Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Am I the only fundie in the village (of MN?)

308 replies

porridgeisbae · 14/02/2024 20:50

Anyone else?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
13
Ratherstandonacliffandsetfiretomyself · 19/02/2024 13:52

I’m just absolutely baffled why you keep saying things like ‘I wish I could do x but I can’t’ And ‘I wish it didn’t say that but it does’ (especially when you’re justifying things like homophobia!). Why are you so adamant in following something that you don’t obviously agree with 🙄

porridgeisbae · 19/02/2024 13:18

I respect more (not that I particularly respect their theology at all) people who go 'the bible says X, I'm going to ignore that because it's not politically correct/doesn't let everyone do whatever they fancy' than people who lie and claim scripture says stuff it doesn't, in order to claim it justifies what they want to say is ok.

I'd love it to say I could shag women whenever I want, for instance, or have as much premarital sex as I want. That'd be awesome. But it doesn't.

OP posts:
SnipSnipMrBurgess · 18/02/2024 01:57

Anyone who says we must cut this child's hair because God says so, is not taking the right message out of the books in any way.

Seems to be as if you are happy to latch on to any ideal that you feel gives you an identity, a structure, a community, but you don't fully buy it.

I fear next time you post you will be a Sikh, or Buddhist or LDS loon.

Tetsuo · 18/02/2024 01:16

I am interested @porridgeisbae, at what caused your volte face?

You say you were an left-wing, intellectual, bisexual.

Then suddenly...

It seems quite an extreme switch. As someone who has self-proclaimed critical thinking skills, what predicated such an extreme reevaluation?

porridgeisbae · 17/02/2024 15:00

My degree was partly in Ancient Greek. I got a 1st in Classical Civilisation from a red brick university. It's not quite the same as Koine Greek but it is similar. And of course this degree means I have been trained in how to study texts in ancient languages and translations, and have an appreciation for cultural context.

I expect the only degrees that would make it any easier than that would be in Theology and direct study of Biblical languages.

So yes, I do somewhat know what I'm doing and how to use the tools required.

OP posts:
Hagbard · 17/02/2024 14:40

I would disagree that the bible is clear - there wouldn't be so much bloodshed over it if that was the case. The hair cutting is a perfect example of it's lack of clarity.

I hope you find your answers OP. The Bill and Ted quote a PP gave upthread (be excellent to each other, and party on) is a pretty good guide to life I've always found.

Hagbard · 17/02/2024 14:25

ErrolTheDragon · 16/02/2024 22:48

I was listening to a podcast by Bart Ehrman a while ago in which he said something to the effect of fundamentalists idolise the Bible.

And it's a bit like deciding to have a meal, but getting sidetracked by the menu. Then focussing on the description and missing out on the lovely food. Or pointing at the moon and becoming fixated on the pointing finger. I've paraphrased Alan Watts there (badly)

JobsLot · 17/02/2024 12:53

@porridgeisbae what will happen if you don't start getting results from your venture into Christianity though? There are no pay offs as such. You develop a closer relationship with God through prayer, but Christians aren't promised an easy life - on the contrary in fact - and to expect tangible results merely reduces God to nothing more than a pocket magician.

porridgeisbae · 17/02/2024 11:46

Hagbard · 16/02/2024 17:25

If I understand correctly, the religion you practice takes their interpretation of the bible completely literally, at face value? But aren't the writings in the bible supposed to be allegory? You know better than me I'm sure, but didn't Jesus himself say this?

Can I ask, what put you off occultism? And what makes you know you have chosen the correct path this time?

I find this subject fascinating, sorry for all the Q's.

I think it's clear where Jesus is using a parable to teach, and then he often explains what he means to His disciples.

I went off occultism because that is supposed to give results in terms of at least a spiritual sense that a working has achieved something. I wasn't getting those results despite doing more and more extreme workings. There could be reasons for that though. Also it can make you feel kind of alienated from the rest of the world. At least with the more hardcore stuff (but I don't mean animal sacrifice or anything like that) if people knew what you were saying in a ritual they'd be unnerved.

OP posts:
porridgeisbae · 17/02/2024 11:37

Eleganz · 16/02/2024 13:21

Yeah, you can't advocate for biblical literalism based on certain English translations of the bible (in taking about hair, sexuality, etc claiming that what is written in those translations is God's word unchanged) and then criticise others you disagree with for not using the context around the biblical texts in their interpretation. That is totally inconsistent. You need to interpret the NT through the lens of first century Jewish society under Roman occupation and the times in which these books were written and the selection of texts for the bible through the lens of the 4th century early church and the society it was in.

Of course inconsistency regarding biblical interpretation is exactly what I would expect from evangelical fundamentalism so I suppose it is consistent in one way. Fooling yourself into thinking that you are somehow not interpreting the bible through a modern, largely right wing socially conservative lens but connecting directly with God is one of the major flaws of most fundamentalist Christian denomination in the western world. It is utterly arrogant as well.

I'm not really sure what you're on about but I do know some Greek and also have texts to check and follow what the words mean in the NT, plus watch stuff online where they go through it.

I'm not arguing for biblical literalism based on certain translations of the bible. Decent academic translations agree on the sense of the Bible in most instances. I also own several bibles I use of course.

OP posts:
HotChocolateNotCocoa · 17/02/2024 01:19

I have questions.

  1. If God had a name, what would it be?
  2. And would you call it to his face?
  3. If you were faced with him in all his glory?
  4. What would you ask if you had just one question?
  5. And yeah, yeah; God is great. And yeah, yeah; God is good. Yeah, yeah, yeah yeah yeah - but what if God was one of us?
  6. Just a slob like one of us?
  7. Just a stranger on the bus, trying to make his way home?
  8. Back up to heaven all alone?
  9. Nobody calling on the phone?
  10. Except for the Pope, maybe, in Rome?
ErrolTheDragon · 16/02/2024 22:48

Hagbard · 16/02/2024 17:32

Sorry, to add, I feel that when we get too attached to our beliefs, it obscures our relationship with God

I was listening to a podcast by Bart Ehrman a while ago in which he said something to the effect of fundamentalists idolise the Bible.

Hagbard · 16/02/2024 17:32

Sorry, to add, I feel that when we get too attached to our beliefs, it obscures our relationship with God

Hagbard · 16/02/2024 17:25

If I understand correctly, the religion you practice takes their interpretation of the bible completely literally, at face value? But aren't the writings in the bible supposed to be allegory? You know better than me I'm sure, but didn't Jesus himself say this?

Can I ask, what put you off occultism? And what makes you know you have chosen the correct path this time?

I find this subject fascinating, sorry for all the Q's.

Uricon2 · 16/02/2024 15:08

@porridgeisbae , thanks for your replies, but I honestly don't think that you understand what historical/cultural context means when it comes to the Bible. I do think that you've fairly recently come out of something that is TBH fairly out there in terms of most peoples beliefs (theistic Satanism) and you are looking for cast iron certainties to give you a framework that you can espouse without having to do much questioning.

On a level I can understand that but would advise this on your search; if your discernment tells you that something seems cruel, or petty, or unloving, or contradictory in the context of the 21st century, it is probably because it is. I've seen people go from denomination to denomination in search of a perfection that really doesn't exist, when reading the teachings of Christ and looking to their own morality and commonsense would have served them far better.

Brawcolli · 16/02/2024 14:55

@porridgeisbae see that’s what I mean. If you agree with literally any of Shapiros’ opinions, you must be quite a hateful person. I’m 100% sure Jesus wouldn’t have stood for the wee arsehole!

Oneofthesurvivors · 16/02/2024 14:25

Eleganz · 16/02/2024 13:21

Yeah, you can't advocate for biblical literalism based on certain English translations of the bible (in taking about hair, sexuality, etc claiming that what is written in those translations is God's word unchanged) and then criticise others you disagree with for not using the context around the biblical texts in their interpretation. That is totally inconsistent. You need to interpret the NT through the lens of first century Jewish society under Roman occupation and the times in which these books were written and the selection of texts for the bible through the lens of the 4th century early church and the society it was in.

Of course inconsistency regarding biblical interpretation is exactly what I would expect from evangelical fundamentalism so I suppose it is consistent in one way. Fooling yourself into thinking that you are somehow not interpreting the bible through a modern, largely right wing socially conservative lens but connecting directly with God is one of the major flaws of most fundamentalist Christian denomination in the western world. It is utterly arrogant as well.

💯

Barack Obama Applause GIF by Obama
ThatLemonBird · 16/02/2024 13:33

There are things the Bible implies we should and shouldn't do, which I personally wish were another way. But they're not.

Oh FFS take ownership of your decisions for once in your life.

Eleganz · 16/02/2024 13:21

Yeah, you can't advocate for biblical literalism based on certain English translations of the bible (in taking about hair, sexuality, etc claiming that what is written in those translations is God's word unchanged) and then criticise others you disagree with for not using the context around the biblical texts in their interpretation. That is totally inconsistent. You need to interpret the NT through the lens of first century Jewish society under Roman occupation and the times in which these books were written and the selection of texts for the bible through the lens of the 4th century early church and the society it was in.

Of course inconsistency regarding biblical interpretation is exactly what I would expect from evangelical fundamentalism so I suppose it is consistent in one way. Fooling yourself into thinking that you are somehow not interpreting the bible through a modern, largely right wing socially conservative lens but connecting directly with God is one of the major flaws of most fundamentalist Christian denomination in the western world. It is utterly arrogant as well.

ZebraPensAreLife · 16/02/2024 13:17

The views on slavery and how to treat slaves are softened in the NT. I do think it's a cultural thing that it was approved of in the NT at all. Then when people were working towards slavery being abolished in the West, it was often Christians who were part of trying to abolish it.

But if the Bible is literally how people are meant to behave, then surely those Christians were being bad Christians as they aren’t following what God said 2000 years ago?

Or if they were right to work against slavery (which they were), how can you pick and choose which other bits God wants you to stick with and which bits have become outdated as society and culture has progressed?

It’s always male dominance, anti-homosexuality and anti-abortion that seems to survive. Weird that.

porridgeisbae · 16/02/2024 13:08

God is omnipotent and created the earth and universe but chose to create a version that has earthquakes and tsunamis that cause untold suffering. God created humanity but chose to create a species that gets cancer etc. The free will argument doesn't work for this like it does for actively created evil.

The illness etc is a result of the Fall (though I suppose that was God's choice too.) I watched something where someone was talking about The Problem of Evil, natural disasters etc. They said that we're lucky God doesn't strike us all down anyway, as we all deserve it. We all survive through His grace.

Other people have referenced slavery being okay in the bible. You've noted that the coming of Jesus relieved Christian's of the need to keep Jewish laws (but not Jews?)

Jews, too. Hence the disciples wouldn't still have followed all the Jewish rituals in the temple etc. They would maybe have done some of the things still to try and subtly advance Christianity.

but haven't noted where the Bible changes it's mind about slavery. Does it? I'd be interested to know where.

The views on slavery and how to treat slaves are softened in the NT. I do think it's a cultural thing that it was approved of in the NT at all. Then when people were working towards slavery being abolished in the West, it was often Christians who were part of trying to abolish it.

OP posts:
JobsLot · 16/02/2024 13:01

There are some depictions of Jesus from his time that show him with shorter, curly hair.

porridgeisbae · 16/02/2024 12:51

LoobyDop · 15/02/2024 20:03

The predestination stuff is all very interesting, but if boys have to have short hair, how come Jesus had long hair? Is it only juvenile human males who aren’t allowed?

I don't think he did. Except insomuch as he wandered around a lot and probably didn't focus on personal grooming, so mightn'tve had chance to cut it all that often. But at Gethsemane they didn't say 'arrest him over there! The long haired one!' So he looked like the other guys in terms of his hair and skin tone.

OP posts:
porridgeisbae · 16/02/2024 12:47

Eightfour · 15/02/2024 13:18

I do think unless you were indoctrinated as a child, this particular brand of Christianity just targets the vulnerable and hard of critical thinking.

I have plenty of critical thinking skills. I was into that stuff for a long time, was an atheist for a time, and still am a skeptic when it comes to flakey alternative medicine etc.

Not that I'm likening myself to them, but some of the brightest people in this world have a religion.

You say you’re ‘a former leftie’, so I assume especially with the fundamentalist beliefs that you’re right wing now. What’s Christian about right wing politics? Anyone with half a brain surely can see that they harm the majority of people and only benefit the rich, who Jesus famously wasn’t a great fan of?

@Brawcolli Christianity has some ideas which are left wing and some that lefties now consider right wing. It's not party political or falling entirely on one side or the other.

Sounds like all healthcare should be banned then. Must be God's will to have life-threatening illnesses, mobility limiting conditions, septic wounds, broken bones (splinting allowed as long as it's with naturalwood and bandage made from a single type of fibre)

@Anniegetyourgun @whatsitcalledwhen No, because He wants us to be alive when He has given us life. So most forms of medicine He is a fan of.

From what I understand in the fundie lifestyle the sole purpose of marriage/sex is for the procreation of children. You say that you've never been blessed with children - presuming due to health reasons here - and I'm guessing that you would see that as being God's plan for you but how do you reconcile that inside yourself since you've been prevented from fulfilling one of the sole purposes that women exist?

@Uricon2 It obviously wasn't His plan for me personally or it would've happened. Some women do have other callings, whatever they are. Both sexes' primary purpose is to serve God.

What completely put me off the (according to fundamentalists) Biblical God (and I attended a Reformed Baptist Church, because Baptists, were not strict enough) was predestination.

@ChristmasFluff That's similar to Calvinism and I don't think most Christians (or at least plenty) agree with that. A lot of denominations are Arminian i.e. they think God died for everyone and anyone can be saved if they choose Jesus.

M Scott Peck is New Age waffle.

Do you think that there is something about having rejected the beliefs that you say you followed in the past that makes you drawn towards the doctrinaire, authoritarian and infallible now?

@Uricon2 I don't think so. It'd be easier to not follow a path that requires things of us that are difficult. I could just've stopped being an occultist but carried on being bisexual or whatever.

Wait are you actually being serious? I didn’t think anyone actually thought BS had any good points! Wild!

@Brawcolli I (of course) agree with most things he comes out with, except that he's not a Christian yet. Smile But I stopped following all the Daily Wire crew for a bit because content mocking people etc was giving me an uncharitable heart.

OP posts: