Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do I just give up? Am I just destined to be fat

235 replies

Sianholby · 15/02/2024 22:28

Just coming in here as I’m just feeling down at the moment. I’m perimenopausal, just started HRT and hate the way I look.
I swim and go on our home cross trainer twice a week. I work full time and have three kids. We eat relatively healthily and I’m trying to cut down my carbs.

i just look like a whale, my belly sticks out further than my breasts. I can just can’t shift this weight.
iVe attached a photo of me currently, I want to lose the belly and the fat below my breasts that sticks out. Any tips as exercising three times a week around work and children and walking almost everywhere just isn’t doing it

OP posts:
IStandWithACrutch · 16/02/2024 10:51

Another bit of advice to swap the cross trainer for weight training. It will change your body’s shape.

5128gap · 16/02/2024 10:50

user1471556642 · 16/02/2024 10:40

I agree with @brunettemic, there is some terrible advice above.
Yes you do need to be in a calorie deficit but you do not need to cut out foods you enjoy, or starve yourself. I’m 5’3’’ size 14, 47yr old, eating 1800-1900 calories a day (on average over the week) and I’m reliably losing weight
Portion control has been the main thing for me, and we still have a takeaway once a week

The lighter you get the lower your calories requirements drop though. I got to BMI of 21, and loved how that felt, but at 8 stone 10 and 5' 4" then, could only maintain that by keeping to 1600 calories. 1700 if I walked a lot. If I hadn't cut out a lot of foods I enjoyed, I'd not have had enough calories available to meet my nutrional needs. The OP may find initially she can lose on more and include 'treats' as she's heavier to start with, but at her height when she's at her ideal weight, she will need to be strict to maintain it. Or settle for a higher weight of course.

Sususudio · 16/02/2024 10:47

Can one have diastiasis recti if your youngest DC is 19?😂And what can be done about it? Asking for a friend.

EighteenBaldingStars · 16/02/2024 10:45

You look a lot like I do! But you seem to be leaning way back so your breasts look smaller than your belly? That doesn't look like it would be the case if you just stood up tall.

I'm focusing on yoga and cutting out booze for now. Will maybe then tackle sweets, but taking one thing at a time...

I agree with people saying exercise won't help that much, but yoga in particular makes a massive difference to how I look and feel although it won't cause me to lose weight

Toopolitetoask · 16/02/2024 10:44

OP it's true that you could lose weight by dropping to 1000 calories, or fasting, or cutting out all carbs and sugar.... But for many people it isn't sustainable because it's bloody depressing. It also won't necessarily change your shape, it would make you smaller but you might not feel you look 'better'.

I'd second what people have said about speaking to your GP about the HRT. And seriously look at weight training/resistance training instead of the cross trainer. I'm a few years younger than you, same height and have a tendency to gain weight around my middle. My weight gradually crept up on 1500-1600 calories a day. For a few years now I've trained with (heavy) weights, and because I carry more muscle on my body I can eat 1800 calories a day without gaining weight. That is so much easier to manage and still enjoy life. Not just that though - my arms and shoulders are broader which means my waist looks smaller - I've lost a bit round my waist but not loads, however people comment that I look like I've lost weight. I look 'toned' because I have a (tiny!) bit of muscle definition. My posture is better, I feel more energetic and I've reduced my risk of osteoporosis (something that runs in my family)

If you're already taking the time to exercise it's worth considering switching it for something that will give you noticeable results. It doesn't happen overnight but it does change things.

RandomMess · 16/02/2024 10:43

@brunettemic that's not strictly true if you eat 1500 of UPF or "crap" you are nutritionally deficient which has an impact on how your body processes what you do eat. Lots of relatively new research results on these.

The low carb diet is about cutting out refined and processed sugar which has a large impact on nutrition and feeling satisfied on far fewer calories.

Sadly most of us are addicted to carbs ie sugar.

Sususudio · 16/02/2024 10:41

I think there is a hormonal and genetic element too, as I was slim enough until my mid-forties. My mum is a size 8 and has a belly!

Somethingsnappy · 16/02/2024 10:41

I've not read the entire thread, op, so apologies if someone has already mentioned this, but could you have diastasis recti? Where the abdominal muscles come apart during pregnancy and don't always knit back together properly again afterwards. After 3 children, it's certainly a possibility. I have 4 children, and I look like you. The tell-tale sign to me is the little bump under your breasts. Does your abdomen go into a cone shape when you do a sit-up? That would be caused by diastasis recti.

Of course, with a BMI of 30, some weight loss will improve the appearance of it, with less fat in that general area, but it might also be worth speaking to a physiotherapist who has knowledge in post pregnancy exercises.

Ive been losing weight recently, as a result of giving up dairy and wheat (because of intolerances). The weight loss has been a happy side effect of that, as I don't actually feel like I'm eating less. It's been slow, but steady, and it's definitely improving the appearance of my diastasis recti and general abdominal area.

Watchkeys · 16/02/2024 10:40

@brunettemic

What are you basing this 'stupid keto', 'stupid intermittent fasting' opinion on?

Do you want some scientific articles with evidence to refute your opinion, or are you set in your critical uneducated views?

You can lose weight by only eating crisps and chocolate as long as you consume fewer calories than you burn

This is true. But the parameters aren't 'lose weight' and 'don't lose weight'. The parameters are 'lose weight easily/healthily', and 'lose weight with difficulty/unhealthily'. There's a lot more to the complex human body's workings than your simple 'Eat less, get thin' advice. People put on weight due to hormonal changes, for example.

@Sianholby Is your exercise all cardiovascular? Have you tried lifting weights? What are your feelings about doing that?

user1471556642 · 16/02/2024 10:40

I agree with @brunettemic, there is some terrible advice above.
Yes you do need to be in a calorie deficit but you do not need to cut out foods you enjoy, or starve yourself. I’m 5’3’’ size 14, 47yr old, eating 1800-1900 calories a day (on average over the week) and I’m reliably losing weight
Portion control has been the main thing for me, and we still have a takeaway once a week

brunettemic · 16/02/2024 10:38

@Sususudio I’ve oversimplified yes but the only way to lose weight, in the sense of removing excess fat, is to burn more than you consume, that’s a scientific fact. I agree about a mix of exercise between cardio and strength (I use resistance bands workouts on YouTube) but in the context of OP jumping into a whole new exercise regime is likely to fail, hence the small adjustments approach. You can trace back almost any “failed” attempt to shape up, lose weight or whatever to someone trying to make changes that are too big too quickly, setting unrealistic goals and the chances not being sustainable.

BestZebbie · 16/02/2024 10:38

A very straightforward way to close the gap between belly and breast projection is to buy a new bra! A middle-aged 'bosom' requires more scaffolding to stay up front near the collarbones than it would have taken in your 20s, so you may need to invest - proper measurements (probably less band more cup), sturdy construction and uplift including side support panels.

Sususudio · 16/02/2024 10:37

I probably eat 40 plants a week. I have been Zoe since my childhood😁But not making much difference in menopause.

Sususudio · 16/02/2024 10:36

I tried IF and am still doing it, but the weight only melts off my bum. Attempt low carb most days. It's very tough for me as I am veggie.

I recently had a hysterectomy; not sure if that has anything to do with anything.

5128gap · 16/02/2024 10:35

I agree to an extent @brunettemic but when you have so few calories to play with, you have to make hard choices to make sure you get all the nutrients you need and don't feel hungry all the time. Cutting out some things altogether like alcohol and foods of low value, or foods where there are a lot of calories for the nutrition supplied (like dairy and processed carbs) snd focusing on whole foods, ideally mainly plants, for example, is pretty restrictive, but can give you a lot more bang for your buck.

waistchallenge · 16/02/2024 10:34

Plenty of us on Weight Loss Chat low carb and/or do intermittent fasting and have had great success with it. Yes, it takes discipline like most things that are worth doing. Dieting and losing weight does involve cutting things out, that is logical because (apart from a few illnesses and drugs etc.) weight gain is caused by excess.

I'm a size 8 (tops) and 10 (bottoms). I feel pretty confident about giving advice on how I did that and maintained it. You can do this, @Sianholby !

Sususudio · 16/02/2024 10:29

@brunettemic I don't believe in dieting either, but am not sure what you suggest works for menopausal women.
I do need to do more lifting and build muscle, which I find super boring.
My diet cannot get any healthier, since I don't eat processed food and never have.

brunettemic · 16/02/2024 10:26

There’s some horrific advice on here, cut out this, cut out that…do not do that. Cutting things completely out of your diet and all these stupid keto diets, intermittent fasting is nonsense. You just have to manage your diet, control portions and be sensible. There’s a quote, “you can eat anything but you can’t eat everything”, which is so true. The reason people fail is because they start eating abnormally (keto, fasting etc) and then as soon as they go back to normal it’s all a waste of time. You can lose weight by only eating crisps and chocolate as long as you consume fewer calories than you burn (I’m not saying just eat crisps and chocolate!). Set realistic goals, eg lose 1lb a week, make small changes, eg an extra 500 steps per day than you do now etc. Don’t obsess over scales or how you look and you’ll start to see changes.

MamaGhina · 16/02/2024 10:25

Agree with those saying go easy on yourself OP. A lot of people would dream of being a size 12-14.

Reducing calorie intake consistently is hard! Especially when busy and tired looking after 3 children. My top tip would be to swap whatever you are having for lunch with a can of soup. It’s low cal, it’s cheap and it usually has a portion of veg. If you do that and make no other changes, you will drop some weight, I’m sure!

You sound like you are doing a good amount of exercise. If you added a 30 minute brisk walk every evening I think that would help. I go after DH gets in from work. I have a 30 minute circuit I do. I try really hard to do it whatever the weather and I find it makes a difference and gives me 30 minutes to think, when no one else is talking at to me.

Definitely don’t give up!

Sususudio · 16/02/2024 10:19

My BMI is 23.6 , size 10-12, and I am your shape. I am Asian and genetically predisposed to store fat on my belly. I am also menopausal. It sucks. No matter how much weight I lose, it only goes off my breasts and bum.

5128gap · 16/02/2024 10:16

I agree about the calories. For a short woman after a certain age the requirement seems tiny compared to what has become the norm to eat (and drink) these days. It doesn't help that we spend most of our lives believing the 'average' woman needs 2000 calories a day, when this often applies only to younger, taller and more active women than ourselves.

handfulofsugar · 16/02/2024 10:15

On a positive note your legs look great

waistchallenge · 16/02/2024 10:13

I'm the same, @AnnoyingMildew . It takes constant effort and I can't take my eye off the ball. But, going back to the idea of feeling it's impossible, no I don't think it's impossible or that we have to give up.

RandomMess · 16/02/2024 10:10

I'm very surprised MFP said 1500 to lose weight. How many calories is it saying that exercise burns and are you being 100% accurate with length and type of exercise as well as what you eat.

My maintenance calorie level is 1400 a I'm 5, to lose weight I need to be very strict on 1200 and ignore calories burned through exercise.

A great exercise to flatten your tummy is dead bugs and dish hold.

AnnoyingMildew · 16/02/2024 10:04

I'm the exact same shape as you, OP.

The only way I've managed to flatten down my stomach (and even then it wasn't completely flat) was to really really (obsessively) control my calories - whether that's intermittent fasting (which, is really just skipping meals), or sticking to 1200 calories per day (upping it to 1500 if I exercise regularly).

It's so frustrating that the options for staying slim(mer) feel so unsustainable - I'm not one of those people who if they eat reasonably, and exercise moderately, will ever stay slim.

Swipe left for the next trending thread