Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do I just give up? Am I just destined to be fat

235 replies

Sianholby · 15/02/2024 22:28

Just coming in here as I’m just feeling down at the moment. I’m perimenopausal, just started HRT and hate the way I look.
I swim and go on our home cross trainer twice a week. I work full time and have three kids. We eat relatively healthily and I’m trying to cut down my carbs.

i just look like a whale, my belly sticks out further than my breasts. I can just can’t shift this weight.
iVe attached a photo of me currently, I want to lose the belly and the fat below my breasts that sticks out. Any tips as exercising three times a week around work and children and walking almost everywhere just isn’t doing it

OP posts:
Brianmaysmagicfingers · 16/02/2024 17:06

I’m about the same height and was the same size/bmi. I’m 40 so not quite peri yet but have always struggled with weight and a healthy relationship with food. After having kids my weight just crept up.

last year I signed up for a trial for Noom and then forgot to cancel it. So I thought fuck it I’ve paid for it. Might as well do it. So for almost a year I’ve been following it and lost 3 stone.

so it is possible. I didn’t cut out any for groups at all. Just looked at my portions and made sure half my plate was filled with vegetables or salad and made some swaps with things (full fat mayo to extra light etc) so I got to carry on eating everything I loved. Logging everything I ate made me realise how much I was actually eating without realising it.

good luck!

Watchkeys · 16/02/2024 16:48

@Projectme

The thought of a calorie deficit for the next 18 months to lose the weight makes me want to cry tbh

Why? It can be delicious and filling, and include treats. Why is it such a problem?

RatatouillePie · 16/02/2024 15:45

@Sianholby

The problem with healthy eating (which is great) is that it's still far too easy to over-eat.

It's a simple case of too many calories, even though they are healthy ones.

My parents and a couple of friends swear by the 5-2 diet. They eat 500 calories on two days of the week (whichever two they want) then eat "normally" on the others (so don't have to think about dieting).

I just go for lots of exercise. I do about 15,000 steps a day then cardiovascular exercise for 3 hours week.

Choux · 16/02/2024 15:40

Beautiful3 · 16/02/2024 14:58

I'm exactly in the same boat as you. I have tried everything (e.g fruit and veg diet/juicing/slim fast/running 5 x a week). Fasting definitely works well for us, but I found it unsustainable. I hate being hungry. So I've been sticking to 1200 calories daily, using my fitness pal app. In a year, I've slowly gone from a size 16 to a 12. I'm aiming for a size 10 by christmas. I doing yoga every day and walking as much as I can. I'm still round like you, around my tummy. You can do it. Don't give up.

Well done. And well done to everyone who is sticking at whatever is their preferred diet and exercise regime.

I need to get back on My Fitness Pal as the OPs photo could be a photo of me. I am not happy with the way I look and only I can change my body.

Stillfalling · 16/02/2024 15:09

5128gap · 15/02/2024 22:38

I'm mid point healthy BMI, but I look just like you if I stand there letting my muscles slack and my spine curve. Stand up straight with your shoulders back and tighten your core. Do this ALL the time. It makes a world of difference once it becomes a habit.

Agree with this. My first though on seeking your photo was you could do a lot just by improving your posture.

AndSoFinally · 16/02/2024 14:58

I haven't read the whole thread, but I feel your pain

However youve got great legs and bum (if that's not too weird a comment!), so you're one up on me at least.

Good luck with your plan

Beautiful3 · 16/02/2024 14:58

I'm exactly in the same boat as you. I have tried everything (e.g fruit and veg diet/juicing/slim fast/running 5 x a week). Fasting definitely works well for us, but I found it unsustainable. I hate being hungry. So I've been sticking to 1200 calories daily, using my fitness pal app. In a year, I've slowly gone from a size 16 to a 12. I'm aiming for a size 10 by christmas. I doing yoga every day and walking as much as I can. I'm still round like you, around my tummy. You can do it. Don't give up.

Artemis6 · 16/02/2024 14:30

Sounds like you do a good amount of exercise.

However, this alone will not shift the pounds.

You get skinny in the kitchen and fit at the gym.

I am 54 and menopausal. My BMI is 23. I guess I could lose some weight but for me, getting older, it's more about health. I feel lucky to be here and am fed up with sabotaging my wellbeing with stress/guilt around food.

I try to eat less processed foods and more fruit and veg.

I walk the dog about 3 miles every day and go on the treadmill 3 or 4 times a week.

teaandtoastwithmarmite · 16/02/2024 14:09

Are you writing everything down you eat? I'm doing slimming world and tracking the food is the dealbreaker

VeryStressedMum · 16/02/2024 13:58

I agree it's a combination of peri menopause, lack of oestrogen etc however if you're not losing weight you're eating too much.

By all means do exercise it's very good for your heart health and body but to lose weight you have to cut down your calories.
Tweak it little by little until you find you are losing weight then adjust as you get lighter.

Eat healthy nutritious food and cut down processed carbs (like you are doing already)

You didn't put on excess weight overnight so don't aim to lose it too quickly even half a pound a week is great, it all adds up

Also think about doing weights.

MyLadyTheKingsMother · 16/02/2024 13:47

Exercise DAILY. 20 minutes of cardio in the living room will do if you can't get out. Work on your core stomach muscles. Stand up straight and suck your tummy in.

Track your calories like an obcessive and burn more than you put in.

GinaB8 · 16/02/2024 13:42

Sianholby · 15/02/2024 23:02

160cm so 5ft2/3. I feel like a weeble

Right OP, I’m 161cm (5ft3.5) and I maintain on 1500. I have to eat 1200 to lose. It’s shit, I know. Especially when I could eat 2000-2200 on active days in my early thirties just a few years ago before kids. Mind you, if you’re exercising loads it’ll obviously be a bit more.

WhatNoUsername · 16/02/2024 13:19

Pigeonqueen · 15/02/2024 23:36

Lack of oestrogen can lead to putting on weight around the middle - lots of googleable stuff about it out there. Happened to me. Your dose of HRT may not be correct, you may need to increase your oestrogen (and progesterone to balance if you take progesterone as well). Speak to a menopause specialist if your GP is not helpful.

I was going to say this. Looks like (at least partly) menopause belly. It's also harder to lose weight generally as your oestrogen drops. You might find that when you get your HRT to the right level your weight starts to come off.

brunettemic · 16/02/2024 13:17

5128gap · 16/02/2024 10:35

I agree to an extent @brunettemic but when you have so few calories to play with, you have to make hard choices to make sure you get all the nutrients you need and don't feel hungry all the time. Cutting out some things altogether like alcohol and foods of low value, or foods where there are a lot of calories for the nutrition supplied (like dairy and processed carbs) snd focusing on whole foods, ideally mainly plants, for example, is pretty restrictive, but can give you a lot more bang for your buck.

That’s sort of my point though, you shouldn’t be existing on a super low calorie diet, it’s not good for you or sustainable. A balanced diet should give you the ability to have a bit chocolate or whatever your vice is from time to time whilst still supporting your goals. Depending on how you approach it you can run a calories deficit say across the week and if your net position is a deficit it will help. Obviously if you 1,000 calories for 5 days then over the weekend go crazy it’s not going to be good for you. If I’m focusing on weight, which I tend not to do as for me it’s more about body image, I weigh myself for a week daily and then take the average.

Projectme · 16/02/2024 13:11

53, menopausal on HRT and your photo looks like me! I have same body shape but am a little taller at 5'5" and heavier I expect as my BMI is😱 33.9.

I was always a size 10/12. Had kids. Stopped smoking 13 years ago and that's when the weight crept up. It's been the last 6 years (since peri started) that the weight seriously started packing on. Life events and stress stopped me addressing my ever increasing waist (i no longer have one!) and now I'm at least 4 stone overweight.

Every attempt I make...calorie counting, slimpod, SW, WW, hypnotherapy, intuitive eating...lasts, at most, 2 days. I have shockingly bad issues with food and I wonder if it all stems from when I was in my teens/20s/30s where I restricted eating so much because of my desire to stay 10stone and in a 10/12 dress size, that my brain is just completely ignoring any attempts at following a restrictive diet again.

But I am sleep walking into major health issues if I continue on this road so I do HAVE to do something. The thought of a calorie deficit for the next 18 months to lose the weight makes me want to cry tbh. Just sick of it but needs must! It's so much harder the older one gets.

brunettemic · 16/02/2024 13:08

@Watchkeys I’m clearly being a touch flippant to make a point, of course keto and intermittent fasting help you lose weight. My point is they’re not long term solutions and fail the majority of times because people don’t make appropriate lifestyle changes to support their goals. People are told now, often via social media and the like, these days to try this crazy diet, or this miracle product or plan (V Shred I’m looking at you) and they end up going round in circles of peaks and troughs of weight/body shape/self image, whatever their goal might be. My advice is not eat less, get thin either, my advice is have simple, straight forward and achievable goals in a way that you can manage - people want to drop 2 sizes in 6 weeks and stupid things like that, it’s nonsense. Diet needs to be balanced out, swap lunchtime crisps for fruit, eat smaller portions than you do now if portion size is an issue (I’m not saying small portions). You can include treats in a balanced diet, you can eat bread, you can eat carbs, you can eat processed food, cutting all that out doesn’t need to be the approach in the same way they also can’t be all that you eat.

Marchintospring · 16/02/2024 13:07

brunettemic · 16/02/2024 10:26

There’s some horrific advice on here, cut out this, cut out that…do not do that. Cutting things completely out of your diet and all these stupid keto diets, intermittent fasting is nonsense. You just have to manage your diet, control portions and be sensible. There’s a quote, “you can eat anything but you can’t eat everything”, which is so true. The reason people fail is because they start eating abnormally (keto, fasting etc) and then as soon as they go back to normal it’s all a waste of time. You can lose weight by only eating crisps and chocolate as long as you consume fewer calories than you burn (I’m not saying just eat crisps and chocolate!). Set realistic goals, eg lose 1lb a week, make small changes, eg an extra 500 steps per day than you do now etc. Don’t obsess over scales or how you look and you’ll start to see changes.

Well of course when people go back to “ eating normally” they put on all the weight. It was never “normal” in the sense of being the right amount to stay thin.

You call it “ abnormal” but the thin people I know, whether it’s only crisps and chocolate or organic vegetables eat intermittently or limit there food in some way. They do it naturally or intentionally but you give them what a fatter person eats and they’ll become fat.

Telling over weight people to make small changes is fine but the reality is those changes need to be lifetime changes. It doesn’t matter if they diet hard or diet slowly.

MabelWotsits · 16/02/2024 13:00

I'd recommend wegovy.

I used to have a tummy like yours despite exercising loads and it didn't shift until I went on the wegovy and lost a few stone.

endofthecorridoor · 16/02/2024 12:47

Hi OP
I'm 52 if i relaxed and slouched i would look similar but am taller.

Its horrible to face but after 45 i would say it gets harder every year to loose weight. Exercise affects how your body looks when you loose weight and can see the toning , however swimming particularly does not burn off enough calories to make a difference. If one digestive biscuit for example has over 70 calories that's a lot of swimming just to burn that off.
The only way i can loose weight is to cut the carbs and eat very little every single day !! for months on end as it takes ages.
I do 10 fitness classes including spin running and weights and this makes virtually no difference to my weight.

jdebalt · 16/02/2024 12:44

Read Ultra Processed People by Chris Van Tulleken and the books by Tim Spector. It's amazing how much UPF makes a huge difference. Good luck!

CKL987 · 16/02/2024 12:44

I'd suggest your carb intake is the answer. Insulin resistance is a big thing for menopausal women because of all of our hormonal changes.
If you go very low carb you'll also find your hunger drops but that will only happen if you are strict and not if you cut carbs from one meal a day.

OhMyOhMyiy · 16/02/2024 12:42

I was always very thin. Then put a bit of weight on and when trying to shift it I actually put more on as did the dieting / exercising wrong. Went through this cycle a few times and ended up on 78kg at which point I thought I have to stop trying to loose it as doing it wrong.

I got the Joe Wicks app and followed the recipes and exercises and shifted the weight. The food was the key. Exercise important but as they say you can’t outrun a bad diet.

Zanatdy · 16/02/2024 12:38

Exercise / activity alone won’t shift much weight. Work out your TDEE online and drop calories by 500 a day to lose 1lb a week. I’ve lost 8-9lbs since New Year’s Day. It’s harder when we get older but not impossible. You can’t out run a bad diet as they say, 80% of weight is lost via what we eat

waistchallenge · 16/02/2024 12:37

BMI is fine as a tool for the vast majority of people. It slightly disadvantages tall people.

anxioussister · 16/02/2024 12:36

Haven’t read all replies - but in common with some PPS I think some of the issue for you is probably pelvic floor / core + the way you hold yourself (women often do after multiple pregnancies

The cross training + the swimming won’t make a jot of difference to that.

If you have some resources I would really recommend finding a female personal trainer who specialises in post natal care - it’s never too late to improve core function.

and then to work on building muscle by lifting weights a couple of times a week instead of swimming

Swipe left for the next trending thread