Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have been told off by HR for this?

588 replies

Mhassy · 14/02/2024 16:17

I asked a member of the HR team if they had children, in the context of discussing a flexible working request. This was in the small talk/intro part of the conversation, it wasn’t said to make a point or anything, or to bolster my request for flexible working. It was literally a polite back and forth before the actual meeting began, she asked how things were going with DD, I mentioned some new teething and it was all very chatty and I just asked - I thought politely! - if she had children. She told me she didn’t and the time had passed for her to now. We then moved onto the meeting itself.

Anyway, a day later I have a called from someone high up in HR to say I shouldn’t ask people if they have children and this is not an appropriate question in the workplace.

I do get that pregnancy etc can be a sensitive topic. I lost a baby a few years ago and it was and incredibly painful time at work and I felt triggered by any small talk about babies. However I would never have made an issue and I didn’t make an issue when the topic was raised.

AIBU to think this is a step too far to be policing this sort of conversation? I am recently a single parent and wouldn’t launch into being offended if I was asked if I had a partner? Where does it end? I was only making conversation!

OP posts:
MarkWithaC · 16/02/2024 08:41

OTT – and does this 'high up' HR person really have nothing better to do than ring you up about it?!

The other woman actively volunteered sensitive info by saying 'the time had passed' for her to have children. She could have just said 'No, I don't' and then moved things on to the subject meeting.

RandomUsernameHere · 16/02/2024 08:37

YANBU I don't think you were being inappropriate at all. Anything could be a "sore point" for anyone really. It seems no one can have a conversation anymore without running the risk of offending someone.

Noideawwhatsoccuring · 16/02/2024 08:37

Herdinggoats · 16/02/2024 08:25

Personally I think given the context of your conversation- flexible working because of childcare I would find your question inappropriate. I would read it as a clumsy attempt at rapport building and a bit of a way to find an “in” with the person leading the conversation -rather than genuine interest.

Are you really interested in whether a woman you have been in a room with for 2minutes has kids or were you trying to find common ground?

Childcare is irrelevant when talking about a flexible working request.

The reason for any flexible working request is entirely irrelevant. Ops child was irrelevant. By making it relevant, the person could the company vulnerable to claims of discrimination.

Flexible working request shouldn’t take into account the reason for the request to ensure fairness.

Do you think the woman asking was genuinely interested in the child of a woman she was in a room with for 2 minutes. Or just making chit chat?

Shefliesonherownwings · 16/02/2024 08:32

I personally wouldn’t ask someone if they have children or how many children they have because having lost a child these are not always the innocent questions they seem to be because you just don’t know what’s going on or gone on in peoples lives. However I also know that not everyone realises this and obviously you didn’t know this was a trigger for the other person. Presumably you explained you didn’t know and didn’t mean any harm and I’d leave it there. Maybe be a bit more mindful in the future.

Herdinggoats · 16/02/2024 08:25

Personally I think given the context of your conversation- flexible working because of childcare I would find your question inappropriate. I would read it as a clumsy attempt at rapport building and a bit of a way to find an “in” with the person leading the conversation -rather than genuine interest.

Are you really interested in whether a woman you have been in a room with for 2minutes has kids or were you trying to find common ground?

HoneyButterPopcorn · 16/02/2024 08:20

People just need to grow up and use common sense as to what is and what isn’t appropriate. Running off to HR with hurty feelings?

General chit chat in the office kitchen waiting for your soup to come out of the microwave:

Family/leisure - fine
Any holidays planned? - fine
nice weekend - fine
do you know any decent hairdressers/dry cleaners/cake shops hear here? - fine

probing personal questions (I hear your mum died… what was it? Car crash? Overdose? Cancer?) - not fine
’Have you/do you think Jenny on accounts has had a boob job?’ - not fine
Sex life - not fine
Politics and football - best avoided (as we say in Glasgow)

I you don’t want to talk to your colleagues about anything other than work, well that may look a bit unfriendly (but they might all be jerks or a’holes), but why not (we go to work to pay the bills after all).

Noideawwhatsoccuring · 16/02/2024 08:11

Hididi11 · 16/02/2024 07:00

Agree. Absolutely sick of people asking this question. And it's always those that have children that ask and say oh you don't have much time left.
It's not a question that should be asked.
Far too personal and nosy
You never know what the other person is going through
Also
I am sick of parents thinking they are entitled to time off during the holidays but childless folk should not be.
I am someone's child too and like to visit my mum during the holidays and my niece's and nephews.

Then remember not ask about parents personal lives, especially during a work meeting (as this was labelled) when it’s not relevant. You never know what another person is going through.

Not all of us want to discuss our kids. Not all of us want that to be part of a working meeting.

Don’t start a conversation about a subject if you don’t want reciprocal questions, about that subject, asked.

If you don’t ask about people’s children, during work meetings when it’s irrelevant, than you are talking about a completely different situation.

Hididi11 · 16/02/2024 07:00

Agree. Absolutely sick of people asking this question. And it's always those that have children that ask and say oh you don't have much time left.
It's not a question that should be asked.
Far too personal and nosy
You never know what the other person is going through
Also
I am sick of parents thinking they are entitled to time off during the holidays but childless folk should not be.
I am someone's child too and like to visit my mum during the holidays and my niece's and nephews.

Abeona · 15/02/2024 23:41

Naheeda03 · 15/02/2024 15:03

Really? I'm an employment barrister and senior hr adviser so love I know my stuff lol 😆

Come off it. So what protected characteristic of the Equality Act might the OP have broken? How, merely by asking the question 'And do you have children?' in response to enquiries about her own child, did she discriminate against or persistently harass the woman questioning her?

If you're an employment barrister then I'm a custard cream.

Runnerinthenight · 15/02/2024 20:37

Noideawwhatsoccuring · Today 20:23

@StarlightLime 😂😂😂

@HoneyButterPopcorn brawling like drunken barristers apparently 😂

Don't forget the HR advisers too!! 😂

Noideawwhatsoccuring · 15/02/2024 20:23

@StarlightLime 😂😂😂

@HoneyButterPopcorn brawling like drunken barristers apparently 😂

Runnerinthenight · 15/02/2024 20:23

HoneyButterPopcorn · Today 20:15

I turn my back for a few hours and you lot start brawling like drunken sailors on shore leave…

Only the one lol! The rest of us were well-behaved! 😄

HoneyButterPopcorn · 15/02/2024 20:15

I turn my back for a few hours and you lot start brawling like drunken sailors on shore leave…

StarlightLime · 15/02/2024 19:51

Noideawwhatsoccuring · 15/02/2024 19:44

That’s funny.

if anyone has paid for their crappy legal and Hr advice, they should be asking for their money back 😂

Well, it was worth exactly what we paid for it 😂

Noideawwhatsoccuring · 15/02/2024 19:44

Runnerinthenight · 15/02/2024 18:34

Noideawwhatsoccuring · Today 18:12

I am a bit gutted I didn’t see the pretend barristers response to me (and others) before being deleted.

Turned very aggressive and nasty because I asked them to reference case law 😂flinging out insults like Smarties!! Most un-barrister-like!

That’s funny.

if anyone has paid for their crappy legal and Hr advice, they should be asking for their money back 😂

Runnerinthenight · 15/02/2024 18:34

Noideawwhatsoccuring · Today 18:12

I am a bit gutted I didn’t see the pretend barristers response to me (and others) before being deleted.

Turned very aggressive and nasty because I asked them to reference case law 😂flinging out insults like Smarties!! Most un-barrister-like!

Noideawwhatsoccuring · 15/02/2024 18:12

I am a bit gutted I didn’t see the pretend barristers response to me (and others) before being deleted.

I am going to they just reinforced the fact that barrister and HR advisor were jobs she was very bad at.

wevegotthepower · 15/02/2024 17:35

FirstFallopians · 14/02/2024 16:35

Very OTT. Yes it can be a sensitive subject for some, but it sounds like you asked during a conversation where it was in context, and you didn’t follow up with nosey questions.

They're basically saying no-one should ask any questions about anyone’s personal life under any circumstances lest it cause upset.

Well exactly

Once you start where is the line?

Maybe ask for guidance to refer to, to help you understand the rules of what is and isn't allowed

HollyKnight · 15/02/2024 17:33

Convictions are rare, sure, but SA and rapes are not rare at all. Whatever the statistic is, try doubling it. There are many, many more SA and rapes happening that no one knows about or even recognised by the victims as assault. Just look at MN and the countless threads by women saying what their partners do to them and they don't even realise it is assault/rape.

IHaveNeverLivedintheCastle · 15/02/2024 17:11

Runnerinthenight · 15/02/2024 17:05

@IHaveNeverLivedintheCastle your figures suggest that 75% of the population have not experienced rape, and when I was at school, that was considered to be quite a large proportion. And you talk about "ignorance"???!

Anyway I am not going to respond to your comments any more. You are derailing the thread completely. It's irrelevant.

Are you seriously saying 25 % of women and girls experiencing rape and sexual assault is "rare"? D

Do you know how many millions of people that is? Do you know how often it happens on a daily basis?

You posted a nonsense comment about rape being "rare". You had no idea what you were talking about.

IHaveNeverLivedintheCastle · 15/02/2024 17:07

Runnerinthenight · 15/02/2024 15:32

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · Today 00:26

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · Today 00:14

The estimated prevalence of uncaught rapists is around 6% of men. See Lisak and Miller.
Show quote history
@Runnerinthenight Rape Crisis estimate that around one quarter of women are the victim of an an attempted or completed rape at some point during their lives. One girl in four has been sexually assaulted by age 16. Victims of sexual violence are not the tiny minority that you think they are and for that reason alone rape "jokes" shouldn't be allowed at work.

WTAF ever said they should be?

I have no idea how you have managed to conflate rape with one woman asking another if she had a child. It's quite the reach!

Nobody conflated the 2.

You were the one who started talking about rape being "rare".

Runnerinthenight · 15/02/2024 17:05

@IHaveNeverLivedintheCastle your figures suggest that 75% of the population have not experienced rape, and when I was at school, that was considered to be quite a large proportion. And you talk about "ignorance"???!

Anyway I am not going to respond to your comments any more. You are derailing the thread completely. It's irrelevant.

IHaveNeverLivedintheCastle · 15/02/2024 17:01

Runnerinthenight · 14/02/2024 23:56

@IHaveNeverLivedintheCastle That comment about the vast majority of us don't know someone who has been raped is one of the daftest comments I've seen on here.

The vast majority of us have no idea about the experiences of victims of rape and sexual assault, victims of both sexes, because so many victims don't ever talk about it.

So far as conversations about rape and rape alarms in a workplace, absent, police, social services, and the like, where it's part of the work, I can't really see any need to discuss it.

Well if that is one of the "daftest comments" then you have clearly led a very sheltered life!! How fucking rude!

I don't 'knowingly' know anyone who has been raped, thankfully. Rape victims are a minority in the population, and I hope all of them get the support they deserve, although I doubt it.

In all my life, I have ever only known one convicted rapist. I went to school with him - he was older than me. He was convicted of raping his step-daughters.

I have no doubt it's a horrendous experience but please don't insult our intelligence by suggesting it's the norm, or it's common! It's not!

I have never, ever had such a conversation in the workplace, and would shut it down if I heard it.

I have no doubt it's a horrendous experience but please don't insult our intelligence by suggesting it's the norm, or it's common! It's not!

I don't need to insult your intelligence. Your own posts amply show your ignorance about the statistics on rape and sexual assault. 1 in 4 women and girls.

Stats on sexual assault

Rape, sexual assault and child sexual abuse statistics

Want to know how many people are raped, sexually abused or sexually assaulted? We have key statistics from trusted sources showing the scale of the problem.

https://rapecrisis.org.uk/get-informed/statistics-sexual-violence/

Runnerinthenight · 15/02/2024 16:50

Gonnagetgoingreturnsagain · Today 16:43

Whatafustercluck · Today 16:40

Just to say to any HR professionals on here, this was not my experience where I worked last. Of course the HR Director is there to protect the organisation and not the individual, but the HR team I worked with were ultra professional, really lovely, supportive people. They helped me through the worst time in my life/ career to date. Mind you, they were the best HR team I've ever worked with. Edited
Show quote history
You were lucky then. Some HR are good some bad. In one organisation they quite literally told me after being supportive that they could get me fired...

I guess that's more likely in the private sector? I'm public sector and there are so many hoops to jump through under the disciplinary procedure, there's no way that any one individual HR manager could get anyone sacked.

See plenty of managers trying it on though... take a dislike to someone and then try to throw the kitchen sink at them! It's our job then to make sure that doesn't happen, both in fairness to the employee, and to protect the interests of the organisation.

VeryHungrySeaCucumber · 15/02/2024 16:48

By the same token why is she asking about your personal life then??

This. Grounds for a counter complaint. I'd be doing nothing other than looking for a new workplace I think.