Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Aibu to ask how elderly grandparents have dealt with trans grandkids

222 replies

Lenalovewitch · 15/02/2024 12:57

My niece who is 15 is visiting from the US at Easter. DN is clearly gay and has recently also identified as a trans boy adopting a gender neutral name and third psn pronouns. My DS is dealing with it well and being as supportive as poss to DN. DN is possibly autistic and struggles socially which seems often the case for young people identifying as trans. Sorry if i am getting the terminology wrong it's a minefield. The situation has been explained now to our DPs. They are in their 80s, conservative and religious. DM is now freaking a bit about the visit and struggling to accept it. One part of me feels DN should just not make a bit deal of it as it's just a week and they are v old but this doesn't seem to be the way of things. Everyone is now is very apprehensive in advance of the visit. DN gets furious if referred to as she or her birth name which is going to be tough if the GPs/ we get it wrong. Anyone been through this with trans teenagers- how did the GPs react .

OP posts:
LeftLion73 · 15/02/2024 16:53

lifeturnsonadime · 15/02/2024 16:51

Lion do you have a GRC so you are legally male?

Having a GRC or not makes no difference to your legal rights.

LeftLion73 · 15/02/2024 16:52

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

lifeturnsonadime · 15/02/2024 16:51

LeftLion73 · 15/02/2024 16:42

"Living as a man" is a pretty meaningless statement, I agree, but it's a requirement to access gender affirming health care so I'll tell you how my clinicians defined that I have met this criteria:

  • I have told my friends, family and place of work that I am trans, I use a male-coded name (well actually my name is pretty neutral but it'll do), and I prefer he/him pronouns
  • The forms of ID that I have been able to update say male/Mr.
  • I have paperwork to evidence all of the above.

And that's it really. It doesn't really mean anything else. In terms of how I act/behave/dress etc I generally please myself.

Lion do you have a GRC so you are legally male?

LeftLion73 · 15/02/2024 16:45

Apologies for the double post, my wifi is down and I'm relying on a dodgy 4g connection.

ilovesooty · 15/02/2024 16:45

Bleakmidwinter1977 · 15/02/2024 16:34

And when someone changes a name you have long-since known them by, they should be prepared to accept that not everyone will remember and there will occasionally be slip ups.

Of course. It's courtesy to make the effort though.

LeftLion73 · 15/02/2024 16:43

hariboss · 15/02/2024 16:29

@LeftLion73 when you say you're not
a stereotypical man, I'm curious about this. As a female living a male
identity, what does living as a male or
having the identity of a
man, not a woman, entail/mean?

"Living as a man" is a pretty meaningless statement, I agree, but it's a requirement to access gender affirming health care so I'll tell you how my clinicians defined that I have met this criteria:

  • I have told my friends, family and place of work that I am trans, I use a male-coded name (well actually my name is pretty neutral but it'll do), and I prefer he/him pronouns
  • The forms of ID that I have been able to update say male/Mr.
  • I have paperwork to evidence all of the above.

And that's it really. In terms of how I act/behave/dress etc I generally please myself.

Bleakmidwinter1977 · 15/02/2024 16:42

RobertaFirmino · 15/02/2024 15:37

I don't see the name issue as being any different from when Rebecca asks you to use her full name as she hates being called Becky.

This isn't just about changing a name though? There is the wider aspect of gendered language - he/she etc.

LeftLion73 · 15/02/2024 16:42

hariboss · 15/02/2024 16:29

@LeftLion73 when you say you're not
a stereotypical man, I'm curious about this. As a female living a male
identity, what does living as a male or
having the identity of a
man, not a woman, entail/mean?

"Living as a man" is a pretty meaningless statement, I agree, but it's a requirement to access gender affirming health care so I'll tell you how my clinicians defined that I have met this criteria:

  • I have told my friends, family and place of work that I am trans, I use a male-coded name (well actually my name is pretty neutral but it'll do), and I prefer he/him pronouns
  • The forms of ID that I have been able to update say male/Mr.
  • I have paperwork to evidence all of the above.

And that's it really. It doesn't really mean anything else. In terms of how I act/behave/dress etc I generally please myself.

Bigcat25 · 15/02/2024 16:41

My parents would struggle, they do with a friend that goes by "they/them." I don't think being around in the sixties necessarily makes a difference. My parents weren't involved in sixties music and culture scene and are quite traditional. My mom acts like premarital sex is a new and shocking thing.

The Gp's should practice using the new name and pronoun as habits are hard to break. It should be explained to the niece that they are trying and making an effort, but they then do have to make a good faith effort.

lifeturnsonadime · 15/02/2024 16:38

@LeftLion73 no one has presumed to speak for you.

It is the fact that trans people want additional rights, to be treated in all respects as the opposite sex by compelling speech and for what were single sex spaces to become mixed sex when this is proven to harm women and girls, that many people object to.

This is not a simple matter of courtesy. Trans people are demanding that the whole of society shifts to accommodate trans people's wishes without consideration of the fact that this harms others.

lifeturnsonadime · 15/02/2024 16:34

LeftLion73 · 15/02/2024 15:15

"I don't have a problem with trans people, they can do what they want as long as they don't dare actually be trans" is the message you're putting across here.

But this begs the question what is a trans person?

And why does being a trans person confer additional rights on the trans person over and above the rest of society?

I have previously said that I don't care what a person wears or how they present themselves. I'm a child of the 80s and back then males frequently wore makeup and grew nails and no one batted an eyelid. Women don't have to adhere to stereotypes either, why should we?

It's imposing on others by insisting we treat trans people in all circumstances as though they are the opposite sex either by compelling speech (in this example) or accept males who identify as trans in spaces which were previously reserved for the female sex that I object to because this is proven to be harmful to women as a sex class.

Trans ideology is proven to be harmful to children too. The explosion in the number of gay , autistic or otherwise vulnerable children who identify as trans who may go on to body modifications that will make them infertile really worries me. It should worry society.

If we ask other children to treat these children as the sex they present as in all circumstances then we are eroding the rights of the other children. We are compelling the children to lie. Spaces in school become mixed sex. How is that kind to girls?

Bleakmidwinter1977 · 15/02/2024 16:34

ilovesooty · 15/02/2024 14:26

Whatever one's views it's basic courtesy to use someone's preferred name.

And when someone changes a name you have long-since known them by, they should be prepared to accept that not everyone will remember and there will occasionally be slip ups.

TheKeatingFive · 15/02/2024 16:33

I literally do not give a shit what you do or don't believe, but I'd still expect to be treated with the same basic respect, courtesy and personhood you'd grant anyone else

And I'm sure everyone on this thread would be 100% behind that. My use of pronouns refers to sex though. It always has. So the whole idea of 'Misgendering' doesn't make any sense to me. I am totally behind your right to identify as whatever gender you want to be, but it doesn't feel like that would be relevant to my interactions with you.

hariboss · 15/02/2024 16:29

@LeftLion73 when you say you're not
a stereotypical man, I'm curious about this. As a female living a male
identity, what does living as a male or
having the identity of a
man, not a woman, entail/mean?

iamjustlurking · 15/02/2024 16:27

I was concerned when my DD who is doted on by my in laws came out as they are very Conservative and Jehova Witnesses.

We didn't share her sexuality until she was in a relationship.
They were more than accepting did call her GF her friend 😂 but we felt that wasn't a hill to die on.

My line is they don't have to "understand" it just accept it if they want us in their lives

LeftLion73 · 15/02/2024 16:21

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Dogfisher · 15/02/2024 16:17

LeftLion73 the compelled speech aspect of this is that some people feel that this forces them in to outwardly complying with an ideology that they do not believe.
Many of us do not believe in this thing called a gender identity - I have a sex and a personality and that's it.

But I am a feminist and can't stand any gender stereotypes so I find this weird adherence to gender stereotypes that is now everywhere quite depressing.

The compelled speech thing is akin to someone telling you that you must say that the earth is flat or that the moon is made of cheese and if you don't then you are a bigot.

TomeTome · 15/02/2024 16:15

Ladybrrrd · 15/02/2024 15:41

"Most people", or you? You and this bubble of mumsnet who must figure out what's going on in someone's pants before they respect their pronouns. Don't include me in your "most people" please. I've got mates who have changed their pronouns two or three times. Nothing to do with their sex and never been a problem even when I do inevitably slip up.

No I mean “most people” as in the majority of people, a larger number than those that believe pronouns refer to gender. It’s factual. If you are referring to someone’s gender when you use pronouns you have a different understanding of what they are than most people. I didn’t include or exclude you in anything.

Dogfisher · 15/02/2024 16:11

Things don’t change and improve when people bend to old-fashioned opinions and ideals

Except it's not really 'old fashioned' to understand biology now is it?

TWCITW · 15/02/2024 16:06

cauliflowerqueen · 15/02/2024 15:56

I rarely ever call people by name to their face (apart from DH, perhaps), and I also rarely need to refer to people with third person pronouns in their presence, so it may not be necessary to do either, particularly during the confines of a relatively brief visit.

I'm mid-40s now, but in my youth we understood very well that the elders in our family might have different, non-politically correct opinions. It wasn't necessary to discuss those things. I don't see why this should be much different. If anyone should 'bend', I'd say it's the teenager. Surely they're aware that not everyone gives a shit about agrees that they can change sex or be 'gender neutral'. It won't be the first time someone hasn't called them by their preferred pronouns/name, assuming there were to be a slip-up.

what Non-politically correct opinions did your elders have that they had a free pass for?
If those opinions prevailed today because the younger generation should ‘bend’ for the older generation then the world would be in a bigger mess than it is already.
Things don’t change and improve when people bend to old-fashioned opinions and ideals.

itsmyp4rty · 15/02/2024 16:05

I've accidentally called my autistic son by his dads name twice today. Everyone should be polite but DN needs to get over themselves, people make mistakes.

LeftLion73 · 15/02/2024 16:04

ItsFunToBeAVampire · 15/02/2024 15:57

Yes, that comment shows that some trans people do want to compel speech, doesn't it?

No more than anyone else also wants to be addressed by their correct name and pronouns. I imagine you'd be pretty peeved if we knew each other IRL and I decided one day I was going to start referring to you as Dave and using xe/xim pronouns for you. You might even dare to try and "compel my speech" by correcting me. Again, this is not actually a trans issue specifically- we call people what they want to be called every day as a matter of course. If that only becomes a problem for you when it involves a trans person then you have a problem with trans people, not with "compelled speech".

Or you know, try calling your boss at work a cunt and see if your company accepts the "you can't compel my speech!" argument when you're pulled into a disciplinary.

thecatsthecats · 15/02/2024 16:01

LeftLion73 · 15/02/2024 13:39

I'm a trans man.

When I transitioned, I was warned I couldn't possibly expect the great aunts (three of them in their 80s, the matriarchs of our family) to remember my new name and pronouns. But in fact all three were the most careful and respectful and supportive of anyone in my family, one even continued to remember my new name long after she'd forgotten how we were related.

As such it's bizarre to me the assumption that older people can't or shouldn't or wouldn't be able to cope with trans relatives. Most people that age will have known trans people before - nothing new under the sun etc. I discovered when I came out that another relative by marriage was a trans woman, I'd had no idea previously. Age has been no predictor of who has been supportive to me and who hasn't.

This made me smile, as it reminded me of my grandma.

She had severe dementia at the end of her life, and in the care home, they realised that they always should use Asian staff to care for her because she was super polite. She didn't know who we were, but she was insistent that people were so horrible to immigrants that you should be extra kind to them.

Sodndashitall · 15/02/2024 16:01

lifeturnsonadime · 15/02/2024 15:11

Of course it's a form of compelled speech to insist a person lies about what they see with their own eyes and they know to be the truth.

Why should the grandparents be compelled to go along with the fact that their granddaughter is now a boy. It's impossible to change sex?

As someone else said it gives a person a lot of power to be able to control people in that way.

And this notion that it's unkind to tell the truth is ridiculous.

People, mostly women and children, are being harmed by the lies of gender.

No one is asking them to declare whether the grandkid is a boy or girl.
They are asking to use a name. Which doesn't matter what the name is, if that's the name that they want to go by, then those who love the kid should make the effort to call them by it.
They are also not asking to be called by the opposite gender pronoun but by neutral ones. I use these a lot as I work with people of different backgrounds and don't always know if they are a man or woman. It's no big deal. There are other cultures who don't even have gendered pronouns in their language. They haven't lied to the world either.

This is as PP said about being polite, considerate and understanding. There's a new name, a request to use it and hopefully everyone can get on board and if mistakes happen hopefully no one gets upset.

Goldshelfie · 15/02/2024 15:59

It’s not kindness to any young person to go along with the lie that they have changed sex. Using a new name is not a problem, people change their names for all sorts of reasons and she is entitled to be called a new name if that’s what she wants.

She is not entitled to be referred to as the wrong sex even when not present, just because she has decided that she has changed sex, which we all know is impossible.

Pandering to these beliefs is dangerous to young people, and the adults in their lives must hold the line on reality. This girl cannot opt out of biology, and cannot expect the world to lie about how they perceive her just because she wants them to. It’s unreasonable!

Swipe left for the next trending thread