Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

"Human Remains" isn't specific enough

256 replies

Woodenwonder · 14/02/2024 22:02

Last weekend had an impromptu wander around the world museum in Liverpool. (Fantastic and free). Anyway in the Egypt section it states that the next exhibit features human remains or words to that effect. I'm thinking a sarcophagus with a mummy inside. And yes that was there, a couple of examples of wrapped up mummies, tastefully and respectfully displayed. Turn the corner and there are 3+ corpses. Not wrapped up and obviously somewhat dessicated.

I'm not squeamish but I find looking at a collection of led out bodies (albeit 1000s of years old) a bit disrespectful for want of a better word. It made me feel really weird.

Yes these souls are long gone but I was not prepared to see them laid out in that way. I don't think I was even expecting full bodies.

Aibu to think the sign could have been a touch more descriptive before entering the room?

The museum is a fantastic place but I just felt a little rattled.

OP posts:
Woodenwonder · 15/02/2024 09:48

ChocolateRat · 15/02/2024 03:59

What's the intent of the notice?

If it's there just to attempt to get people into a respectful state of mind and demeanour and to behave appropriately, then I think "the next exhibit features human remains" is sufficient.

But if it's intended to give an idea of the nature of what's there, let people know that the next room has certain exhibits that not every visitor may feel comfortable viewing, and give people an opportunity to make an informed decision on whether members of their party might find it distressing, then yeah, I agree that "human remains" is a bit too vague to fulfil that purpose adequately.

Not everybody can be assumed to have the existing knowledge or understanding to know precisely what to expect in that room. "Human remains" can be things like ashes in a jar, a single finger bone barely visible behind glass, an unrecognisable dried-out or preserved organ, a whole wrapped mummy complete with mask and accoutrements, ancient remnants of skeleton mixed up with grave goods, or sometimes a full desiccated corpse with face visible.

(I once came across the last of those completely unexpectedly, in a small Italian church. "Oh this looks like a nice church", "Ah isn't this bit beautiful", "It's so calm and cool walking through here", BAM surprise corpse display case. I should probably have read the town guidebook first, in retrospect.)

And many people who could cope with a murky finger bone, or a jar with a sign saying there are human parts inside, or a fully wrapped mummy, might struggle with seeing a dead human being, skin stretched taut over bones, and for a lot of reasons, may not have realised that they'd be seeing that. It could be the first dead person they've ever seen.

So really to me it depends what they were trying to do with the sign.

If it's to signal that respectful behaviour is expected in the next room, it's fine.

If it's intended to provide useful information to help people choose whether the display will be appropriate for their party, it's only useful if you have such a level of preexisting knowledge about what's there that you probably don't really need the sign.

Thank you for that balanced view, that's what I was thinking

OP posts:
SausageRoll5862 · 15/02/2024 09:48

I've just Googled them. They look amazing and I read the fascinating articles. You go into a particular part of a museum KNOWING there are people in there who died yonks ago then get queasy when you see a couple of skeletons?

The sign stating ''Human Remains; Skeleton'' is very clear.

Whatever you do, don't ever get a job as a forensic scientist, a mortician or a pathologist!

I wouldn't go to a medical museum KNOWING there's bits of human stuff in jars then complain about feeling queasy!

So if you don't like skeletons then avoid certain parts of the museum. Simples!

Woodenwonder · 15/02/2024 09:46

Mumoftwo1312 · 15/02/2024 03:48

On the one hand op goes on about being respectful, a self styled "mega empath", then on the other, using a phrase like "human pepperami". Comparing a dead body to a cheap snack.

Yabu op, yabu.

It's all flesh, apparently. I'm being unreasonable to be phased so ...

OP posts:
Woodenwonder · 15/02/2024 09:46

RobinHumphries · 15/02/2024 03:22

The image….. the bodies are clearly wrapped so I don’t know what point you were trying to prove?

Don't worry about it.

OP posts:
Woodenwonder · 15/02/2024 09:45

InWalksBarberalla · 15/02/2024 02:10

I can't believe you found it so disrespectful but yet still managed to take a photo. And then to top it off post the photo on mumsnet. Hardly respectful behaviour.

I did not take a photo. It's on Google. Obviously.

OP posts:
Woodenwonder · 15/02/2024 09:44

homezookeeper · 15/02/2024 02:09

I wonder if they took that photo or googled it, but yes, if it's that offensive to the OP then why take it/post it for everyone else to see? Hmm

Two things:

89% of posters think I'm being unreasonable being phased

And too show that clearly I'm not and even though you're on a thread about human remains - so you knew what was coming - the actual sight of human remains as full bodies can still be unsettling

OP posts:
Woodenwonder · 15/02/2024 09:42

homezookeeper · 15/02/2024 02:03

Well yes, it does. Because at the bottom of that photo, you can see the hand that I mentioned previously (which has a placard with description). On the other side that is pictured, if you walk around then you'll see the feet and the hair that I mentioned (both have placards too). I think you've missed my point love.
This entire section is inside a huge rectangular glass case that almost fills the room. The sign about human remains is there before you walk in. There is a little corner you can walk around into with a couple of sarcophaguses and one or maybe two fully wrapped Mummies, provided that you walk past this bit first. But inside this huge section behind glass, the majority of the bodies still feature wrapping. Did you just walk along one long side before you felt freaked out or did you actually take in the entire thing?

Yes.

OP posts:
Woodenwonder · 15/02/2024 09:41

InWalksBarberalla · 15/02/2024 02:00

Wow, can't believe you just put up an image with no warning. That's really poor form.

Right??

OP posts:
WitheredBloom · 15/02/2024 09:34

Mamma142526 · 15/02/2024 09:00

I agree with this (though not your OP), in that I don't feel it's right to excavate tombs and display the remains - as fascinating as it is, it's not what they intended for their bodies. Though obviously they very much don't care now.

Yes exactly this. As I say, I don’t have any religious or spiritual beliefs but these people would have felt them very acutely, so it feels so disrespectful to put them on display. Even people who were found in leaf bogs or murdered etc, give them the burial they deserve.

The Museum of Witchcraft in Boscastle used to have a woman’s skeleton hanging outside. She had been accused of witchcraft during her life and her remains had been hung outside the museum. When the new Curator took over her took her down and had her buried in a local woodland. I really respected that, he put another human over the museum. Joan, the woman in question, would have been treated poorly in life, there’s no need to treat her poorly in death too for our own fascination and pleasure.

WitheredBloom · 15/02/2024 09:30

FoxtrotSkarloey · 15/02/2024 09:27

you're moving the conversation on though, from "human remains" sufficient remains to warn you of what to expect, (mn says it was) to should said remains be displayed on museums. That's a different AIBU 🤷‍♀️

Was this for me? If so, I guess I was, but I just thought that was natural part of the conversation to be honest.

FoxtrotSkarloey · 15/02/2024 09:27

you're moving the conversation on though, from "human remains" sufficient remains to warn you of what to expect, (mn says it was) to should said remains be displayed on museums. That's a different AIBU 🤷‍♀️

ClivetheDestroyer · 15/02/2024 09:22

oOmoonhaOo · 14/02/2024 22:43

There’s a museum I went to in the Netherlands that had a baby in a jar and an eye with a tumor attached. Can’t remember the name.

Also in the Liverpool museum is a skeleton of a child… with no warning

I went to a museum in romania once that had several foetuses in jar, of various gestations which I actually did find a bit upsetting. They were miscarried ones and some had some obvious disfigurements (like anencephaly, extra/missing limbs - type things)

Notacrescentcroissant · 15/02/2024 09:20

@Woodenwonder Don't go to Mexico in November for God's sake!

In the small village of Pomuch (state of Campeche) there is a very particular tradition that includes digging up the bones of the dead, which are then cleaned and added to each family's altar as a way of honoring them and having them present during the festivities.

IncompleteSenten · 15/02/2024 09:16

If you walk into the ancient Egyptian section of a museum and see a sign that says human remains, you should expect to see mummified human remains, wrapped and unwrapped.

Anyotherdude · 15/02/2024 09:16

OP, I think your reaction is somewhat natural, given how removed from reality our lives are in western civilisation. Your reaction may, however, give you pause to reflect on how lucky we are, that we aren’t faced with human remains daily, as a lot of people are, on this planet, right now…

Notacrescentcroissant · 15/02/2024 09:11

@Mumoftwo1312 YABU - pepperami isn't cheap! 😂

Notacrescentcroissant · 15/02/2024 09:10

InWalksBarberalla · 15/02/2024 02:00

Wow, can't believe you just put up an image with no warning. That's really poor form.

😂😂

Notacrescentcroissant · 15/02/2024 09:08

@Woodenwonder The full people just laying there prone got me a bit shooketh

Fairly pointless to display in the prone position - you would only see their back!

Notacrescentcroissant · 15/02/2024 09:06

@Woodenwonder I think I would have liked it to say "the next room contains a small number of entire human bodies" I think that's succinct.
They may be entire, but they are mummified, so look different. So, that trigger warning would not work for you either
A sign saying 'Read the history of Egyptian mummification processes and the effect they have on the body because they won't look like you expect them to and might discombobulate you' is more apt.

incognitothismorning · 15/02/2024 09:03

museum display cases with human remains in are legally graves, and are treated as such by staff - the remains are totally respected.

Literally you can't move a box of human remains from one shelf to another in a museum store room without the right paperwork. Because the shelf is technically a grave at that point

Notacrescentcroissant · 15/02/2024 09:02

@Woodenwonder I feel like that was not what they had in mind for the afterlife, given that dignity and respect in the next realm was such a big deal to the ancient Egyptians.
The very act of going to see such things contradicts your feeling. If you believe in dignity after death, you wouldn't visit such an exhibition no matter who had dug them up or how long ago.

Mamma142526 · 15/02/2024 09:00

Woodenwonder · 14/02/2024 23:13

Right?! That's why it felt a tad disrespectful as, in as much as they were very carefully displayed behind glass with muted light etc , they are still very much exposed for us to gawp at. Opened up the question how many years dead is acceptable for a human to be displayed in such a way? I mused on that whilst I was buying overpriced souvenirs in the gift shop

I agree with this (though not your OP), in that I don't feel it's right to excavate tombs and display the remains - as fascinating as it is, it's not what they intended for their bodies. Though obviously they very much don't care now.

TheBirdintheCave · 15/02/2024 08:57

bluetongue · 14/02/2024 23:47

I’ve been to Japan a couple of times but not sure I could deal the Hiroshima museum. Not because I’m squeamish but because it’s just so horrific and depressing. When I was younger dark tourism stuff was more appealing to me but now in my 40’d I’m not sure In can stomach it anymore.

Love Egyptian exhibitions and petrified remains / mummies are fine. It’s just places dedicated to tragic events that I won’t go to.

It was truly harrowing. We ummed and ahed about going as we were on our honeymoon BUT decided it was too huge a part of Japanese history to not visit. It's an incredible museum though we both felt physically and mentally drained by the end of it.

Jacopo · 15/02/2024 08:54

I was brought up going to that museum from a very young age and absolutely loved it. OP, you and your children are likely to have to face much worse things as you go through life, and it is good practice to move out of your comfort zone a bit. YABU. And the most disrespectful thing about this story is your description of the dead people.

WitheredBloom · 15/02/2024 08:54

I used to be fascinated by such exhibits but the more I think about it, the more I dislike human remains on show. The individuals were likely very religious and would have hated being on show for others - I’m not religious in any sense and believe that when we die, we just die, but it feels insanely disrespectful and I wonder how many people would be happy with one of their relatives being put on display for people to gawk at. I’m not ‘precious’ in any way, but I don’t like such exhibits any more.

Swipe left for the next trending thread