Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do I just give up? Am I just destined to be fat

235 replies

Sianholby · 15/02/2024 22:28

Just coming in here as I’m just feeling down at the moment. I’m perimenopausal, just started HRT and hate the way I look.
I swim and go on our home cross trainer twice a week. I work full time and have three kids. We eat relatively healthily and I’m trying to cut down my carbs.

i just look like a whale, my belly sticks out further than my breasts. I can just can’t shift this weight.
iVe attached a photo of me currently, I want to lose the belly and the fat below my breasts that sticks out. Any tips as exercising three times a week around work and children and walking almost everywhere just isn’t doing it

OP posts:
Muthaofcats · 16/02/2024 21:20

specialsauce · 16/02/2024 21:10

pause on exercise for now

for the love of geoff, do not take this absolute shite advice

Sorry but you’re incredibly rude. I’ve just lost 3 stone doing fast 800 after finding exercise alone wasn’t doing anything. I am now back to exercising and feeling incredible. Are you sat calling other peoples genuine attempts to help OP shite whilst admiring your six pack. I highly doubt it, and if you are, you probably don’t know how desperate it feels to be stuck overweight and struggling to shift it.

specialsauce · 16/02/2024 21:18

I've built my metabolism up through exercise @Toopolitetoask

this is great advice.

I'm just angry that so many people are on the 'starve yourself so you can eat cake at your friends birthday' brigade.

It's bullshit.

Where has the 'treat yourself with a burger' mantra come from? Fucking mcdonalds that's where. And now people feel deprived cause they can't eat shit.

BIWI · 16/02/2024 21:13

Are you ok @specialsauce? You seem to be very angry with people!

specialsauce · 16/02/2024 21:12

Muthaofcats · 16/02/2024 21:03

You can do it !

Just decide what day you’re going to do it and commit. Write yourself a long list of why and all the things you want for yourself.

then, pause on exercise for now. What you need is a significant calorie deficit. Exercise alone won’t help you lose weight, but will be key when you come to maintaining your new weight later. Obv there are lots of other longer term benefits too, but for now, your focus should be on shifting the weight.

If you did fast 800 youd fall into ketosis and not even feel hunger. You’d lose weight extremely fast which can be very motivating. It’s also excellent for you in terms of reducing cancer risk / inflammation etc. I don’t find longer term ‘trying to cut calories’ works because it’s too slow burn so one can give up because the results don’t seem worth it quickly enough. Lighter life is great if you prefer to take ‘food’ off the table for a bit. Any 800 cal a day diet whether Michael Moseley or lighter life you can expect to lose a stone a month.

go away with your 'don't exercise, don't eat instead' advice.

Crock of shit.

SkaterGrrrrl · 16/02/2024 21:12

The Maintenance Phase podcast is worth a listen.

https://www.maintenancephase.com/

xx

Maintenance Phase

https://www.maintenancephase.com

Toopolitetoask · 16/02/2024 21:11

@specialsauce there's a big difference between eating everything you want, and being able to enjoy food socially. Restricting food to 1200 calories a day is very, very limiting. Panicking because you've got no wiggle room in your TDEE to ever eat out, buy food on the go, or enjoy food with friends is not a good way to live and for some leads to disordered eating.

I mentioned up thread that I am the same height as the OP and do fine on 1800, because I've built my metabolism up through exercise. The majority of what I eat is nutritious food, but it is far easier to live life, share meals with my partner, socialise etc on 1800 than it is on 1400 or 1200.

GinaB8 · 16/02/2024 21:11

Muthaofcats · 16/02/2024 21:03

You can do it !

Just decide what day you’re going to do it and commit. Write yourself a long list of why and all the things you want for yourself.

then, pause on exercise for now. What you need is a significant calorie deficit. Exercise alone won’t help you lose weight, but will be key when you come to maintaining your new weight later. Obv there are lots of other longer term benefits too, but for now, your focus should be on shifting the weight.

If you did fast 800 youd fall into ketosis and not even feel hunger. You’d lose weight extremely fast which can be very motivating. It’s also excellent for you in terms of reducing cancer risk / inflammation etc. I don’t find longer term ‘trying to cut calories’ works because it’s too slow burn so one can give up because the results don’t seem worth it quickly enough. Lighter life is great if you prefer to take ‘food’ off the table for a bit. Any 800 cal a day diet whether Michael Moseley or lighter life you can expect to lose a stone a month.

Any 800 cal a day diet whether Michael Moseley or lighter life you can expect to lose a stone a month.

I imagine it does drop off you when it’s so low. Is this even enough calories for certain bodily functions like ovulation? My periods go out of whack if I restrict/exercise too much and I suspect I have anovulatory cycles when I do. It’s a genuine question if anyone can share any insight. I am more inclined to go on a slightly stricter diet to get the weight off faster too but I do worry about what this does to my body.

specialsauce · 16/02/2024 21:10

pause on exercise for now

for the love of geoff, do not take this absolute shite advice

specialsauce · 16/02/2024 21:08

You are doing a decent amount of exercise

what? are you taking the piss?

a swim and 2 go's on a cross trainer a week?

My son's walk to school on one day is more exercise than that.

Come on people - you all need to massively rethink what you think is a 'decent amount of exercise' . It's peanuts. Someone needs to call it out

Muthaofcats · 16/02/2024 21:03

You can do it !

Just decide what day you’re going to do it and commit. Write yourself a long list of why and all the things you want for yourself.

then, pause on exercise for now. What you need is a significant calorie deficit. Exercise alone won’t help you lose weight, but will be key when you come to maintaining your new weight later. Obv there are lots of other longer term benefits too, but for now, your focus should be on shifting the weight.

If you did fast 800 youd fall into ketosis and not even feel hunger. You’d lose weight extremely fast which can be very motivating. It’s also excellent for you in terms of reducing cancer risk / inflammation etc. I don’t find longer term ‘trying to cut calories’ works because it’s too slow burn so one can give up because the results don’t seem worth it quickly enough. Lighter life is great if you prefer to take ‘food’ off the table for a bit. Any 800 cal a day diet whether Michael Moseley or lighter life you can expect to lose a stone a month.

addictedtotheflats · 16/02/2024 20:57

You are doing a decent amount of exercise so I'd be inclined to say you are eating too many calories if you arent losing weight. All you need to do is be in a calorie deficit. Try something like my fitness pal or nutra check for a few weeks on maybe 1600/1700 calories a day, you might even be able to have more if you work out your bmr (not bmi) No restrictions on what you eat just stick to you calories.

specialsauce · 16/02/2024 20:56

yeah maybe.

I just feel annoyed that so many people on the weight loss threads respond with - just do this, just do that, then you can eat this and have some cake blah blah blah.

We all need to face facts - shit food + little movement equals big belly, high cholesterol and terrible health prospects.

Lets all just be honest.

We need to cut the shit, get busy and active, face it full frontal. Walk up some fucking steps every day. Literally, every day.

I'm gonna fucking kick the shit out of the two stone I need to lose after being 'woe is me' for way too long.

Let's do this thang!

Superstar22 · 16/02/2024 20:55

Please follow health with Holland on Instagram or anything related to cortisol…. It is likely you have high cortisol & this contributes to where fat is stored.

i know it’s so easy to say but the less stressed I am the better I look. So rather than “taking things” away from myself I try to be kinder & walk & eat & rest in healthy ways to be kind, rather than to punish myself

GinaB8 · 16/02/2024 20:50

specialsauce · 16/02/2024 20:48

oh ffs. When it's someone's birthday 'spilt half a cupcake'? wtf is wring with that?
We in the west expect to be able to eat all the shit coming then we wonder why we are unable to move properly and feel like shit.

Get with the real world.

Stop eating shit and start being healthy.

That's all there is to it.

If you think you 'deserve' or 'should have if you want' cake, chocolate and random weekly takeaways' and then expect to grow your belly. If your overall happiness depends on high calorie food then that's something strange you need to confront.

It's not rocket science.

Bad day at work, @specialsauce ? 😆

specialsauce · 16/02/2024 20:48

oh ffs. When it's someone's birthday 'spilt half a cupcake'? wtf is wring with that?
We in the west expect to be able to eat all the shit coming then we wonder why we are unable to move properly and feel like shit.

Get with the real world.

Stop eating shit and start being healthy.

That's all there is to it.

If you think you 'deserve' or 'should have if you want' cake, chocolate and random weekly takeaways' and then expect to grow your belly. If your overall happiness depends on high calorie food then that's something strange you need to confront.

It's not rocket science.

browneyes77 · 16/02/2024 20:10

@Sianholby I know the feeling!

I’m 46 and perimenopausal.

I do WW and work out but the weight is coming off soooo slowly!

I did WW and exercise before when I put weight on (about 3.5 yrs ago) and it dropped off then. But this time round since the perimenopause kicked in, it’s really not shifting!

One thing I’m yet to do that I haven’t because of a back injury is weight/strength training. Using weights in your workout helps build lean muscle which boosts your metabolism and burns fat. Might be worth adding to your exercise regime, as I know it will help me once I start doing it again.

Pigglyplaystruant99 · 16/02/2024 19:11

1400 calories is as much as I can eat if trying to lose weight too, so not much.

Pigglyplaystruant99 · 16/02/2024 19:10

I could never cut out bread. But to lose any weight I had to cut out alcohol and sugar. I only walk about a mile or two every day and that was enough. I also eat 5 small meals/graze every day. Weight slowly dropped off. As soon as I drank alcohol or chocolate again, it started to creep up. I've never been massively overweight bit trying to lose just 6lbs can be SO hard!

Toopolitetoask · 16/02/2024 19:01

@Watchkeys I think you're being somewhat obtuse. Given the OP said she's eating 1500 calories a day and can't bear the thought of 18 months of a calories deficit then just adding 'why, it can be delicious' doesn't exactly read as 'it can be delicious if you learn about nutrition, gradually increase your calories along with consistent resistance training, accept adding muscle and some fat for at least six months, and then start a calorie deficit'

But I think you know that. It's not exactly helpful to the OP but well done if it made you feel good.

hothotheatbag · 16/02/2024 18:46

The exercise is the icing on the cake, the food is the key.

You'd need to be about 1100 maybe 1200 to loose, and try and increase protein, lower carbs.

Maybe get some protein shakes, One for breakfast, try not to snack and one for lunch then a dinner.

You'll feel full and you'll 100% drop weight, when you feel lighter and see a fast result you can then refine and have a lovely breakfast of eggs etc and small lunch and dinner. And if you are busy you can revert back to the shakes.

Free soul protein is tasty, and they also have greens which are nice and make sure you are getting fluids in. I mix my shakes with milks sometimes and water others and pop in some peanut butter.

Beautiful3 · 16/02/2024 18:35

@Choux You can do it, I believe in you. A lot can change in a year. 💪 💪 💪

Sausagesinthesky · 16/02/2024 18:34

OP - exercise it’s good, but it’s your diet that’s making you overweight.

intermittent fasting is amazing - look at that. Cut out sugar and procecessed food and watch the weight melt off. Of course exercise it good for health overall and mentally, but weight is mainly diet.

GinaB8 · 16/02/2024 18:30

Toopolitetoask · 16/02/2024 18:03

@Watchkeys Can you show me a delicious, filling, food diary that includes treats and social events for an average 1000-1200 calories a day? As that's what the OP would need to be going for given by what she has shared so far.

When you're short and over 40, a much more realistic (and happier!) way to manage weight loss is to increase the metabolism first. Otherwise it's just a race to lower and lower calorie limits. And then you become the type of person who asks others in the office if they'll split half a cupcake when it's someone's birthday.

Yeah, I said upthread when I was in the gym often doing minimal cardio I ate up to 2200 Cals a day and maintained. At only 5ft3.5. Different story now after kids. More like 1500 to maintain and 1200 to lose. It’s miserable dieting. Exercise really makes a difference. I was hardly body building, just using some weights machines.

Watchkeys · 16/02/2024 18:13

@Toopolitetoask

Can you show me a delicious, filling, food diary that includes treats and social events for an average 1000-1200 calories a day

Doubt it. But why would I want to? I agree with you; up the metabolism. I've already suggested lifting weights rather than CV work. Then a kcal deficit doesn't have to be under 1200. Your question makes no sense.

Toopolitetoask · 16/02/2024 18:03

@Watchkeys Can you show me a delicious, filling, food diary that includes treats and social events for an average 1000-1200 calories a day? As that's what the OP would need to be going for given by what she has shared so far.

When you're short and over 40, a much more realistic (and happier!) way to manage weight loss is to increase the metabolism first. Otherwise it's just a race to lower and lower calorie limits. And then you become the type of person who asks others in the office if they'll split half a cupcake when it's someone's birthday.