Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have been told off by HR for this?

588 replies

Mhassy · 14/02/2024 16:17

I asked a member of the HR team if they had children, in the context of discussing a flexible working request. This was in the small talk/intro part of the conversation, it wasn’t said to make a point or anything, or to bolster my request for flexible working. It was literally a polite back and forth before the actual meeting began, she asked how things were going with DD, I mentioned some new teething and it was all very chatty and I just asked - I thought politely! - if she had children. She told me she didn’t and the time had passed for her to now. We then moved onto the meeting itself.

Anyway, a day later I have a called from someone high up in HR to say I shouldn’t ask people if they have children and this is not an appropriate question in the workplace.

I do get that pregnancy etc can be a sensitive topic. I lost a baby a few years ago and it was and incredibly painful time at work and I felt triggered by any small talk about babies. However I would never have made an issue and I didn’t make an issue when the topic was raised.

AIBU to think this is a step too far to be policing this sort of conversation? I am recently a single parent and wouldn’t launch into being offended if I was asked if I had a partner? Where does it end? I was only making conversation!

OP posts:
StarlightLime · 15/02/2024 15:01

Naheeda03 · 15/02/2024 14:56

You didn't mean anything bad but it was an inappropriate question to ask especially someone in HR! I know you were just being chatty and I am like that but sometimes asking personal questions is considered a breach of the equality act and this was a sore topic for the person you asked, clearly. Learn from it and just don't get into such personal small talk in your job next time unless you are friends with a colleague. Don't beat yourself up over it lovely. That person made a massive issue and didn't need to she could have told you it isn't appropriate to ask directly that day rather than grass you up lol.

A breach of the equality act? Don't talk nonsense.

Naheeda03 · 15/02/2024 14:56

You didn't mean anything bad but it was an inappropriate question to ask especially someone in HR! I know you were just being chatty and I am like that but sometimes asking personal questions is considered a breach of the equality act and this was a sore topic for the person you asked, clearly. Learn from it and just don't get into such personal small talk in your job next time unless you are friends with a colleague. Don't beat yourself up over it lovely. That person made a massive issue and didn't need to she could have told you it isn't appropriate to ask directly that day rather than grass you up lol.

GenevièveSapha · 15/02/2024 14:33

Some people huh... 🤷🏼‍♀️

Peeps need to chillax a tad...

Hadalifeonce · 15/02/2024 14:28

If she was the first person to bring up the subject of children, I don't think she has a leg to stand on.

Jennaxoxox · 15/02/2024 14:27

Some people are ridiculously sensitive. I wouldn't pay too much attention. Seems like she's one of those people who would have found fault without reason. That was not an inappropriate question, especially in the context of that meeting. I don't think you should dwell on this. You were prob only "told off" to keep the peace. Also if your flexible working request is denied file a grievance and appeal the decision!

Idontusuallypostonherebut · 15/02/2024 13:47

I agree that it can be a touchy subject but I don't think you're being unreasonable. I didn't read all the comments so don't know if it's already been answered. But as a mum I've found myself chatting with all sort of people when they see children and they ask about them/how old they are/developmental milestones that sort of thing, because even if they don't have kids themselves they probably know of someone who complains about sleepless nights and all that. Some people say they didn't have children, and the conversation moves on. Maybe the HR person was triggered by someone asking, but I am sure she can see that you didn't ask maliciously

Noideawwhatsoccuring · 15/02/2024 13:46

Anony199 · 15/02/2024 13:34

I don't think it should be brought up. Talk about your own children, absolutely. If the other person has children they will let you know. If they don't mention them presume they have not. I'm in this exact position. I do not have children but want to in the near future. I happen to work within education and people ask this politely in most interactions with new people. From my side it feels as though I'm being undermined because I don't have children. Although it's asked with the best of intentions. It singles me out and when I'm conversation with professionals older than me the impression is that I am too young to understand. I'm 31 and many of my friends have children. I am not unqualified or too young because I am childless but it makes me feel very uncomfortable.

Edited

And many women don’t want to feel singled out in he work place for having kids. Or maybe it’s not going well, or the child is ill.

The op was told this was not appropriate for a work place conversation. The other person brought her child up. Op could as easily claim that wasn’t a workplace conversation.

It was not relevant to the subject they were meeting about. Don’t ask people about a subject if you don’t want them to ask you similar questions.

If we are going to police work place conversations so heavily, then the person who asked about Ops child was inappropriate and their question led to the whole situation.

Anony199 · 15/02/2024 13:34

I don't think it should be brought up. Talk about your own children, absolutely. If the other person has children they will let you know. If they don't mention them presume they have not. I'm in this exact position. I do not have children but want to in the near future. I happen to work within education and people ask this politely in most interactions with new people. From my side it feels as though I'm being undermined because I don't have children. Although it's asked with the best of intentions. It singles me out and when I'm conversation with professionals older than me the impression is that I am too young to understand. I'm 31 and many of my friends have children. I am not unqualified or too young because I am childless but it makes me feel very uncomfortable.

Eightfour · 15/02/2024 13:21

My stance would be completely different if OP followed up with why not, but she didn’t.

Katherina198819 · 15/02/2024 13:17

Gosh. I would never even consider that a question like this would be inappropriate. It's not like you randomly walked to a person and asked if they have children. You were discussing yours and potential future pregnancies.
She shouldn't work in HR if this topic is too sensitive to her.

74Violette · 15/02/2024 13:14

Wow some of the comments on this post are a real eye-opener. I didn't realise there was so many prickly people. I'm grateful that I work in a friendly, relaxed team, we can talk about anything and everything with each other and nobody gets offended or hypersensitive. If I worked somewhere else I'd maybe have a shock.
I don't think you did anything wrong at all OP.

Dinkydo12 · 15/02/2024 13:13

Woke society going overboard again! Where will it end! I would guess they asked you what your childcare arrangements were.

FETFirstTimer · 15/02/2024 13:10

Ann444 · 15/02/2024 13:08

Someone's got their nose outa joint and it's not you. Not your problem her ship has sailed. Yes, this wokey woke thing us too much.

Your empathy is outstanding 👏🏼

Ann444 · 15/02/2024 13:08

Someone's got their nose outa joint and it's not you. Not your problem her ship has sailed. Yes, this wokey woke thing us too much.

Ethylred · 15/02/2024 12:44

The other person raised the subject and you replied in a completely ordinary way. If my employer behaved like this I'd start looking for another job.

Noideawwhatsoccuring · 15/02/2024 12:41

wombat15 · 15/02/2024 10:46

Who knows what HR have to ask in order to process a flexible working request. It would depend on the company policy in deciding what was and wasn't reasonable surely?

No. HR should never ask if someone has children to process a flexible working request.

It’s entirely irrelevant to the process. And could open the company and the HR team to accusations of discrimination.

Noideawwhatsoccuring · 15/02/2024 12:40

thesurrealist · 15/02/2024 11:21

Flexible working requests should be taken into account based on the business’ needs. How OP’s daughter is doing is irrelevant to the company and OP’s request. So HR woman didn’t need to ask, she chose to ask. She chose to start a conversation about children and then ran to HR about it.

Generally people say why they want the flexible working, so if the OP said it was because of childcare, then it is polite to ask after said child. I doubt very much whether the HR person really cares or wanted to start a conversation about kids.

There was no reason why the OP then had to ask her if she had kids. It wasn't relevant to the conversation which was about the OPs flexible workign request presumably due to childcare.

She didn't run to HR about it. She is HR. We don't know what conversation happened after the meeting. We also don't know whether the OP asked just in conversation or whether there was the "if you have children you will understand but if you don't you won't" theme that women like us have to endure constantly.

And the language in some of the posts about childless women even on this thread demonstrate the bullshit and insults that we have to hear every day.

No. Your reason for wanting flexible working is not part of the request. It should never be considered as part of it.

It’s also polite, when someone brings up a subject and asks questions, to reciprocate and ask similar questions.

If you don’t want to discuss a subject, don’t start the conversation related to the subject.

furryfrontbottom · 15/02/2024 12:22

Movinghouseatlast · 14/02/2024 18:31

When people ask if you have children they are actually expecting you to say "yes" in my experience. Everyone always looks aghast/ embarrassed when I say no. What they REALLY mean is "how many children do you have and how old are they?". They are not expecting a woman to say she does not have children because it's not the norm.

I've taken to saying "no, I'm barren".

I find the response 'no, dodged that bullet, thank God' is a very effective way of shutting the conversation down.

Melonmango70 · 15/02/2024 12:20

This is so tricky. I don't have children for whatever reason (ie, a reason I don't want to go into) but it is such a sensitive subject in this world we now live in where everyone is talking about themselves, their family life on social media etc. The person may have been upset, but you didn't do anything wrong. It's very difficult (in my experience) to be a person who doesn't have children (and not just women, my husband has felt the same on many occasions) because it's a natural ice-breaker "Have you got kids?" "Oh yeah, we're going to that with the kids too" etc etc. And we don't always want to explain ourselves (and does anyone care?!), particularly if it's because of an unseen condition that isn't infertility. You didn't do anything wrong, but it's easy to be over-sensitive in this world we live in now, where everything is so scrutinised. It's a natural ice-breaker, but it is hard for some people. I have found myself trying to justify myself as I'm a woman of X age, but without children. It's hard. I am neither "child-less" (fertility isn't my issue), nor "child-free" (it isn't down to personal choice"). It's hard. But you definitely didn't do anything wrong :) xx

StarlightLime · 15/02/2024 12:15

KimberleyClark · 15/02/2024 10:49

I think it’s bit odd to ask how someone’s evening went unless they happened to mention they were going to see a film or show or something. “Good weekend?” On a Monday morning is not quite the same.

How is it different? 😵‍💫

Abeona · 15/02/2024 12:08

I think you've hit on something really relevant, @LightsCameraBloodyDoSomething I was talking only the other day to a friend whose two DDs in their 20s are steadily climbing the career ladder, which has taken her by surprise because neither of them was a stellar student. I reminded her that they were both great with people and able to talk to anyone — which frankly isn't that common among a lot of young people.

I had a cousin's daughter come to stay over the weekend and having any kind of a conversation with her was painful. She'd asked to stay (and travelled for three hours to get here) but once here hardly raised her eyes from her phone. She's not thriving at work and I can guess why.

TotalAbsenceOfImperialRaiment · 15/02/2024 12:05

Unless it's information you actually need to have, I wouldn't ask in the course of a work conversation. If the other party wants you to know she has children, she will usually volunteer the information.

LightsCameraBloodyDoSomething · 15/02/2024 11:57

Quite genuinely, I wonder whether part of the mass-offence-taking that seems to be on the increase stems from fewer children and adults being taught how to hold a polite conversation.

Less talking round a dinner table, less expectation to make polite conversation with your parents friends, less experience in showing an interest in people with whom you have nothing in common etc.

And because there is no sense of these things, there is a sense that every question is really truly Directed At Them and no sense of ritualistic social norms around conversational turn-taking or standard form polite deflections.

The irony is, of course, that we had a perfect solution for this already, which was, "how do you do?" with the correct response being, "how do you do?" with no expectation of actually answering the question! Bring that back!

CheeseNPickle3 · 15/02/2024 11:49

Some of the other examples of "what not to ask in case you upset someone" seem a bit concerning to me.

People at work together might not be friends or family but they're still part of a community. Purposely not asking if someone had a good Christmas because they might be suffering in a violent relationship might mean they're not upset at work but it does nothing to help get them out of that situation. Is that really the better outcome? Presumably if they didn't need help to get out of the relationship then they already would have done. Even just being a friendly ear might encourage them to get help - but hey - congratulations on using exactly the right form of words that won't potentially get you into trouble!

LightsCameraBloodyDoSomething · 15/02/2024 11:49

Abeona · 15/02/2024 11:45

@LightsCameraBloodyDoSomething I swear that I hadn't read your post before I wrote mine. Good to know I'm not the only one thinking these thoughts.

Great minds!