Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To explode at family pressuring to see newborn?

457 replies

coconean · 15/02/2024 20:25

I have a newborn and not had the best birth and have been quite poorly.

I have explained to family several times now when I am ready I will let them know.
Quite a few of family members have complained of fevers, flu etc so for obvious reasons im keeping my distance.

Nobody seems to be respecting what I am saying and keep bombarding me with texts, like let me enjoy my baby!

I feel ready to explode, I didnt do this when they had babies and left them to it until they were ready and just want the same respect.

OP posts:
FortunataTagnips · 16/02/2024 10:31

Honestly? I think you need to get over yourself. Absolutely fine to ask people not to come if they’re unwell, but otherwise for heaven’s sake let them meet the baby!
My DD was born premature and with a surprise disability. She spent her first month in hospital. Even so, family saw her on her first day, and I’m so glad they did. We now have some happy pictures to look back on from what was, in retrospect, a very confusing and frightening time.

Nanny0gg · 16/02/2024 10:29

YoBeaches · 16/02/2024 09:41

@Bbq1 I think your view point here is quite dangerous. We shouldn't be saying it's natural
And normal for family to visits so soon, it creates a wild expectation on women to 'perform' and hand their maybe out when they may not be ready, emotionally of physically

this lady spent 2 days post birth on a high dependency ward. Her experience is entirely different to yours as are her relationships.

You might have wanted people to visit, but that doesn't make it natural or normal.

So so so many threads on Mumsnet from
Women who are out under pressure from family's.

We need more empathy and empowerment for mums, and support from their partners to advocate for them when they can't.

I think 'dangerous' is a bit extreme

I think we do put pressure on new parents but by 'over-dramatising' to a degree.

If it's been a straightforward birth (and the OP's obviously wasn't) then all this hunkering down (imo) is over the top.

It's your family, do what you want to do. But it's a normal part of life.

Bananasandtoast · 16/02/2024 10:27

Another of these sad threads.
Why must women always fight for their right to their own boundaries?
Some people find it very difficult to accept that the post partum period is absolutely all about the mother and baby - their health/safety/feelings are paramount.
It's not about what everyone else wants at this time and this should be so glaringly obvious that a quick text saying that you are unwell, need to rest, hope to see them when better should be the end of it.
If you need to explode, then explode. There's only so much asking nicely you can do when people will not listen nicely.

Nosleeptheo · 16/02/2024 10:25

I would send either one of these 2 messages

No fuck off I will let you know when we are ready as right now I feel like shit

Or

More then happy for you to come round. The hoovering really needs to be done and the pile of dishes in the sink would be great. As you know iv been very ill and a traumatic birth so yes help would be appreciated and bonus you can see the baby afterwards (no kissing though).

I had the same issue when I had my 1st and had to put my foot down with my 2nd i just ignored people until I was ready.

Hope you are feeling better soon, don't let them push you around your health and the babies health is more important then them seeing the baby x

Nanny0gg · 16/02/2024 10:25

The only thing I really disagree with here, is that whatever visitors you do or don't have, you will still bond with your baby unless possible PND

You don't need a solid week/month to do that. If you want that time on your own that's up to you but you will bond anyway

Matronic6 · 16/02/2024 10:16

Bbq1 · 16/02/2024 10:00

Okay. I'm obviously getting piled on here for sharing a different viewpoint . My family relationships are very close and my dh was present at the birth and most of the time afterwards. He did advocate for me during the birth. It's apparently "dangerous" according to you to have an alternative view to shutting everyone out and "hunkering down". You think that but to call my view, my experience dangerousl is ridiculous . No womam is going to feel pressure to "perform" just because I was more than happy to see my close family the day after my ds was born.

I think the point the other poster was trying to make was that your experience is not universal and that it's not right to compare it to OP's situation. It's completely irrelevant. That's what they said is dangerous, the assumptions that 'all women' must be happy to have visitors on day one because 'some women' were happy to.

If you think you are getting piled on by the few responses to you, spare a thought for OP who has had multiple people call her precious, OTT and worse because she has a different perspective, experience and need than they did.

MidnightPatrol · 16/02/2024 10:09

Donoteven · 15/02/2024 20:36

You'll be on in a couple of years complaining that your DC's grandparents and uncles and aunts aren't interested in the DC and barely bother visiting, a precedent that you are setting now.

In my experience people are v desperate to see babies when they are born, and then generally lose interest regardless.

I was amazed at all the random people that came out of the woodwork around my due date to want to know if I’d had the baby yet.

Also - not a single person asked about me. I always make sure to ask about the new mother now - she seems to get forgotten in the excitement about the baby, despite probably having just been through the biggest medical event of her life.

Lollypop701 · 16/02/2024 10:03

If the op was just very unwell would she be expected to have visitors? I don’t think anyone would say yes. Op is unwell and also dealing with a newborn so I’d also tell them to bugger off, it’s not like she will see them anyway as they don’t usually give a shit about her

Imfreetofeelgood · 16/02/2024 10:02

YADNBU - you have had an extremely rough time and need to recover and bond with baby. It's not clear if you have actually allowed your own parents to visit - if they are well, I would let them, or they'll be frantic with worry, desperate to see baby, and feeling left out, as DH's family have already had the honour. No house guests - far too invasive, unless you feel your mum would be a comfort and support. DH needs to enforce no kissing rule , and be firm with his family - they've met baby and need to back off. To all wider, not wanted family, get DH to make a very short WA vid of baby only, thank everyone for their kindness and good wishes in an accompanying message, explaining coconeon is still unwell and under orders to rest, so he's sure everyone will understand she's taking a break from phone/social media messages, and socialising, until well enough, then block, and unblock individuals as you feel ready. That's what I would do, as a mother, and having previously worked with new mothers for 12 years. A very big CONGRATULATIONS!!

Bbq1 · 16/02/2024 10:00

YoBeaches · 16/02/2024 09:41

@Bbq1 I think your view point here is quite dangerous. We shouldn't be saying it's natural
And normal for family to visits so soon, it creates a wild expectation on women to 'perform' and hand their maybe out when they may not be ready, emotionally of physically

this lady spent 2 days post birth on a high dependency ward. Her experience is entirely different to yours as are her relationships.

You might have wanted people to visit, but that doesn't make it natural or normal.

So so so many threads on Mumsnet from
Women who are out under pressure from family's.

We need more empathy and empowerment for mums, and support from their partners to advocate for them when they can't.

Okay. I'm obviously getting piled on here for sharing a different viewpoint . My family relationships are very close and my dh was present at the birth and most of the time afterwards. He did advocate for me during the birth. It's apparently "dangerous" according to you to have an alternative view to shutting everyone out and "hunkering down". You think that but to call my view, my experience dangerousl is ridiculous . No womam is going to feel pressure to "perform" just because I was more than happy to see my close family the day after my ds was born.

SparklyOwls · 16/02/2024 09:58

Could husband take lead with visits with IMMEDIATE family members to the house whilst you can pop your head around and say hi and then go back to rest?

I was a zombie for visits, what I do regret was people visiting way down the pecking order and some just wouldn't leave for hours and expected to be waited on.

VimtoEverywhere · 16/02/2024 09:53

Bbq1 · 16/02/2024 09:44

You have absolutely no idea how the birth was one and you raised it, not me! As it happens i found it quite easy. I only had gas and air as it was too late for pethidine, but I did have an episiotomy, 3rd degree tears, they had to break my waters and we had to stay in hospital for 5 days as ds was jaundiced. Maybe not that easy but I found it relatively easy, especially pain wise. I'm sorry if pp's have haf difficult or traumatic births but there's no need to be nasty just because your dc's birth was difficult. Talking about birth never occurred to me on this thread. The following day I was in pain obviously but that made no difference to wanting to see my parents and IL's.

Ok then tell me this, how is telling op how wonderful your experience was helpfull? Telling someone who is (understandably) struggling that you found it easy? How will that make her feel?

Mothership4two · 16/02/2024 09:52

Oh I don't know @honeylulu with baby no.2 the whole of OH's family plus children turned up on day 2 and it was a flipping nightmare. I had my own hospital room as I had the flu (which made the actual birth a load of fun) which seemed to give them the impression they could extend the visit. I wish I had had to foresight to delay them.

MintyCedric · 16/02/2024 09:50

When I read your first post I though you were being a bit dramatic and unreasonable.

Having read your other posts for context, I think you’re pretty justified.

As someone else said, I would send a message to your extended family saying that whilst you appreciate their kind thoughts and desire to meet baby, you’ve been extremely unwell as a result of the birth and are still recovering and will therefore not be having visitors until next month, and will be in touch when you feel up to it.

Then individually block anyone who is being persistent for the time being.

Y6yhnsr5 · 16/02/2024 09:47

Doesn't matter how long it's been, I don't understand the questions asking how old is your baby. You see them when you want to! Ignore messages and calls. Turn off your phone if you need to.

mitogoshi · 16/02/2024 09:47

Perhaps op you could ask for your title to be amended to extended family members ... you have seen close family which the heading appears otherwise. I certainly wouldn't expect to visit early on if I didn't have a close relationship, but for my DD's I would expect to see their future children nearly straight away, very different

BusyMum47 · 16/02/2024 09:46

@coconean
You're not being unreasonable in the slightest- you've been through a horrid time, you're 6 days out the other side, feeling ill & in pain/discomfort. All you need right now is support - your baby is not a new exhibit in a zoo for these extended family members to come & play with!

Tell them (or better yet, your husband should be running interference for you & telling them) to back off & give you space. Be as rude about it as you like & don't feel in the least bit guilty!

Unless people are going to properly, actually be of help to you in some way, then they need to eff off!!

Hope you feel less shit soon & enjoy your baby bubble time.

Whatyoutalkingabouteh · 16/02/2024 09:46

Not read the whole thread but could you send a message to all those trying to visit and just say you’re Ill, you need time to recover and so won’t be having visitors yet but you’ll be in contact when. Don’t answer any other requests.
i remember my in laws visiting and I was stopped over in pain making a f’ing roast dinner. I look back and think what the hell was I doing?!!!
congrats on your little one!

Mothership4two · 16/02/2024 09:44

I'm guessing you weren't in a high dependency unit with a third degree tear then @forgotmyusername1?

Bbq1 · 16/02/2024 09:44

VimtoEverywhere · 16/02/2024 09:25

Tell me you had an easy birth without telling me you had an easy birth 🙄

You have absolutely no idea how the birth was one and you raised it, not me! As it happens i found it quite easy. I only had gas and air as it was too late for pethidine, but I did have an episiotomy, 3rd degree tears, they had to break my waters and we had to stay in hospital for 5 days as ds was jaundiced. Maybe not that easy but I found it relatively easy, especially pain wise. I'm sorry if pp's have haf difficult or traumatic births but there's no need to be nasty just because your dc's birth was difficult. Talking about birth never occurred to me on this thread. The following day I was in pain obviously but that made no difference to wanting to see my parents and IL's.

YoBeaches · 16/02/2024 09:41

@Bbq1 I think your view point here is quite dangerous. We shouldn't be saying it's natural
And normal for family to visits so soon, it creates a wild expectation on women to 'perform' and hand their maybe out when they may not be ready, emotionally of physically

this lady spent 2 days post birth on a high dependency ward. Her experience is entirely different to yours as are her relationships.

You might have wanted people to visit, but that doesn't make it natural or normal.

So so so many threads on Mumsnet from
Women who are out under pressure from family's.

We need more empathy and empowerment for mums, and support from their partners to advocate for them when they can't.

CheerioDarling · 16/02/2024 09:40

I think it's reasonable for parents and siblings to see the baby with some priority.

Beyond that, it's your decision who you want to see, with the caveat that people will feel excluded if you leave it too long (I would say a couple of weeks is reasonable).

Your partner needs to police this and have words with anyone who refuses to listen. He also needs to kick people out if they outstay their timeslot (though remember you can take the baby and retire upstairs if it gets too much).

WickedSerious · 16/02/2024 09:39

forgotmyusername1 · 16/02/2024 09:29

My parents, inlaws and siblings all saw us in hospital on day 1

How lovely for all concerned.

CurlewKate · 16/02/2024 09:39

"My doctor recommend giving yourselves 6-8 weeks to adjust before accepting visitors. Both as a doctor and a Mum of 3 herself"

No she didn't.

VimtoEverywhere · 16/02/2024 09:38

forgotmyusername1 · 16/02/2024 09:29

My parents, inlaws and siblings all saw us in hospital on day 1

And another one....day 1 after birth I hadn't slept for 48 hours, I'd been in surgery for two hours, I was numb from the waste down because they had to give me a spinal block and there was a bag of urine attached to the side of my bed because I had a catheter in. I was traumatised. Please understand not everyone is fit for visitors straight away.

Swipe left for the next trending thread