Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Independent school teacher forced to leave due to pay cut.

114 replies

Pensionworries · 14/02/2024 20:43

I left the state sector to teach in an independent school a few years ago and I have loved how much more freedom I have had to be creative and really be the teacher I’ve always wanted to be. Having smaller class sizes has meant I get amazing job satisfaction from meeting the children’s individual needs. My colleagues are lovely and it’s a beautiful, friendly environment to work in.

But… recently us teachers were told by the governors that the school, like many independent schools, is not able to keep up with the Teacher Pension Scheme contributions so all teachers are now encouraged to either go to a different scheme (all are rubbish compared to the TPS) or take a 10% pay cut in order to pay in to it ourselves. There’s a hike in April and apparently another 5% hike due later in the year. Thanks government. 😔

I was happy-ish to take the hit now and maintain my TPS pension but, because my pension is based on my average earnings over the course of my career, I can’t really justify staying somewhere where I’m about to lose £5K a year plus take a hard hit on my pension just because I’m happy there.

I feel like it’s taken me years to find a school that I’m really happy working in and now it’s all been taken away in the blink of an eye. I’m gutted. 😞

It’s pretty galling that the school is also currently having a new swimming pool and equestrian facility built, ‘to attract new customers’, whilst I’m pulling 12 hour days and set to lose so much money. It feels like a real kick in the teeth.

Aside from asking for a pay-rise, I can’t think of any other way to go other than to leave.

I’m already worrying about awful academy chain schools run by toxic managers, under managers, executive managers and so on. I’m a good teacher and work extremely hard. Is it too much to ask to commit to a good school and be rewarded financially for my skills and hard work?

OP posts:
caringcarer · 15/02/2024 02:42

Well once Labour get into government and put 20 percent VAT on independent school fees, as they won't get charity status any more, lots of kids will be put back into the state sector so less need for as many teachers in independent schools.

Oblomov23 · 15/02/2024 02:38

I don't understand your viewpoint. You have choices. And your comment about the swimming pool is odd. Independents are under extreme pressure, they need to attract more parents, to pay your salary. And all this nonsense of the VAT, which probably won't come into effect imminently, but just adds to the cash flow and budgeting nightmare that the Finance Director of any Independent will face.

toastwithmarmalade · 15/02/2024 02:27

The way I see it there are many jobs that are better for mental health and well-being, some that are better for that feeling of contributing and helping society and others that are better for pay/disposable income etc. Some teachers would never want to work in independent schools because they want to help more vulnerable children they choose schools in deprived areas. Some people work in the charity sector despite being able to earn double in the private sector, because that feeling of making a difference is really important.

I don't view it as right/wrong, more what aligns with people's values, choices, needs, wants and everything in between.

If that 5k is more important than all the other job satisfaction points you mentioned, then it's fine to jump ship. But you may find you would prefer to swallow that 5k. Do you also get more paid holidays? Sometimes teachers in the private sector get another 3 ish weeks paid leave + a year. That means something too.

Winter2020 · 15/02/2024 02:05

Milkandnosugarplease · 14/02/2024 22:26

TPS is unaffordable for independent and state schools. Independent schools have the option of leaving and offering alternatives. At my school there is the option of staying in TPS but in effect take a pay cut to fund it or take the offer of an alternative with Royal London.

We are not a large school and have spent money on a lovely new learning resource centre and drama suite. We are currently full for September 2024, of course that may change if VAT is placed on fees.

I fear that teaching in independent schools will become the preserve of those who can ‘afford’ it

I'm not anti private schools but I was tickled by the comment
"I fear that teaching in independent schools will become the preserve of those who can ‘afford’ it".

Considering private schools pupils are generally families that can afford it I doubt that there would be too much concern from the general public if the same applied to the staff.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 15/02/2024 00:21

Onheretoomuch · 14/02/2024 23:27

You obviously know nothing about independent schools if you think there is no ‘true diversity’ in them !!

Of course they aren't truly diverse.

There is plenty of ethnic diversity, yes. But very little socioeconomic diversity.

I'm sure you'll be back to tell us all about how most independent schools offer loads of scholarships/bursaries and so there is socioeconomic diversity after all. That simply isn't true. Firstly, there are actually very few schools that offer 100% scholarships for those on the very lowest incomes, and most parents end up contributing at least something. That immediately wipes out whole swathes of the population whose families simply don't have anything to give, because they're already struggling to choose between the basics such as food and heating. And even on those odd occasions when the schools do fully fund places for kids on the lowest incomes, these are typically aimed at the exceptionally bright children who would almost certainly do well anywhere, and more often than not, the places will be sought out by ambitious middle class parents who have somehow fallen on hard times. I am not aware of any independent schools that are falling over themselves to offer fully funded places to ordinary working class kids from low income backgrounds.

So no, I'm sorry, I don't buy it. There can never be true diversity in the independent sector because the whole point of it is that it's supposed to be exclusive.

Topofthemountain · 14/02/2024 23:59

The TPS is an absolute shambles, they were the worst company to deal with when MIL died. The time wasting bureaucracy that we had to go through to close the small pension (by then a widow's pension) was unreal.

Nameychango · 14/02/2024 23:50

Op, I feel for you I have no words of advice but I feel this is a very poor show and I'm sad it's come to this. I'm aware at my daughter's school teachers went on strike before Xmas. She's in the middle of her A levels and is stressed that her teachers might leave. My son's school nearby has had 3 subject teachers leave mid GCSE too. It's a small independent school, so that's a huge loss and very unsettling.

I think schools with the deepest pockets will absorb the financial hit but there are many smaller independent schools struggling at present. One school closed in my local area due to financial reasons and both my daughter's and son's independent schools lost a lot of staff last term. It's a worrying time.

As a parent, I would rather they increased the fees slightly or think the school should have it because without great teachers there is no school and teachers are a valuable resource!!!

If any independent school mangers are on this site... please consider how bad it looks when disillusioned teachers are leaving in droves due to this- not good for business or the children or the exam grades!!

Sorry to ramble, tired but wanted to post!

Teachers are amazing 😻

CreateHope · 14/02/2024 23:50

@Onheretoomuch that massively depends on your definition of diversity 🙄

EnidSpyton · 14/02/2024 23:49

My independent school has never been part of the TPS in my time being here. Our pension is shit but the salary is sufficiently inflated above state to make me better off regardless (I’m on over £60k as a classroom teacher with no responsibilities).

More and more independents are leaving the TPS as the contributions are unaffordable. You’re talking hundreds of thousands extra a year in some large well paying schools when it comes to the wages bill. That is the cost of a new building. It’s ridiculous. The government are asking too much of all schools and of teachers, too, when it comes to the level of contributions. Two friends of mine in other indies have both been told their schools are pulling out of the TPS this year and they are actually relieved as it means they can lower their contributions. They have been struggling to pay their mortgages with the contribution hikes taking so much out of their wages every month. I don’t think it’ll be long before all independents pull out and then there’ll be a crisis as that will leave a big whole in the TPS funds. At this rate I do wonder whether there’ll be a TPS left by the time I retire!

Before you make any decisions, please see a financial advisor. They will be able to walk you through the implications of any decisions you make. You may find that the salary drop you take to go back to state will outweigh the loss of the TPS depending on what stage of your career you are at.

Applespies23 · 14/02/2024 23:43

Very similar position here OP. Worse salary, worse pension, no job security. I'm leaving very soon. Teachers aren't valued anymore.

Onheretoomuch · 14/02/2024 23:27

Mammyloveswine · 14/02/2024 22:49

👏

Education should be truly universal.. private schools should be abolished imo. It's not better teachers that children get, it's smaller class sizes and no true diversity..

You obviously know nothing about independent schools if you think there is no ‘true diversity’ in them !!

LuluBlakey1 · 14/02/2024 23:25

Please don't think state schools are financially more stable. The government have underfunded them for years and many are now in huge deficit budgets which LAs can no longer contain and academy chains can no longer continue with. There are redundancies in many schools coming up. The LA I work for (in School Improvement) will have more than half of its secondary schools with deficit budgets between 1 and 6 million each. Those are huge sums and schools can not hope to ever rebalance those deficits.

Two of the largest deficits are schools with historic deficits due to falling rolls- both have been up for academisation and no academy chain wants them because of their financial problems. They should both close but all of the other schools are full or over number so there is nowhere for the children to go. They both face another round of radical staff cuts- they will cut support staff because teaching staff are down to the bone in one in particular but they will need to lost two support staff rather than 1 teacher because there is a smaller saving with most support staff. The only safe job in either school is the HT. Nothing is off the table. In one school they have lost 4 of their SLT since September and none have been replaced. In the other the English dept had 5 staff- it now has 3 and much larger class sizes. The LA has withdrawn it's additional funding and that means the loss of the equivalent of 3 well-paid teachers salaries will disappear.

Private schools choose to spend their money on small class sizes and on maintaining extra 'gloss' to attract parents. No state school gets even a fifth of the funding per pupil of what an average private school charges per pupil.

I don't think Labour have any idea how big the financial mess is they are going to inherit. The LA next to the one I work for has huge loans with Japanese banks that it adds to every year and is on the point of complete collapse. It has had £70 million + removed from its budget by the Tories over the last 10 years. It is one of the most deprived areas in the country. It now no longer runs school meals, has barely any services for the homeless left, has stopped garden waste collections, reduced household waste collections by half, stopped planting of plants/bulbs, closed brand new council offices and sold them off pushing council services into an old school that leaks water, has no School Improvement Team, closed leisure centres and swimming pools, almost doubled council tax, provides no subsidy at all to adult learning - I could go on, the list is shocking.

Please also bear in mind teachers contribute a lot to their pensions- more than every other public service I think. All public services are having the age pensions can be accessed raised, and private pensions are also going to have the age raised of ability to access pension pots. Teacher pensions drop about £2500 per year for every year they are taken early and a full pension only comes (currently) after 40 years service and contribution. Police and some other pensions are fully-funded after 30 years.

I think we will see all pensions less accessible until an older age, even larger contributions expected from the employed and over a longer working period.

justasking111 · 14/02/2024 23:00

Containerhome · 14/02/2024 21:10

Really @justasking111 ? I thought delivery drivers where striking for more pay today!

That's in the cities where there's an army of people that fly under the radar. We're in a semi rural affluent pocket in Wales where it's hard to fill jobs.

Rocksonabeach · 14/02/2024 22:58

Beryls · 14/02/2024 21:33

I hope you don't struggle of course, but it might not be as easy as you think to walk into a state school job on UPS3. The budgets are so tight now that jobs are usually advertised with a limit to M6.

Yes it will for me. I am a governor at two local state schools and I know the Headteachers at those schools would welcome me with open arms. I have a post grad and at least twenty outstanding lesson obs under my belt and my references and results speak for themselves both at my indie and state schools. I have worked for the BBC on programmes in parallel and have huge links to exam boards as a top examiner. I have helped my pupils win top subjects competitions within my subject area in each of the indie and state schools I have worked in for the last ten years plus and I have won awards for my teaching and mentoring of other staff. I’m passionate about my teaching and I’ve worked in some very challenging schools. I took my current post as I relocated and it was the first job up. State schools normally do have money for staff- the squeeze is nothing new - schools have been saying they can’t afford stuff since I started teaching. I found a school I really loved and stayed but I’m not taking another hike down.

I started teaching on the old pay scale which went up to 9 I think and I started on point 7 (the Head was keen as shortage subject and I had a postgrad- you then went up every year) but I was HOD in 2 years - state school. And given then a D scale on top. With UPS you don’t need it to be HOD. I had UPS3 nearly twenty years ago - and I just applied and went straight through. I think once you have it - it’s rare for it to be removed. A school can’t discriminate on the grounds of age or experience they need a balance of new and old staff.

@Baircasolly I’ve always negotiated a minimum of a TLR and an R and R in a state school - you have to deliver, of course, but my last state school gave me a TLR of nearly £10 K and effectively made a job - and gave me a whole school responsibility for mentoring and Stem etc and then an R and R of £5 K. My current indie school has an enhanced pay scale - I’m on the top of it but it’s still lower than state - but I do get an extra 5 weeks holiday and we finish very early / late June which enables me to crack on with examiner work a bit more easily. So I might scale that back down if I go to state. I would get your evidence ready to apply as part of your accepted and assume they will take it but make it crystal clear without it you won’t go- get your results, obs, extra etc all nicely tied up.

There is a huge gender pay gap in most schools - I have sat as a governor where candidates have negotiated great salaries to start on (male candidates are much more likely to do this!) one NQT she negotiated an M6 to start and we wanted her and accepted it, she had been offered a job the day before at another school and they were waiting on her and she negotiated with us - well the Head - very politely. Some heads refuse - I worked in one school where the school was in special measures and the Head had a huge chip on his shoulder and literally cut anyone’s salary that he could and felt you should be grateful to work for him in an SM school. He didn’t last too long - no one wanted a job, everyone left and he could not recruit anyone decent and the new trust removed him quickly. I had gone by then but the new trust asked me back - I didn’t go!

As for the TPS I stand by it won’t exist in ten years but the government will not let it fold and will have to honour it. The next pay review is in 4 years - Teacher contribution can go down but highly unlikely so a potential freeze and then finish I wouldn’t be surprised. I am going to be out of it by then though. If I was a new teacher I’d Chuck as much in the TPS as I can for the next few years - not be leaving. Most of mine is ring fenced under the old final salary scheme though.

Barrenfieldoffucks · 14/02/2024 22:51

Fergie51 · 14/02/2024 21:18

Many independent schools pay less than the state sector, but offer a wide curriculum, smaller classes, engaged pupils and pleasant surroundings.
I took quite a pay cut to move from a state school. The school day was longer and all staff were on a rota for a Saturday boarding duty. I remained in the independent sector until retirement and never regretted the move despite the loss in earnings.

The OP indicates she is on around £50k, to be on more than that in the state sector she'd be fairly well up SLT.

Letsgetouttahere2023 · 14/02/2024 22:51

Sounds like your pension has been insanely good

Parents aren't bottomless pits

Mammyloveswine · 14/02/2024 22:49

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 14/02/2024 21:05

I think it's your choice to work in the private sector, so you have to accept the pros and cons that go along with that.

My priority is the salaries, pensions and working conditions of the hardworking teachers who stay in the state sector, despite the many challenges. If there are some perks like pensions that help to keep them there, that's brilliant.

👏

Education should be truly universal.. private schools should be abolished imo. It's not better teachers that children get, it's smaller class sizes and no true diversity..

Dixiechickonhols · 14/02/2024 22:42

It’s same with any profession though? Salaries and packages vary and you choose what suits you.
If salary or pension package is no longer suiting you then look to move to a different school.
The school can presumably still attract staff at lower salary package as there are so many fed up teachers - if you are in a horrible state school about to crack and resign then earning a bit money teaching 15/20 well behaved children is attractive.
If you stay put and are wanting to make up difference to put in pension then you could pick some work up in 15 weeks hols eg tutoring or holiday childcare.

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 14/02/2024 22:42

Rocksonabeach · 14/02/2024 21:27

Oh and there will not be a TPS on ten years time - but I will be out of it and retired by then

How else will they attract teachers? Lots go into it for the pension.

Milkandnosugarplease · 14/02/2024 22:26

TPS is unaffordable for independent and state schools. Independent schools have the option of leaving and offering alternatives. At my school there is the option of staying in TPS but in effect take a pay cut to fund it or take the offer of an alternative with Royal London.

We are not a large school and have spent money on a lovely new learning resource centre and drama suite. We are currently full for September 2024, of course that may change if VAT is placed on fees.

I fear that teaching in independent schools will become the preserve of those who can ‘afford’ it

jcyclops · 14/02/2024 22:18

Just for background the TPS is managed by DofE and administered by Crapita (shortly to be Tata). A teacher on £32,000 currently pays 7.4% employee contributions to TPS (£2,368).

The employer pays 23.68% (includes 0.08% for the administrators) ie £7,577.60
This 23.68% is increasing to 28.68% from April making the total £9177.60
This is on top of £3160.20 employers NI.
So the £32,000 teacher will cost the school £44,337.80

It is not surprising that independent schools want to cut staff costs.

spirit20 · 14/02/2024 22:15

It's a well known fact at this stage that lots of independent schools have left or are currently planning to leave the TPS. I do think it'll impact their ability to recruit staff, as that will put a lot of teachers from the state sector off applying for them. A local independent school announced two years ago that they were leaving it and consequently had a mass exodus of staff, including some who joined my state school.

I do worry about the future of the TPS ,even for those of us in state schools though, and if they'll actually pay out the money once I'm actually old enough to take it.

Tinkerbyebye · 14/02/2024 22:00

What’s the government got to do with it? They have chosen to build a swimming pool etc rather than pay staff is it’s the school that’s the issue

DragonCatcher · 14/02/2024 21:56

@Baircasolly anyone can be a HoD in a state school. UPS is not a requirement.

Usually, you'd be allocated a pay scale based on your current salary before any TLR payments. If your salary is closest to M4 then that's what you would be given, unless you can negotiate well.

Baircasolly · 14/02/2024 21:42

SoLuckyToHaveYou · 14/02/2024 21:38

I don’t think you could automatically assume that you would be put on UPS. It is supposed to be applied for.

Thanks. I thought I'd been told at one point that you had to have gone through threshold and be on UPS in order to be given a HOD role, but it sounds like I might have misunderstood that one.