Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have been told off by HR for this?

588 replies

Mhassy · 14/02/2024 16:17

I asked a member of the HR team if they had children, in the context of discussing a flexible working request. This was in the small talk/intro part of the conversation, it wasn’t said to make a point or anything, or to bolster my request for flexible working. It was literally a polite back and forth before the actual meeting began, she asked how things were going with DD, I mentioned some new teething and it was all very chatty and I just asked - I thought politely! - if she had children. She told me she didn’t and the time had passed for her to now. We then moved onto the meeting itself.

Anyway, a day later I have a called from someone high up in HR to say I shouldn’t ask people if they have children and this is not an appropriate question in the workplace.

I do get that pregnancy etc can be a sensitive topic. I lost a baby a few years ago and it was and incredibly painful time at work and I felt triggered by any small talk about babies. However I would never have made an issue and I didn’t make an issue when the topic was raised.

AIBU to think this is a step too far to be policing this sort of conversation? I am recently a single parent and wouldn’t launch into being offended if I was asked if I had a partner? Where does it end? I was only making conversation!

OP posts:
EmmaGrundyForPM · 15/02/2024 09:46

Marblessolveeverything · 14/02/2024 16:36

Professionally I never ask anyone their family set up. If they offer the information then fine. We never know what that person has been through. Having or not having children doesn't limit a persons ability to make a resource decision.

This.

And men tend not to be asked the same question.

IHaveNeverLivedintheCastle · 15/02/2024 09:44

Abeona · 15/02/2024 08:39

The vast majority of us have no idea about the experiences of victims of rape and sexual assault, victims of both sexes, because so many victims don't ever talk about it.

If we don't discuss difficult things we'll be stuck talking about the weather and pets (though, actually, best avoid pets in case someone's cat's just died) and we'll be back where my grandmother's generation started: focussed on gossip and trivia, silent on things that really need need talking about.

You can't expect the world to mysteriously know a particular subject is painful for you and run to HR if someone fails to pick up the vibes. You have to learn to manage your own feelings and responses. Emotional pain is an intrinsic part of life: none of us escapes it. Trying to shut the world down so that you feel better is both impossible and approaching the issue from the wrong angle.

You've completely missed the point. The comment about "the vast majority of us not knowing" is unfounded , unsubstantiated nonsense which demonstrates that poster has zero understanding of how sexual assault happens.

As far talking about and making jokes about rape alarms in a workplace, how can you think that's appropriate?

HoneyButterPopcorn · 15/02/2024 09:40

I wonder if the HR person actually tried to speak to the complainer and gently explain that this is what comes under ‘normal conversation’ and not bullying, insensitivity, whatever…

it’s so silly - you have to monitor your conversation? At work most people don’t care if you have a husband, wife, kids, cat, car… most often they are just making polite small talk and probably won’t remember anyway.

nighttimeforgenerals88 · 15/02/2024 09:38

Honestly, what an overreaction.

RatatouillePie · 15/02/2024 09:37

If the HR woman was asking about your kids then she can't just have a tantrum because you then asked if she had kids.

I'd be expecting the same stern conversation with the HR person!

TonTonMacoute · 15/02/2024 09:35

Well it seems that OPs workmate started the whole thing off by making an enquiry about OPs DD. If someone asks you about your own children you sort of feel it's polite to return the question.

If she didn't want to be asked about her own parenthood status perhaps she shouldn't have mentioned children in the first place. Perhaps HR would like to point that out to her so she won't risk being offended in future.

Beautiful3 · 15/02/2024 09:33

Did you tell them that she asked about your daughter first?! You simply responded with fine thanks, do you have any children? I think you should bring it up. So that they can tell her not to ask staff about their children too. It works both ways.

gannett · 15/02/2024 09:20

On the face of it this seems like harmless small talk but actually I think HR were totally right - there are so many ways of making small talk that don't directly intrude on someone's private life.

Would you ask "do you have a husband/boyfriend?" No, it would be deeply inappropriate. There are all sorts of reasons someone might not want to answer that. "Do you have a child?" is very akin to that imo. I've had to make a lot of small talk over the years and I've never come close to asking either of those things. I also don't ask about people's parents, I don't ask whether they own their house or rent, I don't ask them what political party they support.

To get the conversation going I might talk about whatever bits of my life I'm happy to - I might mention DP or that I'm child-free. The nature of small talk is that if the person I'm talking to feels comfortable to talk about similar things the ball is in the court to do so; if they're not we move on to something else. I wouldn't talk about being NC with my parents and if someone talked about their parents I would say "mm-hmm that's nice" and change the subject.

Small talk is meant to be bland and neutral, it's not the most meaningful interaction there is.

CosyNewt · 15/02/2024 09:11

Just to add a point of view from someone that works in HR. I returned to work following a miscarriage and soon after, during a similar kind of meeting I was asked the same. It took everything I had in me not to cry as I was still quite hormonal and understandably upset so I politely said ‘maybe one day’ and it was a struggle through the rest of the meeting. When I got back to my desk I burst into tears and my manager (the HR Director) asked what had happened and similarly wanted to contact the person but I told her not to. It was more of a protective thing as she was upset that I was upset but of course, you can only communicate it’s inappropriate without giving away my personal circumstances. I know you absolutely did not mean any harm with your question like I’m sure the person who asked me didn’t but just to give another potential point of view.

angsanana · 15/02/2024 09:04

It was thoughtless to ask, and I think the context of a flex working request makes it even worse! If HR says they don't have children and then deny you your request, face it, you'd be much more likely to assume they are not understanding/ empathetic to your situation, and pursue an escalation/ grievance etc.

Kalevala · 15/02/2024 08:40

Eightfour · 14/02/2024 23:59

Yep. Also not everyone who disagrees with you @VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia is neurotypical you know.

Not neurotypical here and I could not work in
Vito's ideal workplace. I need that normal human interaction. I've found that when I get to know many neurotypicals, they aren't completely different to me. They find some things easier, but not necessarily easy.

Abeona · 15/02/2024 08:39

The vast majority of us have no idea about the experiences of victims of rape and sexual assault, victims of both sexes, because so many victims don't ever talk about it.

If we don't discuss difficult things we'll be stuck talking about the weather and pets (though, actually, best avoid pets in case someone's cat's just died) and we'll be back where my grandmother's generation started: focussed on gossip and trivia, silent on things that really need need talking about.

You can't expect the world to mysteriously know a particular subject is painful for you and run to HR if someone fails to pick up the vibes. You have to learn to manage your own feelings and responses. Emotional pain is an intrinsic part of life: none of us escapes it. Trying to shut the world down so that you feel better is both impossible and approaching the issue from the wrong angle.

Babsexxx · 15/02/2024 08:34

unfortunately you don’t know her past etc but if she was asking about your child I think I would probably of asked back if they had children so I’m a bit torn on this one!

Divebar2021 · 15/02/2024 08:28

@KimberleyClark

Would those posters who think it an appropriate question be offended by the reply “no, and that’s all I want to say on the subject”?

Well there are ways of saying no that don’t necessitate being that blunt. Adults learn techniques for diverting conversations away from sensitive subjects. ( or some do…. Some don’t judging by this thread). Even if someone responded as you suggest and even if the OP / whoever was offended I doubt they’d go running to HR to complain about it. That’s the part I have an issue with. You can’t prevent the whole world from touching on bruising subjects but you can formulate responses to many of them.

Abeona · 15/02/2024 07:48

No, of course I wouldn't be offended. And I'm a woman who doesn't have children (for various reasons) and wouldn't have found the question offensive in the first place.

KimberleyClark · 15/02/2024 06:00

Would those posters who think it an appropriate question be offended by the reply “no, and that’s all I want to say on the subject”?

When you are asked you have no idea whether the questioner will move on to another subject or start digging. That’s why you dread the question.

FinFan24 · 15/02/2024 03:36

Picklestop · 14/02/2024 17:46

You were there for a work related meeting with HR. Most meetings might start with some small talk, but it is best to stick to the weather or last nights TV, not asking whether somebody had had children. I am glad that you were pulled up on this and hope you learn from it.

You’d fit right in to the old USSR! Or perhaps you took 1984 as a literal handbook.

Grow up!

JMSA · 15/02/2024 02:07

Wow, what a petty reaction. YANBU.

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 15/02/2024 01:51

Noideawwhatsoccuring · 15/02/2024 01:18

You clearly tried to state your opinions as facts. And tried to tell people what is definitively OK what's not.

If you find it easier to navigate the world like that, that's OK. But it's not how everyone else has to act.

I also think given your offensive post about all managers being 'morons' deeply offensive. I would assume, given you think that's appropriate to write. The incidents you have spoken about have been far more offensive than you care to acknowledge.

And I am ND. But it would be entirely inappropriate for me to say 'all admin staff, everyone one of them is uneducated or useless', because I have come across some admins who weren't great at their job. It would also be entirely inappropriate to use very offensive language and claim I didn't know because I am ND.

Edited

I also think given your offensive post about all managers being 'morons' deeply offensive. I would assume, given you think that's appropriate to write. The incidents you have spoken about have been far more offensive than you care to acknowledge.

Do you really think that I would say that to management or in any forum where I thought it could be credibly relayed to them? I'm autistic, not stupid.

It's what bottom-tier workers everywhere think. I've never worked anywhere where the bottom-tier staff didn't voice disparaging opinions about management when amongst themselves.

The incidents you have spoken about have been far more offensive than you care to acknowledge.

Telling a store manager who had put a flatpacked end-of-life seasonal display in front of a fire extinguisher, obstructing it got me threatening, to give an example of an incident. So much for "safety is everyone's business".

"You can't put that there, it's obstructing a fire extinguisher" wasn't met with "fair point, but perhaps 'shouldn't' and 'please' next time?" nor was it met with "do you have a better suggestion of where to put it?", it was met with him backing me against a door and saying right into my face "look, I don't have time for this". That's the one I remember most clearly, from decades ago, because I was genuinely scared. I was scared before I spoke, that's why my language was so unfiltered, but I knew I had to say something because it was a safety risk. Bullies like that can detect autistic people, that we are vulnerable and can be intimidated.

I still won't shop at the Co-op.

I'm going to hide this thread because recalling that incident has made me shakey and my heart beat really fast like I was at the time, and I don't think that continuing to argue with people who think I'm "mad" and "enjoy being a victim" will help with that.

Noideawwhatsoccuring · 15/02/2024 01:18

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 15/02/2024 01:09

@Noideawwhatsoccuring I gave thanks because most of your last post demonstrated understanding.

I quibble this: However, that doesn't mean that anything you think isn't appropriate isn't appropriate as fact. because that's not what I was trying to say when I said things like "don't do that". My explanation of what I did mean is quoted above. I was using imperative verbs to give advice, not stating facts. There are very few facts in this world and last time I looked I didn't have to say "IMO" whenever giving an opinion just in case it was mistaken for a fact. Maybe I should add that to my defences? I don't know why it's OK to say "leave the bastard" but not OK to say "don't ask that".

The way I do things, by not asking personal questions, means that I can't ask someone a question that can hurt them. By never asking any personal questions, there's no risk of misjudging whether a question is OK or not.

The replies to me on this thread have illuminated starkly why my policy of never saying anything not work-related is correct for me. I've been accused of being manipulative, mad, and of having "enjoyed being the victim" (perhaps that poster would like to "enjoy" my autism and my rape history and my toxic colleague?) all because I don't know how to express people-related stuff well.

Edited

You clearly tried to state your opinions as facts. And tried to tell people what is definitively OK what's not.

If you find it easier to navigate the world like that, that's OK. But it's not how everyone else has to act.

I also think given your offensive post about all managers being 'morons' deeply offensive. I would assume, given you think that's appropriate to write. The incidents you have spoken about have been far more offensive than you care to acknowledge.

And I am ND. But it would be entirely inappropriate for me to say 'all admin staff, everyone one of them is uneducated or useless', because I have come across some admins who weren't great at their job. It would also be entirely inappropriate to use very offensive language and claim I didn't know because I am ND.

Eightfour · 15/02/2024 01:14

@VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia - (perhaps that poster would like to "enjoy" my autism and my rape history and my toxic colleague?) - these things are not unique to you so please do not assume things about me or other posters. They are also not at all relevant to the argument you are making and my issue with it, in that it’s an extraordinary response to your experience and is not relevant or helpful to the vast majority of work communication or the OP.

I am done now because it’s like speaking to a wall.

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 15/02/2024 01:09

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 14/02/2024 22:58

What I said was: "Seriously, don't put a DV victim in a position where she has to choose between lying and disclosure."

When I say on a Relationships thread "LTB", am I saying that it is "unacceptable" for the OP of that thread to stay with their partner, or am I using the imperative form of the verb "leave" to advise the OP to leave their partner?

@Noideawwhatsoccuring I gave thanks because most of your last post demonstrated understanding.

I quibble this: However, that doesn't mean that anything you think isn't appropriate isn't appropriate as fact. because that's not what I was trying to say when I said things like "don't do that". My explanation of what I did mean is quoted above. I was using imperative verbs to give advice, not stating facts. There are very few facts in this world and last time I looked I didn't have to say "IMO" whenever giving an opinion just in case it was mistaken for a fact. Maybe I should add that to my defences? I don't know why it's OK to say "leave the bastard" but not OK to say "don't ask that".

The way I do things, by not asking personal questions, means that I can't ask someone a question that can hurt them. By never asking any personal questions, there's no risk of misjudging whether a question is OK or not.

The replies to me on this thread have illuminated starkly why my policy of never saying anything not work-related is correct for me. I've been accused of being manipulative, mad, and of having "enjoyed being the victim" (perhaps that poster would like to "enjoy" my autism and my rape history and my toxic colleague?) all because I don't know how to express people-related stuff well.

fuchsteufelswild · 15/02/2024 01:00

Zone2NorthLondon · 15/02/2024 00:21

Key is appropriate interpersonal relationships. I work in a role were team is very important, for support,safety and learning. The interpersonal makes things easier and work. As the work it’s intense and scary if you are not sharing and maintaining appropriate interpersonal relationships as a buffer & defence

Yeah, exactly. I'd worry quite a bit over getting on a plane with a cabin crew taking care not step on each other's toes over children, holidays, illnesses lest they want to be told off. It shouldn't be a priority in a cramped space like that in the first place, pun not intended.

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 15/02/2024 00:53

Runnerinthenight · 15/02/2024 00:19

So, why do so many organisations engage in team building, I wonder???!!!

Because management are morons. This is universally the case everywhere.

I was sent to a team-building event where the practical challenge involved latex balloons. One of the participants was allergic to latex. We haven't had another team-building event since then, strangely.

It's a pretty common allergy and you'd have thought that someone would have asked whether anyone attending was latex-allergic first.

Noideawwhatsoccuring · 15/02/2024 00:52

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 15/02/2024 00:35

How do I differentiate "appropriate" from "inappropriate" reliably whilst autistic, other than by being really private and avoiding anything not work-related as I do now?

If you choose to be really private because that's how you best navigate the work place that's entirely your right and choice.

However, that doesn't mean that anything you think isn't appropriate isn't appropriate as fact.

We learn what's appropriate and what's not by experience. It's more difficult for those of who are ND because we, often, can't take one experience and use that to navigate lots of other similar situations.

My teenager is also autistic and struggles with this. It does mean that we tend to be more introverted. However, it doesn't mean that the rest of the world needs to behave in the way we find it best to navigate these situations.

As this thread shows different people feel different ways about things. I hated 'sorry for your loss' but can understand people's intent. So although it annoyed me a complaint would be ridiculous. As would a complaint about people asking for me if I had a nice Christmas because they hadn't heard my mum died just before Christmas. Again, it bothered me but that doesn't mean anyone did anything wrong. If you said 'sorry for your loss' and it bothered me, its OK for me to be bothered by it and still OK for you to have said it.

And other people will have different opinions. If we worked together and you said 'sorry for your loss' and I cried to HR, the correct response would be for them to be understanding of it upsetting me. But not raising it with you because you didn't do anything wrong.

Swipe left for the next trending thread