Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to ask parents to condition their sons this way?

109 replies

TiredGatekeeper · 15/02/2024 08:38

There is a situation in my marriage that has been going on for years and I am sick of it. However, before I go into that, I want to explain what I see as the best case scenario.

I have brothers. They are both married to nice women. One lives close to my parents, the other a few hours away. Both of my brothers go out with my parents, pop in on their way somewhere or back, arrange to go out with my dad to the footy, go round for a cup of tea etc. ON THEIR OWN. Sometimes they bring their wife, or wife and DC, but a lot of the time they go round to my parents on their own. FYI they are not neglecting their families. They are "popping in" for a bit, or spending an hour with them if their wife is off doing something. Also, my grown up nieces and nephews do this. They call up, then pop in. My SIL's are very nice, and very welcome when they come over. They are family and we love them.

My DH does none of this. It is as if I am the gatekeeper. Everything seems to have to be run by me. An example is we have been invited to something, I can't go, so he said "we can't go as TiredG is busy". Why can't he go on his own?
He never pops in, goes round on his own, has an independent relationship with his blood family. I am certainly not a control freak, I want him to go. Why can't I see them sometimes, and the rest of the time he goes and has a cup of tea, goes down to Homebase with his dad and other stuff?

As a result there is animosity between PIL and me. They think I block them. I don't. My DH just doesn't want to go there alone. I can see that a lot of it is that his mum and dad are difficult. I know I have a DH problem, but he has also been conditioned this way. When he got married his mum basically wrote off having a son, even though it turns out DH and I do way more for them than their DD's. My FIL wouldn't be allowed out without MIL at his side, so I also think my DH has been conditioned that your wife controls your movements and you don't do anything without her say so. My MIL thinks it is all my fault, and I am quote: "the one wearing the trousers" but that really isn't true according to my own family and friends, who say he clearly does. I think it is their fault, for not investing enough time and effort and having a good relationship with their son.

So, I'd like to ask mums (and dads) to instil in their sons that just because they have met someone, doesn't mean they lose all autonomy over their familial relationships, and it is OK, and in fact healthy to still go hang out with your parents and siblings ON YOUR OWN.

Women do this all the time. It is not controlling, or manipulative, or you are not a MIL from hell if your adult son comes over and chills on your sofa for an hour with a cup of tea and goes and opens the fridge and gazes a bit. In fact, it is healthy.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
cockadoodledandy · 19/02/2024 10:59

You don’t have a DH problem. You have an in laws problem. They sound toxic and I don’t blame your husband for not wanting to be around them unless he needs to be. Don’t force him; he’s probably spent a lot of his life waiting for the time he can get away from them. Have you considered he might want to cut ties to them?

Just because someone is a blood relative doesn’t mean they aren’t toxic.

Katemax82 · 19/02/2024 07:23

My dh avoids seeing his mum as much as possible. Of course it's my fault so I know where you are coming from

Spicastar · 18/02/2024 22:47

You say you're scared your own sons won't visit you because DH doesn't like visiting his overbearing and controlling mother. This is a more complex situation than monkey see, monkey do. Your sons will base their decisions on whether they have a close, caring, mutual relationship with you and that's what you can try to build now. They don't just decide not to see you because dad doesn't see grandma. You're not your MIL and your sons have a different upbringing and childhood memories than your DH, I'd believe. Focus on creating beautiful memories and a warm relationship with your own kids and stop pressuring your DH to see a person he's clearly not comfortable to visit alone. Cut him some slack.

fruitbrewhaha · 18/02/2024 22:08

I think your situation is unusual here op.

What happens when you tell your dh to go without you? And that he needs to facilitate his relationship with his parents.

RhubarbGingerJam · 17/02/2024 17:52

TiredGatekeeper · 16/02/2024 08:08

I hate that we all end up going to the in laws house and it ends up as a whole day affair and we all have to do the same thing like go for a walk. It's so suffocating.

Same here. It is a whole day out drinking endless tea, and sitting on the sofa for 6 hours. I wish we did go for a walk!

Why can't you say oh we'll have to go now - or insist on a walk? My IL block anything I suggest so have sometimes got DC or DH to suggest or just announce we are doing a trip to shop etc and ignore/brush off any attempts to stop.

Why aren't you talking to husband pre arrange walks or cut short visits - telling him to stop blaming you for things and pushing his family jobs back at him.

I think Op you should stop being so passive and thus growing quietly resentful - have a clear conversation with your DH and stop just accepting the situation. If you're unhappy at 6 hour visits stop doing them - meet them somewhere else or have something to rush back for - or use your words and leave or just refuse to go to them.

mathanxiety · 17/02/2024 17:27

Xiaoxiong · 15/02/2024 08:44

If you pull DH up on it and say "why are you blaming me here, you can go round on your own without me" what does he say?

Or if you say "you are causing bad blood between your parents and me because they think I am blocking you going round, which I absolutely am not and you need to cut it out blaming me for this"

This.

You're a human shield, OP.

Emma8924 · 17/02/2024 17:15

Maybe for whatever reason he doesn’t feel comfortable visiting alone. Just have a conversation wit him about it, and explain the issue you have with it

Laiste · 17/02/2024 17:13

Surely you can point to your brother's loving relationship with your parents wrt answering your son's questions?

You don't have a husband problem. You have a you problem.

Leave his relationship with his parents to him to manage and stop worrying about what they think. They sound like umpleasable people. You're enabling their twattery by giving it headspace.

Ariona · 17/02/2024 17:02

Why do you even care what your IL's think about you??

Catza · 17/02/2024 16:47

This is MN so you will be getting “nobody is controlling their DHs and DCs” from the same people who go ballistic every time their husband doesn’t check in when they arrive at work.

Julimia · 17/02/2024 16:11

You say ' Lose all autonomy' but really has there ever been any autonomy to lose?

asdunno · 17/02/2024 06:24

I find my dad hard work . I do go see him alone but I prefer it when someone comes with me as conversation is easier.

I use to be the one arranging to see dh side but I stopped as I find them stressful. Now we see them around once a month and dh sorts it. We usually all go together but if dh had a reason to he would pop and see them alone. (They are a bit further away tho so we don't tend to just nip in for a cuppa)

JustMyView13 · 17/02/2024 06:03

Just because you are related to someone, it doesn’t mean you have to like them or enjoy their company. I think you’re other thinking it & he probably cannot face his difficult parents without a bit of moral support.
you’re never going to change the MILs opinion of you so you need to find a way of letting it go like water off a ducks back. You’ll be much happier.

Frangipanyoul8r · 17/02/2024 00:04

I have a great relationship with my parents but never visit them on my own. My whole extended family visits each other in groups, we’re a big sociable family. It would feel strange to have small one to one chats. It isn’t because of a sense of obligation, it’s just how we do it.

HollyKnight · 16/02/2024 23:55

I don't really think this is a DH problem in this case. Your in-laws aren't nice, kind, loving easy-going people who he is neglecting to visit because he's lazy. They're the opposite, so I think it's understandable that he avoids them. They blame you because they're not going to blame themselves.

Whyohwhywyoming · 16/02/2024 22:39

Your DH doesn’t want to see his parents because he doesn’t have the best relationship with them, and given how they sound, regardless of what he did or said, they would blame whoever he was married to.

Cornflakes44 · 16/02/2024 22:03

Does he go out by himself to other things? Work events, friends stuff. Or is it just the family? If just family he probably wants you to do the heavy lifting socially. It's lazy and annoying but is it your problem to solve? It's probably easier said than done but you could just leave it. Try not to care what they think of you. Make it clear if anyone asks he won't go on his own. tell your children adults do go see their family but dad just doesn't want to go on his own, tell them to ask him why. If he doesn't want a closer relationship with his family then leave him to it.

missushbbb · 16/02/2024 21:55

Hmm I don't know about this one. My parents in law act like that, all decisions through his mum, my DH is the opposite I wish he was more like his
Dad, he does what he likes! However he does see his family without me, will take kids over, but usually it's all of us- his parents are quite quiet so he likes me there to do the heavy lifting I think! I have a son and I hope he does see me himself- I'll be like Pamela in Gavin and Stacy 😂

diddl · 16/02/2024 21:51

but really, you want these people in your life? Are they worth the effort? Mine aren’t!

But you still make effort on behalf of your husband?

Does he want you to?

NoThanksymm · 16/02/2024 21:05

lol! I have a similar situation. DH parents kinda suck, they treat him like the unwanted step child. EVERYTHING is ALWAYS about his sister. Including our wedding.

i bug him too arrange Christmas and at least one other get together a year (live ten hours apart,score) and it’s like pulling teeth.

he of course gets all the credit and I get the first side eye. Send his mum flowers and HES sooo thoughtful (lol. Not a descriptive work for him), you know, the things.

no bigs. I don’t much like them because they treat him like crap.

And honestly I’m ok taking the crap because it’s his relationship with them that matters, not mine. But I’d appreciate some recognition from him.

anyway. You’re not alone. And maybe his family sucks more than yours and he doesn’t want to pop over for tea.

maybe start loudly suggesting on speaker phone that your busy but he may be free?

but really, you want these people in your life? Are they worth the effort? Mine aren’t!

diddl · 16/02/2024 20:37

I'd be pretty fucking furious if my DH told my in laws he cannot go over because I am busy and therefore blaming me.

And don't his parents say that it's ok to visit alone?

Obviously not if they think Op is blocking him.

I suppose that's easier than admitting that your son isn't bothered about seeing you.

I wonder if he ever lived alone what he did then?

MumblesParty · 16/02/2024 20:33

LoveAHamSandwhich · 16/02/2024 19:15

Yet another aspect of men's behaviour that women are apparently supposed to be responsible for 🙄

Yes I was thinking the same. Something of an irony OP. You’re fed up with being responsible for men so you’re asking other women to be responsible for future men!

LauderSyme · 16/02/2024 19:38

AhNowTed · 15/02/2024 13:22

Once you're a grown adult, it's time to stop blaming your upbringing for your actions.

Often much easier said than done. It takes a lot of insight and emotional work to move beyond the templates set in childhood by one's caregivers. It is more than many people can manage.

You sound like someone who either had an entirely unproblematic childhood and can't imagine anyone else's being otherwise, or someone who is emotionally shut down and in denial.

BronwenTheBrave · 16/02/2024 19:37

Yes, important to condition men from birth.
I believe there are various training regimes that can be adopted. At worst, a stick or carrot approach can be used. Those that can’t be conditioned will face a difficult future.

FirstTimeMum887 · 16/02/2024 19:26

You have a DH problem. I'd be pretty fucking furious if my DH told my in laws he cannot go over because I am busy and therefore blaming me. Like that's seriously not ok.

Blaming parents everywhere is not your solution.