Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To explode at family pressuring to see newborn?

457 replies

coconean · 15/02/2024 20:25

I have a newborn and not had the best birth and have been quite poorly.

I have explained to family several times now when I am ready I will let them know.
Quite a few of family members have complained of fevers, flu etc so for obvious reasons im keeping my distance.

Nobody seems to be respecting what I am saying and keep bombarding me with texts, like let me enjoy my baby!

I feel ready to explode, I didnt do this when they had babies and left them to it until they were ready and just want the same respect.

OP posts:
Babyboomtastic · 16/02/2024 17:07

LabradorFiasco · 16/02/2024 16:57

@Babyboomtastic thank you for a thoughtful and respectful reply. It would be great to continue a civilised discussion on postnatal confinement on another thread. I’m actually an anthropologist and would have a few things to say!

I might start one once toddler goes to bed. I won't derail any further than to quote the section that I was arguing, so you can see what it was that was being debated. I won't get into it any further on here though.

*Did a little Social Anthropology at university, and read about a culture where women give birth then are placed in accommodation alone with their newborn for three whole months. People bring them food, and take care of their older children, but no-one is allowed in with mother and baby. It seemed like a good system - time to establish breastfeeding, get to know each other and bond, no need to fend off demanding relatives, no germs etc.

Not sure what would happen if the mother has a toddler she's still feeding as well as the newborn. Common sense says they'd be in with the mother but I don't know*

LabradorFiasco · 16/02/2024 16:57

@Babyboomtastic thank you for a thoughtful and respectful reply. It would be great to continue a civilised discussion on postnatal confinement on another thread. I’m actually an anthropologist and would have a few things to say!

Babyboomtastic · 16/02/2024 16:52

LabradorFiasco · 16/02/2024 14:54

@Babyboomtastic glad you had a great early postnatal period, but OP has a third degree tear. That’s a tear into the muscle surrounding anal sphincter. Depending on severity, possibly the anus itself. She’s been hospitalised for 6 days. Sex is not going to be possible or advisable for weeks, and realistically, months. I still have complications from my 3b tear 3.5 years on (and had another baby on top of it!) Basically, your comment is more applicable to women fortunate enough to have a straightforward delivery, with minimal injuries or blood loss.

OP, I hope you recover well. Be gentle with yourself - you’ve taken a battering! Those who’ve been there, will understand.

I'm well aware of what a difficult birth the OP had, and think her approach to wider family etc is fine. She needs time to recover. She had my sympathies for the pain she is on, and her family are being unreasonable. I did obviously think maybe she should let the grandparents in sooner rather than later, but that was before it emerged that (1) they had (2) the nagging relatives are more distant (3)she's only just got home from hospital. I agree in sending a firm message and then switching off her phone. She needs peace and recovery.

My comment was in response to a very extreme postnatal confinement scenario suggested as the ideal by another poster.

It's a bit of a spin off discussion that emerged on post natal confinement.

It wasn't the optional 'stay in if you want and we'll look after you' scenario of many cultures, but more extreme than that.

The confinement lauded has a woman and her baby alone for 3 months, with the father and other children excluded. It would mean not even anyone to hold the baby whilst the mum has a nap or a shower. No breastfeeding support group, no one to make the mum a cup of tea even.

Toddlers would have 3 months without their mum. Dad's wouldn't be able to spend any time with their newborn, wouldn't be able to share the load. It was specifically mentioned that this would mean women wouldn't be subject to men's advances for sex. 3 months in a flat just mum and baby and no one else so they could get to know each other. As someone else pointed out, the whole setup seems more about notions of 'uncleanliness after birth' than supporting mums.

I'm by no means suggesting that the OP should be even thinking about sex, or holidays. (Really no...). After such a tricky birth, she's in recovery mode and extended family can get stuffed. It was more that that being in literal solitary confinement was not needed to get to know a baby, that some women can enjoy going out, can enjoy sex, and wouldn't want to be in a prison where they couldn't even take baby for a walk in the pram. That is possible to do those things and still get to know your baby.

@IfOn please see above. This was the context I'd what I posted.

I think postnatal confinement is an interesting concept and worth discussing but this isn't the thread for it. I got sucked into an interesting side discussion because the concept horrified me so much but maybe it's one we can take elsewhere (as long as it's not banned for being a TAAT)

girlfriend44 · 16/02/2024 16:36

Why are people so funny!!

When I'd given birth the mil came 2 days later to hospital. Bought flowers etc. I would never have dreamt of saying no. Probably didn't look my best but hey ho.
They are excited and they care.

No wonder there's such a divide in some families.

YoBeaches · 16/02/2024 16:15

OriginalUsername2 · 16/02/2024 14:53

I feel for families in this situation. Humans have so much love for newborns, it’s a miracle to hold one. Especially when you’re older, it means so much to see brand new life in your family.

I think it’s good for the baby to feel all that love and wonder.

(and build a strong immune system)

See here..... not a single word about the mother in your post. Point made.

MustBeGinOclock · 16/02/2024 16:05

Newhere5 · 16/02/2024 11:34

Would you say something like that to someone recovering from an operation and not wanting to see anyone?
How come visitors wishes trump Mother’s preferences?

Not here to argue op looking for opinions i gave mine now off you pop!

megletthesecond · 16/02/2024 15:53

yo yes. Now that mums are chucked out after 1-3 days there's no support and no one to keep visitors at bay. New dads are often as out of their depth as mums. A proper hospital stay would allow for recovery.

telestrations · 16/02/2024 15:17

amieloue · 16/02/2024 08:20

@telestrations

My doctor recommend giving yourselves 6-8 weeks to adjust before accepting visitors

No doctor would say this

Well mine did

An obstetrician/gynecologist to be precise

Possibly in response to personal circumstances (I have no idea) but was very welcomed by us both and exactly the excuse we needed

DissidentDaughter · 16/02/2024 15:01

OpieMo · 16/02/2024 14:22

'kept away' 'denied their rights' betrays the person's perspective very clearly. That they feel family members have an absolute right to contact with the baby, however the baby's mum feels about it.

Indeed.

Perhaps carrying and birthing a baby could be better done tidily and politely via an app!

IfOn · 16/02/2024 14:56

Babyboomtastic · 16/02/2024 13:57

No. It's bonkers.

I mean, how absolutely crap would someone's support system have to be to find solitary confinement preferable? To find being on your own easier then with your own partner?

No one to share night duties
No one to hold the baby whilst you have a nap or shower
No one to take the baby out for an hour so you can have some peace.

I remember a thread on mn months ago about a woman considering sending her toddler away for a few months when having a newborn. She was universally criticised for how harmful that would be for the toddler. This is the same.

The being kept confined is awful enough. Having to do it without your partner and other children is whole level extra awful.

Your views on how it's better for men to literally stay away for the first few months of their children's lives to save the woman from sex says a lot about your views/experience of men.

Ps: i had visitors from day 1, went out every day from getting home. Sex by 2 weeks, holiday abroad by 6 weeks. Ebf baby who I still 'got to know' perfectly well. No need to lock me in a box for this.

Edited

I find your comment to be extremely distasteful especially the last paragraph 🙄

LabradorFiasco · 16/02/2024 14:54

@Babyboomtastic glad you had a great early postnatal period, but OP has a third degree tear. That’s a tear into the muscle surrounding anal sphincter. Depending on severity, possibly the anus itself. She’s been hospitalised for 6 days. Sex is not going to be possible or advisable for weeks, and realistically, months. I still have complications from my 3b tear 3.5 years on (and had another baby on top of it!) Basically, your comment is more applicable to women fortunate enough to have a straightforward delivery, with minimal injuries or blood loss.

OP, I hope you recover well. Be gentle with yourself - you’ve taken a battering! Those who’ve been there, will understand.

OriginalUsername2 · 16/02/2024 14:53

I feel for families in this situation. Humans have so much love for newborns, it’s a miracle to hold one. Especially when you’re older, it means so much to see brand new life in your family.

I think it’s good for the baby to feel all that love and wonder.

(and build a strong immune system)

YoBeaches · 16/02/2024 14:42

50 years ago both my mother and mother on law spent two weeks in hospital after the birth of their first child, with baby. They had nurses who helped them with breastfeeding, meals prepared and delivered and visiting times for people to come if they wanted.

This was in the UK. It was deemed that women needed that type of support in the beginning.

And they do, but many families fail at this and belief their involvement, their visits are not about THEM.

I only spent 6 hrs in hospital from arriving to discharge. Clearly straightforward birth. Baby came early and family lives 250miles away. We had a week to ourselves before the onslaught arrived and it was lush. And I have a great family who DO help out and respect my boundaries but I still relish those early days we had to settle ourselves.

Y6yhnsr5 · 16/02/2024 14:28

OpieMo · 16/02/2024 14:22

'kept away' 'denied their rights' betrays the person's perspective very clearly. That they feel family members have an absolute right to contact with the baby, however the baby's mum feels about it.

What's sad is there are still a lot of women who feel that way, it's evident on this thread alone. It's sad. Poor OP. Poor women.

StopStartStop · 16/02/2024 14:27

@Babyboomtastic Think whatever you like.

OpieMo · 16/02/2024 14:22

DissidentDaughter · 16/02/2024 14:17

The desperate framing of those beyond the inner circle as being ‘kept away’ or ‘denied their rights’ to an early visit, while you’re painfully shuffling about in stitches is plain bonkers.

So glad you’ve got some kindly gatekeepers doing their job, OP. Have a peaceful day with little one & the chosen few. X

'kept away' 'denied their rights' betrays the person's perspective very clearly. That they feel family members have an absolute right to contact with the baby, however the baby's mum feels about it.

DissidentDaughter · 16/02/2024 14:17

The desperate framing of those beyond the inner circle as being ‘kept away’ or ‘denied their rights’ to an early visit, while you’re painfully shuffling about in stitches is plain bonkers.

So glad you’ve got some kindly gatekeepers doing their job, OP. Have a peaceful day with little one & the chosen few. X

MrsTrue · 16/02/2024 14:15

I'd be tempted to schedule something for max 30-60 minutes in a week or so once you've managed to recover from the infection a bit more. Reschedule closer to the time if you need to. Get your parents there is you want too, so you don't have to clean up after them and you have help kicking them out.

I'd probably give them all the gory details of the tear and recovery process too tbh! Make them uncomfortable and show how ignorant and selfish they were being!

A third degree tear is hard, you're completely justified to feel the way you do when dealing with that on too of caring for your newborn. The last thing you need is people pestering you.

Babyboomtastic · 16/02/2024 13:57

StopStartStop · 16/02/2024 13:12

That's a ridiculous generalisation. A lot of us would love it.

Imagine for a moment... you live in a culture where when women give birth, they go into seclusion with their baby, and everyone else looks after them. This happened to you when you were newborn. You saw it when your family members and neighbours gave birth. Mothers emerge from their seclusion fully bonded with their baby, with breastfeeding established, fully rested, having been protected from demands to restart a sex life... It's your expectation. You've supported others and now it's your turn.

You'd be perfectly normal to take part in it and enjoy it.

Edited

No. It's bonkers.

I mean, how absolutely crap would someone's support system have to be to find solitary confinement preferable? To find being on your own easier then with your own partner?

No one to share night duties
No one to hold the baby whilst you have a nap or shower
No one to take the baby out for an hour so you can have some peace.

I remember a thread on mn months ago about a woman considering sending her toddler away for a few months when having a newborn. She was universally criticised for how harmful that would be for the toddler. This is the same.

The being kept confined is awful enough. Having to do it without your partner and other children is whole level extra awful.

Your views on how it's better for men to literally stay away for the first few months of their children's lives to save the woman from sex says a lot about your views/experience of men.

Ps: i had visitors from day 1, went out every day from getting home. Sex by 2 weeks, holiday abroad by 6 weeks. Ebf baby who I still 'got to know' perfectly well. No need to lock me in a box for this.

MyrtlethePurpleTurtle · 16/02/2024 13:42

Didimum · 15/02/2024 20:29

No need to explode. Just stop checking your messages until you are ready/have your partner communicate on your behalf.

yep - no need to explode or tell people to fuck off or go into fiether hyper stress . State you're not well, urgent messages to be routed to DP and block

JudgeJ · 16/02/2024 13:42

Would you tell someone going through cancer or any other type of “temporary” change in their body causing issues that they need to suck it up and let the world visit?

A gold medal for the day's most stupid comparison!

I know that the MN mantra is about 'little families' and 'bubbles' but some new mothers do take it to extremes!

StopStartStop · 16/02/2024 13:24

OOBetty · 16/02/2024 13:15

@StopStartStop
what culture was this
dare I say did it have anything to do with idea of original sin and having to hide away until baby and mother are cleansed
Or was this purely a caring thing.

Good question. I'd answer but it was over thirty years ago so... who knows? I'm expecting someone to turn up who has that background, to dispute my comments. But, I stand by them.

I don't think 'original sin' had ever taken hold with them but 'cleansing' might have. You can tell me you're cleansing me if you give me three months off to get to know my baby, and I'm not going to care. Context might make a difference to how you thought about it, though.

ClaudiaWankleman · 16/02/2024 13:23

StopStartStop · 16/02/2024 13:12

That's a ridiculous generalisation. A lot of us would love it.

Imagine for a moment... you live in a culture where when women give birth, they go into seclusion with their baby, and everyone else looks after them. This happened to you when you were newborn. You saw it when your family members and neighbours gave birth. Mothers emerge from their seclusion fully bonded with their baby, with breastfeeding established, fully rested, having been protected from demands to restart a sex life... It's your expectation. You've supported others and now it's your turn.

You'd be perfectly normal to take part in it and enjoy it.

Edited

I don't need to imagine - I've got close friends who have 'sat the month' in Chinese culture. What you have described was not what I was responding to, which was 'no one is allowed with the mother and child'. That is social deprivation and any normal person wouldn't cope. Women with low social contact and support have higher rates of post natal depression.

You've described a situation where a group of people have access to the mother and child and contribute to the wellbeing f both. That is completely different. When you sit the month it's expected that you won't spend 100% of your time looking after the baby's needs, for example, but that your mother and mother in law will meet the baby's needs while the mother recovers.

BusyMum47 · 16/02/2024 13:17

coconean · 16/02/2024 12:48

Thanks to the kind posters.

My two siblings have taken the funnies after again offering to drive up to see me with OF and brood of kids.

They are not the type of people to offer to help, they will come, leave a mess and expect me or DP to tidy up as that is what has happened in the past.

My siblings dont ever invite me to their houses so I am not being weird for not wanting to come to mine.

I have never been invited to any of their kids birthday parties but they feel so entitled to meet my son for some reason when we arent even close.

My parents are the only people who offered to help and have even advised me not to invite the siblings as they know how they like to leave a mess in people's houses and its not fair for me or my DP to be tidying up after them when I have a newborn.

It is getting to the stage where its bullying as my brother told my mum that he feels as if I will keep my son away and he will miss out on him growing up.
Just to add my brother is a bully and terrorised me in my teens.

Even again today both siblings just text me to invite themselves over which I find so rude given how ill I feel.

@coconean

They sound hideous! Tell them bluntly to eff off....or get your mum or hubby to do it.

What's the worst that can happen if you don't have a relationship with them anyway? Their loss. Most certainly not yours.

I'd just block them & focus on getting well & enjoying the time with your baby.

OOBetty · 16/02/2024 13:15

StopStartStop · 16/02/2024 13:12

That's a ridiculous generalisation. A lot of us would love it.

Imagine for a moment... you live in a culture where when women give birth, they go into seclusion with their baby, and everyone else looks after them. This happened to you when you were newborn. You saw it when your family members and neighbours gave birth. Mothers emerge from their seclusion fully bonded with their baby, with breastfeeding established, fully rested, having been protected from demands to restart a sex life... It's your expectation. You've supported others and now it's your turn.

You'd be perfectly normal to take part in it and enjoy it.

Edited

@StopStartStop
what culture was this
dare I say did it have anything to do with idea of original sin and having to hide away until baby and mother are cleansed
Or was this purely a caring thing.

Swipe left for the next trending thread