Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do I just give up? Am I just destined to be fat

235 replies

Sianholby · 15/02/2024 22:28

Just coming in here as I’m just feeling down at the moment. I’m perimenopausal, just started HRT and hate the way I look.
I swim and go on our home cross trainer twice a week. I work full time and have three kids. We eat relatively healthily and I’m trying to cut down my carbs.

i just look like a whale, my belly sticks out further than my breasts. I can just can’t shift this weight.
iVe attached a photo of me currently, I want to lose the belly and the fat below my breasts that sticks out. Any tips as exercising three times a week around work and children and walking almost everywhere just isn’t doing it

OP posts:
waistchallenge · 16/02/2024 21:59

Advising people not to exercise is pretty bad advice tbf. I, too, have seen some clangers rolled out on these threads. Things like "just treat yourself" and "you don't need to restrict yourself". There's the phenomenon of the recent emphasis on the importance of diet being, by general consensus, morphed into something unrecognisable that's being repeated on most weight loss forums as gospel. I do see where @specialsauce is coming from on this.

specialsauce · 16/02/2024 21:58

BIWI · 16/02/2024 21:48

@specialsauce

Dr Michael Mosley - British Television Journalist, Producer and Presenter

Michael studied PPE at Oxford and then became an investment banker...before realising that this really wasn’t the industry for him...so he retrained as a doctor.

After studying medicine at the Royal Free Hospital in London and qualifying as a doctor...he realised that this wasn’t really the industry for him either!

Michael joined the BBC as a trainee assistant producer and over the ensuing 25 years has made numerous science and history documentaries for the BBC, first behind the camera and more recently as a presenter.

https://www.ifst.org/events/michael-mosley#:~:text=Michael%20studied%20PPE%20at%20Oxford,the%20industry%20for%20him%20either!

Fair do's.
It reads everywhere else, except for the BBC pages (his biggest promoters) that he studied psychiatry but switched to journalism in his 20's and is not registered as a doctor. He is definitely not a registered doctor. He clearly never practised as a doctor. He basically just graduated from medical school then switched career to journalism.

Muthaofcats · 16/02/2024 21:57

specialsauce · 16/02/2024 21:51

You advised the OP to 'stop exercising'.

Are you completely happy that she should do this?

I think it's shit advice. I stand by my original post.

I am not 'deranged' or having a 'bad day'. I just can't sit here and watch people sanctimoniously dishing out horrendous advice. Especially to someone who is actually already doing really fucking well.

Actually I said ‘pause on exercising for now, exercise alone won’t help you to shift weight’.

I stand by that. Funny you call me sanctimonious - assuming because I say it worked for me whilst you’re still swearing at people online without having found something that works for you.

calling my advice ‘shit’ is rude. It just is. There’s no need to talk to people like that.

if exercise alone was working for OP then she wouldn’t be posting on a forum upset about not shifting weight despite her best efforts. It’s not sanctimonious to share stories and suggestions.

teaandtoastwithmarmite · 16/02/2024 21:53

I'm not sure if I'm missing something but I don't get the level of nastiness directed @specialsauce

Muthaofcats · 16/02/2024 21:53

OP the other thing I’ve seen that has worked for others is Zoe. It is expensive though and it wasn’t great for me but I do know others who say they struggled for years and now that they follow a Zoe approach it’s the first time in their life they aren’t calorie counting or constantly hungry / miserable. It helped me to realise how different each of our bodies are - so what would work for me might not fit you. Understanding the types of foods that send me into a sugar spike and which keep a good balance was helpful. I think I will incorporate what I learned from Zoe now that im trying to maintain but the reason it didn’t work for me is I didn’t lose weight doinG it and that was the main priority for me which is why I wanted something I’d see results with and fasting was amazing for that.

specialsauce · 16/02/2024 21:51

Muthaofcats · 16/02/2024 21:46

I have literally struggled with weight too which is why I am offering my experience and support to someone in the same boat. You’re on one tonight and I’m sorry you’re not feeling good about yourself. No one is laughing at anyone for weight struggles.

If the approach you’re so incandescent about is so good then I assume you are a healthy weight and feeling great right now. I don’t know many significantly overweight muscular healthy people, if you are then great, and if you’re happy with yourself as you are then even better.

oP said that exercising a lot isn’t getting her results, and lots will agree that that’s because calorie deficit is the only way to lose weight. If exercise alone was enough she wouldn’t be struggling now.

You advised the OP to 'stop exercising'.

Are you completely happy that she should do this?

I think it's shit advice. I stand by my original post.

I am not 'deranged' or having a 'bad day'. I just can't sit here and watch people sanctimoniously dishing out horrendous advice. Especially to someone who is actually already doing really fucking well.

BIWI · 16/02/2024 21:48

@specialsauce

Dr Michael Mosley - British Television Journalist, Producer and Presenter

Michael studied PPE at Oxford and then became an investment banker...before realising that this really wasn’t the industry for him...so he retrained as a doctor.

After studying medicine at the Royal Free Hospital in London and qualifying as a doctor...he realised that this wasn’t really the industry for him either!

Michael joined the BBC as a trainee assistant producer and over the ensuing 25 years has made numerous science and history documentaries for the BBC, first behind the camera and more recently as a presenter.

https://www.ifst.org/events/michael-mosley#:~:text=Michael%20studied%20PPE%20at%20Oxford,the%20industry%20for%20him%20either!

Michael Mosley

Dr Michael Mosley - British Television Journalist, Producer and PresenterMichael studied PPE at Oxford and then became an investment banker...before realising that this really wasn’t the industry for him...so he retrained as a doctor.After studying med...

https://www.ifst.org/events/michael-mosley#:~:text=Michael%20studied%20PPE%20at%20Oxford,the%20industry%20for%20him%20either!

Muthaofcats · 16/02/2024 21:46

specialsauce · 16/02/2024 21:40

(although realistically I doubt many people who are significantly over weight have much muscle to preserve anyway 🤣)

Well that's quite rude and also untrue. There you are - laughing at people carrying more weight. How fucking dare you.

People carrying weight have pretty well developed muscle sets as they need them to carry the extra weight. They are usually very strong. This puts them at a great advantage to use this as an aid to exercise and burn the fat calories that are holding them back.

Hence my anger at people being advised on this, and other threads, to 'stop exercising and fast'. It's terrible advice. Exercise should never be given up and replaced with not eating. It's irresponsible and could seriously impact the health of many people.

I have literally struggled with weight too which is why I am offering my experience and support to someone in the same boat. You’re on one tonight and I’m sorry you’re not feeling good about yourself. No one is laughing at anyone for weight struggles.

If the approach you’re so incandescent about is so good then I assume you are a healthy weight and feeling great right now. I don’t know many significantly overweight muscular healthy people, if you are then great, and if you’re happy with yourself as you are then even better.

oP said that exercising a lot isn’t getting her results, and lots will agree that that’s because calorie deficit is the only way to lose weight. If exercise alone was enough she wouldn’t be struggling now.

specialsauce · 16/02/2024 21:45

BIWI · 16/02/2024 21:43

He studied at the Royal Free in London and qualified as a doctor.

(Although I'm sure you could have googled that yourself Hmm)

Upon graduation from medical school, and having become disillusioned by psychiatry, Mosley joined a trainee assistant producer scheme at the BBC in 1985

He studied psychiatry. He is not a qualified doctor.

BBC - Wikipedia

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/British_Broadcasting_Corporation

teaandtoastwithmarmite · 16/02/2024 21:45

Psychiatry apparently. He's not a dietician

specialsauce · 16/02/2024 21:43

BIWI · 16/02/2024 21:37

Michael Moseley is a qualified doctor.

I think, @specialsauce, you need to step away from the computer/your phone for a while. You're not really doing yourself any favours and, to be honest, you're sounding a bit deranged.

Being rude to other posters really isn't a good look.

What medical qualification does he have please?

BIWI · 16/02/2024 21:43

He studied at the Royal Free in London and qualified as a doctor.

(Although I'm sure you could have googled that yourself Hmm)

specialsauce · 16/02/2024 21:41

Muthaofcats · 16/02/2024 21:37

He is a doctor? You’re right he is currently a journalist but he has medical qualifications so you’re quite mistaken. Look, if it’s not for you, it’s not for you. I’ve seen people have great success with it, and I have too. I hope you find something you can feel positive about.

Edited

What medical qualifications does he have?

teaandtoastwithmarmite · 16/02/2024 21:41

I started last January with walking 10000 steps a day. I joined slimming world and did a weekly clubbercise class. Previously if I exercised I found I didn't watch what I ate because 'I've exercised so it's fine'. Once I started losing the weight I moved onto couch 2 5k then I joined the gym. The weeks I track what I eat and stay on plan I lose, the weeks I don't but exercise I don't. I don't think starving yourself or fasting is sustainable but I know it works for some. Slimming world doesn't work for everyone but ultimately it's the food which makes you put on the weight and reducing the junk is what will make you lose it. The exercise will make you feel good, tone you up and motivate you

specialsauce · 16/02/2024 21:40

(although realistically I doubt many people who are significantly over weight have much muscle to preserve anyway 🤣)

Well that's quite rude and also untrue. There you are - laughing at people carrying more weight. How fucking dare you.

People carrying weight have pretty well developed muscle sets as they need them to carry the extra weight. They are usually very strong. This puts them at a great advantage to use this as an aid to exercise and burn the fat calories that are holding them back.

Hence my anger at people being advised on this, and other threads, to 'stop exercising and fast'. It's terrible advice. Exercise should never be given up and replaced with not eating. It's irresponsible and could seriously impact the health of many people.

Muthaofcats · 16/02/2024 21:37

specialsauce · 16/02/2024 21:31

Yeah - he's making loads of money out of that little nugget isn't he. Initially that was for people who were pre-diabetic - now he's selling it as weight loss. He'll sell it for wherever the next money maker is. He's sold himself out. He's not even qualified to be advising the nation on their health. He's got no medical qualifications. He's literally a journalist.

He is a doctor? You’re right he is currently a journalist but he has medical qualifications so you’re quite mistaken. Look, if it’s not for you, it’s not for you. I’ve seen people have great success with it, and I have too. I hope you find something you can feel positive about.

BIWI · 16/02/2024 21:37

Michael Moseley is a qualified doctor.

I think, @specialsauce, you need to step away from the computer/your phone for a while. You're not really doing yourself any favours and, to be honest, you're sounding a bit deranged.

Being rude to other posters really isn't a good look.

Muthaofcats · 16/02/2024 21:35

GinaB8 · 16/02/2024 21:11

Any 800 cal a day diet whether Michael Moseley or lighter life you can expect to lose a stone a month.

I imagine it does drop off you when it’s so low. Is this even enough calories for certain bodily functions like ovulation? My periods go out of whack if I restrict/exercise too much and I suspect I have anovulatory cycles when I do. It’s a genuine question if anyone can share any insight. I am more inclined to go on a slightly stricter diet to get the weight off faster too but I do worry about what this does to my body.

Not sure on impact on conception so would speak to doctor about that but I certainly wouldn’t have whilst pregnant or breast feeding either. I guess only consideration is that it’s healthier to conceive when a healthy bmi so arguably losing weight before doing so might help to conceive and lead to a healthier pregnancy. But this I deffo would speak to an expert about. I’d probably be focusing on nutrition and reducing stress if I was looking to conceive as the starting point.

specialsauce · 16/02/2024 21:31

Muthaofcats · 16/02/2024 21:25

Is it though? I understand if you don’t believe me. I’m just a stranger on the internet and ultimately what works for me might not work for you. But lots of doctors will tell you the same thing. Have you read Michael moseleys fast 800? It’s a great place to start.

Yeah - he's making loads of money out of that little nugget isn't he. Initially that was for people who were pre-diabetic - now he's selling it as weight loss. He'll sell it for wherever the next money maker is. He's sold himself out. He's not even qualified to be advising the nation on their health. He's got no medical qualifications. He's literally a journalist.

Muthaofcats · 16/02/2024 21:31

specialsauce · 16/02/2024 21:25

but if you stop doing any exercise you must realise that you are losing muscle which is going to make you ill in the long run?

You know this right?

I don't have a six pack hahahahah. I wouldn't want one. I have loads to lose but I sure as fuck aint gonna sit in a chair and eat nothing for six months hoping to waste away.

Sounds like you’re going to remain over weight with your current attitude if you can be that negative and dismissive of someone else’s experience.

Recent studies suggest you don’t lose muscle on a low cal diet no. although I only recently read that. I had assumed the same as you previously but my recent fasting hasn’t affected my muscle (although realistically I doubt many people who are significantly over weight have much muscle to preserve anyway 🤣)

Also the slight impact on health of limiting exercise to lighter exercise only for a few weeks, like walking or swimming, would be vastly out weighed by the health benefits of being a healthy weight. Exercise is just easier when you’re not over weight too, so you’re more likely to want to do it and stick to it.

I suspect scoffing at well meaning strangers on the internet isn’t going to make you feel good about yourself really . If you were coming from a place with an alternative suggestion that had worked for you , that’s different, but if you’re just being unpleasant because you disagree with the approach I followed then I’d suggest there are better ways to engage in that dialogue?

BIWI · 16/02/2024 21:27

The thing is, @specialsauce, different things work for different people. And people on these threads are only trying to help.

I'm pretty sure we all know that if we ate healthily and did lots of walking about and active stuff we wouldn't be in this mess.

Trouble is, define 'healthily'?! It depends entirely on which approach you believe in is better. I will always argue that low carb is healthier than low fat. The low fat advocates will disagree.

And arguing that people should be more active to lose weight is very much the cornerstone of the whole 'eat less, move more' approach, which many would also argue is faulty.

I hope you manage to find a way that works for you - but don't knock approaches that others might have found works for them and/or are advocating for others.

Muthaofcats · 16/02/2024 21:25

specialsauce · 16/02/2024 21:12

go away with your 'don't exercise, don't eat instead' advice.

Crock of shit.

Is it though? I understand if you don’t believe me. I’m just a stranger on the internet and ultimately what works for me might not work for you. But lots of doctors will tell you the same thing. Have you read Michael moseleys fast 800? It’s a great place to start.

specialsauce · 16/02/2024 21:25

Muthaofcats · 16/02/2024 21:20

Sorry but you’re incredibly rude. I’ve just lost 3 stone doing fast 800 after finding exercise alone wasn’t doing anything. I am now back to exercising and feeling incredible. Are you sat calling other peoples genuine attempts to help OP shite whilst admiring your six pack. I highly doubt it, and if you are, you probably don’t know how desperate it feels to be stuck overweight and struggling to shift it.

but if you stop doing any exercise you must realise that you are losing muscle which is going to make you ill in the long run?

You know this right?

I don't have a six pack hahahahah. I wouldn't want one. I have loads to lose but I sure as fuck aint gonna sit in a chair and eat nothing for six months hoping to waste away.

Muthaofcats · 16/02/2024 21:23

Toopolitetoask · 16/02/2024 21:11

@specialsauce there's a big difference between eating everything you want, and being able to enjoy food socially. Restricting food to 1200 calories a day is very, very limiting. Panicking because you've got no wiggle room in your TDEE to ever eat out, buy food on the go, or enjoy food with friends is not a good way to live and for some leads to disordered eating.

I mentioned up thread that I am the same height as the OP and do fine on 1800, because I've built my metabolism up through exercise. The majority of what I eat is nutritious food, but it is far easier to live life, share meals with my partner, socialise etc on 1800 than it is on 1400 or 1200.

It definitely is restrictive socially at first but most of the time people who are overweight tend to be so miserable they’re not enjoying socialising that much anyway. 8 weeks focusing on losing weight would be worth the slight restriction in the long run. And it doesn’t mean no socialising, can still go out and enjoy a drink without it needing to be alcoholic or go to the cinema or for a walk. I’d be asking myself why good as so required to have a good time. Ultimately I agree it’s limiting to do a low cal diet but I’d got to a place where I felt so crap whenever I went out, nothing to wear as so overweight etc that it wasn’t enjoyable whereas now I feel so much better and more likely to accept invites to things

specialsauce · 16/02/2024 21:22

@BIWI thanks for asking.

Yes I am quite livid this evening. Purely because I've been working out how to lose 2 stone and get fit and there are so many ridiculous diet/starve yourself/do this/do that advice and it's all absolute crap. It becomes like word salad after a while. I'm pretty sure we all know that if we ate healthily and did lots of walking about and active stuff we wouldn't be in this mess.

Everyone wants a quick fix but it DOESNT EXIST.

Swipe left for the next trending thread