Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Am I the only fundie in the village (of MN?)

308 replies

porridgeisbae · 14/02/2024 20:50

Anyone else?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
13
whatsitcalledwhen · 15/02/2024 13:39

You disagree with abortion as you say it goes against gods will for a life to exist.

Do you disagree with chemotherapy? If it's gods will someone has cancer (which it must be, if it's gods will a foetus is incompatible with more than a few minutes of life after birth) then surely it's wrong to intervene?

Do you disagree with CPR? Do you disagree with defibrillators? Do you disagree with insulin for diabetics?

Eightfour · 15/02/2024 13:37

@Previousreligion

I do know personally people who decided to carry a baby to term knowing it wouldn't live more than a day. It was awful but they'd say it was the right decision for them.

For them would be the important part of that sentence. Not for everyone. Therefore choice is important. I do hope that you do not try to push your anti-choice views on other people.

Ratherstandonacliffandsetfiretomyself · 15/02/2024 13:37

Genuine question (and apologies haven't RTFT)

From what I understand in the fundie lifestyle the sole purpose of marriage/sex is for the procreation of children. You say that you've never been blessed with children - presuming due to health reasons here - and I'm guessing that you would see that as being God's plan for you but how do you reconcile that inside yourself since you've been prevented from fulfilling one of the sole purposes that women exist?

Apologies if that sounds horrifically ignorant but I'm an atheist who can't have children (although I don't actually want them regardless) and feel like there is strong judgement there for non-religious reasons.

Previousreligion · 15/02/2024 13:32

I used to be, but no longer practice. I have plenty of friends who do though who are all lovely and I still live a lifestyle that is relatively similar to before. Like dressing modestly, not drinking, making decisions with the environment in mind, giving to charity etc. I have different views on homosexuality now, but still am against abortion in most circumstances.

I do know personally people who decided to carry a baby to term knowing it wouldn't live more than a day. It was awful but they'd say it was the right decision for them.

I wouldn't describe anyone as a fundie though. They're just people who believe in Jesus trying to live life according to their religion.

Anniegetyourgun · 15/02/2024 13:22

Sounds like all healthcare should be banned then. Must be God's will to have life-threatening illnesses, mobility limiting conditions, septic wounds, broken bones (splinting allowed as long as it's with natural wood and bandage made from a single type of fibre)... Reductio ad absurdum you say? Absurd is indeed the word.

I believe if God gave us brains and free will it would be so we can use them to help each other, not so we can shrug and let them die horribly whilst mouthing some platitude that pretends we care but really gives us an excuse for NOT caring.

I look forward to your next religious conversion and hope it's a bit more enlightened than the present one, is all I can say. I'm sure there's a decent person in there struggling to get out - it's why you keep looking. Meanwhile, be excellent to each other and party on, dudes, is a pretty good general rule to live by.

Brawcolli · 15/02/2024 13:22

You say you’re ‘a former leftie’, so I assume especially with the fundamentalist beliefs that you’re right wing now. What’s Christian about right wing politics? Anyone with half a brain surely can see that they harm the majority of people and only benefit the rich, who Jesus famously wasn’t a great fan of?

Eightfour · 15/02/2024 13:18

I do think unless you were indoctrinated as a child, this particular brand of Christianity just targets the vulnerable and hard of critical thinking.

ZebraPensAreLife · 15/02/2024 13:18

I do find it weird that people try and live by rules and conventions that seem to be stuck about 2000 years in the past.

I suspect the Bible would look very different if written today.

Brawcolli · 15/02/2024 13:16

Oblomov24 · 15/02/2024 12:39

@Brawcolli
Satire? About Ben Shapiro being intelligent? Do you not think he is? He argues and debates well in all the clips I've ever seen of him at uni's when students pose questions to him. No?

😂

whatsitcalledwhen · 15/02/2024 13:15

@porridgeisbae

God wanted that baby to live for a long as it will live. Otherwise he wouldn't have let it be conceived.

God would be a cruel entity then who creates some children purely for them to only exist for a few agonising minutes desperately trying to breathe before they die.

To worship an entity who not only sanctions this but actively creates that life, is unthinkable to me.

I don't understand one of your answers, either. I said "Yet in your ideal world, you believe it is right for that woman to have to carry such a child to term and give birth to it so it can be a's live, in pain and desperately trying to breathe, before dying. That is what you believe is right."

You replied"No. I personally think it's a shame, but it's what God says/the Bible implies. I wish it said something different, but it doesn't."

But you do think it's right, by your own logic, so what is the 'no' in reference to? Even if you don't think it's easy or simple, or you think it's a shame, you do absolutely believe it's right. You believe that your god's word says that child should be born no matter what. You believe that your god's word is right. So you do believe that it is right for a woman to have to carry to term even in those circumstances.

Thegoodbadandugly · 15/02/2024 13:14

There's always one that likes to think they are different, who cares!

systemthirtytwo · 15/02/2024 13:13

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Hagbard · 15/02/2024 13:11

This thread reminds me of a book by Will Self - The Book of Dave. In a post apocalyptic future a book is found by surviving humans. This book is the diary of a mentally ill, cross- dressing maniac, and they all follow the "holy book" to the letter

systemthirtytwo · 15/02/2024 13:11

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Uricon2 · 15/02/2024 13:03

I'm Christian and I don't believe in a God who would give a rat's behind about the length of some ones hair.

@Eightfour "ah so there are irrelevant and contradictory bits of the bible then? It’s never the bits about homosexuality or oppressing women though is it? It’s always the Old Testament is irrelevant except for these specific bits to suit my backwards agenda. Funny that."

In spades.

Old lecturer of mine (ordained and fully conversant with all Biblical languages, he wrote books about some them) was fond of saying that you can find anything you want in the Bible, justify any viewpoint (however abhorrent) by ignoring context, selective quotation and having an agenda. He wasn't wrong.

Tetsuo · 15/02/2024 13:02

Pipsquiggle · 15/02/2024 13:00

@porridgeisbae so you think all men are superior to women because some bloke wrote it hundreds of years ago?

Really?

Obviously!

Why would that be problematic?

Pipsquiggle · 15/02/2024 13:00

@porridgeisbae so you think all men are superior to women because some bloke wrote it hundreds of years ago?

Really?

porridgeisbae · 15/02/2024 12:59

Nah, their 'ministry' was and is awful. They're waking up the damage done to them by purity culture but can't admit their own role in selling it. The cognitive dissonance is astonishing.

@betterangels They do claim they think they were over the top before. I think they were at least genuine before, whereas now they've realised sex sells so go on about it. Paul and Morgan have done the same.

Yet in your ideal world, you believe it is right for that woman to have to carry such a child to term and give birth to it so it can be a's live, in pain and desperately trying to breathe, before dying. That is what you believe is right.

No. I personally think it's a shame, but it's what God says/the Bible implies. I wish it said something different, but it doesn't. I sometimes try and imagine having to choose to carry a baby who will die within a few hours to term, because it's what the Bible says. It would be awful, but I would have to try and do it. I wouldn't want to.

I genuinely believe that is a cruel belief. I don't understand how anyone with a fundamentally kind and loving heart can believe that to subject a foetus to a brief, painful few minutes of misery and it's mother to a lifetime of grief, can be preferable to the foetus being aborted.

God wanted that baby to live for a long as it will live. Otherwise he wouldn't have let it be conceived.

ah so there are irrelevant and contradictory bits of the bible then? It’s never the bits about homosexuality or oppressing women though is it? It’s always the Old Testament is irrelevant except for these specific bits to suit my backwards agenda. Funny that.

Well I hope you’ve had fun overhauling your wardrobe anyway OP, those mixed fabrics just won’t fly. Or is that bit irrelevant too?

The Bible itself says that the ceremonial law (rather than the moral law) no longer applies to Christians. It's not a contradiction, it's that we are Christians and the death of Christ removed the necessity for some of the rituals and rules etc. Bits about homosexuality etc are in the New Testament too.

OP posts:
bringincrazyback · 15/02/2024 12:47

ZebraPensAreLife · 14/02/2024 21:27

Are you the same poster who thinks books are evil? If not, there’s at least one other on here somewhere.

Edited

😂

fedupandstuck · 15/02/2024 12:46

I'm intrigued by the flip flopping between different religions. How does it feel to swap from believing one set of prescribed tenets to a fairly different set, when none of that is based in reason and evidence? Why didn't you decide that Zoroastrianism was for you, or Mandaeism or Scientology, for example?

Oblomov24 · 15/02/2024 12:39

@Brawcolli
Satire? About Ben Shapiro being intelligent? Do you not think he is? He argues and debates well in all the clips I've ever seen of him at uni's when students pose questions to him. No?

Tetsuo · 15/02/2024 12:33

Also interesting that you're happy to cast aside Leviticus 19:27, is that not one of the tenets of Orthodox Judaism?

Hmm.

TwistMyMelons · 15/02/2024 12:33

My ex is a ‘fundie’. Can’t divorce him fast enough. Complete basket case.

Tetsuo · 15/02/2024 12:25

Interesting that you keep referring to God as 'he', why do you suppose that is @porridgeisbae?

Eightfour · 15/02/2024 12:25

@porridgeisbae - ah so there are irrelevant and contradictory bits of the bible then? It’s never the bits about homosexuality or oppressing women though is it? It’s always the Old Testament is irrelevant except for these specific bits to suit my backwards agenda. Funny that.

Well I hope you’ve had fun overhauling your wardrobe anyway OP, those mixed fabrics just won’t fly. Or is that bit irrelevant too?

God, America has a lot to answer for with this right wing, evangelical bullshit. Hate speech nestled under the protection of religious freedom.

Swipe left for the next trending thread