Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder why some women Aren’t upset about men being in their safe spaces?

321 replies

Lion400 · 15/02/2024 21:27

Why would we make it easier for men to be in our safe spaces? Don’t twist my words. This is not about being anti trans women - this is about men not being in women’s safe spaces. Why should women have to allow men in so as to ‘save their feelings’? What about women’s safety, feelings and wishes?

Given stories such as these - examples only but they quite clearly demonstrate the issue. As if anyone needs this. The stats are easily available.

https://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/home-news/shana-grice-murder-stalking-police-sussex-a8862611.html?fbclid=IwAR0bJYAs849f0I9VFv7tHw3aguB5C8HZi3yyOMr4LxxIRURs0HBxrc_TxzE

And now the disappointing John Lewis (aka Stonewall) disaster.

https://www.jamesesses.com/p/the-trans-takeover-of-john-lewis

Who puts women first, apart from JKR and friends. It’s a limited list.

To wonder why some women Aren’t upset about men being in their safe spaces?
To wonder why some women Aren’t upset about men being in their safe spaces?
OP posts:
GabriellaMontez · 16/02/2024 10:59

pointythings · 16/02/2024 09:19

I think it's horrific to use this stalker case as leverage. It is yet again deliberately conflating transwomen and predatory males. This man was not trans. What he did is irrelevant to this debate. A truly pathetic effort.

How should we tell the difference?

For example on a single sex ward. What do you think the criteria should be?

scorpiogirly · 16/02/2024 10:56

ShiteRider · 16/02/2024 06:58

It’s not a word salad at all and it’s a valid point. By making everyone use the toilets which are for the biological sex they were born in, this allows people presenting as men into women’s loos. Which means that predators don’t even have to go to the effort of dressing as a woman to get entry to those spaces.

Ultimately the issue is predators, not trans people in general. And they’re not known for their honesty and morals so will abuse whatever system they’re presented with

Of course the answer is third spaces and individual cubicles

Whilst I admit that it isn't always possible to tell that a trans identified female was born female after transition in some cases, I do not think I or anyone would be fooled by a biological man into thinking they were ever female to begin with.

But third spaces do seem like the obvious answer. But as we know, they don't want that.

TheKeatingFive · 16/02/2024 10:35

GabriellaMontez · 16/02/2024 10:33

Judging from a scan of the responses it's about selfishness.

"I'm not bothered/ I'm not a woman in prison/ I'm not vulnerable on a hospital ward".

But I do think this selfishness arises from stupidity (or perhaps a lack of imagination in some cases). The idea that it will never be "me".

And in fairness, there is a lot of social pressure to sweep this under the carpet.

People are starting to wake up though - thankfully

ItsFunToBeAVampire · 16/02/2024 10:35

pointythings · 16/02/2024 10:23

Not at all. You dragged a crime committed by a non trans male into it. We all know that predatory and violent males are a problem. But your arguments would be far more relevant if you quoted crimes involving actual transwomen. As it is, you are still insidiously conflating male crime with the threat posed specifically by transwomen.

I am all for not allowing male criminals who have been caught to conveniently identify as female. I would however like to know what solutions you have for the issues that exist without effectively erasing the rights of trans people.

The point is that men like the stalker are now welcomed into female spaces because people don't care enough to object. How do we know which is a harmless male and which isn't, regardless of whatever they're thinking in their own heads?

When predators realise that all they have to do is claim they're a transwoman and be ushered into women's spaces, we have a problem.

I don't get how its so hard to see the implications.

GabriellaMontez · 16/02/2024 10:33

Judging from a scan of the responses it's about selfishness.

"I'm not bothered/ I'm not a woman in prison/ I'm not vulnerable on a hospital ward".

But I do think this selfishness arises from stupidity (or perhaps a lack of imagination in some cases). The idea that it will never be "me".

TheKeatingFive · 16/02/2024 10:28

erasing the rights of trans people.

Why would anyone have the right to access sex specific places that don't belong to them?

Lion400 · 16/02/2024 10:27

pointythings · 16/02/2024 10:23

Not at all. You dragged a crime committed by a non trans male into it. We all know that predatory and violent males are a problem. But your arguments would be far more relevant if you quoted crimes involving actual transwomen. As it is, you are still insidiously conflating male crime with the threat posed specifically by transwomen.

I am all for not allowing male criminals who have been caught to conveniently identify as female. I would however like to know what solutions you have for the issues that exist without effectively erasing the rights of trans people.

No. So it was the first point (or you are doubling down with the second point. Who knows). Lots of (most?) people on this thread do understand the post.

OP posts:
TheKeatingFive · 16/02/2024 10:27

Got me wondering whether truly mixed toilets would actually be safer for everyone, men, women, transwomen, transmen, children. They’d be busier. There would be no issue about parents accompanying their children.

Assuming there are secure cubicles, maybe. I can see an argument that it would be safer for women than how things stand now - even if that sounds counter intuitive.

But ultimately, I suspect most men want their space too and wouldn't be keen. I also think the type of predatory male who's pushing to access women's spaces, wouldn't be as interested if it wasn't taboo.

It's an interesting thought.

pointythings · 16/02/2024 10:23

Lion400 · 16/02/2024 10:03

Let’s see. Your response is one of two things.
Either your levels of comprehension and analysis are so poor you don’t understand the post at all; or you are purposefully obsfucating. I suspect the latter. I’d rather the latter I suppose, that’s more the expected narrative.

Not at all. You dragged a crime committed by a non trans male into it. We all know that predatory and violent males are a problem. But your arguments would be far more relevant if you quoted crimes involving actual transwomen. As it is, you are still insidiously conflating male crime with the threat posed specifically by transwomen.

I am all for not allowing male criminals who have been caught to conveniently identify as female. I would however like to know what solutions you have for the issues that exist without effectively erasing the rights of trans people.

TheKeatingFive · 16/02/2024 10:20

pointythings · 16/02/2024 09:19

I think it's horrific to use this stalker case as leverage. It is yet again deliberately conflating transwomen and predatory males. This man was not trans. What he did is irrelevant to this debate. A truly pathetic effort.

I will give you the benefit of the doubt here and assume you just don't understand the implications.

As soon as we allow transwomen (however that term is understood) into women's spaces, we are allowing every single man, potentially.

Because all a man has to say is that he 'feels he is a woman'. Then he is entitled to access. There is no way of us limiting that to only the 'good' ones or any reliable marker to tell us who is who.

That will be taken advantage of. It already has been.

KimberleyClark · 16/02/2024 10:14

I was in London for the day recently. Visited the National Portrait Gallery and Lightroom. Both venues had mixed toilets. In the case of the NPG the cubicles were self contained with washbasins. In the Lightroom handwashing area was communal. Got me wondering whether truly mixed toilets would actually be safer for everyone, men, women, transwomen, transmen, children. They’d be busier. There would be no issue about parents accompanying their children. I’m fully prepared to have my arse handed to me though.

Lion400 · 16/02/2024 10:05

jeaux90 · 16/02/2024 08:07

@Lion400 I'm with you.
The trans movement has done a proper number on many of these posters.

As far as I can tell everything out of this movement has benefitted men, and seems more MRA

Bring back radical feminism, proper feminism that focuses on the most vulnerable women in society.

Women in prisons, rape crisis centres, DV shelters, women who find themselves in prostitution etc these are the women we focus on.

These women rely on good safeguarding, safeguarding means no male is allowed in our spaces however they identify.

Eroding boundaries for male performance of femininity is the stupidest thing I've ever seen.

Yes @jeaux90 . Exactly and well said.

OP posts:
Lion400 · 16/02/2024 10:03

pointythings · 16/02/2024 09:19

I think it's horrific to use this stalker case as leverage. It is yet again deliberately conflating transwomen and predatory males. This man was not trans. What he did is irrelevant to this debate. A truly pathetic effort.

Let’s see. Your response is one of two things.
Either your levels of comprehension and analysis are so poor you don’t understand the post at all; or you are purposefully obsfucating. I suspect the latter. I’d rather the latter I suppose, that’s more the expected narrative.

OP posts:
ChunkyTofu · 16/02/2024 10:03

BIossomtoes · 16/02/2024 09:13

if I see a male in the ladies, I get out ASAP.

It might be a trans man who you seem to think has every right to be there - how would you know?

This is an odd response to a poster who said her own sister was raped in the toilets - I think leaving it there's someone she thinks is a man there is a perfectly valid response, and if a tiny percentage might be biologically female surely she is still making a sensible choice

AccidentallyWesAnderson · 16/02/2024 09:59

jeaux90 · 16/02/2024 08:07

@Lion400 I'm with you.
The trans movement has done a proper number on many of these posters.

As far as I can tell everything out of this movement has benefitted men, and seems more MRA

Bring back radical feminism, proper feminism that focuses on the most vulnerable women in society.

Women in prisons, rape crisis centres, DV shelters, women who find themselves in prostitution etc these are the women we focus on.

These women rely on good safeguarding, safeguarding means no male is allowed in our spaces however they identify.

Eroding boundaries for male performance of femininity is the stupidest thing I've ever seen.

Excellent post.

goingrouge · 16/02/2024 09:58

pointythings · 16/02/2024 09:19

I think it's horrific to use this stalker case as leverage. It is yet again deliberately conflating transwomen and predatory males. This man was not trans. What he did is irrelevant to this debate. A truly pathetic effort.

I agree.

RinklyRomaine · 16/02/2024 09:48

@ShiteRider What don't you follow? You are trying to divert to say that we have to accept women who identify as trans so any man could just pretend to be those women. I'm saying I don't have a problem with them using the mens, they pose no risk to me or those men. Men of course can object and I wouldn't blame them. It's still not an argument for ANY male to use women's spaces. Regardless of identity.

pointythings · 16/02/2024 09:19

I think it's horrific to use this stalker case as leverage. It is yet again deliberately conflating transwomen and predatory males. This man was not trans. What he did is irrelevant to this debate. A truly pathetic effort.

BringBackLilt · 16/02/2024 09:18

BIossomtoes · 16/02/2024 09:13

if I see a male in the ladies, I get out ASAP.

It might be a trans man who you seem to think has every right to be there - how would you know?

Excuse me while I go and find my tattoo gun...

BIossomtoes · 16/02/2024 09:13

if I see a male in the ladies, I get out ASAP.

It might be a trans man who you seem to think has every right to be there - how would you know?

Parkrunprom · 16/02/2024 09:10

Trans women that quietly want to live their lives don’t bother me. What bothers me about women’s spaces being opened up to men is that if gives any males bad actors an excuse to waltz right in and you are a bigot if you question them. This is the danger allowing trans women into women’s spaces poses.

ShiteRider · 16/02/2024 09:08

RinklyRomaine · 16/02/2024 07:56

@ShiteRider It's not about everyone using sex based facilities, tho, is it? It's about men, however they identify, using sex based facilities.

I don’t follow?

BringBackLilt · 16/02/2024 09:02

GPTec1 · 16/02/2024 08:38

Have you ever been to a Scandinavian country?

Police not acting against stalkers and men who pose a risk to women and girls is down to poor policing and cuts in the funding to things like the justice system and refuges for women fleeing domestic violence.

Which is why JKR has spent millions of her own money setting up female only refuges because victims of rape can't use the underfunded existing refuges because they are letting men in.

risefromyourgrave · 16/02/2024 08:55

The man who raped me nearly 30 years ago now says he is a transwoman, believe me, you would not want him in the toilets with you…

literalviolence · 16/02/2024 08:46

literalviolence · 16/02/2024 08:34

TW have wanted in ladies loos. That kind of sexual assault (making others see) is also dangerous. My sister was raped by a male in the ladies. He probably wasn't trans but once you make it OK for some males to use them you lose the boundary for all. I.e. if I see a male in the ladies, I get out ASAP. Now I'm being told it will be more commonplace and if I just want to pee, I have to take my chances.

*wanked in public loos.

Swipe left for the next trending thread