Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

"Human Remains" isn't specific enough

256 replies

Woodenwonder · 14/02/2024 22:02

Last weekend had an impromptu wander around the world museum in Liverpool. (Fantastic and free). Anyway in the Egypt section it states that the next exhibit features human remains or words to that effect. I'm thinking a sarcophagus with a mummy inside. And yes that was there, a couple of examples of wrapped up mummies, tastefully and respectfully displayed. Turn the corner and there are 3+ corpses. Not wrapped up and obviously somewhat dessicated.

I'm not squeamish but I find looking at a collection of led out bodies (albeit 1000s of years old) a bit disrespectful for want of a better word. It made me feel really weird.

Yes these souls are long gone but I was not prepared to see them laid out in that way. I don't think I was even expecting full bodies.

Aibu to think the sign could have been a touch more descriptive before entering the room?

The museum is a fantastic place but I just felt a little rattled.

OP posts:
TheBayLady · 15/02/2024 08:51

What do you thing human remains means ? Maybe you need to stay at home wrapped in a security blanket.

Changeusernameseeusernamehistory · 15/02/2024 08:48

Mrsloverlover · 14/02/2024 22:24

Honestly at this rate museums are going to need 10 minute trigger warning videos before we go in . It’ll be like when you go trampolining and you have to watch a special safety vid first .

don’t forget the safe space

BeyondMyWits · 15/02/2024 08:46

Human remains is one of those sanitised meaningless phrases that can be anything from hair to actual bodies.

What's wrong with just saying corpses, or dead people, or bodies on display in next room. It puts it in plain English.

Pippa246 · 15/02/2024 08:42

Puzzledandpissedoff · 14/02/2024 22:39

Don't ever go to the catacombs in Palermo OP Grin

Was going to say this!!! I (mistakenly)thought catacoombs were just caves when we went. I was totally WTF when we went in but then really enjoyed it - although it was still weird. DH had thought it was because they ran out of space to bury the bodies in graves, but apparently it was actually a request of the then rich and famous - so their families could visit and actually see them. We went on a Sunday and there were Scicilian/Italian families there wearing what you would describe as funeral attire. Totally fascinating yet weird.

Perfectlystill · 15/02/2024 08:33

YABU

TheLambtonWorm · 15/02/2024 08:31

Woodenwonder · 15/02/2024 01:22

I think you've misunderstood my gist but that's ok.

Interesting when clearly intelligent and eloquent posters such as @Noideawwhatsoccuring make excellent points, and OP comes back with something to simply shut down that conversation. PP nailed it but you know she's right but you can't see past your willful ignorance, but that's ok......

MeemawTucker · 15/02/2024 08:23

Mumoftwo1312 · 15/02/2024 03:48

On the one hand op goes on about being respectful, a self styled "mega empath", then on the other, using a phrase like "human pepperami". Comparing a dead body to a cheap snack.

Yabu op, yabu.

I was just wading through the thread to see if anyone mentioned this. It’s really horrible (and I am not squeamish at all)

WaitingForMojo · 15/02/2024 08:07

I would be quite happy with my remains being on display to educate and inform future generations. Better than being buried and forgotten.

I don’t think you’re alone in your feelings though. There’s an intact mummy in a local museum and my daughter felt it was disrespectful.

I would personally understand what was coming from ‘human remains’.

helpfulperson · 15/02/2024 08:06

I might be wrong but I think 500 years is the generally accepted age. I know there has been controversy around the inca's and what was OK with excavations there.

Podgedodge · 15/02/2024 08:03

I think it’s one of the idiosyncrasies of the language. If you talk about the remains of your dinner, it’s the bits you haven’t eaten, or the remains of a crayon it’s the bit that’s not been used, but human remains are literally the body after the life force has left, so can be a full body. It’s not what remains after decomposition or animals or whatever, although it can mean that too…

TBNT · 15/02/2024 07:53

I get it OP.

I don't think you're being reasonable in that I think the sign was warning enough.

But I understand that you weren't expecting it. The first time I'd been to the British Museum in years we went for the Egyptian stuff for DC and they have someone there on display who isn't wrapped up.

I wasn't expecting it before we went, and I felt it disrespectful to that person that that's how they're spending some of their years.

I guess it's no different to those who are in there in a sarcophagus etc but it just seems a lot more vulnerable.

TheNoodlesIncident · 15/02/2024 07:53

Can you imagine the bruhaha if someone dug up aunty Flo only 2 years after interrment? So why is it acceptable after a few hundred years?

@Notacrescentcroissant Isn't it kind of obvious that Aunty Flo will have grieving relatives still after two years, but after a few hundred years all those who knew her and loved her dearly will also be long dead?

I don't know, if I saw a warning sign that stated "Human remains in the next room" I'd expect it to be on a more "intact" level than just outlines or wrapped but concealed in sarcophagi. Otherwise there wouldn't be a warning if it was just hair or a few bones..?

exLtEveDallas · 15/02/2024 07:46

Avoiding the arguments, I think I was similarly surprised (and uncomfortable) the first time I saw an Egyptian mummy.

I love all things Egyptian, it fascinates me and in my fantasy world I grow up to be Bettany Hughes!

On my first trip to Egypt we went to a museum and there were 3 mummies on display: one still in its sarcophagus, one still wrapped and one unwrapped. The unwrapped one really affected me. It was the 'look' on his face I think. I was fine with everything else, lots of bones etc, but a mummified face just made me realise exactly what I was gawping at, and I suddenly felt horribly disrespectful. I still feel similar now, and try to avoid the mummies, instead I look at the treasures and awe at the construction.

SophieJo · 15/02/2024 07:43

Scalottia · 15/02/2024 05:33

That's....that's what human remains are, OP. Remains of a human. You are being a little ridiculous.

I agree with you!

Sunnnybunny72 · 15/02/2024 07:42

Love the Liverpool museum. We took the DC many times when they were younger.
I found the mummies etc fascinating. As was the Lindow man who was preserved in a peat bog, can't remember where I saw him though, maybe the British Museum.

Maireas · 15/02/2024 07:38

Skeletal body? I really think that the museum's descriptor is clear enough.
If someone feels that they cannot look at such a thing, that gives a clear warning to avoid.

Tiggermom · 15/02/2024 07:36

I agree , human remains aren't whole bodies in my mind. They are a bit of bone or a skull. So 'skeletal body' or something might be better.

Mummyratbag · 15/02/2024 07:35

In the Vatican they display the bodies of dead popes.... people were taking selfies with them whilst nuns knelt and prayed..one of the most bizarre (and disrespectful) things I have seen (misses point of thread).

Epidote · 15/02/2024 07:34

They were human remains. How do you want to call them?
Some were mummified and wrapped, some may be mummified and due time lost the wrap, or simply disecated in a very aseptic and dry environment (desert) it is really difficult to preserve a body without treatment so I would think they were somehow mummified as well.

I get that the display impressed you but they are humans remains.

Maireas · 15/02/2024 07:30

Thirdsummerofourdiscontent · 15/02/2024 00:16

I would assume human remains means actual human remains on display.

So would I. It's very clear.

DogPaulAnka · 15/02/2024 07:02

Woodenwonder · 15/02/2024 01:54

This does not match your description at all now does it.

I think the museum warning is fine but I had some sympathy with you feeling uncomfortable. I don’t know how you can possibly justify your position and then post this photo with no warning.

Lurkingandlearning · 15/02/2024 06:52

Woodenwonder · 14/02/2024 22:17

Interesting. I think it was quite a catch all description that didn't quite prepare me for what (who) was displayed and how but apparently I'm a bit of a thicko and ridiculous 🤣

Not a thicko unless I am too. (Oh no I’m not😬). I think I would have expected mummies and not unwrapped corpses. But having read the other posts I can see now that would’ve been wrong. If it was only mummies they’d have said that and not remain s.

Tiddlywinks63 · 15/02/2024 06:42

sprigatito · 14/02/2024 23:53

With respect, I think you are being a bit precious. You were led to expect human remains, and that is what you got. If all you were going to see was a sarcophagus and some bandages, there would have been no need for the warning; human remains clearly meant actual bodies or body parts.

This ^^
For heaven’s sake don’t visit the Huntarian museum in London, it’s full of human remains and parts!

Noideawwhatsoccuring · 15/02/2024 06:34

Woodenwonder · 15/02/2024 01:22

I think you've misunderstood my gist but that's ok.

No I don’t think I have.

You went to an Egyptian exhibit. The sign said human remains. You saw the sign and misinterpreted it. You weren’t bothered about people ‘gawping’ at human remains as long as they were wrapped or in pieces or just their bones. You were quite fine viewing bodies or pieces of bodies that have been removed from their burial places and country as long as it for your view of what’s acceptable.

You were bothered when looked like human remains. As people have pointed out that you misinterpreted sign, but that’s on you. You have changed it to ‘I think it’s disrespectful’.

If you feel like that displaying dead bodies, removing them from where they were buried is disrespectful that’s fine. But you chose to participate. If you think it’s disrespectful, it’s disrespectful whether the bodies are wrapped or in pieces.

Really you just didn’t like being face with human remains that looked liked human remains. Again, that’s fine. But it’s not about having empathy.

Notacrescentcroissant · 15/02/2024 06:23

Woodenwonder · 14/02/2024 23:13

Right?! That's why it felt a tad disrespectful as, in as much as they were very carefully displayed behind glass with muted light etc , they are still very much exposed for us to gawp at. Opened up the question how many years dead is acceptable for a human to be displayed in such a way? I mused on that whilst I was buying overpriced souvenirs in the gift shop

I have often thought this! How long does one have ro be buried before it is ok for an archeologist to come along and start the desecration process (yes, I realise not all are buried in 'consecrated' ground [as in Christian context]).
Can you imagine the bruhaha if someone dug up aunty Flo only 2 years after interrment? So why is it acceptable after a few hundred years?
However, you are being a tad unreasonable to be taken aback at the display. 😃

Swipe left for the next trending thread