Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask for your ideas about what research needs doing in midwifery?

133 replies

UpUpUpU · 16/02/2024 09:56

Sorry, posting for traffic!

I am a third year student midwife about to embark on a research project but I am struggling to decide on a topic.

As many of you are parents, is there anything in your experiences of maternity care that you think could have been done better or that you wondered why something was done or suggested? Anything you would have wanted more research on?

Any suggestions would be much appreciated.

Thanks in advance.

OP posts:
RadiatorHead · 16/02/2024 12:39

Something around when babies are very large and yet the mum is allowed to go well over her due date.

DS was estimated to be 8lb 6oz at a
38 week scan but I was still allowed to carry him to 42 weeks and he was 10lb 4oz. I was in labour for 23 hours and pushing for 2.5 hours and had a ventouse delivery in the end.

ru53 · 16/02/2024 12:22

Lack of adequate post natal care/impact of this on mums long term health/mental health/bonding with baby. This seems to be a bit of a lottery and as PPs have mentioned, no one actually examines you unless you request it which is mind blowing.

PermanentTemporary · 16/02/2024 12:22

The NICE guideline includes detailed discussion of the information and processes that should be in place around decisions to induct. Research on women's perspectives of discussions that the health professionals think complied with those parts of the guidelines would be interesting.

ChazsBrilliantAttitude · 16/02/2024 12:07

I agree on post natal physio support. I still have SI joint problems 10+ years later. I had physio whilst pregnant on the NHS because my pelvis was unstable but absolutely nothing afterwards.

The other area is the follow up of damage / issues caused by episiotomy. How many women suffer ongoing problems and what support is offered?

Crabble · 16/02/2024 11:55

Kosenrufugirl · 16/02/2024 10:17

I disagree. I am a midwife working on the labour ward. Forceps is a safe and versatile instrument in experienced hands. I did however raise the question of informed consent at a joint doctors and midwives meeting on our unit some years ago. If the doctors have time to properly consent for a Caesarean in a dire emergency, they have time to consent for an instrumental delivery. I am pleased report that our unit practice has changed and doctors do now take time to explain. This makes a huge difference in an otherwise scary situation. I wouldn't ban forceps, they are often a much better choice than a Caesarean at full dilatation when ventouse isn't possible

How are you defining “safe” though @Kosenrufugirl? If you mean safe as in it won’t kill you then yes I agree, but surely increased risks of horrible and distressing complications is a safety issue?

OP - I would like to see follow up research on the evidence from Canada that actually C-sections are just as safe as vaginal delivery for first time mothers with no contra indications for surgery. The established view that is given to pregnant women is that vaginal birth is inherently better and safer, which I think is outdated and flawed.

Whydosomanywomensleepwithsuchlosers · 16/02/2024 11:50

Bellsra · 16/02/2024 10:51

I’m not sure midwives would have time to explain pelvic floor exercises in detail at antenatal appointments even if they did have more training. I think maybe a routine appointment with a physio in pregnancy for every women would be more effective (although even the physio appointments for women with problems are in short supply) or maybe better signposting to the information on the nhs website or perhaps a class or video for women in early pregnancy to go through all the health advice more clearly and concisely

That could also work. The problem is the NHS website isn't good either! I was "stopping a pretend wee" when I should have been "drawing spaghetti up my back passage" while doing diaphragmatic breathing. I made a lot of progress in a few months, I wonder whether I could have prevented my prolapse entirely if I had been doing it correctly the whole time.

The pelvic problem is compounded by the fact GPs are also poorly trained and will often misdiagnose.

Also, um, the fact that even after a traumatic delivery, forceps etc, literally no-one physically examines you after birth unless you ask??

So many women must walk (/waddle) away with problems that they feel are undeserving of attention. The fact the private Mummy MOT company exists tells you everything you need to know about the failure of NHS postnatal care.

UpUpUpU · 16/02/2024 11:48

kingfisher657 · 16/02/2024 11:45

Birth trauma - the rates are staggering. What are the risk factors, what interventions can help, etc.

Hyper stimulation from induction, especially at the early stages when adequate pain relief is not offered. Whether women are adequately informed about this possibility ahead of time.

Thank you. This is a very valid point.

OP posts:
kingfisher657 · 16/02/2024 11:45

Birth trauma - the rates are staggering. What are the risk factors, what interventions can help, etc.

Hyper stimulation from induction, especially at the early stages when adequate pain relief is not offered. Whether women are adequately informed about this possibility ahead of time.

MidnightPatrol · 16/02/2024 11:34

PermanentTemporary · 16/02/2024 11:28

Yes but... (but, but) 'guidelines' ARE an answer to 'why'. Induction guidelines are based on research evidence. They're not pulled out of the air. The question is of course whether the evidence on resources and knowledge required to implement induction guidelines so that the benefit of fewer babies dying isn't accompanied by a huge increase in maternal morbidity are in place.

The focus should be on the individual patient not jut guidelines IMO.

We should be monitoring the individual circumstances and health of each patient, not just going 'it's a bit riskier so you automatically have to have an induction, even though the likelihood that will end in a very traumatic birth / emergency situation is high'.

These aren't women/babies with serious medical issues most of the time.

How many women could have had perfectly normal births and healthy babies, who actually had a traumatic labour and birth because of being forced to have an induction?

UpUpUpU · 16/02/2024 11:31

PermanentTemporary · 16/02/2024 11:28

Yes but... (but, but) 'guidelines' ARE an answer to 'why'. Induction guidelines are based on research evidence. They're not pulled out of the air. The question is of course whether the evidence on resources and knowledge required to implement induction guidelines so that the benefit of fewer babies dying isn't accompanied by a huge increase in maternal morbidity are in place.

I appreciate this, but surely an obstetrician should have known the physiological reasons why it is needed? Or at least admitted they didn't know? What if a woman about to be induced asked? Would you accept the answer that guidelines say so?

OP posts:
UpUpUpU · 16/02/2024 11:29

OldManSign · 16/02/2024 11:26

Also, with regards to what you can do in your own practice, it’s just taking that time to double check with patients who have declared those conditions. It was rather infuriating to have it in my notes but have to bring it up constantly to every new member of staff. I also think they saw “oh arthritis. Noted.” but never actually thought of the practical implications of that in examinations etc so to have been asked would have been amazing. As it happens, the staff in the NICU always mentioned my arthritis at handover as it had implications for me holding baby and my movement etc especially following a c-section. That was hugely appreciated as it meant I never had to think about it - they just knew I needed more support and it made the world of difference.

Thank you. Our handovers on labour suite are usually very in depth. Postnatal ward wise, it is dependent on the midwife caring for you as to how good of a handover the next midwives receive. There is no excuse though for poor documentation though!

OP posts:
PermanentTemporary · 16/02/2024 11:28

Yes but... (but, but) 'guidelines' ARE an answer to 'why'. Induction guidelines are based on research evidence. They're not pulled out of the air. The question is of course whether the evidence on resources and knowledge required to implement induction guidelines so that the benefit of fewer babies dying isn't accompanied by a huge increase in maternal morbidity are in place.

UpUpUpU · 16/02/2024 11:27

LillyLeaf · 16/02/2024 11:25

Just because I had ivf I automatically had to have an induction if I didn't give birth before 40 weeks. Nothing else was taken into account, not my easy pregnancy, my health, baby's health, nothing. My induction birth was horrible and everything I didn't want to happen, happened due to this intervention.

It seemed there is very little research into ivf babies and delivery.

Also on my radar. All an obstetrician could tell me when I asked the question about IVF induction was because it is an assisted pregnancy! No scientific reason why...
Definitely needs looking into.

OP posts:
OldManSign · 16/02/2024 11:26

UpUpUpU · 16/02/2024 11:10

I am really sad to hear you had such a poor experience. Completely for my own learning as I haven't had the opportunity to care for many women with physical or mobility issues and I want to make sure when I do, I give them the best care. What would have made your care better?

Also, with regards to what you can do in your own practice, it’s just taking that time to double check with patients who have declared those conditions. It was rather infuriating to have it in my notes but have to bring it up constantly to every new member of staff. I also think they saw “oh arthritis. Noted.” but never actually thought of the practical implications of that in examinations etc so to have been asked would have been amazing. As it happens, the staff in the NICU always mentioned my arthritis at handover as it had implications for me holding baby and my movement etc especially following a c-section. That was hugely appreciated as it meant I never had to think about it - they just knew I needed more support and it made the world of difference.

MidnightPatrol · 16/02/2024 11:25

UpUpUpU · 16/02/2024 11:16

In my trust we offer induction for post dates between 40 + 7 and 40 + 10. I know some trusts offer earlier, especially at maternal request. I don't think women are given enough information on the induction process and what it could mean for the their labour and delivery.

I think if you told women what induction might mean for their labour and delivery, you might find very few were willing to agree to it.

For all the emphasis on 'birth plans' and feeling safe and comfortable, every induced labour I know seemed spend days in hospital, forced to labour on a ward, to end up strapped to a bed, army of medical people around, immobile due to epidural / monitoring, concluding in episiotomy/forceps or emergency c-section after 24-48+ hours.

LillyLeaf · 16/02/2024 11:25

Just because I had ivf I automatically had to have an induction if I didn't give birth before 40 weeks. Nothing else was taken into account, not my easy pregnancy, my health, baby's health, nothing. My induction birth was horrible and everything I didn't want to happen, happened due to this intervention.

It seemed there is very little research into ivf babies and delivery.

UpUpUpU · 16/02/2024 11:25

OldManSign · 16/02/2024 11:20

I really do think it’s a case of someone taking the time to sit with you and talk it through. I basically got booted off my community midwife and over to the GD midwife who was awful so I lost that connection I’d had since my booking appointment. I think a specialist midwife for disabled mums would be amazing - in the same way we have those for teenaged mums, GD, mental health (perhaps more). Someone who is able to have a bit more specialist knowledge and the time to sit with you and work out how to best support within their scope. Someone who knows the avenues of support during pregnancy and after birth (our health visitors also have no clue who to seek support from!) rather than these women having to navigate it all on their own. As I say, another woman might have listened to the consultant about mode of delivery but I am older and have enough medical experience to know when to put my foot down. I actually dread to think what would have happened if I wasn’t so stubborn! If I’d had a midwife to fight my corner that would have been a weight off my shoulders. I also think that, to a certain degree, due to my medical conditions I was just sort of left to get on with it - I do think another mum in my situation would have been scooped up by the neonatal mental health team (as our new HV told me probably should have happened when we moved around baby’s first birthday). A specialist midwife could never be completely knowledgable about every disability or condition but they don’t have to be to get the right information to the right person.

Thank you for this. I will at the very least take this on board for my own practice but equally will share this with my peers. You are right that a specialised midwife is needed here and could also incorporate those with SPD as mentioned up thread earlier and possibly higher BMI women with decreased mobility. Thank you.

OP posts:
KnittingKnewbie · 16/02/2024 11:23

UpUpUpU · 16/02/2024 10:21

The PN wards in my trust are not conducive to rest and relaxation so I hear you on this one. It would be interesting to see what the effects of time on a PN ward have on maternal mental health. Thank you.

Oh Yes, the first time I gave birth the ward was like a train station. I left in less than 24 hours. Second birth it was lovely and calm, midwifes had time to check in on everyone. (Different hospitals).

OldManSign · 16/02/2024 11:20

UpUpUpU · 16/02/2024 11:10

I am really sad to hear you had such a poor experience. Completely for my own learning as I haven't had the opportunity to care for many women with physical or mobility issues and I want to make sure when I do, I give them the best care. What would have made your care better?

I really do think it’s a case of someone taking the time to sit with you and talk it through. I basically got booted off my community midwife and over to the GD midwife who was awful so I lost that connection I’d had since my booking appointment. I think a specialist midwife for disabled mums would be amazing - in the same way we have those for teenaged mums, GD, mental health (perhaps more). Someone who is able to have a bit more specialist knowledge and the time to sit with you and work out how to best support within their scope. Someone who knows the avenues of support during pregnancy and after birth (our health visitors also have no clue who to seek support from!) rather than these women having to navigate it all on their own. As I say, another woman might have listened to the consultant about mode of delivery but I am older and have enough medical experience to know when to put my foot down. I actually dread to think what would have happened if I wasn’t so stubborn! If I’d had a midwife to fight my corner that would have been a weight off my shoulders. I also think that, to a certain degree, due to my medical conditions I was just sort of left to get on with it - I do think another mum in my situation would have been scooped up by the neonatal mental health team (as our new HV told me probably should have happened when we moved around baby’s first birthday). A specialist midwife could never be completely knowledgable about every disability or condition but they don’t have to be to get the right information to the right person.

UpUpUpU · 16/02/2024 11:16

KnittingKnewbie · 16/02/2024 11:12

I've seen recently that the average length of pregnancy is actually 40+5 or some such number. I don't have the research to hand!
BUT if this is the case then inductions shouldn't be offered until then, not at 40 weeks

In my trust we offer induction for post dates between 40 + 7 and 40 + 10. I know some trusts offer earlier, especially at maternal request. I don't think women are given enough information on the induction process and what it could mean for the their labour and delivery.

OP posts:
UpUpUpU · 16/02/2024 11:15

MidnightPatrol · 16/02/2024 11:11

A third of births were induced 2021-22!

Every single induced birth I have heard about ended in either a c-section or forceps.

In assessing 'risk', hospitals are forgetting about mothers IMO.

Inductions were my first thought. Some of the reasons we induce seem completely beyond reason. I have worked a lot in inductions and always question the reasoning with obstetricians and a lot of the answers are because it is guidelines? But why? I think this is a topic that will be covered by many in my cohort as we all feel the same way about it. It is quite a large scope for this project but I may narrow it down by taking a particular reason for induction, such as maternal age.

OP posts:
MonaMental · 16/02/2024 11:15

Love51 · 16/02/2024 10:53

This is going beyond the scope of midwifery but it seems that you have an interest in future academic research so I hope you don't mind me sharing. I think it would be beneficial for there to be more research into the impact of surrogacy on the child that is given to the non bio parents to be cared for. Should we expect outcomes similar to birth children or similar to adopted children? It is a big piece of research that would take decades and probably be controversial but basically is the trauma of being removed from the birth parent so insignificant that the practice should be allowed? If you could just look down the back of the couch and find some funding for that, that would be great, thanks!

I’ve often wondered this too, it seems not many want to open this can of worms. It would be a brilliant and groundbreaking piece of research.

KnittingKnewbie · 16/02/2024 11:12

I've seen recently that the average length of pregnancy is actually 40+5 or some such number. I don't have the research to hand!
BUT if this is the case then inductions shouldn't be offered until then, not at 40 weeks

MidnightPatrol · 16/02/2024 11:11

lifeontheup · 16/02/2024 11:04

Increase in unnecessary inductions and the trauma they cause! Particularly leading to c-sections.

A third of births were induced 2021-22!

Every single induced birth I have heard about ended in either a c-section or forceps.

In assessing 'risk', hospitals are forgetting about mothers IMO.

UpUpUpU · 16/02/2024 11:10

OldManSign · 16/02/2024 11:07

Care for disabled women without a doubt.

Just a few examples of what I had to deal with:

  • A complete lack of understanding of my mobility issues with regards to getting up on beds etc. Comments like “oh you’ll be able to walk again when the baby comes, it won’t be for long!” …. No I won’t this is permanent!
  • A complete and utter lack of understanding (and rudeness to boot) from the gestational diabetes midwife regarding my sensory issues around food and mobility restricting exercise (the dietitian was fabulous!)
  • The NICE guidelines state you should have a multi-disciplinary team if you have a long term health condition. I never had that at all.
  • Ignorant comments about the potential impact of vaginal birth on my hip condition from obstetricians which could have caused a less confident woman to attempt an unsafe vaginal delivery.
  • Not a single person suggested any modes of support from social services or even for us to have an exemption from partners not being allowed to stay until a random midwife I happened to speak to heard about my issues and organised it for me (my husband stayed and we had a private room so as not to impact other women).

There’s definitely more but that’s what I can think of off the top of my head. Essentially, I was made to feel like their first ever disabled patient which can’t possibly be true but that was the level of their ignorance.

I am really sad to hear you had such a poor experience. Completely for my own learning as I haven't had the opportunity to care for many women with physical or mobility issues and I want to make sure when I do, I give them the best care. What would have made your care better?

OP posts: