Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have been told off by HR for this?

588 replies

Mhassy · 14/02/2024 16:17

I asked a member of the HR team if they had children, in the context of discussing a flexible working request. This was in the small talk/intro part of the conversation, it wasn’t said to make a point or anything, or to bolster my request for flexible working. It was literally a polite back and forth before the actual meeting began, she asked how things were going with DD, I mentioned some new teething and it was all very chatty and I just asked - I thought politely! - if she had children. She told me she didn’t and the time had passed for her to now. We then moved onto the meeting itself.

Anyway, a day later I have a called from someone high up in HR to say I shouldn’t ask people if they have children and this is not an appropriate question in the workplace.

I do get that pregnancy etc can be a sensitive topic. I lost a baby a few years ago and it was and incredibly painful time at work and I felt triggered by any small talk about babies. However I would never have made an issue and I didn’t make an issue when the topic was raised.

AIBU to think this is a step too far to be policing this sort of conversation? I am recently a single parent and wouldn’t launch into being offended if I was asked if I had a partner? Where does it end? I was only making conversation!

OP posts:
Abeona · 16/02/2024 11:58

I wonder whether the HR woman got back to her office, realised that bringing up the subject of children in formal meeting to discuss a flexible working request might open the door to a claim of discrimination under the Maternity PC and decided to deter the OP with an admonitory shot across the bow?

StarlightLime · 16/02/2024 11:55

Abeona · 16/02/2024 11:46

Why do you think your pain at your infertility is somehow worse than the pain felt by a family being bankrupted? You're working on the basis that your pain is worse and more justified than anyone else's? What would someone else have to be going though to out-pain your pain?

This.

StarlightLime · 16/02/2024 11:55

IHaveNeverLivedintheCastle · 16/02/2024 11:26

But none of those examples are the same as what happened here.

Wittering on about how lovely your (general your) life and family are is just wittering on. Some colleagues might find it interesting, some might be bored by it, some colleagues might compare their own situation and be unhappy.

But it's another step entirely to then start asking questions about your colleagues lives and families. If they want to join in, they will but if they don't, it's not up to you (general you) to start asking them.

Op's colleague did just that 😵‍💫

Noideawwhatsoccuring · 16/02/2024 11:53

Aprilx · 16/02/2024 11:43

That is not what this thread is about. Everybody (me included) encounters general chit chat that might remind themselves of their own less fortunate circumstances.

I still do not expect to go into a formal work place meeting and have the other person, who I may not have even met me before, ask direct questions about my fertility and / or life choices. I am not sure what you are not getting about this.

I don’t expect to go to a workplace meeting and have someone I barely know ask after my children.

Noideawwhatsoccuring · 16/02/2024 11:52

IHaveNeverLivedintheCastle · 16/02/2024 08:45

There's nothing to suggest the HR person was making the OP's children relevant to the request for flexible working. If the OP's child was teething presumably the child is still very new and presumably the OP had been on maternity leave which is knowledge the HR person already had.

I agree that the OP's question was irrelevant and inappropriate.

The person I quoted said ‘flexible working because of childcare’

Theres no such things as a flexible working because of childcare request.

The feedback Op got is that it was inappropriate for a work conversation. In which case asking about a child, in a work place conversation is inappropriate as it has nothing to do with work.

As people have said, there could be many reasons a woman doesn’t want to be asked about her child. She may not be doing well, may be struggling, the child maybe be poorly, the child could have been a twin pregnancy where one was lost and so on.

and if this company is going to be so hard on what’s a workplace conversation bringing up children isn’t a good idea when it has no relevance to the request.

This person started the conversation talking about kids. If it’s inappropriate to ask a woman if she has kids, it’s inappropriate to bring up someone’s children.

Abeona · 16/02/2024 11:46

Aprilx · 16/02/2024 09:42

And your point is flawed. I mean are you seriously comparing not going on holiday to infertility? Or even bankruptcy? Did you really refer to infertility as a mere “sore point”?

Why do you think your pain at your infertility is somehow worse than the pain felt by a family being bankrupted? You're working on the basis that your pain is worse and more justified than anyone else's? What would someone else have to be going though to out-pain your pain?

Aprilx · 16/02/2024 11:43

Abeona · 16/02/2024 11:15

@Aprilx Look back over all the conversations you've had with all the people you've ever worked with. Have you never said anything in passing anything that anyone might have found painful? Never talked about having a lovely day out with your dad on Father's day in front of someone whose dad is dying painfully or who abused and abandoned them? Never gone on about how you've dieted down to a size 8 for a summer wedding/ holiday in front of a colleague who is twice your size and silently feeling suicidal about it? Never grumbled jokily about your husband's minor shortcomings without knowing that the woman you're talking to was widowed only a few months ago and would do anything to have her less-than-perfect husband back? Never said anything that anyone might find racist or anti-semitic or homophobic? Talked about the joys of coupledom and your fantastic sex life in front of people who feel total failures for having neither? Complained about your children's naughty behaviour without knowing that the person you're speaking to has a disabled child who they wish could be as naughty as yours?

I doubt there's a single one of us who hasn't, unknowingly, said or done something that's caused someone else real emotional pain at work. Life is painful. Trying to legislate for this, or enforce it, is ridiculous and futile. I suspect it would be also be very sexist. Women would be expected to be even more ultra-sensitive to everything, and even more anxious, while men would be cut a lot of slack because, well, they're men and we all know men have lower EQ than women, don't we? (That was kinda ironic and also not, IYKWIM. Apologies to all the sensitive men pained by my generalisation).

That is not what this thread is about. Everybody (me included) encounters general chit chat that might remind themselves of their own less fortunate circumstances.

I still do not expect to go into a formal work place meeting and have the other person, who I may not have even met me before, ask direct questions about my fertility and / or life choices. I am not sure what you are not getting about this.

IHaveNeverLivedintheCastle · 16/02/2024 11:37

Blablah1234 · 16/02/2024 10:46

This. If the chit chat is about babies,teething etc anyone with children or who wants to talk about their own children will naturally make a comment in response about their own children at that stage. If they don't mention any experience of their own children, you don't ask them if they have kids and you just assume they're politely talking to you about yours. I thought this was just basic human conversational skills.

Exactly. The HR person will have known OP has recently had a child. Asking about that child, acknowledging the existence of that child is miles different from the OP asking if the HR person has children.

I see we're now getting an invented scenario that HR was making the child a reason for justifying flexible working.

IHaveNeverLivedintheCastle · 16/02/2024 11:26

Abeona · 16/02/2024 11:15

@Aprilx Look back over all the conversations you've had with all the people you've ever worked with. Have you never said anything in passing anything that anyone might have found painful? Never talked about having a lovely day out with your dad on Father's day in front of someone whose dad is dying painfully or who abused and abandoned them? Never gone on about how you've dieted down to a size 8 for a summer wedding/ holiday in front of a colleague who is twice your size and silently feeling suicidal about it? Never grumbled jokily about your husband's minor shortcomings without knowing that the woman you're talking to was widowed only a few months ago and would do anything to have her less-than-perfect husband back? Never said anything that anyone might find racist or anti-semitic or homophobic? Talked about the joys of coupledom and your fantastic sex life in front of people who feel total failures for having neither? Complained about your children's naughty behaviour without knowing that the person you're speaking to has a disabled child who they wish could be as naughty as yours?

I doubt there's a single one of us who hasn't, unknowingly, said or done something that's caused someone else real emotional pain at work. Life is painful. Trying to legislate for this, or enforce it, is ridiculous and futile. I suspect it would be also be very sexist. Women would be expected to be even more ultra-sensitive to everything, and even more anxious, while men would be cut a lot of slack because, well, they're men and we all know men have lower EQ than women, don't we? (That was kinda ironic and also not, IYKWIM. Apologies to all the sensitive men pained by my generalisation).

But none of those examples are the same as what happened here.

Wittering on about how lovely your (general your) life and family are is just wittering on. Some colleagues might find it interesting, some might be bored by it, some colleagues might compare their own situation and be unhappy.

But it's another step entirely to then start asking questions about your colleagues lives and families. If they want to join in, they will but if they don't, it's not up to you (general you) to start asking them.

Abeona · 16/02/2024 11:22

Movinghouseatlast · 16/02/2024 11:04

This is so true. Because there is a reason if someone doesn't have children, it's not just a yes/no answer.

You don't have to explain why you don't have children, do you? 'No' is a complete answer. You have a choice whether to explain or not. If they start prying about why you can say 'Why, does this bother you?' I've done that.

A previous poster suggested a very useful response that I hope I remember:
'No, I dodged that bullet, fortunately.'

Abeona · 16/02/2024 11:15

Aprilx · 16/02/2024 08:54

It is not about “offending”. It can be a sensitive and painful issue for a woman (or man) that has been unable to have children. Surely you can see the difference?

I have had colleagues ask me if I have children and it is usually followed by an awkward pause that I am usually forced to fill with something lighthearted. I tolerate colleagues asking, but I would rather they didn’t / hadn’t. But I do not expect to walk into a formal meeting with a colleague I do not normally work with and be questioned about my fertility or life choices.

Funnily enough I have never ever had to ask any colleague whether they have children, because nobody I have worked with that has children has ever failed to mention them. My point being, there is no need to ask anybody this question.

Edited

@Aprilx Look back over all the conversations you've had with all the people you've ever worked with. Have you never said anything in passing anything that anyone might have found painful? Never talked about having a lovely day out with your dad on Father's day in front of someone whose dad is dying painfully or who abused and abandoned them? Never gone on about how you've dieted down to a size 8 for a summer wedding/ holiday in front of a colleague who is twice your size and silently feeling suicidal about it? Never grumbled jokily about your husband's minor shortcomings without knowing that the woman you're talking to was widowed only a few months ago and would do anything to have her less-than-perfect husband back? Never said anything that anyone might find racist or anti-semitic or homophobic? Talked about the joys of coupledom and your fantastic sex life in front of people who feel total failures for having neither? Complained about your children's naughty behaviour without knowing that the person you're speaking to has a disabled child who they wish could be as naughty as yours?

I doubt there's a single one of us who hasn't, unknowingly, said or done something that's caused someone else real emotional pain at work. Life is painful. Trying to legislate for this, or enforce it, is ridiculous and futile. I suspect it would be also be very sexist. Women would be expected to be even more ultra-sensitive to everything, and even more anxious, while men would be cut a lot of slack because, well, they're men and we all know men have lower EQ than women, don't we? (That was kinda ironic and also not, IYKWIM. Apologies to all the sensitive men pained by my generalisation).

Movinghouseatlast · 16/02/2024 11:04

Overtheatlantic · 16/02/2024 10:50

Because when you say No, I don’t have children, you feel awkward and like you have to explain yourself. It’s tiresome.

This is so true. Because there is a reason if someone doesn't have children, it's not just a yes/no answer.

Overtheatlantic · 16/02/2024 10:50

Because when you say No, I don’t have children, you feel awkward and like you have to explain yourself. It’s tiresome.

Blablah1234 · 16/02/2024 10:46

IHaveNeverLivedintheCastle · 16/02/2024 09:10

It's a bit like that unfunny joke about "how do you know someone is a vegan? Don't worry they'll tell you"

Except it's generally true for parents - unless of course it's a situation where they don't want to mention their children.

Posters are assuming the HR person went off in high dudgeon to her superior to complain about this. It could equally be nothing more than something which came out of feedback about the flexible working request and a question to the superior along the lines of "it's not really appropriate to be asking that question of work colleagues , is it" "no, I'll mention it "

This. If the chit chat is about babies,teething etc anyone with children or who wants to talk about their own children will naturally make a comment in response about their own children at that stage. If they don't mention any experience of their own children, you don't ask them if they have kids and you just assume they're politely talking to you about yours. I thought this was just basic human conversational skills.

LightsCameraBloodyDoSomething · 16/02/2024 10:26

IHaveNeverLivedintheCastle · 16/02/2024 08:45

There's nothing to suggest the HR person was making the OP's children relevant to the request for flexible working. If the OP's child was teething presumably the child is still very new and presumably the OP had been on maternity leave which is knowledge the HR person already had.

I agree that the OP's question was irrelevant and inappropriate.

In which case, the HR person's question was also irrelevant and inappropriate.

If the OP having a child had nothing to do with the flexible working request, it's irrelevant.

If asking questions about people's family life because you may inadvertently step on a sore point is not OK at work, then it was inappropriate. "Do you have children?" And "How's it going with your DD?" both equally run that risk.

You can't have it both ways - either both OP and HR bod were in the wrong or neither were.

At a stretch you could plausibly argue that the OP wasn't wrong but the HR person was, since the HR person was in the position of power in that meeting (considering whether to grant a request of the OP) and potentially giving the impression that an irrelevant and potentially discriminatory reason (children) was relevant when it wasn't - opening the company up to legal challenge.

There is no plausible world in which the OP can be in the wrong but the HR person not.

Personally, I think neither were wrong, but you pays your money, you takes your choice between those three options only.

RandomUsernameHere · 16/02/2024 10:19

@Aprilx where did I mention infertility? Get your facts right before accusing me. I merely make the point that anything has the potential to cause upset. Not ranking things on a scale of how upsetting they are.

Abeona · 16/02/2024 10:16

IHaveNeverLivedintheCastle · 16/02/2024 09:10

It's a bit like that unfunny joke about "how do you know someone is a vegan? Don't worry they'll tell you"

Except it's generally true for parents - unless of course it's a situation where they don't want to mention their children.

Posters are assuming the HR person went off in high dudgeon to her superior to complain about this. It could equally be nothing more than something which came out of feedback about the flexible working request and a question to the superior along the lines of "it's not really appropriate to be asking that question of work colleagues , is it" "no, I'll mention it "

This sounds like self-justifying excuses. Is it in employees' contracts that they mustn't make bog-standard, everyday chitchat with other employees? Are they trained to tiptoe around on eggshells talking only about work and the weather in order to avoid causing offence or hurt? Are the sensitive souls who are easily offended given any training to help them understand that they can't control the things that others say to them, but they can control the way they feel and react? If not, then it's bananas to consider this exchange inappropriate.

No wonder MH issues are sky high and people are fleeing the workplace and work if everyone has to tailor their behaviour to meet the needs of the most sensitive person in the workplace. I'm not suggesting for a moment that rape jokes and sexist remarks or anything unpleasant or openly hurtful is acceptable — but we surely all know there's a middle ground where people can show who they are politely and respectfully to each other (because OP's exchange was polite and respectful) without fear of being shot down? It's a recipe for paranoia.

IHaveNeverLivedintheCastle · 16/02/2024 09:45

RandomUsernameHere · 16/02/2024 09:26

@Aprilx my point is that nearly anything brought up in casual small talk has the potential to be a sensitive topic.
"Got any holiday plans?"
"No, we've just been declared bankrupt and can't afford to keep our home, let alone go on holiday."

I wouldn't ask that either. Partly because I'm not interested tbh and people who have their dream holiday of a lifetime planned will tell you anyway. Others won't want to tell you anything about what they're doing.

I might ask "will you be off in ...as I'm planning to take a couple of weeks then"

KimberleyClark · 16/02/2024 09:45

Aprilx · 16/02/2024 09:42

And your point is flawed. I mean are you seriously comparing not going on holiday to infertility? Or even bankruptcy? Did you really refer to infertility as a mere “sore point”?

Incredible isn’t it.

Aprilx · 16/02/2024 09:42

RandomUsernameHere · 16/02/2024 09:26

@Aprilx my point is that nearly anything brought up in casual small talk has the potential to be a sensitive topic.
"Got any holiday plans?"
"No, we've just been declared bankrupt and can't afford to keep our home, let alone go on holiday."

And your point is flawed. I mean are you seriously comparing not going on holiday to infertility? Or even bankruptcy? Did you really refer to infertility as a mere “sore point”?

KimberleyClark · 16/02/2024 09:34

MarkWithaC · 16/02/2024 08:41

OTT – and does this 'high up' HR person really have nothing better to do than ring you up about it?!

The other woman actively volunteered sensitive info by saying 'the time had passed' for her to have children. She could have just said 'No, I don't' and then moved things on to the subject meeting.

That is a strange, oversharing thing to say in reply to the question “do you have children”. Most people would just say no. Makes me wonder if OP has been entirely candid about the conversation and that the HR person didn’t report her JUST for asking if she had children.

RandomUsernameHere · 16/02/2024 09:26

@Aprilx my point is that nearly anything brought up in casual small talk has the potential to be a sensitive topic.
"Got any holiday plans?"
"No, we've just been declared bankrupt and can't afford to keep our home, let alone go on holiday."

IHaveNeverLivedintheCastle · 16/02/2024 09:10

It's a bit like that unfunny joke about "how do you know someone is a vegan? Don't worry they'll tell you"

Except it's generally true for parents - unless of course it's a situation where they don't want to mention their children.

Posters are assuming the HR person went off in high dudgeon to her superior to complain about this. It could equally be nothing more than something which came out of feedback about the flexible working request and a question to the superior along the lines of "it's not really appropriate to be asking that question of work colleagues , is it" "no, I'll mention it "

Aprilx · 16/02/2024 08:54

RandomUsernameHere · 16/02/2024 08:37

YANBU I don't think you were being inappropriate at all. Anything could be a "sore point" for anyone really. It seems no one can have a conversation anymore without running the risk of offending someone.

It is not about “offending”. It can be a sensitive and painful issue for a woman (or man) that has been unable to have children. Surely you can see the difference?

I have had colleagues ask me if I have children and it is usually followed by an awkward pause that I am usually forced to fill with something lighthearted. I tolerate colleagues asking, but I would rather they didn’t / hadn’t. But I do not expect to walk into a formal meeting with a colleague I do not normally work with and be questioned about my fertility or life choices.

Funnily enough I have never ever had to ask any colleague whether they have children, because nobody I have worked with that has children has ever failed to mention them. My point being, there is no need to ask anybody this question.

IHaveNeverLivedintheCastle · 16/02/2024 08:45

Noideawwhatsoccuring · 16/02/2024 08:37

Childcare is irrelevant when talking about a flexible working request.

The reason for any flexible working request is entirely irrelevant. Ops child was irrelevant. By making it relevant, the person could the company vulnerable to claims of discrimination.

Flexible working request shouldn’t take into account the reason for the request to ensure fairness.

Do you think the woman asking was genuinely interested in the child of a woman she was in a room with for 2 minutes. Or just making chit chat?

There's nothing to suggest the HR person was making the OP's children relevant to the request for flexible working. If the OP's child was teething presumably the child is still very new and presumably the OP had been on maternity leave which is knowledge the HR person already had.

I agree that the OP's question was irrelevant and inappropriate.

Swipe left for the next trending thread