Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to ask parents to condition their sons this way?

109 replies

TiredGatekeeper · 15/02/2024 08:38

There is a situation in my marriage that has been going on for years and I am sick of it. However, before I go into that, I want to explain what I see as the best case scenario.

I have brothers. They are both married to nice women. One lives close to my parents, the other a few hours away. Both of my brothers go out with my parents, pop in on their way somewhere or back, arrange to go out with my dad to the footy, go round for a cup of tea etc. ON THEIR OWN. Sometimes they bring their wife, or wife and DC, but a lot of the time they go round to my parents on their own. FYI they are not neglecting their families. They are "popping in" for a bit, or spending an hour with them if their wife is off doing something. Also, my grown up nieces and nephews do this. They call up, then pop in. My SIL's are very nice, and very welcome when they come over. They are family and we love them.

My DH does none of this. It is as if I am the gatekeeper. Everything seems to have to be run by me. An example is we have been invited to something, I can't go, so he said "we can't go as TiredG is busy". Why can't he go on his own?
He never pops in, goes round on his own, has an independent relationship with his blood family. I am certainly not a control freak, I want him to go. Why can't I see them sometimes, and the rest of the time he goes and has a cup of tea, goes down to Homebase with his dad and other stuff?

As a result there is animosity between PIL and me. They think I block them. I don't. My DH just doesn't want to go there alone. I can see that a lot of it is that his mum and dad are difficult. I know I have a DH problem, but he has also been conditioned this way. When he got married his mum basically wrote off having a son, even though it turns out DH and I do way more for them than their DD's. My FIL wouldn't be allowed out without MIL at his side, so I also think my DH has been conditioned that your wife controls your movements and you don't do anything without her say so. My MIL thinks it is all my fault, and I am quote: "the one wearing the trousers" but that really isn't true according to my own family and friends, who say he clearly does. I think it is their fault, for not investing enough time and effort and having a good relationship with their son.

So, I'd like to ask mums (and dads) to instil in their sons that just because they have met someone, doesn't mean they lose all autonomy over their familial relationships, and it is OK, and in fact healthy to still go hang out with your parents and siblings ON YOUR OWN.

Women do this all the time. It is not controlling, or manipulative, or you are not a MIL from hell if your adult son comes over and chills on your sofa for an hour with a cup of tea and goes and opens the fridge and gazes a bit. In fact, it is healthy.

OP posts:
GingerIsBest · 15/02/2024 10:28

Well sure, but you're describing a fairly dysfunctional family set up so I think it's pretty obvious that your PIL, and anyone like them, is not going to do this as it's not how they operate.

Also, to be fair to in laws, even good ones with good relationships with their sons, I think that on some level, men are taught and programmed by society to be selfish. Or perhaps it's just that selfish behaviour by boys and men isn't knocked on the head in the same way? Hopefully that's changing now.

But in the meantime, parents can't believe their darling child would not want to just hang out with them, so they blame his partner. And of course, there is a ridiculous expectation that women will control things in the home so she is responsible for presents and cards and celebrations (which drives me crazy frankly and the only reason I haven't 100% lost it with DH's family is because it irritates him as much as it irritates me).

Givemepickles · 15/02/2024 10:20

YABU. Other parents aren't all like your parents. They don't all respect and value their children. HTH

bozzabollix · 15/02/2024 10:19

They can’t face their own fuck up, so they are blaming you, it’s easier.

LamonicBibber1 · 15/02/2024 10:16

With my exh, I was a convenient excuse for him to avoid seeing his awful overbearing mother. Even though their relationship was nothing to do with me and I didn't interfere with it or control what he chose to do.

I sympathised with it though, he wasn't able to be direct with her about the real reasons, and I had no problem being the villain 😂 I've also used him as an excuse to not have to see my own unpleasant mother. It's a lazy excuse though and never dealt with the real issues surrounding not wanting to see her.

Just because his siblings have a better relationship with the parents, doesn't mean that they've ever treated their kids the same, so maybe he doesn't want that relationship to be as they are. A shame he can't be more direct with them though.

TheSnowyOwl · 15/02/2024 10:15

For all the criticism and comments I see on here about men not being close with their families or independently spending time with them, I can only think of two males (friend’s husbands) who even remotely fit this category and both of them have unpleasant parents so who can blame them. It’s just not normal from what I can see.

MillshakePickle · 15/02/2024 10:10

Don't tell others how to raise/condition their children. I'd be embarrassed if I were you.

DevotedSisterBelovedCunt · 15/02/2024 10:08

Just stop being the gatekeeper?

He doesn't want to see his parents much, and from how you've described them I can see why. Why is that a problem at all, let alone your problem? Just forget about it.

Maybe once and for all you could make it clear to them that you're not the one stopping him, but honestly I wouldn't bother caring enough to even do that. Stop giving headspace to these people's opinions of you.

RhubarbGingerJam · 15/02/2024 10:03

DH has an OK relationship with his parents. His mother is very controlling to the point his dad isn't allowed to pick out his own clothes to wear.

I do have a DH problem, but I think his parents haven't encouraged a good relationship with him. They massively favour his sisters.

Are you sure he actually wants a relationship with them - perhaps he likes the distance one he has - one where he doesn't have to deal with a controlling parent and being ignored in favour of siblings. Are you trying to project an ideal relationship you think he should have on him.

My DH and brother visits their parents by themselves and always have done . I tend to like to drag DH on my visits as otherwise my parents can't help but fuck up my travel plans and don't do that when he's there - and I've tried everything to stop them over the years.

Also don't get the checking with you issues as I've had opposite problem, I've spent years getting DH to check with me/calendar before agree visits as we are some considerable and thus expense distance away and they like our full attention - so we don't have clashed with kids of other things because clashes are always my fault and there are things especially for the kids I refuse to cancel.

DH deals with his family as I learnt early that women in his family can frequently do no right so refused to do any wife work or like MIL tried to dump on me. I have still found myself blamed for stuff I had no part in at all though because that's what they do.

I would talk to you DH about blaming you for things and tell him to stop - but he's a grown ass adult fuck conditioning tell him what you expect and see what he actually says and listen - he may not want to deal with his parents at all.

makeanddo · 15/02/2024 09:41

I think some women need to take responsibility here too. Let's face it women are still doing the bulk of the bringing up children. There seems to often be an expectation that the wife/partner instigates contact, organising gifts, make sure beds are made and food in for visits etc essentially keeping the family contact going.

I always think it's easier to let each party sort their own family. Work as a team but the 'lead' is whoever's family it is. Many people seem so old fashioned still.

BingoMarieHeeler · 15/02/2024 09:37

YABU to ask anyone to do anything in this sense. Hate that tone! But YANBU regarding the issue.

MightyGoldBear · 15/02/2024 09:36

I'd step down being the gate keeper leave all planning and communication down to your oh. If he doesn't see them he doesn't. It's not your job to facilitate their relationships or your ohs.

Concentrate on your relationships with your children. Being healthy parents who can listen take on board others views and wants for their lives. Is the way to go to ensure they want to actually spend time with you when they grow up.

My husband has recently stopped seeing his parents as much he felt obliged previously but never enjoyed it. They are controlling stuck in their ways can't listen. It's easier for them to blame me as the outsider daughter in law than it is to check their own behaviour.

user146990847101 · 15/02/2024 09:25

SomethingDifferentt · 15/02/2024 09:10

How is your DHs relationship with his parents? They might just not be that close

This. All relationships are not equal.

Dh is similar to ops husband. When we see his mum, it's all of us. Or at least him and dc. He will do errands for his mum when requested, alone, but doesn't 'visit' her alone, ever. For years and years.

It's not because he's an arsehole or lazy or because he's been 'conditioned'.

It's actually because he's a nice guy. He knows his mum is lonely and in poor health. He knows he 'should' (societally) have a relationship with his mum, and allow his dc to have this. But he doesn't want to, for too many reasons to list. I could probably write a book about how dysfunctional dh's upbringing was, and how damaged his relationship with his mum was due solely to her actions. He left home at 15 after being calmly told he was old enough to look after himself now.

He's not close to his mum with good reason. If it wasn't for the existence of the dc he probably wouldn't see her ever - maybe a duty visit every year. As it is, we see her probably every other month and I'm well aware that dc and I are dh's protective blanket for such visits. Once I understood this I'm happy to be it tbh.

Just for clarity - we're not talking about abuse here because if that was the case I obviously wouldn't allow dc to visit. But there are a whole truckload of poor, miserable childhood experiences that fall short of abuse yet mean your dc are not going to be volunteering to pop round for lunch in adulthood...even when on the surface they've put things behind them.

You’ve described our situation much more eloquently than I did - this is exactly how it is for us.
We’ve been together since late teens, and are now 50ish…when we were young I used to instigate dinners, christmases, and general hanging out with his family partly because I have little family of my own. But once we had our own kids at 30ish, I think I finally saw how they treated him and our children who were also second to his siblings children. DH was frankly thrilled to step back as he’d only been going along with it to please me.
MIL is now 80 and I’m sure siblings have a moan about how little we help out but tough!
It’s a good lesson in treating your children equally and fairly.

TonTonMacoute · 15/02/2024 09:21

Mashedorboiled · 15/02/2024 08:49

So, I'd like to ask mums (and dads) to instil in their sons that just because they have met someone, doesn't mean they lose all autonomy over their familial relationships

Very few people are 'conditioning' their sons otherwise? Why would they??
Your husband's attitude sounds very odd.

This.

I would have thought people would be more worried about possibly losing contact with a son when he gets married.

You've just married into a strange family!

CanaryCanary · 15/02/2024 09:18

This sounds like quite a weird specific family dynamic, I’m not sure it’s a general problem with men? All the husbands I know spend time independently with their parents and siblings.

KnittingKnewbie · 15/02/2024 09:14

I (F) do not like visiting my mother without my DH because I don't like spending time with her and I need someone to break the ice (not quite the expression I'm looking for). That's not my DH's fault, it's my DM's

35965a · 15/02/2024 09:11

Not everyone has the same relationship with their family. Your DH felt his sisters were favoured and therefore isn’t that arsed about seeing his parents. Yeah, they blame you and he lets them because it’s easier than having that conversation with them directly. Not everyone can or does get on. In your PILs case it’s ’you reap what you sow.’

SomethingDifferentt · 15/02/2024 09:10

How is your DHs relationship with his parents? They might just not be that close

This. All relationships are not equal.

Dh is similar to ops husband. When we see his mum, it's all of us. Or at least him and dc. He will do errands for his mum when requested, alone, but doesn't 'visit' her alone, ever. For years and years.

It's not because he's an arsehole or lazy or because he's been 'conditioned'.

It's actually because he's a nice guy. He knows his mum is lonely and in poor health. He knows he 'should' (societally) have a relationship with his mum, and allow his dc to have this. But he doesn't want to, for too many reasons to list. I could probably write a book about how dysfunctional dh's upbringing was, and how damaged his relationship with his mum was due solely to her actions. He left home at 15 after being calmly told he was old enough to look after himself now.

He's not close to his mum with good reason. If it wasn't for the existence of the dc he probably wouldn't see her ever - maybe a duty visit every year. As it is, we see her probably every other month and I'm well aware that dc and I are dh's protective blanket for such visits. Once I understood this I'm happy to be it tbh.

Just for clarity - we're not talking about abuse here because if that was the case I obviously wouldn't allow dc to visit. But there are a whole truckload of poor, miserable childhood experiences that fall short of abuse yet mean your dc are not going to be volunteering to pop round for lunch in adulthood...even when on the surface they've put things behind them.

Seeline · 15/02/2024 09:08

So his mum is massively controlling
And his parents (mum?) strongly favoured his sisters.

Hmmm ... I wonder why uses every excuse he can to limit contact?

TheLambtonWorm · 15/02/2024 09:06

Your husband doesn't visit because his parents don't sound like particularly nice people. What you mean is "Can only well rounded, mentally healthy people procreate and raise the same well rounded children?" which is stupid.

user146990847101 · 15/02/2024 09:01

”they massively favour his sisters”
There you go then! Same here with DH, his siblings have to be cosseted and fussed over, he got fed up with being the capable one that didn’t get help, either financially or with time, advice, anything really!

So now, when he wants a handy excuse not to get involved me or the kids are often the excuse. It is what it is - not my circus!

Tatonka · 15/02/2024 08:59

Agree. Generally though don't people tend to visit family with their partners assuming everyone gets along? My DH feels sad if I visit my parents alone as he really loves them. For me visiting on my own or with my DH isn't any different

SquirrelsStars · 15/02/2024 08:56

It's not about being a son or daughter. It's about your dh not wanting to go over more than he has to - and you've given some examples of why that might be.

Aecor · 15/02/2024 08:55

TiredGatekeeper · 15/02/2024 08:53

Perhaps I should change condition to encourage.

DH has an OK relationship with his parents. His mother is very controlling to the point his dad isn't allowed to pick out his own clothes to wear.

I do have a DH problem, but I think his parents haven't encouraged a good relationship with him. They massively favour his sisters.

I do think though that our sons do not have as good, or free and easy a relationship with their parents as daughters do. I want to change this. I think my brothers have a very good relationship with my parents and I want this for my own sons.

Don’t you think it might have something to do with the individuals in question?

TiredGatekeeper · 15/02/2024 08:53

Perhaps I should change condition to encourage.

DH has an OK relationship with his parents. His mother is very controlling to the point his dad isn't allowed to pick out his own clothes to wear.

I do have a DH problem, but I think his parents haven't encouraged a good relationship with him. They massively favour his sisters.

I do think though that our sons do not have as good, or free and easy a relationship with their parents as daughters do. I want to change this. I think my brothers have a very good relationship with my parents and I want this for my own sons.

OP posts:
Changeusernameseeusernamehistory · 15/02/2024 08:50

SquirrelsStars · 15/02/2024 08:41

Well it's your husband so maybe you should sort it out, rather than blaming his and everyone else's parents...

Proving the OP’s point …