Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

"Human Remains" isn't specific enough

256 replies

Woodenwonder · 14/02/2024 22:02

Last weekend had an impromptu wander around the world museum in Liverpool. (Fantastic and free). Anyway in the Egypt section it states that the next exhibit features human remains or words to that effect. I'm thinking a sarcophagus with a mummy inside. And yes that was there, a couple of examples of wrapped up mummies, tastefully and respectfully displayed. Turn the corner and there are 3+ corpses. Not wrapped up and obviously somewhat dessicated.

I'm not squeamish but I find looking at a collection of led out bodies (albeit 1000s of years old) a bit disrespectful for want of a better word. It made me feel really weird.

Yes these souls are long gone but I was not prepared to see them laid out in that way. I don't think I was even expecting full bodies.

Aibu to think the sign could have been a touch more descriptive before entering the room?

The museum is a fantastic place but I just felt a little rattled.

OP posts:
Scalottia · 15/02/2024 05:43

Mumoftwo1312 · 15/02/2024 03:48

On the one hand op goes on about being respectful, a self styled "mega empath", then on the other, using a phrase like "human pepperami". Comparing a dead body to a cheap snack.

Yabu op, yabu.

Yep. OP is trying ever so hard to be witty. Soon there will be spat out tea and woken babies!

Since when did people become so fragile and delicate? We will all be human remains one day.

Our ancestors are probably shaking their heads at our need for trigger warnings. I wish that term would get in the bin! (Yes OP you didn't mention trigger warning, but you may as well have).

Scalottia · 15/02/2024 05:33

That's....that's what human remains are, OP. Remains of a human. You are being a little ridiculous.

Charlize43 · 15/02/2024 05:29

Mrsloverlover · 14/02/2024 22:24

Honestly at this rate museums are going to need 10 minute trigger warning videos before we go in . It’ll be like when you go trampolining and you have to watch a special safety vid first .

I was on a H&S course a while back where one delegate was complaining about trigger warnings saying that they raised her anxiety levels! 😂

ChocolateRat · 15/02/2024 03:59

What's the intent of the notice?

If it's there just to attempt to get people into a respectful state of mind and demeanour and to behave appropriately, then I think "the next exhibit features human remains" is sufficient.

But if it's intended to give an idea of the nature of what's there, let people know that the next room has certain exhibits that not every visitor may feel comfortable viewing, and give people an opportunity to make an informed decision on whether members of their party might find it distressing, then yeah, I agree that "human remains" is a bit too vague to fulfil that purpose adequately.

Not everybody can be assumed to have the existing knowledge or understanding to know precisely what to expect in that room. "Human remains" can be things like ashes in a jar, a single finger bone barely visible behind glass, an unrecognisable dried-out or preserved organ, a whole wrapped mummy complete with mask and accoutrements, ancient remnants of skeleton mixed up with grave goods, or sometimes a full desiccated corpse with face visible.

(I once came across the last of those completely unexpectedly, in a small Italian church. "Oh this looks like a nice church", "Ah isn't this bit beautiful", "It's so calm and cool walking through here", BAM surprise corpse display case. I should probably have read the town guidebook first, in retrospect.)

And many people who could cope with a murky finger bone, or a jar with a sign saying there are human parts inside, or a fully wrapped mummy, might struggle with seeing a dead human being, skin stretched taut over bones, and for a lot of reasons, may not have realised that they'd be seeing that. It could be the first dead person they've ever seen.

So really to me it depends what they were trying to do with the sign.

If it's to signal that respectful behaviour is expected in the next room, it's fine.

If it's intended to provide useful information to help people choose whether the display will be appropriate for their party, it's only useful if you have such a level of preexisting knowledge about what's there that you probably don't really need the sign.

DreamTheMoors · 15/02/2024 03:55

I wonder how I’d feel about my body being on display in a museum 2500-3000 years from now.
Oh God is my hair okay?
Is my stomach flat enough?
How do my nails look?
Do my earrings match my outfit?

Or would I laugh my ass off that somebody thought I was that important enough to put me on display in the first place.

slore · 15/02/2024 03:49

Cherryon · 14/02/2024 22:07

Egyptians would probably be glad their bodies are being safely preserved instead of being ground up to make medicine or charms.

They wouldn't be pleased, they were buried with many objects, inscriptions and rituals to assist them in their afterlife. Taking them out of their tombs is not what they would have wanted.

Mumoftwo1312 · 15/02/2024 03:48

On the one hand op goes on about being respectful, a self styled "mega empath", then on the other, using a phrase like "human pepperami". Comparing a dead body to a cheap snack.

Yabu op, yabu.

Tatonka · 15/02/2024 03:25

Changingplace · 14/02/2024 22:28

The Bodies exhibition I saw was full bodies, so you should research it if you do decide you want to go.

Saw this and it was amazing, but very full on. Don't go to this OP. I agree with you about feeling something when looking, but I think that's just normal

RobinHumphries · 15/02/2024 03:22

The image….. the bodies are clearly wrapped so I don’t know what point you were trying to prove?

Andarna · 15/02/2024 02:11

With that warning I would expect full bodies, yes.

I also feel uncomfortable looking at them, so I mostly don't.

InWalksBarberalla · 15/02/2024 02:10

I can't believe you found it so disrespectful but yet still managed to take a photo. And then to top it off post the photo on mumsnet. Hardly respectful behaviour.

homezookeeper · 15/02/2024 02:09

InWalksBarberalla · 15/02/2024 02:00

Wow, can't believe you just put up an image with no warning. That's really poor form.

I wonder if they took that photo or googled it, but yes, if it's that offensive to the OP then why take it/post it for everyone else to see? Hmm

homezookeeper · 15/02/2024 02:05

Hardly obtuse when I’m far more familiar with the exhibit you're unfairly misaligning than you are Grin

homezookeeper · 15/02/2024 02:03

Woodenwonder · 15/02/2024 01:55

Sorry the image is in response to this comment:

I am very familiar with the museum.
The Mummies are all to certain extents "wrapped up", yeah you might see some hair sticking out of one, a foot sticking out (read the placards that are tailored to each exhibit). Plus there's a hand on display but the majority are wrapped. What difference does that honestly make when you know that there are several real corpses under the wrapping of the rest also? Human remains means actual human remains. The sign is there so that the squeamish can walk away. They're not all stripped and positioned for show. You're being ridiculous as an adult who read the sign, carried on and still felt triggered. On any given weekend or term time holiday days there's plenty of children viewing the same things you did, accompanied by adults. I've taken my DD and DNs there many a time. What they're displaying IS history. You're being rather silly.

Well yes, it does. Because at the bottom of that photo, you can see the hand that I mentioned previously (which has a placard with description). On the other side that is pictured, if you walk around then you'll see the feet and the hair that I mentioned (both have placards too). I think you've missed my point love.
This entire section is inside a huge rectangular glass case that almost fills the room. The sign about human remains is there before you walk in. There is a little corner you can walk around into with a couple of sarcophaguses and one or maybe two fully wrapped Mummies, provided that you walk past this bit first. But inside this huge section behind glass, the majority of the bodies still feature wrapping. Did you just walk along one long side before you felt freaked out or did you actually take in the entire thing?

InWalksBarberalla · 15/02/2024 02:00

Wow, can't believe you just put up an image with no warning. That's really poor form.

Woodenwonder · 15/02/2024 01:55

Sorry the image is in response to this comment:

I am very familiar with the museum.
The Mummies are all to certain extents "wrapped up", yeah you might see some hair sticking out of one, a foot sticking out (read the placards that are tailored to each exhibit). Plus there's a hand on display but the majority are wrapped. What difference does that honestly make when you know that there are several real corpses under the wrapping of the rest also? Human remains means actual human remains. The sign is there so that the squeamish can walk away. They're not all stripped and positioned for show. You're being ridiculous as an adult who read the sign, carried on and still felt triggered. On any given weekend or term time holiday days there's plenty of children viewing the same things you did, accompanied by adults. I've taken my DD and DNs there many a time. What they're displaying IS history. You're being rather silly.

OP posts:
Woodenwonder · 15/02/2024 01:54

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

This does not match your description at all now does it.

"Human Remains" isn't specific enough
OP posts:
Woodenwonder · 15/02/2024 01:52

KnowledgeableMomma · 15/02/2024 01:50

Human remains = dead bodies or parts of dead bodies.

Thanks, can you get a job as a museum steward 😆

OP posts:
KnowledgeableMomma · 15/02/2024 01:50

Human remains = dead bodies or parts of dead bodies.

Woodenwonder · 15/02/2024 01:50

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

RobertaFirmino · 15/02/2024 01:45

Given that the Ancient Egyptians were knowledgeable and progressive people, I think the person who once inhabited these remains might be rather proud of their contribution to education and history.

I loved the mummies as a child, I was always pestering Dad to take me to the museum and to his credit, he often did. They really are superb and when someone asks me about the best things to do in Liverpool, I always recommend them.

homezookeeper · 15/02/2024 01:43

ghostyslovesheets · 14/02/2024 22:19

More importantly do they still have the cat mummies?

Yes they do Grin

Woodenwonder · 15/02/2024 01:42

Happyinarcon · 15/02/2024 01:36

I also had an experience like this except with desiccated body parts, not the whole shebang. I was shock because I had a kid with me. Human remains for me means like a couple of bone fragments and maybe some hair. Im finding even in movies and tv news there’s a lot more images that shock me and seem unnecessary and distasteful.

Yes , I think that , going back to my original OP - if the sign had said "the next exhibit includes a small number or entire deceased human bodies" I'd have swerved it.

I don't know, looking at other people's loved ones fully on display in their entirety, without their wish or permission felt uncomfortable.

OP posts:
homezookeeper · 15/02/2024 01:42

I am very familiar with the museum.
The Mummies are all to certain extents "wrapped up", yeah you might see some hair sticking out of one, a foot sticking out (read the placards that are tailored to each exhibit). Plus there's a hand on display but the majority are wrapped. What difference does that honestly make when you know that there are several real corpses under the wrapping of the rest also? Human remains means actual human remains. The sign is there so that the squeamish can walk away. They're not all stripped and positioned for show. You're being ridiculous as an adult who read the sign, carried on and still felt triggered. On any given weekend or term time holiday days there's plenty of children viewing the same things you did, accompanied by adults. I've taken my DD and DNs there many a time. What they're displaying IS history. You're being rather silly.

Woodenwonder · 15/02/2024 01:39

Lwrenn · 15/02/2024 01:34

@Woodenwonder we go this museum loads and the first time my wee sensitive lad saw them he got very upset at them being displayed.
The other one less so and instead kept doing impressions to freak his brother out 😂

I understand what you mean though, I didn't really expect them to be so... dead bodyish which I know sounds ridiculous. I've had to lay out a few dead folks in my time and even though I'm as comfortable as I'll ever get with death it is quite sad isn't it? Just ancient dead people being all unaware they're an artifact.

(That said, I do still find them interesting 😂)

Exactly this!!

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread