Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be concerned about husband's weight

31 replies

Littlelighthouse · 16/02/2024 03:55

DH has always been on the 'bigger side' as long as I've known him. His weight isn't something that's ever bothered me attraction wise, but since having a child it's something I've grown increasingly concerned about.
He's 6ft 2, and the number on the scales has always been 'bigger', but he always looked in proportion to his height. However, since covid, things have just gotten really out of hand. He's an emotional eater and if he's sad he turns to food, just as if he's happy/wants to celebrate he turns to food. He hasn't weighed himself for months now, but last time he did he was over 19st and was disgusted with himself, which was so hard to see. I know he can lose the weight though, as for our wedding he decided to and he lost 2 stone (bringing him to just over 15st at the time) and honestly looked in the best shape I'd seen him in and he said he felt better/healthier too, but then it was covid.
We come from very different backgrounds regarding eating/exercise. As a child I hardly ate out/had takeaways (more of a parents financial issue than anything else), and exercised 3 times a week through various activities from being about 6 years old. DH, however, had parents who worked long hours and so they relied on McDonald's/burger king etc. He also did no out of school activities/exercise. His parents and siblings are all also overweight.
We are very open, and I've shared my concerns about passing bad habits onto our child, but he is very adamant that he doesn't want them having the same upbringing around food that he did.
But my biggest concern is that his dad is currently in hospital with heart failure (+other things caused by his weight). He's only in his late fifties, and I can sadly see this being th future for my husband and it terrifies me.
I've tried to talk to him in the past gently, and he says he wants to change, but he does absolutely nothing to make those changes. It's such a sensitive subject for him and it's something he was bullied about growing up, so I'm cautious to not evoke shame, but I also feel like I'm just sitting back and watching him put himself in an early grave.
So AIBU to be concerned? And if not, how would you gently approach the subject again?
Thank you

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
lifebeginsaftercoffee · 16/02/2024 12:09

I don't actually think there's anything wrong with using apps if it helps you, but I do think you need to careful how you suggest them to other people - especially if they haven't actually asked for your advice in the first place.

I just feel that if a woman posted on here about how her husband was changing her diet by cooking her fish and vegetables, or was trying to suggest "fun activities" or apps to help her lose weight, he'd be hung, drawn and quartered for being controlling.

TallandSkinny · 16/02/2024 11:26

Look, maybe I am a sap or an idiot. Maybe I enjoy being treated like an idiot or patronized (not that that was my experience, but you guys obviously know better).

And as a person with family members with autoimmune conditions, imo the microbiome is more than just a buzzword. Yes research is in it's infancy. And apparently the data from Zoe participants has revealed quite a high number of previously unknown gut microbes. Who knows what their importance might be; there isn't the research yet. Zoe is contributing to that body of knowledge which I find mildly exciting.

I just found it helpful, ok? And have found many more men interested and asking me about it that when I did slimming world or whatever. It was just a suggestion.

Catza · 16/02/2024 11:03

@TallandSkinny "microbiome" became a buzz word recently and Zoe, alongside other dubious businesses, fully capitalize on the buzz. But even superficial research into the topic will tell you people have vastly different microbiota in their gut and what is normal for me isn't normal for you. Therefore the "personalised poo samples" are as useful as.. well ... poo. Since nobody can actually tell you what you are supposed to do with this information.
As far as sugar and fat spikes, what is Zoe telling you that you don't know about dietary guidelines already? Eat complex carbohydrates, fiber and protein, avoid excessive amounts of saturated fats. Really, I don't need to have a make-shift lab in my house to follow what is already an established guideline.

lifebeginsaftercoffee · 16/02/2024 10:53

I haven't misunderstood anything @TallandSkinny.

Adults don't need to be patronised and told how to eat - they know. It's just the reasons behind food addiction and other issues are often incredibly complex and just being told to use an app or eat more fish is completely pointless.

TallandSkinny · 16/02/2024 10:34

Lol at me being sponsored content! Mumsnet can vouch for me having been here years and years.

It's just something I personally found helpful, and I have noticed a lot of men being interested in - in fact the guy who does my tesco click and collect was asking me about it last week - and it's in the zeitgeist at the moment so I thought he might find it interesting. It was just a suggestion, like all the others here.

TallandSkinny · 16/02/2024 10:25

GinForBreakfast · 16/02/2024 10:14

You've totally swallowed the Zoe hype! It's great that it's working for you but it is prohibitively expensive for most people and lacking in scientific evidence. It's like prescribing a Peleton subscription to someone who could get just as healthy going out for a brisk walk every day.

https://unherd.com/2023/10/we-need-to-talk-about-zoe/
https://www.ft.com/content/abe98fe9-bf58-461b-aa9a-313ed9a49f82

But if OP's dh gets in to it, he will eat better, and many men like the "evidence" it gives. Of course you are right, but ATM this man isn't eating well. If course he could just choose to eat better. But sometimes it's not that easy.

The recipes and foods recommended by Zoe are very healthy. It's not rocket science in any way. It boils down to, eat more veg, pulses and nuts, a bit of lean meat, drink in moderation. Cook from scratch. Avoid highly processed foods and white carbs. Of course I knew all that before. But paying 200 quid or however much it was and seeing the impact of foods on me - seeing my waking blood sugar hovering at around 6.5 - has made all the difference to me. So carry on feeling superior that you didn't need the extra push to apply those healthy eating principles. I did, and I am happy to have spent it.

Toopolitetoask · 16/02/2024 10:18

Shaming people into change isn't effective. I'm not suggesting that's what you are intending to do, but bringing up his weight, or referring to FIL, or discussing the health implications would likely all have the same effect - which you know, because you mention that he'd emotionally eat.

If he eats to deal with unhappy feelings then he needs to find another thing that he enjoys that lifts his mood, otherwise any attempts at healthy eating will go out of the window at the first sign of stress. People say that weight loss is always down to diet and not exercise, and while it is definitely true that we can't out exercise a bad diet, the mood lift that comes with regular exercise can really help some people to curb their emotional eating.

Could you have a conversation with him about whether he'd be up for setting a goal to be more active? Just something as simple as walking daily would make a difference initially. Focusing on goals for positive things (health) is much more likely to be effective than focusing on negative things (things we want to stop or restrict)

LolaJ87 · 16/02/2024 10:15

I think the less you say at the moment, the better. Trust me when I say us overweight people are generally aware of their weight. It also sounds like he is overweight rather than obese? If so, while he would no doubt benefit from some lifestyle changes, his health isn't under imminent threat.

He'll be emotionally wobbly at the moment over his dad, it's not the time to try and change his eating habits. I think you need to just offer your love and support to him. Change has to come from him.

Definitely sounds like the ideas of active family life are good and set a great example for your child though 🙂

p.s. the Zoe stuff reads like sponsored content and if my husband came to me with that, I'd not be receptive.

GinForBreakfast · 16/02/2024 10:14

You've totally swallowed the Zoe hype! It's great that it's working for you but it is prohibitively expensive for most people and lacking in scientific evidence. It's like prescribing a Peleton subscription to someone who could get just as healthy going out for a brisk walk every day.

https://unherd.com/2023/10/we-need-to-talk-about-zoe/
https://www.ft.com/content/abe98fe9-bf58-461b-aa9a-313ed9a49f82

We need to talk about ZOE

How scientific is the must-have health app?

https://unherd.com/2023/10/we-need-to-talk-about-zoe

TallandSkinny · 16/02/2024 10:07

lifebeginsaftercoffee · 16/02/2024 09:10

I think you need to be really careful as a lot of these suggestions come across as being pretty infantilising and patronising.

If my DH suddenly insisted on cooking me lots of fish and veg, or told me to use an app to measure how certain foods affected me, I would feel like he thought I was a bit thick, quite frankly. It certainly wouldn't make me feel loved or like he was coming from a place of concern.

You have completely misunderstood Zoe. It's not just an app. It's about being proactive about your health with personalized evidence from your microbiome (poo sample), blood sugar responsiveness (wearing a monitor for a fortnight while logging foods) and blood fat responsiveness (eating a test meal then taking blood after a given amount of time).

Many people who aren't overweight are doing Zoe. Which is why I thought it might be of interest to OP. They could both do it under guise of being healthier and understanding more about their own bodies.

@Catza of course blood sugar spikes are expected. However a rapid rise and subsequent rapid crash is not ideal and what leads, over years and years, to insulin resistance and the prediabetic state I was in. Doing Zoe showed me that my personal blood sugar and blood fat responses were both very poor and I feel it has pulled me back from the brink of a future of type 2 diabetes.

Twilightstarbright · 16/02/2024 09:58

I’m with @Mrsttcno1 my DH had a Frank discussion with me about my weight and health and he was right- I owed it to DS and myself to be as healthy as possible (lots of serious chronic illnesses). I got counselling to help with the emotional eating, used Ozempic and followed a healthy eating plan and lost 25kg. I still have bad days but I’ve learnt to feel my feelings and not eat them.

Mrsttcno1 · 16/02/2024 09:13

Honestly OP I would sit down together and just have a very frank, open and honest chat. Even if it’s a difficult one to have. I would hope if it was me then my husband would feel able to do that and I would if the roles were reversed.

lifebeginsaftercoffee · 16/02/2024 09:10

I think you need to be really careful as a lot of these suggestions come across as being pretty infantilising and patronising.

If my DH suddenly insisted on cooking me lots of fish and veg, or told me to use an app to measure how certain foods affected me, I would feel like he thought I was a bit thick, quite frankly. It certainly wouldn't make me feel loved or like he was coming from a place of concern.

Ruralrules · 16/02/2024 09:05

Just reading your comments about facing this as a family and I'm probably being negative due to my own situation but I can't help but feel my DH bowed out of his commitment to his family when he allowed his weight to soar to the extent that his health declined. The reality for us is that he couldn't even get life insurance due to his weight issues. You can face it as a family in terms of supporting him but he needs to face reality.

Ruralrules · 16/02/2024 09:00

My DH died at 60 after a lifetime of obesity , type 2 diabetes, heart disease etc. He had weight loss surgery in his 30's but he seemed to find ways to still eat what he wanted.
Two of my children are still at university and his recent sudden death has been so difficult for them that I genuinely feared they'd drop out of uni. I'm not sure what advice I can offer but there's a really stark reality when someone's facing multiple co morbidities in their 50's.
He had just become a grandfather and it's really upsetting to think my 1 year old grandson won't remember him.

Catza · 16/02/2024 08:48

TallandSkinny · 16/02/2024 08:10

Some people need to see the actual impact of McD on their blood sugar, blood fat response and the long term impact on their microbiome in order to be shocked into eating differently, and that is what Zoe does. We all know McD is unhealthy in theory, but actually watching your blood sugar spike and crash brings that message home differently. I will never eat a steak slice again after watching my blood sugar spike at 12 within an hour of eating it. I knew they were unhealthy before, but I didn't know how they affect me before.

Except that sugar spikes are normal after any food consumption.

Catza · 16/02/2024 08:47

I empathise but the truth is, unless he decides to do it, nothing will change. I am in a similar boat except my partner is very active - gym 5 times a week and a physical job. But he just doesn't seem to be able to put the fork down in the evenings. His dad had a heart attack a few years ago, my partner himself has an autoimmune and clotting disorders which would improve drastically with weight loss. He is about 17st now and needs to be somewhere around 15 for his height and muscle mass. Unfortunately, he thinks that because he is active, he can eat as much as he wants and he massively underestimates how calorie dense most of his meals are.
All I can do is to be encouraging (and keeping snacks out of the house as much as possible).

BobbyBiscuits · 16/02/2024 08:22

I'd just mention that you want to try and be healthier as a family. Cooking using less fat, adding more veg and less carbs to the plate, stock up on loads of healthy snacks you all like. Then also you could try and get him moving a bit. Just go for nice long walks locally at first, then maybe see if he's up for joining a gym (with you) once he's a bit more confident with exercise? If he's into team sports could he join a 5 a side team locally or something? Also taking the child swimming as a family is good exercise. I think if you introduce it kind of organically without even really mentioning his weight, as he already knows he's too big. Heart issues are a literal killer sometimes for men in their 50s. My dad was one of them. It's great you want to help him get healthier.

TallandSkinny · 16/02/2024 08:10

GinForBreakfast · 16/02/2024 08:04

People eating MacDonalds etc. regularly don't need to spaff £100s on Zoe (I'd argue no one does).

Some people need to see the actual impact of McD on their blood sugar, blood fat response and the long term impact on their microbiome in order to be shocked into eating differently, and that is what Zoe does. We all know McD is unhealthy in theory, but actually watching your blood sugar spike and crash brings that message home differently. I will never eat a steak slice again after watching my blood sugar spike at 12 within an hour of eating it. I knew they were unhealthy before, but I didn't know how they affect me before.

Candleabra · 16/02/2024 08:09

Difficult one. I understand what you’re saying, but it sounds like it’s up to you to devise healthy eating plans and then your husband may or may not engage (but will probably be upset and sulk about you raising the problem). I wish I had another adult to deal with my life for me….

He knows he’s overweight, and he could/would do something if he wanted to. Understandably you’re worried about his health though, no idea what the answer is other than him taking responsibility for himself.

GinForBreakfast · 16/02/2024 08:04

People eating MacDonalds etc. regularly don't need to spaff £100s on Zoe (I'd argue no one does).

Pigeonqueen · 16/02/2024 07:54

I actually don’t think there is anything you can do. He is obviously well aware of his weight - he lost weight for your wedding, he knows he’s put it back on, he knows his Dad is unwell with issues made worse by being overweight. He’s not daft. I think you need to be careful that you don’t become a nag about it all - I know it’s coming from a place of concern but honestly as someone who is overweight myself (mainly through long term steroid use for autoimmune issues) there is nothing worse than someone going on at you or trying to “helpfully” change things. It’s a bit like being an alcoholic- it’s a similar addiction. He needs to reach a point of wanting to change himself.

TallandSkinny · 16/02/2024 07:48

I'd recommend doing Zoe together. It's focused on health and getting blood sugar scores, what your microbiome is like etc is very illuminating. It doesn't focus on weight loss but on eating better for your body.

LizzieSiddal · 16/02/2024 07:23

My Dh is similar in that he is an emotional eater and has piled on weight over the past few years.
I suggested we try to lost weight together, I’m not over weight but at the upper end of ok. So we cleared everything out of the house which is processed, and we’re cooking from stretch, he’s on NOOM which he’s found really helpful to learn about food and how calorific things are. He’s really got into it and says it’s so much easier because there’s no temptations in the house and we’re doing it together.

At his age he does need to be careful, would he consider going to the Drs and having an overall check up- blood pressure, cholesterol etc?

Babsexxx · 16/02/2024 07:09

Only he can change op the best thing to do is not bring it up I’m afraid as if he’s a emotional eater and you bringing it up it could come across as him thinking you don’t find him attractive= more comfort eating.

I would advise the best thing you can do is cook healthy meals plan fun activities but please don’t push as hard as it is.

Swipe left for the next trending thread