Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Aibu to ask how elderly grandparents have dealt with trans grandkids

222 replies

Lenalovewitch · 15/02/2024 12:57

My niece who is 15 is visiting from the US at Easter. DN is clearly gay and has recently also identified as a trans boy adopting a gender neutral name and third psn pronouns. My DS is dealing with it well and being as supportive as poss to DN. DN is possibly autistic and struggles socially which seems often the case for young people identifying as trans. Sorry if i am getting the terminology wrong it's a minefield. The situation has been explained now to our DPs. They are in their 80s, conservative and religious. DM is now freaking a bit about the visit and struggling to accept it. One part of me feels DN should just not make a bit deal of it as it's just a week and they are v old but this doesn't seem to be the way of things. Everyone is now is very apprehensive in advance of the visit. DN gets furious if referred to as she or her birth name which is going to be tough if the GPs/ we get it wrong. Anyone been through this with trans teenagers- how did the GPs react .

OP posts:
ilovesooty · 15/02/2024 15:15

lifeturnsonadime · 15/02/2024 15:14

I haven't said I wouldn't use a preferred name. In fact in my first post I said I would.

Fair enough - thanks. Sorry if I missed you saying that.

Aecor · 15/02/2024 15:15

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Hear, hear.

My 79-year-old mother would agree 100% while also being concerned for the welfare of the child in question.

Sexuality not any kind of issue for either of my parents, who have known and been very fond of my lesbian friends since my student days.

Dogfisher · 15/02/2024 15:15

People, mostly women and children, are being harmed by the lies of gender

This is sadly very true.

I think that treating her with compassion and kindness is the way forward and hopefully she will come out the other side as so many teens do. Many people will 'misgender' her (accidentally) as she is not a boy but she will need to have to cope with this.

lifeturnsonadime · 15/02/2024 15:14

ilovesooty · 15/02/2024 15:13

So you don't think it's basic manners to use this young person's preferred name?

I haven't said I wouldn't use a preferred name. In fact in my first post I said I would.

LeftLion73 · 15/02/2024 15:14

Sorry to rain on your parade but I'm in my 70s and there was no such thing as young people being trans in the 1960s. It was only in the late 60s that homosexuality became legalised!

Funny, because there are trans people alive now the same age as you and older. Do you think there were no gay people before it was legal/socially acceptable either?

lifeturnsonadime · 15/02/2024 15:13

Oh @LeftLion73 I don't have a problem with individual trans people. They can do what they want so long as they don't encroach on the rights of others to speak freely and to women to have single sex spaces.

ilovesooty · 15/02/2024 15:13

lifeturnsonadime · 15/02/2024 15:11

Of course it's a form of compelled speech to insist a person lies about what they see with their own eyes and they know to be the truth.

Why should the grandparents be compelled to go along with the fact that their granddaughter is now a boy. It's impossible to change sex?

As someone else said it gives a person a lot of power to be able to control people in that way.

And this notion that it's unkind to tell the truth is ridiculous.

People, mostly women and children, are being harmed by the lies of gender.

So you don't think it's basic manners to use this young person's preferred name?

SerenChocolateMuncher · 15/02/2024 15:12

I think it's reasonable and polite for the grandparents to use their niece's new name. I'm quite happy to call a girl Frank or a boy Nancy if that's what they want.

I don't think it's reasonable to expect anyone to go along with the pretence that a girl is a boy, unless they too are into all this gender nonsense.

There's nothing wrong with being a lesbian. She doesn't need to pretend to be a boy to have a relationship with a woman. That's what those closest to her should be telling her. Not playing the game, pretending that she can be whatever gender she chooses. She can't. She's a girl.

There is no treatment or surgery that will turn her into a boy. No matter how many people do the 'kind' thing and pretend she is a boy. She will always be a girl and eventually a woman. Playing along, pretending that people can change sex is dishonest, not kind and can only lead to disappointment. It's a damaging lie.

Dogfisher · 15/02/2024 15:12

Cazpar · 15/02/2024 14:49

This is the same kind of shit TRAs pull.

"I'm going to push my views on you no matter what and you can go and fuck yourself and it doesn't matter if you're upset, but I'm still a good person because I'm in the right."

Doesn't matter if it's coming from TRAs or those on the GC side, it's always poor behaviour.

GC people are not generally trying to make others pretend that human beings can change sex though?

lifeturnsonadime · 15/02/2024 15:11

LeftLion73 · 15/02/2024 14:39

It's not "compelled speech" to call people what they prefer to be called, it's the basic minimum courtesy of polite society, and we do it all the time in all sorts of situations. I think it's a bit anachronistic when women take their husband's name when they marry, but I don't feel I'm entitled to simply continue calling them by their maiden name - it's obviously not up to me. There's a client at work I'd love to call a twat, is it "compelled speech" that I'm not allowed to use that language in the workplace (or at least not without consequences)? My BIL has a first name that I really loathe because it's the same name as one of my exes - is it "compelled speech" that I can't just arbitrarily decide to call him Stephen instead? We change what we call people and how we address people all the time, and there are so many situations in life where we can't just say exactly what we want to - if it only becomes "compelled speech" when there's a trans person involved that just sounds like you have a problem with trans people.

Of course it's a form of compelled speech to insist a person lies about what they see with their own eyes and they know to be the truth.

Why should the grandparents be compelled to go along with the fact that their granddaughter is now a boy. It's impossible to change sex?

As someone else said it gives a person a lot of power to be able to control people in that way.

And this notion that it's unkind to tell the truth is ridiculous.

People, mostly women and children, are being harmed by the lies of gender.

blackcherryconserve · 15/02/2024 15:11

If they're in their 80s, then they'd have been in their 20s in the 1960s and so I don't think there is likely to be a new-fangled issue for them.

Sorry to rain on your parade but I'm in my 70s and there was no such thing as young people being trans in the 1960s. It was only in the late 60s that homosexuality became legalised!

I'm with your parents OP. They will no doubt make mistakes in how they address your DN.

LeftLion73 · 15/02/2024 15:11

DreadPirateRobots · 15/02/2024 14:51

My DPs are in their 80s and have recently had a grandchild announce they are trans. They had some questions, but they call their grandchild by their chosen name and use their preferred pronouns.

There were inevitably a few slips in terms of previous name when we all spent time together over Christmas, mostly not by the DGPs, which the grandchild let go.

I think people often massively overestimate the rigidity and conservativism of people in this age range.

Absolutely this. It bears repeating someone in their 80s now will have been a teen/young adult in the 60s. We're not talking about people who grew up in Victorian times here.

Laiste · 15/02/2024 15:10

JudgeJ · 15/02/2024 14:44

Surely if it isn't a deliberate slight there's no problem there? If she keeps on doing it deliberately then that's another issue. With today's obsession with the correct terminology, which can change almost weekly, I think most people probably commit a faux pas on occasion.

I agree. OP says the kid 'gets furious' if anyone gets it wrong though ...

I'd probably be wary of the visit under those circs. as well! With my mother getting it wrong and people getting ''furious'' ... eek.

xxBULLSHITxDETECTIONxSERVICExx · 15/02/2024 14:55

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

DreadPirateRobots · 15/02/2024 14:51

My DPs are in their 80s and have recently had a grandchild announce they are trans. They had some questions, but they call their grandchild by their chosen name and use their preferred pronouns.

There were inevitably a few slips in terms of previous name when we all spent time together over Christmas, mostly not by the DGPs, which the grandchild let go.

I think people often massively overestimate the rigidity and conservativism of people in this age range.

Cazpar · 15/02/2024 14:49

BeardieWeirdie · 15/02/2024 13:37

Good opportunity for niece to learn that not everyone is on board with this, and they’re not obliged to play along with pretending she’s a boy.

This is the same kind of shit TRAs pull.

"I'm going to push my views on you no matter what and you can go and fuck yourself and it doesn't matter if you're upset, but I'm still a good person because I'm in the right."

Doesn't matter if it's coming from TRAs or those on the GC side, it's always poor behaviour.

JudgeJ · 15/02/2024 14:44

Laiste · 15/02/2024 13:50

My mother's in her 80s and would certainly put her foot right in it at some point.

Surely if it isn't a deliberate slight there's no problem there? If she keeps on doing it deliberately then that's another issue. With today's obsession with the correct terminology, which can change almost weekly, I think most people probably commit a faux pas on occasion.

ilovesooty · 15/02/2024 14:44

Cazpar · 15/02/2024 14:42

Presumably this is a loving grandparent-grandchild relationship and therefore neither have any desire to deliberately upset the other.

Therefore it would be best if GPs made an effort and weren't deliberately rude, and that DN understands that mistakes are made and doesn't kick off for an honest mistake.

Sounds fair enough to me.

Skiphopbump · 15/02/2024 14:43

A few months ago my SIL who lives abroad told DH that my nephew now identifies as a woman. Nephew still has the same name and wears the same clothing style - outwardly nothing has changed. SIL said she was going to tell her parents, they video chat online weekly.

ILs have never brought it up so we assume they are ignoring it. They use he/him pronouns when referring to him.

Ladybrrrd · 15/02/2024 14:43

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Encourage your relatives to do this only if they wish to alienate and grow apart from niece.

If they want to keep a good relationship, everyone just needs to remember to keep calm. Give your DM some grace if she forgets, give your DN some grace if she gets angsty; she is a teenager and it's what they do.

Of course it would be the height of rudeness to purposefully ignore how someone wishes to address themselves, so I'm sure they're not planning on doing that. As long as everyone does their best it will be fine.

Laiste · 15/02/2024 14:43

I'd use the new name (i mean how many times is that actually going to come up anyway after Hello Dave how are you dear?

Her getting furious about it all is her issue, and is for herself and those around her most to work on together.

LeftLion73 · 15/02/2024 14:42

SomeCatFromJapan · 15/02/2024 14:18

This stuff gives teens an awful lot of power, doesn't it?

I hope when my kids are teens they will feel they have the power to ask to be treated with basic courtesy and dignity and respect.

Cazpar · 15/02/2024 14:42

Presumably this is a loving grandparent-grandchild relationship and therefore neither have any desire to deliberately upset the other.

Therefore it would be best if GPs made an effort and weren't deliberately rude, and that DN understands that mistakes are made and doesn't kick off for an honest mistake.

Waitingfirthephone · 15/02/2024 14:39

Lovin Bud and Dude as a way through

LeftLion73 · 15/02/2024 14:39

lifeturnsonadime · 15/02/2024 14:15

I agree with Dogfisher and the Banana Room

I also feel uncomfortable with the idea of compelled speech. Everyone has to run rings about DN to the extent about worrying about family members being compelled to modify their language.

If the DN has changed their name, well lots of people do that but the rest of it is compelling everyone else to go along with something akin to a religious belief. Humans cannot change sex.

Going along with this perpetuates the myth that people can change sex and this is harmful for many many reasons.

It's not "compelled speech" to call people what they prefer to be called, it's the basic minimum courtesy of polite society, and we do it all the time in all sorts of situations. I think it's a bit anachronistic when women take their husband's name when they marry, but I don't feel I'm entitled to simply continue calling them by their maiden name - it's obviously not up to me. There's a client at work I'd love to call a twat, is it "compelled speech" that I'm not allowed to use that language in the workplace (or at least not without consequences)? My BIL has a first name that I really loathe because it's the same name as one of my exes - is it "compelled speech" that I can't just arbitrarily decide to call him Stephen instead? We change what we call people and how we address people all the time, and there are so many situations in life where we can't just say exactly what we want to - if it only becomes "compelled speech" when there's a trans person involved that just sounds like you have a problem with trans people.

Swipe left for the next trending thread