Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Arguments over dinner, it's always somebody else's fault with him.

132 replies

SparkleSmash · 15/02/2024 18:13

We did our weekly food shop at Tesco on Monday. I got a roast chicken and rosemary parmenter potatoes with it for a mini 'roast' in the week + 5 or so other meals. We then nipped to Iceland afterwards where I saw some loaded potatoe skins and suggested we could make our own at some point in the week.

DP is cooking this evening as I have a stinking migraine. A roast he says. I go into the kitchen to see him scooping potatoe out of the skins. Confused, I ask what he's making. A roast he says. With cheese and bacon loaded potato skins.

I ask why he's doing that instead of using the rosemary & garlic parmenter potatos.

He then tells me that I said we are having loaded potato skins with the roast chicken when I never said any such thing. I suggest he must have misunderstood as that's not the case, he digs his heels in and insists that I did. He will not be budged. I know I didn't say that as it's not something I'd generally pair with a roast chicken.

Admittedly I'm getting slightly annoyed at this point as its a running theme. If he ever makes a mistake, which we all do and is no big deal, he never owns it and always passes it off as somebody else's fault. Every time. That is what has annoyed me, not the simple mistake.

I said it doesn't matter now we'll eat it regardless. He throws the potato's in the bin, still insisting that I said it.

I wish I could say this is an isolated thing but it isn't. The man is completely unprepared to own his mistakes whether something insignificant like this or something more important. It's always somebody else's fault.

We haven't been getting on very well lately and as you might have guessed there are deeper problems, but am I the unreasonable one here?

OP posts:
SparkleSmash · 15/02/2024 19:40

MercanDede · 15/02/2024 19:18

“DP is cooking this evening as I have a stinking migraine. A roast he says. I go into the kitchen to see him scooping potatoe out of the skins. Confused, I ask what he's making. A roast he says. With cheese and bacon loaded potato skins. I ask why he's doing that instead of using the rosemary & garlic parmenter potatos.”

”Admittedly I'm getting slightly annoyed at this point as its a running theme. If he ever makes a mistake, which we all do and is no big deal, he never owns it and always passes it off as somebody else's fault. Every time. That is what has annoyed me, not the simple mistake.”

Two questions:
How is a roast chicken with loaded potato skins a “mistake”?! It’s not.
So why are you framing it to your DH as if he has made a mistake in cooking your dinner?

I saw the public transport delay story and also fail to see how that was his fault either? Do you also blame him for the train strikes? Public transport is unreliable and often delayed but no one looks at the customers and goes “it’s your mistake, you should have left earlier”

You seem unreasonably critical of your DH.

The loaded potatoe skins were a mistake because they were not intended for this meal. We shopped together and meal planned together. Loaded potato skins were tacked on at the end, intended to be a side dish with something else or a snack.

Things we bought for the roast:
Chicken
Parmenter potatoes
Veg
2 big Yorkshire puddings
Stuffing

When have you ever had loaded potato skins on a roast?

Regarding your second question, there was no transport delay. I'm pointing out that it was a bad decision to wait until late afternoon to take the kids on a day out when he had work that night.

He was late home because he was late going out. He blamed the kids for the fact he was late getting home, completely absolving himself of the decision to go out so late in the day.

OP posts:
C00k · 15/02/2024 19:38

Changingplace · 15/02/2024 19:33

Tbh not remembering in detail a fairly dull conversation about potatoes hardly makes him a liar and if this is the level of ‘mistakes’ he’s being accused of no wonder he’s pissed off.

‘The man is completely unprepared to own his mistakes whether something insignificant like this or something more important. It's always somebody else's fault.’
^^sounds like a liar, but ok.

Changingplace · 15/02/2024 19:33

C00k · 15/02/2024 19:20

It’s a shame the whole OP is wittering on about potatoes instead of the broader issue that her boyfriend is a petulant liar and the relationship sounds tedious. Is this boyfriend enhancing your life and making it fun OP? Are you dependent on him in any way?

Tbh not remembering in detail a fairly dull conversation about potatoes hardly makes him a liar and if this is the level of ‘mistakes’ he’s being accused of no wonder he’s pissed off.

Changingplace · 15/02/2024 19:31

You sound nit picky OP, he was making dinner while you’re not feeling well, who cares if he’s making slightly different potatoes?

In his shoes I’d be pissed off too, not to the point of binning the spuds but he’s hardly made a ‘mistake’ has he? Is this typical of the kind of ‘mistakes’ you think he makes? Because if so no wonder you’re having issues in your relationship.

BobbyBiscuits · 15/02/2024 19:25

It seems foolish to have binned them, but I guess he was annoyed as he was trying to cook a meal and thought that was what you had asked for.
Why is it so bad to have potato skins with roast chicken? Sounds lovely to me!
I'd say if you don't like the way he cooks you have to do it yourself. I always cook as I feel the need to control every aspect of the meal.

C00k · 15/02/2024 19:20

It’s a shame the whole OP is wittering on about potatoes instead of the broader issue that her boyfriend is a petulant liar and the relationship sounds tedious. Is this boyfriend enhancing your life and making it fun OP? Are you dependent on him in any way?

MercanDede · 15/02/2024 19:18

“DP is cooking this evening as I have a stinking migraine. A roast he says. I go into the kitchen to see him scooping potatoe out of the skins. Confused, I ask what he's making. A roast he says. With cheese and bacon loaded potato skins. I ask why he's doing that instead of using the rosemary & garlic parmenter potatos.”

”Admittedly I'm getting slightly annoyed at this point as its a running theme. If he ever makes a mistake, which we all do and is no big deal, he never owns it and always passes it off as somebody else's fault. Every time. That is what has annoyed me, not the simple mistake.”

Two questions:
How is a roast chicken with loaded potato skins a “mistake”?! It’s not.
So why are you framing it to your DH as if he has made a mistake in cooking your dinner?

I saw the public transport delay story and also fail to see how that was his fault either? Do you also blame him for the train strikes? Public transport is unreliable and often delayed but no one looks at the customers and goes “it’s your mistake, you should have left earlier”

You seem unreasonably critical of your DH.

Aquamarine1029 · 15/02/2024 19:10

Your relationship sounds like a nightmare.

Daffodilsandsunshine · 15/02/2024 19:10

How was he parented - was he frightened of his DPs and punished if he made a mistake so he hides it? If he can't "own" any mistake because he's frightened of a particular outcome how does he manage mistakes at work - or is everyone else wrong except him?

Luckydog7 · 15/02/2024 19:05

Throwing the potatoes away was completely unreasonable of him regardless, what a waste. He threw a tantrum because you pointed out he had misunderstood you.

I disagree about the other potatoes being wasted. Just chuck them in the freezer until next roast or rejig your meals to match no big deal.

I relate to the being oversensitive though. Dh and I have started a clean slate recently. We had a rough few years, renovations, babies, redundancies and he responded with stress and anger and I responded with passivity which made things really upsetting for me and really frustrating for him.

The kids are older now and we have made the conscious decision to be less reactive too each other and it's made a massive difference. Sex life is better, both are happier we are talking about our retirement together.

Obviously this is dependent on him being reflective enough and conscious of his behaviour. How would he react if you told him everything you have said on here?

TheIceQween · 15/02/2024 18:50

I’m echoing what some are saying in that the potato’s aren’t the problem it’s deeper than that. I’d have a light hearted chat with him later after all has settled and tell him the potatoes weren’t the issue and explain your feelings. I’ve been in a similar situation where my ex just would not accept fault at any level. Pretty frustrating. Pretty narcissistic…

Anjea · 15/02/2024 18:43

Potato Potahtoh

SugarMitts · 15/02/2024 18:42

I disagree with most here and aswell as the bigger issue the potato thing would really piss me off
There is a meal plan, he’s gone completely off it now you have not one but two random meals or, most likely, the parmentier potatoes will have to go in the bin as the rest of the week is planned and they now have no place, what a waste!
It also shows that he just doesn’t listen when you speak

It could also be an example of weaponised incompetence- if you’re not there to make the meals you get completely made up random shite, especially if in future he won’t do it because he “always does it wrong” 🙄

Yeah I’d be pissed off too

JMSA · 15/02/2024 18:40

newyearsresolurion · 15/02/2024 18:17

If someone was cooking for me I will just appreciate it!

Same!

I mean, at the end of the day, it's only tatties Confused

SparkleSmash · 15/02/2024 18:37

Fuckthemall · 15/02/2024 18:28

I don't think the OP cares much about the potato incident I think it's just being used as a example on how her DP never takes responsibility for his fuck up and it's everyone's fault bar his.

This is exactly it.

We had similar just two days ago. I worked until 4 and he had the kids. He was due into work at 9pm having had Monday night off.

I let him know I was heading home just before 4 at which point he decided he was going to take the kids out somewhere miles away after sitting indoors all day.

He got back late (doesn't drive so had to use multiple modes of public transport) which meant he ate late and didn't get as much sleep before work.

Of course all of that was the kids fault. It couldn't possibly he that he made a bad choice by waiting until late afternoon to go out, could it?

Everything is always somebody else's fault. It drives me mad.

OP posts:
TheNewSchmoo · 15/02/2024 18:37

Oh honestly. If you have a stinking migraine, just let it drop. It is potatoes.

And I know that isn't the point, but I would suggest winding yourself up and looking at a screen won't help with that.

Fuckthemall · 15/02/2024 18:33

Maybe the fact he accused her of saying she told him what potatoes to have when she clearly knew she didn't.

KnowledgeableMomma · 15/02/2024 18:31

As for the example you gave about the dinner potatoes, does it really matter what potatoes went with what? You would have used the roast potatoes but you were down with a migraine and someone else was in charge of dinner. Hubby can cook what he likes.

As to the, never-acknowledging-a-mistake, this seems like an entirely different problem than the example. What does he say when you bring it up?

Mrsttcno1 · 15/02/2024 18:30

Have to agree with other posters, just leave whoever is cooking to do the cooking. Especially when it’s already “in progress” AKA too late to divert to a different plan. I’d probably have my back up a bit as well if DH started questioning why I was making a different type of potato for tea and I’d be telling him he should go to a restaurant for a meal if he wants to make requests🤣

justasking111 · 15/02/2024 18:30

My husband will swear that he told me something when I'm sure he hasn't. He did it again today. I do tune out sometimes though especially if he's on a moaning mission

GiantHornets · 15/02/2024 18:30

Fuckthemall · 15/02/2024 18:28

I don't think the OP cares much about the potato incident I think it's just being used as a example on how her DP never takes responsibility for his fuck up and it's everyone's fault bar his.

But how has her DP fucked up? He’s cooking roast chicken with potatoes, sounds good to me

justasking111 · 15/02/2024 18:28

My OH when cooking I stay well clear, we get random portions, you're lucky you didn't get pilau rice 😂

Fuckthemall · 15/02/2024 18:28

I don't think the OP cares much about the potato incident I think it's just being used as a example on how her DP never takes responsibility for his fuck up and it's everyone's fault bar his.

SparkleSmash · 15/02/2024 18:27

I'll keep my beak out of the kitchen next time. I probably should have just left him to it.

I think with the general state of the relationship at the minute I'm a bit sensitive to anything that highlights one of the problems that we have.

Edited to add, I made it clear I was going to eat the loaded potato skins. He didn't need to bin them. I wouldn't have wasted the food.

OP posts:
Violettaa · 15/02/2024 18:24

I’m not sure he has made a mistake? He’s just doing a different type of potato to the one you would have done.

Imagine this from his POV. ‘I’m cooking for DW, doing loaded potatoes which I know she likes because we talked about it a few days ago. She’s telling me I’ve done it wrong though because she would have done rosemary ones’.

Chalk it up to migraine grumpiness and move on.