Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

"Human Remains" isn't specific enough

256 replies

Woodenwonder · 14/02/2024 22:02

Last weekend had an impromptu wander around the world museum in Liverpool. (Fantastic and free). Anyway in the Egypt section it states that the next exhibit features human remains or words to that effect. I'm thinking a sarcophagus with a mummy inside. And yes that was there, a couple of examples of wrapped up mummies, tastefully and respectfully displayed. Turn the corner and there are 3+ corpses. Not wrapped up and obviously somewhat dessicated.

I'm not squeamish but I find looking at a collection of led out bodies (albeit 1000s of years old) a bit disrespectful for want of a better word. It made me feel really weird.

Yes these souls are long gone but I was not prepared to see them laid out in that way. I don't think I was even expecting full bodies.

Aibu to think the sign could have been a touch more descriptive before entering the room?

The museum is a fantastic place but I just felt a little rattled.

OP posts:
Scirocco · 15/02/2024 10:39

I'd say YABU on 2 separate counts.

Firstly, a sign saying 'Human remains' is a pretty clear indicator that there are going to be human remains. If that's potentially an issue for you or someone you're with, then you have the option of checking with someone working there or with the museum's website to see if you want to proceed or not. I've done that before when out with my DC, and I've always found people are very helpful and supportive.

Secondly, you posted a photograph with no warning, no 'sensitive image' blurring, no nothing. Despite the fact that you were sufficiently unsettled by the sight of human remains like that, that you started a thread to discuss it, you chose to expose other people to the thing that had caused you distress, without even the basic courtesy of affording people the warning you had received. That's just inconsiderate.

Onlinetherapist · 15/02/2024 10:38

Woodenwonder · 14/02/2024 22:17

Interesting. I think it was quite a catch all description that didn't quite prepare me for what (who) was displayed and how but apparently I'm a bit of a thicko and ridiculous 🤣

@Woodenwonder no, I completely get it. The term ‘human remains’ to me might better describe unrecognisable parts, charred remains for example. There are other terms that might better describe whole intact bodies, eg human corpses, cadavers etc. In our culture, that is not something we see often, (or at all?) And certainly not without warning/informed consent.

Human remains are sacred in my opinion and should be treated with the upmost dignity and respect. Some of the comments from previous posters are flippant to say the least. That might be their way of dealing with their own death anxiety/fear of their own mortality, so try not to take it to heart OP (this is Mumsnet remember 😉).

Your emotional response to these souls is natural and to be expected. It’s a fine line/balance between education and respecting dignity and the fact that these people almost certainly didn’t consent to being displayed in a museum for all to see.

mrssquidink · 15/02/2024 10:38

I’m not your average person as I’ve studied archaeology and excavated human remains, so yes, to me human remains could be anything up to and including whole bodies.

The ethics around the keeping and display of human remains is a big topic of discussion in the museums world and most if not all museums have policies on this (Liverpool Museums’ is here https://www.liverpoolmuseums.org.uk/about/reports-plans-and-policies). Although most of the concern tends to be around more recent remains collected in the recent colonial past.

For what it’s worth, I’d be happy to be displayed as it would mean I’m interesting! But then I have said that if I’m cremated, I don’t want my cremated remains ground into powder so that if a future archaeologist excavated me, hopefully there’d be enough bits of bone left to be able to age and sex me.

Reports, plans and policies

A range of reports, plans and policies covering National Museums Liverpool activities can be accessed on this page.

https://www.liverpoolmuseums.org.uk/about/reports-plans-and-policies

cerisepanther73 · 15/02/2024 10:33

@Woodenwonder

Why did you attend this museum in the first place if you were triggered 😳 by the human remains section then?

You extremely highly sensitive lot by allmost everything
need to take your own responsibilities in life

If you want to be wrapped in cotton wool bubble 🫧 in life,

Just stay indoors all the time or just stay in safe places such as a cafes or libarey
Make a list of them

MassageForLife · 15/02/2024 10:23

Woodenwonder · 15/02/2024 09:44

Two things:

89% of posters think I'm being unreasonable being phased

And too show that clearly I'm not and even though you're on a thread about human remains - so you knew what was coming - the actual sight of human remains as full bodies can still be unsettling

Two things:

  1. given the percentage, I would expect about 10% of people to have an issue with the photo. The fact that someone does, doesn't prove that YANBU
  2. You had a warning about what you would see before you went into the room. If you had gone into a room that was full of people writing and talking about human remains, I don't think you would have had an issue. Nobody had a warning when clicking on the thread that you were going to share the photo.
RabbitsRock · 15/02/2024 10:16

YABU saying “ led out”

Mumoftwo1312 · 15/02/2024 10:13

89% of posters think I'm being unreasonable being phased

Nope. 89% of posters think "human remains" is an adequate warning. Some of that group may be fazed by the remains, some may not.

I feel a Venn diagram coming on

InWalksBarberalla · 15/02/2024 10:11

Woodenwonder · 15/02/2024 09:44

Two things:

89% of posters think I'm being unreasonable being phased

And too show that clearly I'm not and even though you're on a thread about human remains - so you knew what was coming - the actual sight of human remains as full bodies can still be unsettling

That's completely unreasonable. This thread was about whether the words human remains were enough warning at the museum. So a thread about the meaning of the words.

If the thread was called human remains, or photos with human remains then posters could know to expect the picture.

Mumoftwo1312 · 15/02/2024 10:09

Woodenwonder · 15/02/2024 10:05

It's not my own photo, it's clearly on display on Google too. Please learn to read properly.

And no I didn't know you can post "sensitive photo" and don't try and gaslight me into saying that lost of posters have said they'd be fazed because that's not the case. The vast majority are being very withering about delicate me.

The showing of the photo demonstrates how halting the image is - so if it feels uncomfortable on a screen, imagine not expecting it in person.

I can read properly (and spell, while we are on the subject). I never said it was your photo. It was still disingenuous of you to post photos of mummies on SM when you originally said you felt it was disrespectful to ogle at them.

I'm not sure you know what gaslighting means.

We are nearly all agreed that "human remains" is an adequate warning. Whereas your initial argument is that it's an inadequate warning.

Why are you trying to prove some kind of point by posting a photo with no warning at all? I don't think you understand the logic of your own argument.

Woodenwonder · 15/02/2024 10:06

Guys, it's been enlightening. I'm off to work.
☺️

OP posts:
Woodenwonder · 15/02/2024 10:05

C8H10N4O2 · 15/02/2024 10:00

Yes agree with this.

A large museum with exhibits from ancient Egypt and a warning of "human remains" - why on earth would you be shocked to see mummies? Don't ever go to the British Museum.

As PP say, the remains are treated as grave sites in these large museums and if you don't want to see human remains you don't have to go into the exhibition. Whether its a whole mummy or skeleton or a few teeth and bones it is still human remains - either you are OK with this or you avoid the exhibition.

I'm clearly not ok with it. I need to learn to time travel back to when I first saw the sign.

OP posts:
Woodenwonder · 15/02/2024 10:05

Mumoftwo1312 · 15/02/2024 09:59

I think you're being very unreasonable. Some commenters, by no means a majority, felt you needn't be fazed by bodies. Many/most of us felt we would be fazed by bodies but that "human remains" would be a perfectly adequate warning to avoid that room.

Lots of commenters initially agreed with your stance that it's important to be respectful of dead bodies, what would the deceased have wanted, etc then KAPOW you call them "human peperami" and then post a photo. Wowie, you are so respectful of the dead. So mega empath.

You know you can click "sensitive photo" before uploading to mumsnet? And to illustrate your point perfectly, you could have chosen your own description that you feel is more apt than "human remains"?

It's not my own photo, it's clearly on display on Google too. Please learn to read properly.

And no I didn't know you can post "sensitive photo" and don't try and gaslight me into saying that lost of posters have said they'd be fazed because that's not the case. The vast majority are being very withering about delicate me.

The showing of the photo demonstrates how halting the image is - so if it feels uncomfortable on a screen, imagine not expecting it in person.

OP posts:
C8H10N4O2 · 15/02/2024 10:00

Noideawwhatsoccuring · 15/02/2024 06:34

No I don’t think I have.

You went to an Egyptian exhibit. The sign said human remains. You saw the sign and misinterpreted it. You weren’t bothered about people ‘gawping’ at human remains as long as they were wrapped or in pieces or just their bones. You were quite fine viewing bodies or pieces of bodies that have been removed from their burial places and country as long as it for your view of what’s acceptable.

You were bothered when looked like human remains. As people have pointed out that you misinterpreted sign, but that’s on you. You have changed it to ‘I think it’s disrespectful’.

If you feel like that displaying dead bodies, removing them from where they were buried is disrespectful that’s fine. But you chose to participate. If you think it’s disrespectful, it’s disrespectful whether the bodies are wrapped or in pieces.

Really you just didn’t like being face with human remains that looked liked human remains. Again, that’s fine. But it’s not about having empathy.

Yes agree with this.

A large museum with exhibits from ancient Egypt and a warning of "human remains" - why on earth would you be shocked to see mummies? Don't ever go to the British Museum.

As PP say, the remains are treated as grave sites in these large museums and if you don't want to see human remains you don't have to go into the exhibition. Whether its a whole mummy or skeleton or a few teeth and bones it is still human remains - either you are OK with this or you avoid the exhibition.

Mumoftwo1312 · 15/02/2024 09:59

Woodenwonder · 15/02/2024 09:46

It's all flesh, apparently. I'm being unreasonable to be phased so ...

I think you're being very unreasonable. Some commenters, by no means a majority, felt you needn't be fazed by bodies. Many/most of us felt we would be fazed by bodies but that "human remains" would be a perfectly adequate warning to avoid that room.

Lots of commenters initially agreed with your stance that it's important to be respectful of dead bodies, what would the deceased have wanted, etc then KAPOW you call them "human peperami" and then post a photo. Wowie, you are so respectful of the dead. So mega empath.

You know you can click "sensitive photo" before uploading to mumsnet? And to illustrate your point perfectly, you could have chosen your own description that you feel is more apt than "human remains"?

Woodenwonder · 15/02/2024 09:59

Notacrescentcroissant · 15/02/2024 09:10

😂😂

Everyone seems ok with it tbf.

OP posts:
Woodenwonder · 15/02/2024 09:58

TheLambtonWorm · 15/02/2024 08:31

Interesting when clearly intelligent and eloquent posters such as @Noideawwhatsoccuring make excellent points, and OP comes back with something to simply shut down that conversation. PP nailed it but you know she's right but you can't see past your willful ignorance, but that's ok......

Edited

Ok thanks.

OP posts:
Woodenwonder · 15/02/2024 09:58

SausageRoll5862 · 15/02/2024 09:48

I've just Googled them. They look amazing and I read the fascinating articles. You go into a particular part of a museum KNOWING there are people in there who died yonks ago then get queasy when you see a couple of skeletons?

The sign stating ''Human Remains; Skeleton'' is very clear.

Whatever you do, don't ever get a job as a forensic scientist, a mortician or a pathologist!

I wouldn't go to a medical museum KNOWING there's bits of human stuff in jars then complain about feeling queasy!

So if you don't like skeletons then avoid certain parts of the museum. Simples!

I won't go into that job thanks for the heads up. Go see them in person, you'll apparently love it.

OP posts:
Woodenwonder · 15/02/2024 09:57

Notacrescentcroissant · 15/02/2024 09:06

@Woodenwonder I think I would have liked it to say "the next room contains a small number of entire human bodies" I think that's succinct.
They may be entire, but they are mummified, so look different. So, that trigger warning would not work for you either
A sign saying 'Read the history of Egyptian mummification processes and the effect they have on the body because they won't look like you expect them to and might discombobulate you' is more apt.

That'd be great thanks 👍

OP posts:
Agapornis · 15/02/2024 09:56

Woodenwonder · 14/02/2024 23:13

Right?! That's why it felt a tad disrespectful as, in as much as they were very carefully displayed behind glass with muted light etc , they are still very much exposed for us to gawp at. Opened up the question how many years dead is acceptable for a human to be displayed in such a way? I mused on that whilst I was buying overpriced souvenirs in the gift shop

There's thankfully lots of discussion now about this in the museum sector. As @Aecor put it, museums have withdrawn bodies from display, and are repatriating them.

That's just display though. Have a think about the poor sods who aren't deemed good enough to be looked at! I know of at least one Big London Museum that has human remains, but doesn't display or talk about them. 'Deaccessioning' i.e. removing objects from a museum collection, even to repatriate, can be difficult and in the British Museum's case, not legal. Yes, there's a law stopping them! It's quite something to steal, and then change the law so you can't be made to return someone's property.

I'd highly recommend the events at Barts Pathology Museum for the ethics around how human remains are treated (it is pretty much all human remains/bits in jars, definitely not for everyone).

In case you're worried about your own body, I think current archaeological good practice in the UK is that any human remains found must be respectfully reburied as soon as possible, within max 2 years. I don't think many public museums add newly 'discovered' human remains to their collection. There's also the Human Tissue Act stopping some of the Victorian 'this person is dead but has a weird medical condition, let's cut it off and bottle it' behaviour. I'm kind of hoping I'll be found in 2000 years, mummified in a peat bog with leathery skin and ginger hair...but then also reburied after a while.

Woodenwonder · 15/02/2024 09:55

Jacopo · 15/02/2024 08:54

I was brought up going to that museum from a very young age and absolutely loved it. OP, you and your children are likely to have to face much worse things as you go through life, and it is good practice to move out of your comfort zone a bit. YABU. And the most disrespectful thing about this story is your description of the dead people.

My child is 21 so I think we're out of the woods.

My description of dessicated flesh feels banging on tbf.

I think you're being precious.

OP posts:
DottieMoon · 15/02/2024 09:55

Ginandjuice57884 · 14/02/2024 22:07

They are human remains. Not sure how much more specific you can be without providing a reference image and defeating the point of the warning.

I agree, not sure how much clearer they can be. I think you are being ridiculous.

WitheredBloom · 15/02/2024 09:54

SausageRoll5862 · 15/02/2024 09:48

I've just Googled them. They look amazing and I read the fascinating articles. You go into a particular part of a museum KNOWING there are people in there who died yonks ago then get queasy when you see a couple of skeletons?

The sign stating ''Human Remains; Skeleton'' is very clear.

Whatever you do, don't ever get a job as a forensic scientist, a mortician or a pathologist!

I wouldn't go to a medical museum KNOWING there's bits of human stuff in jars then complain about feeling queasy!

So if you don't like skeletons then avoid certain parts of the museum. Simples!

These things aren’t comparable though. A job as a mortician or pathologist has a specific role that supports the dead person and their relatives. Plus, you can go into a museum with an expectation and be disconcerted. I always loved this sort of thing but then I went to Colchester Castle and upon seeing the corpses on display, something shifted and I just felt like it was wrong and my opinion changed.

The idea of ‘you should know how to feel before you’ve experienced something’ is a bit naive and simplistic. You can go to somewhere and it not be what you expected and your reaction be different to what you expected too. It’s okay to change your mind.

Woodenwonder · 15/02/2024 09:51

DogPaulAnka · 15/02/2024 07:02

I think the museum warning is fine but I had some sympathy with you feeling uncomfortable. I don’t know how you can possibly justify your position and then post this photo with no warning.

Because so many posters seemed so at home with it and the majority rule is that I'm being precious and a bit thick by having a reaction to a dead person.

OP posts:
Woodenwonder · 15/02/2024 09:50

Tiddlywinks63 · 15/02/2024 06:42

This ^^
For heaven’s sake don’t visit the Huntarian museum in London, it’s full of human remains and parts!

Thanks for the heads up.

OP posts:
Woodenwonder · 15/02/2024 09:49

Scalottia · 15/02/2024 05:43

Yep. OP is trying ever so hard to be witty. Soon there will be spat out tea and woken babies!

Since when did people become so fragile and delicate? We will all be human remains one day.

Our ancestors are probably shaking their heads at our need for trigger warnings. I wish that term would get in the bin! (Yes OP you didn't mention trigger warning, but you may as well have).

Yes, I didn't the only person mentioning trigger warnings is you 🙄

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread