Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Independent school teacher forced to leave due to pay cut.

114 replies

Pensionworries · 14/02/2024 20:43

I left the state sector to teach in an independent school a few years ago and I have loved how much more freedom I have had to be creative and really be the teacher I’ve always wanted to be. Having smaller class sizes has meant I get amazing job satisfaction from meeting the children’s individual needs. My colleagues are lovely and it’s a beautiful, friendly environment to work in.

But… recently us teachers were told by the governors that the school, like many independent schools, is not able to keep up with the Teacher Pension Scheme contributions so all teachers are now encouraged to either go to a different scheme (all are rubbish compared to the TPS) or take a 10% pay cut in order to pay in to it ourselves. There’s a hike in April and apparently another 5% hike due later in the year. Thanks government. 😔

I was happy-ish to take the hit now and maintain my TPS pension but, because my pension is based on my average earnings over the course of my career, I can’t really justify staying somewhere where I’m about to lose £5K a year plus take a hard hit on my pension just because I’m happy there.

I feel like it’s taken me years to find a school that I’m really happy working in and now it’s all been taken away in the blink of an eye. I’m gutted. 😞

It’s pretty galling that the school is also currently having a new swimming pool and equestrian facility built, ‘to attract new customers’, whilst I’m pulling 12 hour days and set to lose so much money. It feels like a real kick in the teeth.

Aside from asking for a pay-rise, I can’t think of any other way to go other than to leave.

I’m already worrying about awful academy chain schools run by toxic managers, under managers, executive managers and so on. I’m a good teacher and work extremely hard. Is it too much to ask to commit to a good school and be rewarded financially for my skills and hard work?

OP posts:
SoLuckyToHaveYou · 14/02/2024 21:38

I don’t think you could automatically assume that you would be put on UPS. It is supposed to be applied for.

Baircasolly · 14/02/2024 21:35

Rocksonabeach · 14/02/2024 21:26

I work in an indie school. I work longer hours and took a £10 K pay cut to work there we have a 10% pay cut next year if you want to stay in the TPS. So at that point I’m leaving - I won’t struggle to get a job in a state school - on UPS 3 and with my pension back - I’ll also probably be able to get an R and R due to my skill set - so I will last it out for 8 years in a state school very local and then retire. At least 6 people are leaving this year - when we leave the TPS they are going to struggle massively to recruit.

Sorry to derail slightly. I only worked 5 years in a state school before I moved to the independent sector, so I never went through threshold. I'm currently HOD at a fairly big independent school (1000 kids). If I were to apply for HOD at a state school now (12 years' teaching, experience, 5 state, 7 independent) would I automatically be put on UPS do you know? Shortage subject, if that makes a difference.

ETA: @Beryls it sounds like you might know the answer to this question?!

Purplecatshopaholic · 14/02/2024 21:33

It is upsetting when something changes and you realise you are likely going to have to leave a job you love. Has happened to me (different reasons), and it was gutting. However, there is always a choice - stay or go. Weigh up the pros and cons.

Pythag · 14/02/2024 21:33

Pensionworries · 14/02/2024 20:43

I left the state sector to teach in an independent school a few years ago and I have loved how much more freedom I have had to be creative and really be the teacher I’ve always wanted to be. Having smaller class sizes has meant I get amazing job satisfaction from meeting the children’s individual needs. My colleagues are lovely and it’s a beautiful, friendly environment to work in.

But… recently us teachers were told by the governors that the school, like many independent schools, is not able to keep up with the Teacher Pension Scheme contributions so all teachers are now encouraged to either go to a different scheme (all are rubbish compared to the TPS) or take a 10% pay cut in order to pay in to it ourselves. There’s a hike in April and apparently another 5% hike due later in the year. Thanks government. 😔

I was happy-ish to take the hit now and maintain my TPS pension but, because my pension is based on my average earnings over the course of my career, I can’t really justify staying somewhere where I’m about to lose £5K a year plus take a hard hit on my pension just because I’m happy there.

I feel like it’s taken me years to find a school that I’m really happy working in and now it’s all been taken away in the blink of an eye. I’m gutted. 😞

It’s pretty galling that the school is also currently having a new swimming pool and equestrian facility built, ‘to attract new customers’, whilst I’m pulling 12 hour days and set to lose so much money. It feels like a real kick in the teeth.

Aside from asking for a pay-rise, I can’t think of any other way to go other than to leave.

I’m already worrying about awful academy chain schools run by toxic managers, under managers, executive managers and so on. I’m a good teacher and work extremely hard. Is it too much to ask to commit to a good school and be rewarded financially for my skills and hard work?

You don’t have to work at an awful academy chain school. I work in a grammar school which is an academy but there are no toxic managers etc! And the kids are great! There are lots of excellent schools in the state sector: choose wisely!

Beryls · 14/02/2024 21:33

Rocksonabeach · 14/02/2024 21:26

I work in an indie school. I work longer hours and took a £10 K pay cut to work there we have a 10% pay cut next year if you want to stay in the TPS. So at that point I’m leaving - I won’t struggle to get a job in a state school - on UPS 3 and with my pension back - I’ll also probably be able to get an R and R due to my skill set - so I will last it out for 8 years in a state school very local and then retire. At least 6 people are leaving this year - when we leave the TPS they are going to struggle massively to recruit.

I hope you don't struggle of course, but it might not be as easy as you think to walk into a state school job on UPS3. The budgets are so tight now that jobs are usually advertised with a limit to M6.

SecondUsername4me · 14/02/2024 21:29

What % do you currently pay in and what is the new %?

Is a defined contribution pension or a defined benefit?

Spendonsend · 14/02/2024 21:29

Im not sure i quite undrrstand. I wouldnt expect it to affect your career average earnings as i would think that is based on your gross income. Your 'pay cut' shouldnt be an actual reduction on your gross salary, but that you are now contributing an extra 10 percent to the TPS so you have less net pay. (Which is still crap for you but different) Or did they actually cut your gross pay and maintain paying the full employer contribution from a lower salary?

As for facilities - this is very tricky. Schools do have to attract customers. They can often borrow from the bank for capital projects as long as they can service the debt but the bank wouldnt lend for salaries - theyd expect that to be covered out of fee income or your school isnt really viable if it cant pay its wages without a loan.

Rocksonabeach · 14/02/2024 21:27

Oh and there will not be a TPS on ten years time - but I will be out of it and retired by then

SoLuckyToHaveYou · 14/02/2024 21:27

The pension changes are being introduced into more & more private schools OP. As an ex-teacher I’m sympathetic to other teachers being screwed over. But private schools deviate from state in so many ways - not always for the good - so you have to go with what means most to you. I’ve applied to ‘successful’ private schools where a teacher’s salary is capped at main scale and where teachers were expected to attend Saturday swimming galas. With apologies to L P Hartley, private schools are a foreign country. They do things differently there.

BTW, I’ve never got the VAT for private schools, as parents who pay to send their kids to private are already saving the tax payer a bit. Income tax would inevitably have to rise to fund all the state places when parents can no longer afford to send kids to private schools. Oh wait – the Labour party are still expecting people to send their kids to private schools in the same numbers aren’t they?

Rocksonabeach · 14/02/2024 21:26

I work in an indie school. I work longer hours and took a £10 K pay cut to work there we have a 10% pay cut next year if you want to stay in the TPS. So at that point I’m leaving - I won’t struggle to get a job in a state school - on UPS 3 and with my pension back - I’ll also probably be able to get an R and R due to my skill set - so I will last it out for 8 years in a state school very local and then retire. At least 6 people are leaving this year - when we leave the TPS they are going to struggle massively to recruit.

Tupeytupe · 14/02/2024 21:25

People should probably remember that the contributions aren't funding OP's eventual pension, but rather current retired teachers. The TPS is an unfunded scheme which is I believe in massive deficit. It doesn't make a difference to OP whether her employer has to pay in 5% or 28% - the pension she receives at retirement age would still be the same. IF it still exists when she needs it!

topcat2014 · 14/02/2024 21:20

OP, the whole workforce outside of the public sector generally get a few percent employers contribution.

We are all free agents and can choose to work where we want.

I wish you the best, if course.

rwalker · 14/02/2024 21:19

Big pension needs big contributions up to you

Fergie51 · 14/02/2024 21:18

Many independent schools pay less than the state sector, but offer a wide curriculum, smaller classes, engaged pupils and pleasant surroundings.
I took quite a pay cut to move from a state school. The school day was longer and all staff were on a rota for a Saturday boarding duty. I remained in the independent sector until retirement and never regretted the move despite the loss in earnings.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 14/02/2024 21:18

Merryoldgoat · 14/02/2024 21:13

The TPS contributions are unsustainable for both sectors - it’s just the independent can choose to leave or share the costs.

The capital projects likely have been in the pipeline for years and come from reserves fundraising - not operating surplus.

With VAT coming, loss of charitable rates relief the TPS is another item that will just hit surpluses too hard.

I’m not doing a poor me - I think independent schools should be paying full rates and VAT. It’s just a fact that 30% employer contributions are insane.

The point still stands. Spend per pupil is higher in the private sector than in the state sector, so it comes down to how schools prioritise the funds.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 14/02/2024 21:15

RawBloomers · 14/02/2024 21:11

They’re putting up the contributions so that it’s financially stable. The alternative would be that the pension collapses in years to come.

The government (through taxation) are increasing their contribution for state school teachers. To suggest the general public should subsidise private school teachers’ pensions so that OP can stay in a cushier job helping elite children get an education that will help them continue to take more of the country’s resources than average is incredibly self-centered and entirely unreasonable.

Edited

Well, quite. It isn't the government's responsibility.

Tupeytupe · 14/02/2024 21:13

*They’re putting up the contributions so that it’s financially stable. The alternative would be that the pension collapses in years to come.

The government (through taxation) are increasing their contribution for state school teachers. To suggest the general public should subsidise private school teachers’ pensions so that OP can stay in a cushier job helping elite children get an education that will help them continue to take more of the country’s resources than average is incredibly self-centered and entirely unreasonable.*

I didn't suggest anything of the sort - just explained what the government had to do with it as a PP asked 🤷‍♀️

Merryoldgoat · 14/02/2024 21:13

The TPS contributions are unsustainable for both sectors - it’s just the independent can choose to leave or share the costs.

The capital projects likely have been in the pipeline for years and come from reserves fundraising - not operating surplus.

With VAT coming, loss of charitable rates relief the TPS is another item that will just hit surpluses too hard.

I’m not doing a poor me - I think independent schools should be paying full rates and VAT. It’s just a fact that 30% employer contributions are insane.

madderthanahatter · 14/02/2024 21:12

justasking111 · 14/02/2024 21:09

Was shocked tonight to learn that a friend of my son in his forties packed in teaching had a breakdown. He's now earning £1k a week as a Just Eat delivery driver, happy as a clam and has set up a private pension to make up for losing his teacher one.

As a teen my ds worked weekends in a takeaway and he said there were so many professionals working side jobs as delivery drivers.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 14/02/2024 21:11

Tupeytupe · 14/02/2024 21:01

Presumably because it's the government that sets the contribution level to the TPS. Private schools, particularly smaller ones, just can't financially keep up with the increases which is why they are coming out of the scheme.

Yes, but that's because the independent schools are choosing not to prioritise the budgets to pay for teacher pension contributions. The government is not responsible for this.

Schools could choose to prioritise teachers pensions instead of investing in fancy equestrian centres and swimming pools, but some choose not to. I presume that they think their paying customers care more about the swish facilities than the teachers' terms and conditions, and they may well be right. If the decision to pull out of the TPS results in a massive exodus of staff, then they'll have to rethink - either reprioritise what they spend their money on or charge the parents more to cover their costs.

RawBloomers · 14/02/2024 21:11

Tupeytupe · 14/02/2024 21:01

Presumably because it's the government that sets the contribution level to the TPS. Private schools, particularly smaller ones, just can't financially keep up with the increases which is why they are coming out of the scheme.

They’re putting up the contributions so that it’s financially stable. The alternative would be that the pension collapses in years to come.

The government (through taxation) are increasing their contribution for state school teachers. To suggest the general public should subsidise private school teachers’ pensions so that OP can stay in a cushier job helping elite children get an education that will help them continue to take more of the country’s resources than average is incredibly self-centered and entirely unreasonable.

Containerhome · 14/02/2024 21:10

Really @justasking111 ? I thought delivery drivers where striking for more pay today!

BlusteryLake · 14/02/2024 21:10

Private schools are struggling to attract enough people who can still afford the fees, whilst simultaneously facing higher running costs. Some have already closed. This is the downside of opting out of state provision. As PP have said, your choices are really around balancing lifestyle, happiness and prospects.

DearGod24MoreYears · 14/02/2024 21:10

Yep NHS here too. Hence the user name! I chose to stay for the pension, benefits and annual leave. However with the stress I worry I may not live to benefit from it.

justasking111 · 14/02/2024 21:09

Was shocked tonight to learn that a friend of my son in his forties packed in teaching had a breakdown. He's now earning £1k a week as a Just Eat delivery driver, happy as a clam and has set up a private pension to make up for losing his teacher one.

Swipe left for the next trending thread