Pick an interesting question, sure, but pick something which lets you showcase what you can do so you get the best mark you can. Pick something for which the information already exists - secondary data like this is much quicker to use than collecting your own through interviews etc. Look at the last five years of the Maternity Survey. Compare what it shows about Black women (who say that they have good experiences of maternity care) with what we know about maternal and infant deaths (more common in Black women). Write something about why that might be, and then suggest some further research.

For the love of god, just pass your degree. You don't need to do original research.

Agree, and also choose something that you will be able to apply to your practice on a regular basis as a midwife to make a positive difference for women and of course within the scope of the midwife

Phineyj · 16/02/2024 11:09

Wow, advice on back care/lifting and handling. I bet lots and lots of new parents get injuries that way, especially with car seats and lifting in and out of cots (I didn't even know a drop sided cot was a thing till my mum mentioned it).

I actually thought when I was on maternity (after both DH and I injured our backs) that that would be the most cost effective thing the NHS could do, even if it was just a leaflet.

lifeontheup · 16/02/2024 11:09

Also lack of exploration when it comes to pelvic girdle pain. Mine was so severe I couldn't walk. Ended up with crutches but still couldn't cope. I felt totally disabled and it started from 3 months pregnant and became progressively worse. Saw a different person at every appointment and when I was asked the general 'how are you?' Each time I tried to flag the extreme pain but the only support I got was a physio appointment. Which was a fat lot of use when I couldn't do the recommended exercises because of the pain. It got so bad towards the end they thought I had sepsis and I feel my care overall was absolutely dire. I'd love another baby but it was the toughest thing I've ever gone through and I genuinely don't even know what caused it!

OldManSign · 16/02/2024 11:07

Care for disabled women without a doubt.

Just a few examples of what I had to deal with:

  • A complete lack of understanding of my mobility issues with regards to getting up on beds etc. Comments like “oh you’ll be able to walk again when the baby comes, it won’t be for long!” …. No I won’t this is permanent!
  • A complete and utter lack of understanding (and rudeness to boot) from the gestational diabetes midwife regarding my sensory issues around food and mobility restricting exercise (the dietitian was fabulous!)
  • The NICE guidelines state you should have a multi-disciplinary team if you have a long term health condition. I never had that at all.
  • Ignorant comments about the potential impact of vaginal birth on my hip condition from obstetricians which could have caused a less confident woman to attempt an unsafe vaginal delivery.
  • Not a single person suggested any modes of support from social services or even for us to have an exemption from partners not being allowed to stay until a random midwife I happened to speak to heard about my issues and organised it for me (my husband stayed and we had a private room so as not to impact other women).

There’s definitely more but that’s what I can think of off the top of my head. Essentially, I was made to feel like their first ever disabled patient which can’t possibly be true but that was the level of their ignorance.

Rhino94 · 16/02/2024 11:07

UpUpUpU · 16/02/2024 10:08

Thank you for this. In my trust, we are not qualified to diagnose TT but we are able to refer if we see an obvious one. It is definitely something to consider as I carry out NIPE checks and one of the checks is whether there is a TT visible.

This is definitely on my list, thank you.

I second this, we had a very noticeable tounge tie that me and DH both noticed but were told at the hospital that nothing was really done about it these days! Finally got a referral two weeks later and the person that snipped tie was amazed I had been able to feed for so long like that

Bellsra · 16/02/2024 11:05

Bushmillsbabe · 16/02/2024 10:27

When I was a junior physio 15 years ago we went round every women on postnatal ward and talked to them about pelvic exercises, back care post baby, what activities to encourage and what to avoid, and tgey were given a phone number to call to request an outpatient review with a physio if any continence issues. But this, as with many things, has been cut

We used to have a physio visit all postnatal women on the ward and go through everything with them, give them a leaflet and contact details for if they ever had any problems. Physios really are the experts in this. Hopefully they will bring it back with the new focus on pelvic health

whyyy321 · 16/02/2024 11:04

Impact of partners staying or not staying the night after delivery on post natal mental health (of the woman and the partner), perhaps controlling for delivery method. I had a C-section and my husband had to leave for the night before I could move my legs. I couldn't pick my baby up without help (or put them down again if holding them) that whole night (and tbh with C-section recovery, only with significant discomfort after). I feel this affecting bonding and definitely sleep (couldn't put baby down to sleep without help, which usually woke the baby). Was in hospital for a week so wonder if I'd have had a better experience if he (husband) stayed.

lifeontheup · 16/02/2024 11:04

Increase in unnecessary inductions and the trauma they cause! Particularly leading to c-sections.

Slowcomfortablescrew · 16/02/2024 11:04

Improved postnatal care specifically pelvic floor issues. I had a 3rd degree tear and now have a prolaspe. No one checked I was doing pelvic floor exercises properly and it is only after paying to see a private pelvic floor physio I have had any help with this.

Phineyj · 16/02/2024 11:03

@Porridgeislife glad to hear it! The trust in question used to regularly appear in the "worst NHS trusts" so it doesn't surprise me...

Porridgeislife · 16/02/2024 11:03

Also, women’s experiences of postnatal wards and the impact it has on their early motherhood experience.

I went in with zero expectations (they were met at the same level) that I would receive any care or help postnatally but I was also quite lucky that I’d had experience of abdo surgery and knew what to expect. I was also an older mum so able to vocally advocate. Lots of NCT friends had really awful post birth care and you hear about it all the time on Mumsnet.

Every time I walked past the nurse station they were furiously filling out paperwork and it made me sad. Audit trails are important but not at the expense of care.

SlurpSlooChortle · 16/02/2024 11:01

HELLP Syndrome

UpUpUpU · 16/02/2024 10:59

Love51 · 16/02/2024 10:53

This is going beyond the scope of midwifery but it seems that you have an interest in future academic research so I hope you don't mind me sharing. I think it would be beneficial for there to be more research into the impact of surrogacy on the child that is given to the non bio parents to be cared for. Should we expect outcomes similar to birth children or similar to adopted children? It is a big piece of research that would take decades and probably be controversial but basically is the trauma of being removed from the birth parent so insignificant that the practice should be allowed? If you could just look down the back of the couch and find some funding for that, that would be great, thanks!

I wrote about the law and ethics or surrogacy in a recent piece and so can appreciated there is a lot that needs to be considered in these arrangements. It is something I already have on my radar as I have come across it numerous times already in my short 3 years of practicing. Thank you.

OP posts:
Porridgeislife · 16/02/2024 10:59

The use of forceps. The UK is unusual in still using them commonly and it was one of the reasons I went for a c-section in the end as they wanted to induce me.

Porridgeislife · 16/02/2024 10:56

This was in 2022 as well so recent

Porridgeislife · 16/02/2024 10:56

Phineyj · 16/02/2024 10:11

I'd like to see if antenatal care can be improved. Most pregnant women are working - many in professional jobs. The practice of making everyone rock up for the same clinic at the same time and then making the clients hang around for several hours before you see them is really inefficient and stressful. I had to get my classes covered for a whole afternoon each time and was never ever seen till after school had finished!

If GPs can offer timed appointments, why can't midwifery?

That’s definitely a Trust issue. My London hospital gave me timed appointments and I was able to choose the time when I rebooked at the end of that day’s appointment. Usually I went for the 5pm Friday appt!

Love51 · 16/02/2024 10:53

This is going beyond the scope of midwifery but it seems that you have an interest in future academic research so I hope you don't mind me sharing. I think it would be beneficial for there to be more research into the impact of surrogacy on the child that is given to the non bio parents to be cared for. Should we expect outcomes similar to birth children or similar to adopted children? It is a big piece of research that would take decades and probably be controversial but basically is the trauma of being removed from the birth parent so insignificant that the practice should be allowed? If you could just look down the back of the couch and find some funding for that, that would be great, thanks!

Bellsra · 16/02/2024 10:51

Whydosomanywomensleepwithsuchlosers · 16/02/2024 10:23

Sodding forceps use. My hospital has 9% forceps delivery- I wonder how many of those women have significant pelvic floor issues.

Midwives seem to have limited knowledge of effective pelvic floor exercises, and only make passing references to it antenatally ( my NCT friend literally didn't know what they are until 8 week PP GP appointment- we had the same midwife). It wasn't until I started going to physio that I learnt I hadn't been doing them properly the while pregnancy. I wonder how much suffering you could alleviate if physios ran training for trainee midwives.

I’m not sure midwives would have time to explain pelvic floor exercises in detail at antenatal appointments even if they did have more training. I think maybe a routine appointment with a physio in pregnancy for every women would be more effective (although even the physio appointments for women with problems are in short supply) or maybe better signposting to the information on the nhs website or perhaps a class or video for women in early pregnancy to go through all the health advice more clearly and concisely

MonaMental · 16/02/2024 10:47

I would agree with more research on Tongue Tie. Both my children had it, not diagnosed until my 1st baby was 4 weeks old - I was suffering and about to give up midwives and HV dismissed it. It was a volunteer breastfeeding supporter that first mentioned it. Doctor who snipped it said it was obvious! 2nd baby I asked several times after birth and during first check ups about it but again I was dismissed, HV finally did a referral to ‘reassure me’ it was fine . It wasn’t and again needed correcting. 2 babies who I nearly stopped breastfeeding due to lack of knowledge and support from professionals. It’s a very simple procedure, effective and cheap and I would like to see every midwife trained and it be part of the newborn check.

BurrosTail · 16/02/2024 10:46

The impact of induced deliveries without adequate pain management in the likelihood of having further children.

UpUpUpU · 16/02/2024 10:42

leafinthewind · 16/02/2024 10:37

Oh god, don't do a PhD! OK, I'll admit that many HCPs make fabulous PhD students - but think very carefully about what you want to achieve with it. If you're sure that's what you want, use this opportunity to practice your research skills. Use data or conduct interviews. Practice keeping your data in good order. Start building a reference library in e.g. Mendeley (other referencing software is available). Good luck!

Thank you. It is something I have in me that I need to get out. Midwifery is my second degree (I am not young anymore!) and whilst I am very passionate about it and aim to practice for many years, I don't want to be a hospital midwife in my later years and would rather try an leave my mark and help midwifery if I can.

My partner is an academic and a well known researcher so I am in good company should I need some help :)

OP posts:
leafinthewind · 16/02/2024 10:37

UpUpUpU · 16/02/2024 10:29

Thank you, I appreciate this.

I did a lot of research in my former role and plan to carry over my topic into a Masters and PhD so something with scope is what I am looking for.

Oh god, don't do a PhD! OK, I'll admit that many HCPs make fabulous PhD students - but think very carefully about what you want to achieve with it. If you're sure that's what you want, use this opportunity to practice your research skills. Use data or conduct interviews. Practice keeping your data in good order. Start building a reference library in e.g. Mendeley (other referencing software is available). Good luck!

overthinkersanonnymus · 16/02/2024 10:36

Perinatal mental health.

UpUpUpU · 16/02/2024 10:34

sleepandcoffee · 16/02/2024 10:30

Oh I have another one - the lack of infomation on how to care for yourself after a c-section .

I wasn't told anything on how to look after the scar and what to expect in the coming months to do with recovery from an operation

This is something I am very hot on but I appreciate not all trusts are the same.

It is such a big thing to have to recover from, whilst caring for a baby, so thank you.

I will put together a list and will share this with my cohort so that more ideas can be used. You are all wonderful, thank you.

OP posts:
UpUpUpU · 16/02/2024 10:33

Bushmillsbabe · 16/02/2024 10:27

When I was a junior physio 15 years ago we went round every women on postnatal ward and talked to them about pelvic exercises, back care post baby, what activities to encourage and what to avoid, and tgey were given a phone number to call to request an outpatient review with a physio if any continence issues. But this, as with many things, has been cut

It is sad isn't it. I do put a lot of focus on pelvic floor health and drum it home every contact I have with women. We do have a self referral to a women's physio but passed given women the contact details, I am not sure what happens past that point. I should find out.

This is actually starting to form some ideas in my mind. My pelvic floor is not great after my son and I didn't have much in the way of pelvic floor care in my pregnancy. if I can save some women from pelvic floor issues in the future, that would be a big achievement. Thank you.

OP posts: