Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have been told off by HR for this?

588 replies

Mhassy · 14/02/2024 16:17

I asked a member of the HR team if they had children, in the context of discussing a flexible working request. This was in the small talk/intro part of the conversation, it wasn’t said to make a point or anything, or to bolster my request for flexible working. It was literally a polite back and forth before the actual meeting began, she asked how things were going with DD, I mentioned some new teething and it was all very chatty and I just asked - I thought politely! - if she had children. She told me she didn’t and the time had passed for her to now. We then moved onto the meeting itself.

Anyway, a day later I have a called from someone high up in HR to say I shouldn’t ask people if they have children and this is not an appropriate question in the workplace.

I do get that pregnancy etc can be a sensitive topic. I lost a baby a few years ago and it was and incredibly painful time at work and I felt triggered by any small talk about babies. However I would never have made an issue and I didn’t make an issue when the topic was raised.

AIBU to think this is a step too far to be policing this sort of conversation? I am recently a single parent and wouldn’t launch into being offended if I was asked if I had a partner? Where does it end? I was only making conversation!

OP posts:
Runnerinthenight · 15/02/2024 16:47

Whatafustercluck · Today 16:40

Gonnagetgoingreturnsagain · Today 10:24

Yep learned this the hard way. HR are never ever your friend. And they stick together and back each other up. Can get you fired if they so wish.
Show quote history
Just to say to any HR professionals on here, this was not my experience where I worked last. Of course the HR Director is there to protect the organisation and not the individual, but the HR team I worked with were ultra professional, really lovely, supportive people. They helped me through the worst time in my life/ career to date.

I am always a bit taken aback at the warped attitudes expressed here towards HR. We're all just human beings doing what can be a very difficult job! Now there are individuals in my team who aren't my cup of tea for various reasons but I can honestly say that all of us without exception try to do our very best for the employees we are dealing with.

I don't understand either how people don't see that in protecting the organisation, employees are also protected from mistreatment? It's not rocket science.

Gonnagetgoingreturnsagain · 15/02/2024 16:43

Whatafustercluck · 15/02/2024 16:40

Just to say to any HR professionals on here, this was not my experience where I worked last. Of course the HR Director is there to protect the organisation and not the individual, but the HR team I worked with were ultra professional, really lovely, supportive people. They helped me through the worst time in my life/ career to date. Mind you, they were the best HR team I've ever worked with.

Edited

You were lucky then. Some HR are good some bad. In one organisation they quite literally told me after being supportive that they could get me fired...

Whatafustercluck · 15/02/2024 16:40

Gonnagetgoingreturnsagain · 15/02/2024 10:24

Yep learned this the hard way. HR are never ever your friend. And they stick together and back each other up. Can get you fired if they so wish.

Just to say to any HR professionals on here, this was not my experience where I worked last. Of course the HR Director is there to protect the organisation and not the individual, but the HR team I worked with were ultra professional, really lovely, supportive people. They helped me through the worst time in my life/ career to date. Mind you, they were the best HR team I've ever worked with.

Whatafustercluck · 15/02/2024 16:29

At this point, I think it would be easier to list the things you can quite safely talk about with work colleagues:

  • Work.

That's it. But how sad is that?! We spend most of our lives at work, and social conversation is therefore incredibly important.

In my old workplace it was only through conversing about our families that one of the HR managers and myself realised we were both dealing with some really tough issues as a result of our dc's neurodivergence. She by far had it worse (her son was non verbal and becoming more and more violent by the day), but far from finding it triggering, it helped her as much as it helped me to talk about it.

How is anyone supposed to form good working relationships with colleagues with so many conversations now apparently being off-limits?! This was an innocuous exchange ahead of a meeting. Had op gone on to question why HR lady didn't have children, that would of course be very different.

ClementineChoc · 15/02/2024 16:13

In this context no YANBU as she started the convo off by asking about your dc.
I would have thought she was asking as she had children herself.
She sounds a touch sensitive, at least you know you can't trust her.

Runnerinthenight · 15/02/2024 16:08

Eightfour · Today 16:05

@Naheeda03 - A barrister eh?… I assume a barrister wouldn’t be stupid enough to use their actual name as a username given how you are speaking to Runner. I can’t imagine that would reflect well on you professionally.

I think there's more likelihood that my cat is a barrister, to be fair...

Runnerinthenight · 15/02/2024 16:05

I'm not the one whose rude posts are being deleted.

Eightfour · 15/02/2024 16:05

@Naheeda03 - A barrister eh?… I assume a barrister wouldn’t be stupid enough to use their actual name as a username given how you are speaking to Runner. I can’t imagine that would reflect well on you professionally.

Naheeda03 · 15/02/2024 16:03

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Runnerinthenight · 15/02/2024 16:00

This reply has been deleted

We've removed this as it quotes a deleted post.

Runnerinthenight · 15/02/2024 15:59

Gonnagetgoingreturnsagain · Today 10:24

Divebar2021 · Today 10:13

No this is a lesson that no one in HR is your friend.
Show quote history
Yep learned this the hard way. HR are never ever your friend. And they stick together and back each other up. Can get you fired if they so wish.

This is actually hilarious. How I wish I had the power!! I'd be lining them up... 😂

Naheeda03 · 15/02/2024 15:58

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Naheeda03 · 15/02/2024 15:56

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

blacksunhat · 15/02/2024 15:56

To those who think this is inappropriate, which topics do you consider both safe and actually able to sustain a conversation of 5 minutes or so where that is what's needed? (or at the very least get it off the ground without risk of fizzling out and creating a lost opportunity for a good first impression by establishing rapport). Last night's TV, as someone suggested, seems like a minefield - what about all the people who've watched something about sexual violence or true crime? And surely the weather has no legs at all unless there's just been an unusually high drama storm? Saying it's a lovely day today and someone replying with yes, such a nice change from the awful weather we've been having lately isn't a conversation. It's just one comment followed by another which is generally the way any chat about the weather fizzles out before it's begun, again running the risk of broken rapport which can't always be re-established. Many people sadly do use their first impression of someone to set the entire tone of their relationship.

chiwwy · 15/02/2024 15:37

Noideawwhatsoccuring · 15/02/2024 15:27

In which case, the person asking ops children was a breech. You would know this.

The person asked about ops child when it was entirely irrelevant to the conversation. The reason for a flexible working request is irrelevant, asking about the child could be viewed as trying to get information out of op to form part of their decision which is entirely wrong and makes the company vulnerable.

Their questions made the Ops question relevant so not a breech.

Then given a senior HR manager broached this is an entirely unprofessional way there’s a case for bullying/ constructive dismissal.

If the Senior Hr manager believed the equalities act had been breached, they entirely fucked it up by how they handled it.

If the company, stupidly, claimed a breech of the equalities act, given they failed to follow process, a tribunal would find in Ops favour. As you know a massive focus of tribunals is wether the process was followed and wether the process is fit for purpose.

Well said.

Runnerinthenight · 15/02/2024 15:32

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · Today 00:26

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · Today 00:14

The estimated prevalence of uncaught rapists is around 6% of men. See Lisak and Miller.
Show quote history
@Runnerinthenight Rape Crisis estimate that around one quarter of women are the victim of an an attempted or completed rape at some point during their lives. One girl in four has been sexually assaulted by age 16. Victims of sexual violence are not the tiny minority that you think they are and for that reason alone rape "jokes" shouldn't be allowed at work.

WTAF ever said they should be?

I have no idea how you have managed to conflate rape with one woman asking another if she had a child. It's quite the reach!

Runnerinthenight · 15/02/2024 15:27

Naheeda03 · Today 15:03

Really? I'm an employment barrister and senior hr adviser so love I know my stuff lol 😆

Perhaps then love you could cite some relevant case law?

Noideawwhatsoccuring · 15/02/2024 15:27

Naheeda03 · 15/02/2024 15:04

Really? I'm an employment barrister and senior hr adviser of 14 years, so love I know my stuff lol 😆

Edited

In which case, the person asking ops children was a breech. You would know this.

The person asked about ops child when it was entirely irrelevant to the conversation. The reason for a flexible working request is irrelevant, asking about the child could be viewed as trying to get information out of op to form part of their decision which is entirely wrong and makes the company vulnerable.

Their questions made the Ops question relevant so not a breech.

Then given a senior HR manager broached this is an entirely unprofessional way there’s a case for bullying/ constructive dismissal.

If the Senior Hr manager believed the equalities act had been breached, they entirely fucked it up by how they handled it.

If the company, stupidly, claimed a breech of the equalities act, given they failed to follow process, a tribunal would find in Ops favour. As you know a massive focus of tribunals is wether the process was followed and wether the process is fit for purpose.

Runnerinthenight · 15/02/2024 15:25

IHaveNeverLivedintheCastle · Today 09:47

Eightfour · Today 00:25

I must remember tomorrow not to ask my colleagues how their evenings were, how half term is going, how one colleague is coping with an issue they confided in me with. Must remember they are all out to get me and I should only talk about work. Given we work on individual projects that will be a fun future of silence for me. I am sure my mental health will love it.
I'm glad I don't work with you. "How my evening went" is none of your business. My private, out of work life is none of your business.

And I am glad I don't work with you. That's as weird AF. I don't know how you can work with someone without some personal interaction. I've only ever worked with one person as buttoned up as this, and it wasn't a pleasant experience for any of her colleagues. Plus she fell out with everyone, and stopped speaking to them. Juvenile!

StarlightLime · 15/02/2024 15:20

Naheeda03 · 15/02/2024 15:03

Really? I'm an employment barrister and senior hr adviser so love I know my stuff lol 😆

And you still claim two colleagues having a conversation in the workplace could somehow contravene the equality act? Bollocks.

shearwater2 · 15/02/2024 15:17

If it was a breach of the Equality Act then perhaps the stupid HR person shouldn't have asked OP if she had kids either.

Make a counter complaint against her if it's not an appropriate conversation for work.

I wouldn't normally be petty but someone like that deserves it. It's a bit fucking rich when she started the conversation. I would be so angry.

Eightfour · 15/02/2024 15:13

@Naheeda03 - I am interested to know how the OP asking an HR representative if they have children would be a breach of the equalities act?

Apollo365 · 15/02/2024 15:07

As they started the conversation I think you could turn this around. You were there to talk about a flexible working request, not about your children. Why did she bring your child into it?
Also sounds like you were being set up tbh.

Naheeda03 · 15/02/2024 15:04

StarlightLime · 15/02/2024 15:01

A breach of the equality act? Don't talk nonsense.

Really? I'm an employment barrister and senior hr adviser of 14 years, so love I know my stuff lol 😆

Naheeda03 · 15/02/2024 15:03

Really? I'm an employment barrister and senior hr adviser so love I know my stuff lol 😆

Swipe left for the next trending thread