Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Recently widowed dad selling family home

405 replies

cambridgecoral · 15/02/2024 11:18

My mum died in February last year. After starting dating before her funeral had even taken place, my dad almost immediately got himself a replacement servant from the OurTime dating website.

He is selling our family home, she is selling her little house, and they're going to buy a million pound house together.

He says he will put in his will that me and my brother are entitled to a quarter of the house upon the second death - the other two quarters being owned by her two grown up children.

He says he's 'protecting our inheritance' by putting it into property.
Is this true?
As far as I see it, my brother and I have gone from half each in the family home, to potentially a quarter in a house that half belongs his new girlfriend, who'll probably sell it to pay for her care costs in the end if dad dies before her.

How is this protecting our inheritance?
Does anyone know anything about the law on this?
I feel totally betrayed. I have a young son who now has no grandma, and she'd be devastated to know that everything she worked for was essentially being given to a family of near-strangers and not protected for her children and grandchild.

Feeling hopeless and hurt.

OP posts:
BeadedBubbles · 15/02/2024 13:03

It's awful how nasty people can be when anyone posts about potential inheritance issues. I wonder how many of the people who come out with money-grabbing accusations and platitudes like, 'nobody has a right to inherit' or 'it's his money to do what he wants with' would be quite so righteous if they were in the same position.

The thing is, inheritance isn't just about the money - it's about someone's relationship with their parents. An unequal distribution amongst siblings for example - no matter what the good reasons behind it - is likely to cause resentment based on feeing less-loved/deserving. Similarly, knowing that people you aren't even related to may receive part of your inheritance is another smack in the face from someone who has been a rotten father and husband. And knowing that this is not what your mother would have wanted must also be very distressing.

Some people also seem to think it's a given that vast sums of money will need to be spent on care in later life. Of course this may be the case, but it's by no means a certainty. My parents and in-laws all lived into their late 80s/early 90s. Only one needed to go into a care home and only one needed light-touch support from us.

AhNowTed · 15/02/2024 13:02

I understand where the OP is coming from, and her mother would likely be horrified.

My own father was marched down the aisle at the age of 80!

This is the reason neither I nor my husband would ever remarry if something happened to one of us.

What we've worked for for 40 years will go to OUR children, and not someone else's.

AdriftAbroad1 · 15/02/2024 12:55

FirstTimeMum887 · 15/02/2024 12:26

If he's abusive and was a nasty husband and dad...he won't change. I'd write off any inheritance, it won't come. I think holding on hope for this inheritance will make the grief even worse.

Absolutely. He will get worse as he gets older.
If he truly has NPD he will be enjoying this. The triangilation, hurt and control.

You have to write the money off, unfortunately.
Your poor mum x

Mistymornin · 15/02/2024 12:53

Fully understand and agree where OP is coming from. DH and myself are only just doing our wills (we are both in our 60s - I know!). We will own our house 50/50 and on death of first partner, their 50% will be inherited by our two sons. This is our way of protecting their inheritance. I know the consequences (if sons' marriage breakdown, IHT) but we are prepared to take this risk.

CadyEastman · 15/02/2024 12:51

I really feel for you OP but if your DM didn't leave a will stipulating that her share would pass to you and your siblings there is very little you can do. If he's an abuser and a narcissist your DM sadly let you down by not providing for you on her will and by staying with him.

I don't think there is much you can do now. The inheritance would have been lovely but I doubt that will happen.

nomchonge1 · 15/02/2024 12:49

JudgeJ · 15/02/2024 12:39

If they are planning to own the new house as tenants in common this is worth doing, it would protect half of the house from care home fees too if the new wife needs it, all assuming that he dies first. A trust would also protect the OP and sibling from the wife changing her will after his death and leaving everything to her children as often happens.

Ah, yes! This is exactly what I was referring to - thank you for clarifying/explaining! 😊

Worldgonecrazy · 15/02/2024 12:45

So sorry to hear about your mum and your dad’s behaviour both before and after her death. Did your mum leave a will? The earlier post quoting citizens advice may be useful. Your dad will also need probate granted, whatever the will did or didn’t say.

The only hope to keep things safe is to ask your dad to make a new will, specifying who gets what, and allowing his new partner to live in the new home if he should pre-decease her.

I hope it gets sorted, wills and inheritance cause so much bad feeling.

IncompleteSenten · 15/02/2024 12:45

Given how awful you say he is, anything she is left she will have earned.

I'm sorry you lost your mum and I understand you are angry but in order to protect yourself you have to tell yourself you have no inheritance because your father is not dead. What he has is his money and his assets and you have no control over what he chooses to do with them

Anything else will only carry on angering and upsetting you. It's clear this isn't actually about cold hard cash but unfortunately most people won't understand that.

Soontobe60 · 15/02/2024 12:45

Your DF and his new wife could own the house as tenants in common in shares according to how much each pays , eg 30%\70%. In his will he can leave his share to you, with the proviso that his wife can remain in the house until she remarried or dies then you and your brother get your share. A solicitor can sort this out easily.

Mossstitch · 15/02/2024 12:42

Simply owning as tenants in common rather than joint tenants would protect his portion. (Obviously should be 66%/33%). They can then simply will their portion to whom they wish with remaining partner having the right to live in the property til their death or when they choose to leave. This is how my parents did it and it worked correctly. (No moral judgement here, unless people have experienced this kind of childhood/family members they just don't understand💐).

Tetsuo · 15/02/2024 12:42

Thing is @cambridgecoral, if your father is as bad as you say, putting your head in a space where you're so invested regarding potential future inheritance is just going to harm you.

Your relationship and love for your mother is not levied on your father's actions now.

You're going to have to separate the two for your own sake.

Prawncow · 15/02/2024 12:41

The problem here is that your DM left it all to your DF. Understandable, as I think most folks do

Sadly, this ^ It happens so often. I wish more married women were aware of how to protect their children’s inheritance when writing a will.

Maray1967 · 15/02/2024 12:40

FinallyFeb · 15/02/2024 12:36

I’m very sorry to read this. This is why I intend that part of my share of the house will go to our DC with DH having a life interest in the house . When sold they get their ££

Why haven’t you done this yet if it’s important to you?

Because as things stand, that’s what will happen because of what our house is worth. DH will only get part of my half, so it’s not been urgent .

There are other reasons why we’ve been remiss on the will front, mostly because of arguments over who would have the DC. Now DS1 is in a position to be guardian to DS2 which is the best outcome.

But we have got an appointment booked for early next month - time to get it sorted!

JudgeJ · 15/02/2024 12:39

nomchonge1 · 15/02/2024 11:28

Im not sure, but I think he can get a trust put into his will that protects his part of the house to go to his children - worth looking into

If they are planning to own the new house as tenants in common this is worth doing, it would protect half of the house from care home fees too if the new wife needs it, all assuming that he dies first. A trust would also protect the OP and sibling from the wife changing her will after his death and leaving everything to her children as often happens.

aliceinanwonderland · 15/02/2024 12:39

springbrigid · 15/02/2024 11:42

It’s so distasteful and grubby-grabby of you to think like this. It’s your father’s house, not yours, he’s alive and can do whatever he wants with his own property and money. He can sell it and spend all the proceeds on fancy holidays before he dies if he wants to.
If your mother was that concerned about you inheriting anything she could have put that in her will. Therefore, saying that this is somehow about her hard work rather than free money for you is pretty disingenuous.
Be a better person, work on your relationship with your father, make your own money, and reflect on what warped values have led you to this sense of entitlement.

This is a bit harsh. I am certain OP's mother would have wanted her children to have her half share of the current family home (on their father's death of course). But even if she'd made a will, if the house was owned jointly, it would automatically go to him.

Laiste · 15/02/2024 12:36

Your mother didn't protect your interests in her will so she's left you at the whim of your father's will. There is no 'your inheritance' only his money/assets. I'd reset your expectations around that and if he leaves you something, see that as a bonus.

This is blunt, but true.
Accept this and move forwards with your father to put things in place for your future.

I have sympathy with your situation and understand your frustration, but I wouldn't go into negotiations announcing any of it is 'yours' though, because it isn't, and it's going to put backs up.

FinallyFeb · 15/02/2024 12:36

I’m very sorry to read this. This is why I intend that part of my share of the house will go to our DC with DH having a life interest in the house . When sold they get their ££

Why haven’t you done this yet if it’s important to you?

EllacottStrike · 15/02/2024 12:35

Your dad needs to create a property protection trust.

What that means is that on his death, his share automatically goes to you and your sibling. If dies first, legally, his half belongs to the 2 of you. In that case, should your fathers wife need to sell the house to fund nursing care for herself at a later stage, your half is ringfenced.

Maray1967 · 15/02/2024 12:33

cambridgecoral · 15/02/2024 11:25

That's not how the maths is working I'm afraid. It really will be a quarter, if that. We'll likely never see any of that. My mum would be so hurt that our interests weren't being protected.

I’m very sorry to read this. This is why I intend that part of my share of the house will go to our DC with DH having a life interest in the house . When sold they get their ££.

I will not allow all my share of the house to potentially go to a new wife and her kids.

The problem here is that your DM left it all to your DF. Understandable, as I think most folks do .

Phoeebee · 15/02/2024 12:33

T1Dmama · 15/02/2024 12:31

If you read it, op is concerned that if her dad dies first then her inheritance could go on supporting the new gf. They could come out with nothing of the money her mum worked hard to get and would’ve wanted her children to get!

I have read it. If her mother wanted her interests protecting it should have been written in the Mums will. It obviously wasn't which is why the Dad is getting to do whatever he wants with his money. An inheritance isn't a given.

CrispsandCheeseSandwich · 15/02/2024 12:33

My mum would be so hurt that our interests weren't being protected.

But she didn't protect your interests with her will either.

Pinkdelight3 · 15/02/2024 12:31

Belindabelle · 15/02/2024 11:55

Your mum could have (legally) left her half of the house to you and your brother. She didn’t. If it’s important to you make sure you don’t make the same mistake and draw up your own will to leave your estate to your own children.

Thats all we can really do. You can’t change the past. You can’t make your dad into someone he isnt. Just get on with your own life, decide the things you have control over, make your own way.

This is the bottom line I'm afraid.

My mum would be so hurt that our interests weren't being protected.

Your mother didn't protect your interests in her will so she's left you at the whim of your father's will. There is no 'your inheritance' only his money/assets. I'd reset your expectations around that and if he leaves you something, see that as a bonus.

T1Dmama · 15/02/2024 12:31

Phoeebee · 15/02/2024 12:25

Cheers for the bluntness. I just found it a bit confusing. Assuming you mean quarter of a million then. Its your Dads money to do what he wants while he's alive. If you stand to get a quarter of a million pounds between 2 of you it might be worth just saying thanks given that you could risk being cut out altogether.

If you read it, op is concerned that if her dad dies first then her inheritance could go on supporting the new gf. They could come out with nothing of the money her mum worked hard to get and would’ve wanted her children to get!

WrylyAmused · 15/02/2024 12:30

Answering the question @cambridgecoral was actually asking without any kind of moral/ethical judgement:

No, it doesn't really protect your interests at all.

If you can afford to get a solicitor or accountant to look at it, or if you're good at numbers you can set it all out and present it to him to see if you can persuade him to change his mind.

Main issues I can see are:

Can you persuade your father to buy the house with the new partner as tenants in common, in shares relative to their contribution into the property?

I.e. from what you've said, about 66% him/33% her.

You might try to sell it to him as protecting his interests in case the relationship doesn't continue, as otherwise if they buy as joint tenants she's initially presumed to own it 50/50 with him.

Having a deed of trust around the property ownership helps, but at least make sure they're tenants in common in unequal shares.

You then need him to make a Will which:

a) covers any issues about "anticipation of marriage", so that the Will isn't invalidated if he does marry the new partner

b) leaves his (66%) share of the house to you and your brother

c) (possibly) leaves the new partner only a life interest in the house, so that she can live there after he dies but cannot sell it or use it for her care fees if needed.
If he's as nasty as you say, you could probably also get him to put in provisions such that if she has a new partner/marries/ co-habits with someone after his death, then her life interest in the property terminates.

See a solicitor to get full understanding of all the above.

Also be aware that Wills can be changed at any time, as long as the person has capacity.

Offering no moral judgement on the situation, just some practical steps to try to safeguard your father's assets for you and your brother.

DancingFerret · 15/02/2024 12:29

Sadly, OP, because it's too late now, your situation could have been avoided if your parents had changed the ownership to TIC (tenants in common) and written their wills to state that on the first death their share of the property would pass to their children (or any other beneficiary of their choosing).

Other posters have outlined how your father could protect what you regard as your inheritance before buying a house with his new woman, if he's so minded, but really it's his decision.