Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To explode at family pressuring to see newborn?

457 replies

coconean · 15/02/2024 20:25

I have a newborn and not had the best birth and have been quite poorly.

I have explained to family several times now when I am ready I will let them know.
Quite a few of family members have complained of fevers, flu etc so for obvious reasons im keeping my distance.

Nobody seems to be respecting what I am saying and keep bombarding me with texts, like let me enjoy my baby!

I feel ready to explode, I didnt do this when they had babies and left them to it until they were ready and just want the same respect.

OP posts:
Comtesse · 16/02/2024 12:04

You have been through a really tough time physically - of course you need tine to recover. Grandparents popping round? Ok fine. Random cousins who you never see? They are NOT the priority in any way. Congratulations on your little baby and take the time you need to recover Flowers

SweetBirdsong · 16/02/2024 12:03

scoobysnaxx · 15/02/2024 23:24

OMG THIS.

This thread is actually quite disturbing, especially as it's mostly women posting.

  • Giving birth can be a life changing experience, physically and emotionally.
  • Many women have difficult pregnancies and tremendously difficult births. Made worse potentially by pregnancy complications and maternal mental ill health.
  • No one is entitled to see your baby within a certain time frame.
  • Your physical and mental wellbeing come first, this is the most vulnerable time of your life.
  • You don't owe anyone anything. You and baby are number 1. You see people and have visitors when you like.

See them when you want to see them.

The entitlement makes me sick.
If they are not listening to you now I'd be worried about them respecting boundaries when they do see the child (e.g kissing etc).

After having a baby I felt pushed and expected to see everyone. Sometimes it was okay and sometimes I just didn't want to. I didn't want to see them and I didn't want my baby being around so many different people with their winter germs.

This precious baby stuff is misogynistic bullshit. People don't have to like your boundaries but they need to listen to them or it's just downright disrespectful.

If you have any other boundaries make them loud and clear.

100% ^ this!

I am disgusted at the entitlement of some posters, and how they think the iccle wimmin should be there and be hosting and greeting visitor after fucking visitor postpartum, when she's feeling like shit, in pain, tired, sore, fed up, and had fuck-all sleep for days on end (even weeks!) I am also disgusted at the way some posters are making other women feel if they DON'T want be hostess with the mostess! JUST after she given birth!

The 'this only happens on mumsnet' shit pisses me off. NO it fucking DOESN'T. It happens in real life. Not every woman who has just had a baby wants intrusive 'how dare you not let me in!' fuckers pushing their way into their home.

I didn't want ANYONE near me as I felt tired and weary and weepy, and didn't want anyone around me. To my absolute horror, DH got the wife of his mate at work, who I barely knew to pop in (when my first baby was 10 days old,) and visit me 'to keep me company.' Hmm She just sat there and watched while I struggled to get baby to latch onto my breast - she was doing it easily eventually, but struggled for a couple of weeks.- And she watched while I changed her nappy, and she just sat on her arse while I made her coffees and waited on her. I was struggling, frazzled, and fatigued, and she was sitting there like the fucking QUEEN. I asked her to leave after a couple of hours as I needed to SLEEP.

I then scolded DH afterwards and I said 'what the fuck did you send HER around for?!' Hmm For some reason, some people think women who have just given birth want oodles of people around them. Many do NOT, and don't want intrusion, and people pushing them to do anything.

Goatymum · 16/02/2024 12:01

I don’t get this at all. I had a c:s both times and my friends and family visited in the hospital. I wasn’t keen on PILs there that night post-birth, but after that it was lovely to have people see me and the baby.
It’s up to you though , but I wouldn’t say it was usual.

OpieMo · 16/02/2024 11:58

I can tell you now from experience OP, the way these relatives react when you explain you're not ready and you will let them know will shape your relationship with them well into the future.

A bit of initial overexcitement is fine, but when you say 'it's been a rough time, I need some time, I'll let you know when we're ready' and people respond with pressure, it really does sour you on them and make you not want to see them at all. The ones who say 'totally understand, it's a huge thing to go through, we're here if you need us and we'd love to see you when you're ready' are the ones you know you can trust and rely on and will want to see even more of down the line.

People can be just awful to new parents.

LovePoppy · 16/02/2024 11:51

Golden407 · 16/02/2024 07:01

This whole attitude is incredibly narcissistic, having a baby doesn't make you the centre of the universe
By all means politely let people know you're not ready but these people are your child's family. I've seen people have this attitude and alienate those around them irreparably. A couple of years later they complain that no one wants to help out, babysit etc.

Would you tell someone going through cancer or any other type of “temporary” change in their body causing issues that they need to suck it up and let the world visit?

would you say it to men?

or just women, during what is (for most) the most vulnerable they will be?

YoBeaches · 16/02/2024 11:49

I used the word dangerous in the context of regressive. To label having visitors straight away as natural and normal does create an expectation that all women should do this whether they want it or not otherwise you are not behaving 'normally'.

In the case of the OP she has complex health needs of her own which are the priority here.

And at times this is regardless of their birth experience and rather just, a woman's preference. Their choice around how they want to spend those first few days or weeks post birth.

Women should feel enabled and empowered to make those choices without familial or societal pressure to 'put a face on' and do as other people please.

HMW1906 · 16/02/2024 11:48

coconean · 16/02/2024 08:20

Sorry?
Holding s grudge? Wtf!
I literally havent seen some of the family for years and there has been no contact until the birth of my child.

I am fighting of an infection, I am ill and yet I am expected to invite people to my house to see my baby as if he is some mind of novelty when I feel at deaths door, what planet are you on???

I dont expect help of anyone to the poster who says I shouldnt expect help of people in the future.
Its my baby, I do what the hell I want.

I’m with you OP. We have family we never see who came out of the woodwork when our first baby was born. We allowed one set to visit begrudgingly…we didn’t see or hear from them again until our second baby was born when they wanted to visit again...guess who still hasn’t met our nearly 1 year old?!? We did give them the option when he was about 2 months old….all the dates/times we suggested didn’t work for them so we stopped trying. I don’t feel that my children are missing out by not knowing them.

user1492757084 · 16/02/2024 11:46

Send a group text to everyone explaining your health situation and that you are wanting time alone to recover and that baby will not meet any more people until she has had her first immunisation shots.

There are flus about so you are happy to post photos on Tiny Beans. Setup an account, join family and friends and put a picture on there every few days.
Ask people not to be offended when you do not open the door nor respond to texts the same day.

Set up a cosy nest at home, fend for yourself and make contact with the outside World when you are ready.
Do keep a list of those who send flowers and gifts so that you can send thank you notes.

It is not unreasonable for just closest (very well) friends and the grandparents and perhaps a night nurse to see babies before they are six weeks old.

Mariposistaaa · 16/02/2024 11:44

HesterRoon · 16/02/2024 10:57

Do people really tell members of their family to fuck off? I don’t know anyone who does that? If you’re recovering at home, don’t t send shitty rude messages-tell people you’ll let them know and then stop checking messages.

Fully agree with you.
We are above using use that sort of foul language in our family but if anyone told us that they could stick their visits and interest in their lives, and not expect any attention, presents, future childminding too.

DissidentDaughter · 16/02/2024 11:40

Ariela AI gobbledygook

GR8GAL · 16/02/2024 11:40

With colds and flus this time of year, I'd be keeping them at a distance until at least March! At the end of the day, the people that truly love you will respect your wishes.

Ariela · 16/02/2024 11:36

coconean · 15/02/2024 20:49

6 days old.
Its been every day, nobody is offering to help just to come round.

You have this all wrong.

Invite them all on the same day, slightly differing times. When they come round, say you are busy feeding baby, so as soon as they say 'is there anything I can do to help?' ask them to make the tea/coffee, do the washing up, prepare lunch, make soup, peel potatoes for dinner, do the hoovering, clean the downstairs loo, change the bed and put the laundry on or whatever chores you need. There's nothing else for them to do so I promise you they will oblige.

Obviously, when the next lot of people arrive, or the ones after, then the first lot will feel crowded make their excuses and leave. Meanwhile you get all your food/drinks prepared and your house cleaned, kitchen tidied laundry done etc, and you get shot of all your visitors in one day. Yes sure it's a tad tiring to be cheerful for a few hours but once done it's done and you get all the chores done for you, and they get to see the baby albeit briefly

Then have no visitors again the next day, gets it all done in one hit. I promise this works, I didn't believe it but my lovely PA of the job I was in on 1st Mat Leave told me to do this and she was absolutely right.

Newhere5 · 16/02/2024 11:34

MustBeGinOclock · 16/02/2024 08:52

I want to feel sorry for you but also want to say please stop being so precious. Let your family meet their newborn relative. If they didn't want to meet baby I'm sure that'd be wrong too?

Edited

Would you say something like that to someone recovering from an operation and not wanting to see anyone?
How come visitors wishes trump Mother’s preferences?

stayathomer · 16/02/2024 11:26

My doctor recommend giving yourselves 6-8 weeks to adjust before accepting visitors. Both as a doctor and a Mum of 3 herself
I suspect she was speaking more as a mum, and one who doesn’t like her relatives😅 As with others, the kids love looking at baby photos, each with a gp holding them (sadly some weren’t there with the younger two as they’d passed)

OOBetty · 16/02/2024 11:25

Bbq1 · 16/02/2024 10:35

I'm not piling on the Op at all
I merely gave a different point of view then said her choice, it was up to her. The tone from some pp's is one of fury, "How dare you have a different birth experience and post birth experience to me", which is just sad. I wrongly misread the theme of the thread but I see people who wanted to see family soon after birth are not welcome. Only stories to mirror Op's thoughts, to cement her own experiences, to tell her she's right are wanted. I was only show another way. I also won't buy into the idea that my sharing my experiences is dangerous because as I say no woman on here is going to change her views because of me. I could equally argue it is dangerous to encourage women to shut themselves away from the world after birth when they could be struggling or have pnd need family support more than ever. Well, everyone just crack on telling Op what she wants to hear.

Absolutely
MN is supposed to be a forum for discussion and as such people will have different views and all are worthy.
I particularly agree with your comment on not shutting yourself away from the world and how dangerous this can be.
From my own experience after having the twins I hardly left the house for ages until my neighbour came in and practically threw me out to get some me time. It changed my whole perspective and positivity and I will be forever indebted to her.

Bananasandtoast · 16/02/2024 11:11

The argument that you'd better put your needs aside and have them all trailing through your home in case they decide they don't care about your or your baby later is interesting.

  1. If they really cared then they would listen to what you are saying in the first place.
  2. The chances are they won't be around in the long run anyway as OP hasn't seen some of these people for years!
I was railroaded after DS1 and some people who rushed to my bedside on day one to get their photo for social media have seem him a handful of times since. He's nearly 5. It absolutely wasn't worth my discomfort as a new mum. The people who care will still care when OP is feeling better. The problem will take care of itself IMO.
OOBetty · 16/02/2024 11:09

I had a terrible time with my first and then the twins.
I wouldn’t have wanted people staying over but I wouldn’t have refused a visit.

If you’re not feeling up to the visit yourself why not just let dp show of your baby and you can rest in bed. You don’t have to be the host if you’re not up to it but it’s nice that family members are keen to see their new addition to the family.

Newhere5 · 16/02/2024 11:08

scoobysnaxx · 16/02/2024 00:42

@WandaWonder so by your logic a mother who has suffered bad pre natal anxiety, whose relationship is not on good terms, who had a fairly difficult birth or even a traumatic one, who had an emergency c section or episiotomy, who is bleeding profusely, struggling to get baby to latch and had a prolapse making it hard to even sit down, should let people visit within 6 days BECAUSE OTHERWISE SHE IS BEING PRECIOUS?!

Do me a fucking favour. And people don't get the internalise misogyny in this to thread?

Guess what, even a mum who had a straightforward pregnancy and a straightforward birth with no complications or many physical after effects STILL DOES NOT HAVE TO HAVE VISITORS. She can see people whenever the fuck she wants. If she just wants to stay at home, with her family and new baby with PEACE then that's her choice. No ones has a right to be pissed off at her much less annoyed and being called precious for it.

If I thought people were dickheads before having a baby I sure as hell hated some of them after having mine.

This x 100
🙌🏻🙌🏻🙌🏻

Bibblebrox · 16/02/2024 11:01

I can understand the feeling of wanting to explode. You are getting used to newborn life, which is unrelenting and family members are often just that bit too perky and shrill during that time. I understand completely that they are excited, but it can be so overwhelming if you aren't feeling well in yourself. Maybe try and have a short walk once a day (with or without baby) to get out of the house whilst your relatives outstay their welcome 😁 Definitely don't let in sick relatives, your immune system is still recovering and it adds insult to injury if you are healing from the trauma of birth and someone comes along and infects you with germs.

DissidentDaughter · 16/02/2024 11:00

Blimey - The Punishers, revving up competitively on this thread. It’s about individual capacity, not a f*cking competition!

Trust your judgment, OP, just as the mums who were ok with early-days visitors trusted theirs.

If ever there’s a time to be tuned-in it’s now. Your body and your baby are the centre of the universe in this precious moment 💫

HesterRoon · 16/02/2024 10:57

Do people really tell members of their family to fuck off? I don’t know anyone who does that? If you’re recovering at home, don’t t send shitty rude messages-tell people you’ll let them know and then stop checking messages.

ClaudiaWankleman · 16/02/2024 10:56

StopStartStop · 16/02/2024 08:44

To you, maybe.
Not to others.

It would be hellish by the end for anyone normal. It's effectively 3 months of social deprivation.

scoobysnaxx · 16/02/2024 10:55

Bananasandtoast · 16/02/2024 10:27

Another of these sad threads.
Why must women always fight for their right to their own boundaries?
Some people find it very difficult to accept that the post partum period is absolutely all about the mother and baby - their health/safety/feelings are paramount.
It's not about what everyone else wants at this time and this should be so glaringly obvious that a quick text saying that you are unwell, need to rest, hope to see them when better should be the end of it.
If you need to explode, then explode. There's only so much asking nicely you can do when people will not listen nicely.

Because apparently this is the highest form of narcissism according to @Golden407

When actually it's the highest form of internalised misogyny.

Bbq1 · 16/02/2024 10:35

I'm not piling on the Op at all
I merely gave a different point of view then said her choice, it was up to her. The tone from some pp's is one of fury, "How dare you have a different birth experience and post birth experience to me", which is just sad. I wrongly misread the theme of the thread but I see people who wanted to see family soon after birth are not welcome. Only stories to mirror Op's thoughts, to cement her own experiences, to tell her she's right are wanted. I was only show another way. I also won't buy into the idea that my sharing my experiences is dangerous because as I say no woman on here is going to change her views because of me. I could equally argue it is dangerous to encourage women to shut themselves away from the world after birth when they could be struggling or have pnd need family support more than ever. Well, everyone just crack on telling Op what she wants to hear.

Everanewbie · 16/02/2024 10:34

At the end of the day OP, you need to do what is right for you, the baby and DH. But just bear in mind that the extended family are really keen to meet the new arrival, and that enthusiasm is not necessarily malevolent. If you are overly combative and rigid now, you might set a precedent that limits wider relationships with your baby and reduces the potential help you might be offered if you are overly prickly.

Perhaps consider accepting short visits from close family at times that suit you, but have your partner reply on your behalf to explain the situation. Be crystal clear but try (as hard as it feels) to be polite and reasonable.

Congratulations on the new arrival! Navigating this can be difficult as you get all these things drilled in to you about wider family being the enemy, partners need to be gatekeepers. It can get a bit OTT, but you, baby and partner are the priority.