Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Videos in place of text - is it just me!

31 replies

homelessvoter · 15/02/2024 09:36

Is it because I’m in my 40s and not a millennial or whatever- that I just switch off whenever someone puts key information into a bloody video? Instead of continuing the article in written form? …

eg) start off reading an interesting article - watch the rest on a video. Nope - cba

or - FAQs on managing my account / subscription - goes to video. I just never watch. It seems too much of a hassle! I delete the subscription sometimes to save watching it.

or - learning new module at work. Half of its in a video format with someone I don’t know yapping away. I find it really off-putting.

i can’t help but switch off. I find watching videos really uncomfortable. Not sure why! Why is so much content now in video form? Is it just for the sake of improving the website rankings - or do people genuinely want to watch rather than to read?

I know my children do - but do people in their 30s and 40s actually watch all these videos?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
WhatNoUsername · 16/02/2024 12:14

I don't like videos either. There a place for them eg if the skill is something practical that you need to actually see someone do it. But otherwise no thanks. Takes too long and usually way too much waffle. I don't have the patience and I'll drift off. Plus I like to have something to easily refer back to.

There should always be a transcription so if there isn't one I'd challenge that. No transcription means it won't be accessible to some disabled people.

SerendipityJane · 16/02/2024 10:32

Worth noting that - like podcasts - you can watch at 2x speed.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 16/02/2024 10:30

Ugh. Online training, Estimated Duration: 55 minutes.

Actual duration - once I've clicked through the irritating video/animation where somebody reads out the pretend script at the slowest pace known to humankind with appalling audio quality, often with crappy background music to interfere with hearing it, the so fucking slow click here, click there, click every fucking where for a phrase or word to sloooooowwly appear like some throwback to Powerpoint Word Art and gone straight to the bit at the end - 3 minutes 37 seconds.

The worst are the ones that do not have a transcript (because d/Deaf and Hard of Hearing people don't exist in the workplace, and it's never a workplace where there are other people getting on with their jobs and talking as you're trying to resist the impulse to hoy the computer out of the bloody window, clearly) AND lack the facility to click through at the speed of light - so you have no choice but to sit through the entire thing, taking in absolutely nothing.

lieselotte · 16/02/2024 10:18

I want to read too. The only exception to that is fitness videos, it's much easier to watch someone doing a move than follow written instructions.

And sometimes a video is easier to follow if you are trying to work out how to do something like change a tyre.

I don't like podcasts either.

Stormbornform · 16/02/2024 10:15

Gen z here. Depends on the information. If it's a how to fix your washing machine then I appreciate a YouTube video. If it's passing on info then it needs to be text or I won't click on it.

Moltenpink · 16/02/2024 09:56

Totally agreed. I was trying to help my son with his maths homework last night, I couldn’t remember how to do the topic and I was trying to work it out from the video they provided. Absolute nightmare, had to keep pausing and flipping back to the question to work through each part. Would have taken a fraction of the time using a written example.

2024name · 16/02/2024 09:53

I would say, it all depends on the content and the purpose. My preferred method of learning how to do something technical, is to be shown on a one to one basis, so I can actually carry out the operations whilst being instructed.

If I am sent a short video, then this can be helpful, because I can see what the individual is doing (e.g. which keys are being pressed). A wiki with screen shots can also be helpful.

For more theoretical learning, which will be incorporated in an essay or report, then I like text, but short videos explaining concepts also help.

What really frustrates me are badly designed module or courses which comprise repetitive videos, click and match exercises, cloze text exercises, some badly synched virtual learning assistant (where the mouth movements do not match the speech) and waffling paragraphs of contextualising information, for a topic that could be covered by a sheet of information with a few questions at the end.

I am a 'Boomer' (although at the younger end) and so I embrace new technologies (I can remember ploughing through badly written, dry text books and writing whole theses out by hand) and I have found that as I have got older, I need much more of a variety of media to learn from (I love short instructional videos on You Tube to tell me how to do little jobs around the house and so on, but I also like to read academic papers when they are relevant). Yet, I am aware that whilst videos can be helpful, we need variety with respect to how information is presented.

homelessvoter · 16/02/2024 09:43

Finally found my tribe!

OP posts:
pyrocantha · 16/02/2024 09:37

ShiveringMeTimbers · 15/02/2024 09:41

I’m a millennial and find videos unbearable. I speed them up if possible. A friend sends me random YT videos which are often 17+ minutes long and I don’t understand how she has the patience to sit through them. I can barely sit through a 2 minute video. I do have ADHD though which could be a factor.

This is me though I am gen x
I read very very quickly though

EmpressaurusOfTheScathingTinsel · 16/02/2024 09:13

I think one reason I prefer text is control. I can read at my chosen speed & go back over bits without having to fiddle around finding the right place.

upthespoutagain · 16/02/2024 09:11

Yes, loads of my training courses have videos that are unskippable. Doesn't mean I have to wear the earbuds or stay on that tab, though. I just let it burble away while I scan through the summary. It's strange because I love watching normal people sharing their passions on Youtube, but this overly scripted, badly-acted crap turns me off.

Octonaut4Life · 16/02/2024 09:07

Actually so delighted to see lots of other people who feel the same way, I'm only mid thirties but can't stand watching videos for any length of time, I just switch off completely. Have wondered if I have ADHD so interesting a few other people have mentioned that.

Katieflake · 16/02/2024 09:05

Yes hate them.
Very occasionally I will search YouTube for video instructions for something where it’s helpful to see it being done but I will skip to the relevant section.
for anything else please just give me text

ChessieFL · 16/02/2024 09:04

Yes, I hate this. Lots of our training at work now is videos and it’s really annoying. It takes longer to watch in the first place and then is much harder to refer back to later if you want to check a specific point, whereas it’s much easier to find something in written notes.

I generally switch off mentally after a few minutes of watching or listening to something - my mind just wanders no matter how interesting the thing I’m watching or listening to is! With audiobooks I have to restrict myself to books I’m already familiar with, or non fiction books, so I don’t lose track of the plot. I don’t watch a lot of TV dramas or films for this reason too. When I read it’s much easier for me to concentrate and take in the information.

megletthesecond · 16/02/2024 09:02

Yanbu. They're mostly long winded.

newnamechangeforthisone · 16/02/2024 09:02

I hate it too! I'm profoundly head of hearing though, so I need it loud and I have ADHD so I can't retain the information, whereas with text I can go back and forth. I'm 40.

BreakfastAtMimis · 16/02/2024 09:00

I'm with you. I never watch videos. I did a training course recently which used loads of videos and I clicked on "read transcript" every single time. I can scan and read text more quickly, I don't want to have to spend several minutes watching a video. If there had been no transcript, I'd just have skipped it.

EmpressaurusOfTheScathingTinsel · 16/02/2024 08:57

Video recipes.

Instead of just copying & pasting the ingredients to my shopping list I have to write them down as I watch & then type them in, and then constantly stop & start the video. So annoying that I don’t bother unless something looks really good & then I hunt for a written version elsewhere.

SerendipityJane · 16/02/2024 08:52

It's all to do with "da clickz". Much easier to monetise videos than text.

So now rather than reading a quick "how to in 10 seconds", you need to watch some influencer twat for 10 minutes.

If any of the videos you end up watching are about the decline in workforce productivity, the universe may very well explode.

homelessvoter · 16/02/2024 08:37

Not just me then! But apparently still not that many people… I think we are in the minority!

@TitInATrance mugging to the camera - cringe!

@LauritaEvita I think the corporate videos are probably the worst!

@ButWhatAboutTheBees voice notes - me either. I either listen two weeks too late or don’t bother.

OP posts:
TitInATrance · 15/02/2024 10:09

I’m in my 60s and I feel exactly the same. Even a Ted talk will have me reading the transcript.

I can cope with short comedy clips. A previous post reminds me that at 25 I did several weeks IT training based on IBM videos (pre VHS!) I think this worked because they were newsreader style, no mugging the camera or promotions for the next course.

LauritaEvita · 15/02/2024 09:59

It doesn’t help that my workplace has bought all our compulsory training from some naff American company with presenters that talk like they’re on kids tv e.g. ‘make sure your your computer is password protected cos you don’t want any nasty folks to get in!’ accompanied by an image of a cartoon villain. I now just read the script or mute and read subtitles to get through it.

ButWhatAboutTheBees · 15/02/2024 09:59

Put the transcript with the video, let me read that then skip to the end of the video!

Same with voice notes tbh. If you leave me a voice note instead of a text there's a 98% chance I'll never listen

erinaceus · 15/02/2024 09:59

I’m like this too. I find it’s to do with the pace information comes at me. Being unable to control that means I can find it difficult to take in details or understand properly: the irrelevant bits are too slow and the important bits are too fast.

Allegedly it’s easier to put together a video than a written piece which is part of how this is happening (not sure I can see that, I’d rather write something than film myself).

homelessvoter · 15/02/2024 09:58

17 minutes! Ffs! 😅 Ok so that’s interesting as I see lots of adhd content made by and for folks with adhd. Yes to speeding them up @ShiveringMeTimbers!

Impatience is definitely the major factor for me. I feel that if I can read the info I can pick and chose which bits are relevant but with a video you have to work harder to avoid the branding bit, or the basic bits you already know etc.

Plus I find that watching someone talk - who isn’t actually there say on Zoom - is uncomfortable. I don’t know why??

ah adhd… So I’ve diagnosed myself with this 🤣 but no seriously, so my sibling has adhd and watches tons of videos. And they forward me quite a few too which I never open.

OP posts: