Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask for your ideas about what research needs doing in midwifery?

133 replies

UpUpUpU · 16/02/2024 09:56

Sorry, posting for traffic!

I am a third year student midwife about to embark on a research project but I am struggling to decide on a topic.

As many of you are parents, is there anything in your experiences of maternity care that you think could have been done better or that you wondered why something was done or suggested? Anything you would have wanted more research on?

Any suggestions would be much appreciated.

Thanks in advance.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
porridgecake · 18/02/2024 12:06

KnittingKnewbie · 18/02/2024 11:21

Oh that's a really good one!
Specific, measured, focused, interesting!

I can't really take much credit, but I listened to Elaine Miller talking about it and thought that somebody really needs to look at this. The number of posters on here posting in women's health about the birth injuries, prolapse, continence issues is very upsetting. Women shouldn't be left in this state. Postnatal care seems to be getting so poor it seems to be non-existent in some places. My nieces had far worse care ,or lack of it, in the last 10 years than I did in the 1980s.

KnittingKnewbie · 18/02/2024 11:21

porridgecake · 16/02/2024 16:37

In France all post natal mums have specialist obstetric physio. It would be useful to look into the rates of pelvic floor problems postnatally, at 5 years, 10 years and so on in UK compared with France.
Listen to Elaine Miller talking about the cost to the NHS of allowing this situation to continue.

Oh that's a really good one!
Specific, measured, focused, interesting!

Whatevs23 · 17/02/2024 18:14

Weefreetiffany · 16/02/2024 18:18

Thanks @Whatevs23 thats good to hear. I gave birth ten days ago and everything is either numb or tender at the moment. Did you do any exercises to recover?

No, I didn't do any exercises. I wasn't even aware that there were such exercises!
Good luck with the baby.

ItIsLobstersAllTheWayDown · 16/02/2024 21:49

I have since read that intense exercise can cause it.

Perhaps it can so this would be interesting to look at, prevalence against exercise, but it can occur anyway. It can be due to Symphysis Pubis Dysfunction (SPD). Mine always started quite late on and went away after birth, but I knew a woman through NCT who still had problems with it through the first year. We lost touch so I don't know if she had developed a permanent problem or not.

ItIsLobstersAllTheWayDown · 16/02/2024 21:44

If GPs can offer timed appointments, why can't midwifery?

They used to. Perhaps a few of us had the same appointment time, which I can understand, but not a large cohort sitting there for hours on end.

I think it would be a good idea to see which of the improvements to maternity care that had occurred by the 1990s have actually gone back the other way. My birthing experiences in that decade, and both antenatal and postnatal care, in lots of different places, were much better than I am seeing mostly described now and I have heard the same from friends of the same vintage. Yes, the staffing crisis in midwifery, but what else and why?

I'd also be interested in information about back injuries during birth occurring due to (mis)use of different types of midwifery trolleys/beds, with or without stirrups, or prevalence of back problems in people who have had (vaginal) ultrasound with and without proper couch and stirrups being used versus the way they seem to do it now in some places with a chair to put your feet on which results in a very odd position that is not back-friendly. Anecdotally, sore backs from pregnancy and childbirth can often seem to be all right a while after birth, and then flare up as the woman ages.

Itonlytakesaminute · 16/02/2024 21:40

Tongue tie- not one HCP picked it up, I had to pay private as he was feeding well with bottle (breastfeeding was hard) the consultant said I had no chance of breastfeeding due to my babies TT.

Post natal wards- men were allowed to stay overnight if we wanted, but god it was loud, I hardly slept. Doctors coming in talking loudly at 2am.

Inductions - why is gas and air not allowed on the induction ward if you are having contractions and waters have broke ( and your just waiting on a space on delivery ) but is allowed just over the corridor on the delivery ward

Hotpinkangel19 · 16/02/2024 21:37

How stress can affect pregnancy. I have had 4 babies, 3 normal, natural births, and one induction due to my cervix being clamped shut apparently due to major stress - my parents both died whilst i was pregnant.

LabradorFiasco · 16/02/2024 21:18

@Weefreetiffany congratulations on your baby. Please, please do not feel you have failed your baby because you had a forceps delivery! Forceps exist for a reason. They save babies’ and mothers’ lives, and prevent caesareans. I had a kiellands forceps delivery (rotational forceps - only used in one or two Trusts by very experienced practitioners, because of the damage they can cause). I had a mediolateral episiotomy, a midline third degree tear and two deep internal lacerations. I lost 2.9L of blood from the injuries. My baby was born making no respiratory effort and had to be resuscitated for 3 minutes and 47 seconds. He was then absolutely fine; he’s now 3 and incredibly intelligent, sensitive, thoughtful and energetic (how everyone describes their kids, basically). My pelvic floor was a mess. I was doubly incontinent for a while. I had extensive pelvic floor physio and things are now much, much better.

Would I choose the rotational forceps again? Absolutely, because they saved me from having an EMCS at full dilatation (which I ironically had to have for my second child - and the recovery was WAY worse than the forceps delivery). They also meant that I was able to push my baby out myself (rotational forceps aren’t really designed to provide traction, rather they are for turning babies who are malpositoned), and that’s something I’ve held on to as a comfort.

A long post but just to say that no, you made the right choice for your and baby’s health. He was out quickly; you’re healing; hopefully feeding is going well and your little boy will thrive. Well done for making it through!!

FUPAgirl · 16/02/2024 20:17

Weefreetiffany · 16/02/2024 18:10

I ended up with a forceps assisted birth due to baby getting stuck and reading this I’m now so worried for both his health and my pelvic floor. I suddenly feel like I failed both of us.

Congratulations on the birth of your baby 👶 you haven't failed anyone! Your little one was stuck so needed assistance, this wasn't your fault. If he had been injured, it would have been apparent at birth - so please don't worry. Clearly your obstetrician weighed up the risk V benefit and felt the safest option was to assist with the birth, this is very common. It's normal to feel numb down below still at this stage, if you've any ongoing issues then referral to a women's health physio would be beneficial. But please don't worry, it is unlikely that you will have any ongoing issues.

This debate is due to forceps not being an option in some countries, but there's lots of reasons for this, don't let it worry you.

QueenCamilla · 16/02/2024 19:59

Why women's pain in labour is funny and not something that needs to be controlled for better mental and physical outcomes.

Jellybean85 · 16/02/2024 19:39

Istheworldmadorisitme · 16/02/2024 10:18

I developed intrahepatic cholestasis of pregnancy (ICP) during my second pregnancy and none of the midwifes I encountered seemed to know anything about it. I wonder why that was as the internet knows about it as does the NHS website. There also seems to be very little scientific research on the subject and no solution other than get the baby out as soon as possible.

THIS!!! Woefully under researched and nearly killed my baby. Totally ruined my pregnancy and birth too I'll never get over it

OurChristmasMiracle · 16/02/2024 18:34

Pelvic girdle pain diagnosis in pregnancy and the effects it has after and causes

I wasn’t diagnosed until after my son was born, and I could barely move. I struggled from about 5 months in pain and waddling.

I have since read that intense exercise can cause it.

Bellsra · 16/02/2024 18:20

FUPAgirl · 16/02/2024 17:06

Because its a transient bacteria, it comes and goes. The chances of a baby becoming unwell are extremely low however the overuse of antibiotics in labour is helping the infection to become resistant to the usual treatment. There is also risks to the baby from antibiotic exposure. There is no research that proves whether routine testing is better for babies than risk based screening - but there certainly is evidence that it leads to overuse of antibiotics which definitely carries risk.

The WHO are moving towards vaccination - so prevention rather than cure. I have reservations about this too.

Agree, knowing what I know I would not want the offer of routine testing personally. It would lead to so many women and babies being given IV antibiotics for whom there would have been no benefit and use up resources which would no doubt lead to other adverse knock on impacts, not to mention antibiotic resistance. I had a friend in a country which does do routine testing and rigid protocols who had missed the test and then ended up being subject to a lot of worry and kept in hospital for several days for her baby to have IV antibiotics when it turned out neither had GBS anyway. Neither had even had any signs of infection whereas in the UK the response is much more measured. The pros and cons of introducing testing have previously been evaluated. Investing those resources in a quick and effective response to babies that do either have significant risk factors or are showing indications of infection seems much more sensible

blitzen · 16/02/2024 18:19

Agree with a PP about tongue tie, but also more around support for breastfeeding mothers.

Would also like to know more about babies born with meconium aspiration, and the stats on how many end up in SCBU. Having meconium in your waters isn't classed as an emergency as a factor on its own, I believe.

Weefreetiffany · 16/02/2024 18:18

Thanks @Whatevs23 thats good to hear. I gave birth ten days ago and everything is either numb or tender at the moment. Did you do any exercises to recover?

Whatevs23 · 16/02/2024 18:13

Weefreetiffany · 16/02/2024 18:10

I ended up with a forceps assisted birth due to baby getting stuck and reading this I’m now so worried for both his health and my pelvic floor. I suddenly feel like I failed both of us.

I had a forceps delivery with episiotomy over 20 years ago. My pelvic floor is just fine!

Weefreetiffany · 16/02/2024 18:10

I ended up with a forceps assisted birth due to baby getting stuck and reading this I’m now so worried for both his health and my pelvic floor. I suddenly feel like I failed both of us.

Whatevs23 · 16/02/2024 18:07

UpUpUpU · 16/02/2024 11:15

Inductions were my first thought. Some of the reasons we induce seem completely beyond reason. I have worked a lot in inductions and always question the reasoning with obstetricians and a lot of the answers are because it is guidelines? But why? I think this is a topic that will be covered by many in my cohort as we all feel the same way about it. It is quite a large scope for this project but I may narrow it down by taking a particular reason for induction, such as maternal age.

What about induction due to PROM?

My waters broke just before 36 weeks in my first pregnancy, so I was induced. My body was obviously not ready for labour and delivery, and my baby was not ready to be born (she was "sunny side up" for one thing), so it was a long drawn out, painful process, which ended in an episiotomy and forceps delivery. (The alternative, which they were trying to avoid, was an emergency C section).

Despite being a good weight my child struggled at first and was in the NICU. She is neurodiverse, and I do wonder if she had been full term if that would have been the case.

Maybe induction really was the only realistic option in my case, but would there have been alternatives? I think an interesting question might be at which stage of pregnancy does induction due to PROM lead to better outcomes than waiting for labour to start naturally.

menopausalmare · 16/02/2024 18:06

Effect of epidural on rates of caesarian.

Odingodof · 16/02/2024 17:57

Birth trauma.

Birth trauma and opening up the offering of a planned elc as a perfectly safe and positive way of giving birth for all women.

You don't need to have a medically called terrible physical birth for birth trauma you can have a so called medical perfect birth for it to be too much.

Every woman is more than a pair of birthing hips like an animal and they deserve to be listened too

LabradorFiasco · 16/02/2024 17:35
  • The case for tongue tie assessment and division capability as standard within 24h of delivery for all (E)BF babies.
  • Uterine hyperstimulation in labour and more effective management strategies.
  • How to promote recovery and rest in postnatal wards.
  • Perineal wound assessment - are there any standards for this? Does this always take place?
  • Hand expression education where babies are unable to latch at birth - so women can be more effectively supported to give colostrum and protect their supply rather than undermining it with formula.
  • Maternity Assessment Units and their policies for triage/pain relief provision, ie why can a woman in active labour be trapped alone for long periods of time in an MAU with no pain relief and no midwife support?
mummeeee · 16/02/2024 17:34

mathanxiety · 16/02/2024 17:16

@mummeeee

So sorry to hear of your baby's outcome.

There is a body of fairly recent research on SUA, which your team should have been aware of. You and your baby may have fallen victim to bad communication among HCPs wrt the condition.

Thanks. It was some years ago now, but since then I've had friends refer other friends to me, who've had SUA and I've felt at a bit of a loss as to what to tell them.

I've just done some more googling and there ARE some more recent studies, so thank you. They suggest there likely is a link between what happened to dd at 10 weeks and the SUA. There appear to be associations with intestinal atresia whilst in utero, which could well have the same origins as what happened to dd.

This was specifically a mesenteric ischaemia, but likely due to a narrowing/malformation of the superior mesenteric artery.

It's probably good for me to look at these studies every so often, both for interest for dd as she gets older and for my own healing from what was a traumatic event (and aftermath).

She is doing really well, but is dependent on parenteral nutrition due to the loss of all of her small intestine following the ischaemia.

mathanxiety · 16/02/2024 17:30

FUPAgirl · 16/02/2024 17:06

Because its a transient bacteria, it comes and goes. The chances of a baby becoming unwell are extremely low however the overuse of antibiotics in labour is helping the infection to become resistant to the usual treatment. There is also risks to the baby from antibiotic exposure. There is no research that proves whether routine testing is better for babies than risk based screening - but there certainly is evidence that it leads to overuse of antibiotics which definitely carries risk.

The WHO are moving towards vaccination - so prevention rather than cure. I have reservations about this too.

You can be sure that when a test is done routinely in the US, a thorough cost-benefit analysis has been done.

Yes, the risks there include litigation costs. But that's not true for other countries where testing and treatment are routine. No matter where testing is done, part of the cost is the expense of subsequent medical care for babies and educational care for children who have adverse outcomes despite the expensive treatment they must undergo.

The risk of overuse of antibiotics is a global issue not related specifically to AB for GBS.

All strep comes and goes. This particular strain does huge damage. Why not try to limit that risk?

There is really no sound reason why the UK is such an outlier in this area.

NinetyPercent · 16/02/2024 17:18

Oh god where to start! I’ve read half the thread and there’s some really good ideas here. I’ve recently submitted to the birth trauma enquiry chaired by Theo Clarke and Rosie Duffield, and I had a few key points in there that might be of interest. some of it is about lack of funding though so may just be really depressing to research. The best HCP I’ve ever seen was the women’s health physio I saw after my third degree tear high forceps delivery for a good two or three years. This was 13 years ago. She has now left the nhs.

The main issue I’d like to be properly researched is likelihood of women getting PTSD after birth. I had a lot of hospital experiences as a baby and child (surgery as a baby, incubator for 6 weeks, surgery and other hospital stays in early childhood - don’t want to give all details here) and so once I was in hospital in a high dependency unit (partly because of my medical history as a child, plus congenital abnormalities of uterus, cervix and vagina), being induced early with a drip etc etc as my baby hadn’t grown, it triggered all sorts of trauma from my childhood that I’d never really acknowledged. And it took me till my DS was over two to realise I had ptsd, and that it wasn’t just the traumatic birth on its own (which was hideous even for someone without any previous hospital inpatient experience) but it was all the previous experiences that made it worse. So what I want to know is, was it inevitable I’d get ptsd from the birth, because of my history, and what alternative care could the consultants and midwives have put in place to mitigate that? Can they identify who is at risk during pregnancy? Hope that makes sense.

mathanxiety · 16/02/2024 17:16

@mummeeee

So sorry to hear of your baby's outcome.

There is a body of fairly recent research on SUA, which your team should have been aware of. You and your baby may have fallen victim to bad communication among HCPs wrt the condition.

Swipe left for the next trending thread