Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have been told off by HR for this?

588 replies

Mhassy · 14/02/2024 16:17

I asked a member of the HR team if they had children, in the context of discussing a flexible working request. This was in the small talk/intro part of the conversation, it wasn’t said to make a point or anything, or to bolster my request for flexible working. It was literally a polite back and forth before the actual meeting began, she asked how things were going with DD, I mentioned some new teething and it was all very chatty and I just asked - I thought politely! - if she had children. She told me she didn’t and the time had passed for her to now. We then moved onto the meeting itself.

Anyway, a day later I have a called from someone high up in HR to say I shouldn’t ask people if they have children and this is not an appropriate question in the workplace.

I do get that pregnancy etc can be a sensitive topic. I lost a baby a few years ago and it was and incredibly painful time at work and I felt triggered by any small talk about babies. However I would never have made an issue and I didn’t make an issue when the topic was raised.

AIBU to think this is a step too far to be policing this sort of conversation? I am recently a single parent and wouldn’t launch into being offended if I was asked if I had a partner? Where does it end? I was only making conversation!

OP posts:
Blablah1234 · 16/02/2024 16:29

StarlightLime · 16/02/2024 15:56

Surely op told her about her dd's teething in response to being asked how her dd was?

Well yes but isn't it obvious when you have a meeting with someone at work who isn't a colleague that they're being polite and you politely answer "fine thanks" not dive into the ins and outs of what's currently going on with your child? Or do you think HR actually was enquiring for the latest news on OPs baby? Again, if people can relate to teething, they'll likely respond in kind and there isn't a need to ask if they have kids.
Edited to add that if OP returns to say HR was quizzing on DD latest milestones then yes that's totally inappropriate! But so far there's nothing that indicates she was.

Blablah1234 · 16/02/2024 16:27

Noideawwhatsoccuring · 16/02/2024 16:03

My original post, that you quoted, included a situation where op may have been the one to bring it up.

But you are missing the point. The woman complained that she was asked a personal question. After asking a personal question. The complainer may have felt they should. The Op also felt she should enquire so she could reciprocate and show interest.

The person who told Op off said it was inappropriate question for a work meeting. The context wasn’t asked or taken into account. In which case asking personal questions of the Op was also inappropriate. Regardless of context. Just like ops question was deemed inappropriate regardless of context.

Op didn’t know this woman took offence at the time. So the woman had no way of knowing if Op took offence.

We don’t know Ops question was inappropriate at all. You just decided it is. The HR woman, asked a personal question. It’s right there. Then complained the Op then asked a personal question.

If personal questions are appropriate in a work setting, it’s inappropriate. If Op had started an inappropriate conversation HR should have diverted it. Not asked a personal question.

Except we didn't actually get the HR persons question in the OP. OP said she asked after DD, giving us no context. If she asked after OP and OP said "oh I'm tired, DD isn't sleeping" asking "aw how is she doing?" Is not compatible to OPs question and is not a personal question, it's courtesy. It's not necessarily inappropriate for OP to talk about her daughter, especially as it sounds like she offers information unsolicited so there isn't a need for HR to divert the conversation. Some people are acting as if HR was quizzing OP on her daughter's private information. This was also a meeting about OP, not about HR person. Once again, OP didn't get disciplined she just got informed in case she isn't aware that it's a sensitive question and beat to avoid at work.

Noideawwhatsoccuring · 16/02/2024 16:03

Blablah1234 · 16/02/2024 14:05

But we don't actually know she asked anything about OPs child other than how she is doing which may have been necessary to be polite if OP had mentioned her first. Whereas asking if she had children wasn't necessary to be polite and quite obviously an inappropriate thing to ask a colleague. Without knowing the whole conversation we can't assume HR was inappropriate whereas we know clearly OP question was, we don't need to make stuff up about HR person. It could have been entirely rude and complaint worthy if OP had mentioned her child and HR told her not to mention her children. OP clearly took no offense in being asked how her DD was doing whereas HR did take offense to being asked if she had children, probably because it's obvious that she haven't given anything in response to indicate that she does which is why OP asked. OP has learnt if they don't say, don't ask. She was disciplined for it, she was simply informed it's not appropriate.

Asking about something someone is happily talking about (as OP clearly was if she was telling her about teething) is obviously not the same as asking someone for info you don't know.

Edited

My original post, that you quoted, included a situation where op may have been the one to bring it up.

But you are missing the point. The woman complained that she was asked a personal question. After asking a personal question. The complainer may have felt they should. The Op also felt she should enquire so she could reciprocate and show interest.

The person who told Op off said it was inappropriate question for a work meeting. The context wasn’t asked or taken into account. In which case asking personal questions of the Op was also inappropriate. Regardless of context. Just like ops question was deemed inappropriate regardless of context.

Op didn’t know this woman took offence at the time. So the woman had no way of knowing if Op took offence.

We don’t know Ops question was inappropriate at all. You just decided it is. The HR woman, asked a personal question. It’s right there. Then complained the Op then asked a personal question.

If personal questions are appropriate in a work setting, it’s inappropriate. If Op had started an inappropriate conversation HR should have diverted it. Not asked a personal question.

StarlightLime · 16/02/2024 15:56

IHaveNeverLivedintheCastle · 16/02/2024 15:52

Asking about something someone is happily talking about (as OP clearly was if she was telling her about teething) is obviously not the same as asking someone for info you don't know.

Yes, it's clearly different. Not sure why some posters are struggling so much. Probably because they've never given a second thought to asking work colleagues intrusive and nosey questions.

Surely op told her about her dd's teething in response to being asked how her dd was?

IHaveNeverLivedintheCastle · 16/02/2024 15:52

Asking about something someone is happily talking about (as OP clearly was if she was telling her about teething) is obviously not the same as asking someone for info you don't know.

Yes, it's clearly different. Not sure why some posters are struggling so much. Probably because they've never given a second thought to asking work colleagues intrusive and nosey questions.

IHaveNeverLivedintheCastle · 16/02/2024 15:50

Abeona · 16/02/2024 12:59

Oh, stop reaching.

I know. One can't help wondering whether @IHaveNeverLivedintheCastle is a secretly panicked HR professional who puts female employees at their ease by asking about their children in the preamble to meetings...

Edited

Such active imaginations, although it's surprising that can't extend to see how inaporopriate the OP's behaviour was.

No. I'm not. I do however find intrusive questions from people I have no connection with other than at work about my family, my holidays and what I do outside of work very irritating.

The OP was out of order asking if the HR person has children. We don't have enough information on the conversation before that to decide if HR was out order.

Blablah1234 · 16/02/2024 14:05

Noideawwhatsoccuring · 16/02/2024 13:55

Yes that’s why I pointed out 2 suggestions depending on wether op brought the child up or the other person did.

Op said the woman asked how things were going with dd. She don’t need to. Part of the telling off op got was because it was a work conversation. Which this person also actively engaged in. During a work conversation it’s not appropriate to discuss ops children.

If someone is going off tangent during a work conversation you don’t need to engage if you don’t want to join in.

Isn’t the point here that some people find somethings intrusive and others don’t?

Or does this other woman get to decide what she finds intrusive and what others should find intrusive?

Again, don’t ask people personal questions if you don’t want them to ask you personal questions.

But we don't actually know she asked anything about OPs child other than how she is doing which may have been necessary to be polite if OP had mentioned her first. Whereas asking if she had children wasn't necessary to be polite and quite obviously an inappropriate thing to ask a colleague. Without knowing the whole conversation we can't assume HR was inappropriate whereas we know clearly OP question was, we don't need to make stuff up about HR person. It could have been entirely rude and complaint worthy if OP had mentioned her child and HR told her not to mention her children. OP clearly took no offense in being asked how her DD was doing whereas HR did take offense to being asked if she had children, probably because it's obvious that she haven't given anything in response to indicate that she does which is why OP asked. OP has learnt if they don't say, don't ask. She was disciplined for it, she was simply informed it's not appropriate.

Asking about something someone is happily talking about (as OP clearly was if she was telling her about teething) is obviously not the same as asking someone for info you don't know.

Abeona · 16/02/2024 13:58

Noideawwhatsoccuring · 16/02/2024 13:55

Yes that’s why I pointed out 2 suggestions depending on wether op brought the child up or the other person did.

Op said the woman asked how things were going with dd. She don’t need to. Part of the telling off op got was because it was a work conversation. Which this person also actively engaged in. During a work conversation it’s not appropriate to discuss ops children.

If someone is going off tangent during a work conversation you don’t need to engage if you don’t want to join in.

Isn’t the point here that some people find somethings intrusive and others don’t?

Or does this other woman get to decide what she finds intrusive and what others should find intrusive?

Again, don’t ask people personal questions if you don’t want them to ask you personal questions.

This. Particularly this bit:

Or does this other woman get to decide what she finds intrusive and what others should find intrusive?

**

Noideawwhatsoccuring · 16/02/2024 13:55

Blablah1234 · 16/02/2024 12:56

It's not been said though that HR mentioned her child though. It could very well be that the OP mentioned her in which case it's entirely not inappropriate for HR to engage in polite conversation as long as she wasn't asking anything intrusive, and nothing in the OP suggests she did.

Yes that’s why I pointed out 2 suggestions depending on wether op brought the child up or the other person did.

Op said the woman asked how things were going with dd. She don’t need to. Part of the telling off op got was because it was a work conversation. Which this person also actively engaged in. During a work conversation it’s not appropriate to discuss ops children.

If someone is going off tangent during a work conversation you don’t need to engage if you don’t want to join in.

Isn’t the point here that some people find somethings intrusive and others don’t?

Or does this other woman get to decide what she finds intrusive and what others should find intrusive?

Again, don’t ask people personal questions if you don’t want them to ask you personal questions.

Abeona · 16/02/2024 12:59

Oh, stop reaching.

I know. One can't help wondering whether @IHaveNeverLivedintheCastle is a secretly panicked HR professional who puts female employees at their ease by asking about their children in the preamble to meetings...

Blablah1234 · 16/02/2024 12:56

Noideawwhatsoccuring · 16/02/2024 12:40

HR know plenty of stuff that they are obliged not to bring up in a work meeting.

Knowing something doesn’t mean it’s ok to bring it up. Especially in a work place conversation. Which the person having a go said. it was a work conversation. And it was inappropriate to ask if this woman had children.

In which case, it was a work place conversation and it was inappropriate to bring up the Ops private life and her child. Or indulge in a conversation about the child (if op brought the child) and she should have nudged the conversation back to work not then ask questions and join in the conversation then moan she didn’t like where it went.

It's not been said though that HR mentioned her child though. It could very well be that the OP mentioned her in which case it's entirely not inappropriate for HR to engage in polite conversation as long as she wasn't asking anything intrusive, and nothing in the OP suggests she did.

Cantgetausername87 · 16/02/2024 12:51

Totally bonkers!
1- why couldn't that HR person manage that conversation at the time?
2- why would it be OK to ask you about your child in a meeting? Was she inferring you were struggling/ couldn't cope or that she should make small talk about your child because you're a mum and that's all you do?

I wouldn't take it further because nothing formal has come of it. I would just be wary of the ridiculous culture in your workplace!

Noideawwhatsoccuring · 16/02/2024 12:42

IHaveNeverLivedintheCastle · 16/02/2024 12:38

You're inventing stuff now. If OP mentioned baby first, it's not inappropriate for HR to acknowledge the existence of this baby.

That's a mile away from asking "do you have children?"

No it’s not. Part of the objection was that this was a work meeting.

People managers and HR should be able to put the conversation back on track if it’s irrelevant.

StarlightLime · 16/02/2024 12:41

IHaveNeverLivedintheCastle · 16/02/2024 12:38

You're inventing stuff now. If OP mentioned baby first, it's not inappropriate for HR to acknowledge the existence of this baby.

That's a mile away from asking "do you have children?"

Oh, stop reaching 😂

Noideawwhatsoccuring · 16/02/2024 12:40

IHaveNeverLivedintheCastle · 16/02/2024 12:21

It's an assumption of course, but assuming the OP had her maternity leave with the current employer amongst the members of staff who legitimately are entitled to know, without asking, whether an employee has a new baby, are the HR team.

There's clearly a difference between HR's position and OP's so far as casual chat.

HR know plenty of stuff that they are obliged not to bring up in a work meeting.

Knowing something doesn’t mean it’s ok to bring it up. Especially in a work place conversation. Which the person having a go said. it was a work conversation. And it was inappropriate to ask if this woman had children.

In which case, it was a work place conversation and it was inappropriate to bring up the Ops private life and her child. Or indulge in a conversation about the child (if op brought the child) and she should have nudged the conversation back to work not then ask questions and join in the conversation then moan she didn’t like where it went.

IHaveNeverLivedintheCastle · 16/02/2024 12:38

Abeona · 16/02/2024 12:35

Surely if it was inappropriate HR would have shut it down immediately?
'Ahem, now back to your application for flexible working?'

You're inventing stuff now. If OP mentioned baby first, it's not inappropriate for HR to acknowledge the existence of this baby.

That's a mile away from asking "do you have children?"

Abeona · 16/02/2024 12:35

IHaveNeverLivedintheCastle · 16/02/2024 12:29

We don't know if it was unprompted. You can't tell from the OP's version of events who mentioned the child first.

Surely if it was inappropriate HR would have shut it down immediately?
'Ahem, now back to your application for flexible working?'

StarlightLime · 16/02/2024 12:34

IHaveNeverLivedintheCastle · 16/02/2024 12:29

We don't know if it was unprompted. You can't tell from the OP's version of events who mentioned the child first.

I'd have thought it was a fairly safe assumption that if someone says "How is little Jenny?", there hadn't been previous mention of little Jenny.
But whatever.

Abeona · 16/02/2024 12:34

There's clearly a difference between HR's position and OP's so far as casual chat.

You're going to have to spell that out. HR making assumptions based on OP's sex and maternity status and initiating a conversation based on OP's Maternity PC? OP encouraged to think by HR she was having a casual chat about children with someone who was interested while HR may have her on a list of people who they'd quite like to manage out? Something else entirely?

IHaveNeverLivedintheCastle · 16/02/2024 12:29

StarlightLime · 16/02/2024 12:25

Sorry, what's the difference?
But it's another step entirely to then start asking questions about your colleagues lives and families. If they want to join in, they will but if they don't, it's not up to you (general you) to start asking them
The colleague asked about op's dd unprompted.

We don't know if it was unprompted. You can't tell from the OP's version of events who mentioned the child first.

StarlightLime · 16/02/2024 12:25

IHaveNeverLivedintheCastle · 16/02/2024 12:21

It's an assumption of course, but assuming the OP had her maternity leave with the current employer amongst the members of staff who legitimately are entitled to know, without asking, whether an employee has a new baby, are the HR team.

There's clearly a difference between HR's position and OP's so far as casual chat.

Sorry, what's the difference?
But it's another step entirely to then start asking questions about your colleagues lives and families. If they want to join in, they will but if they don't, it's not up to you (general you) to start asking them
The colleague asked about op's dd unprompted.

MarkWithaC · 16/02/2024 12:23

Overtheatlantic · 16/02/2024 10:50

Because when you say No, I don’t have children, you feel awkward and like you have to explain yourself. It’s tiresome.

I don't feel the need to explain myself or say anything beyond 'No' and I can't remember anyone ever pressing me to expand.
Maybe I just give off 'back off, nosey' vibes or something Grin

IHaveNeverLivedintheCastle · 16/02/2024 12:21

StarlightLime · 16/02/2024 11:55

Op's colleague did just that 😵‍💫

It's an assumption of course, but assuming the OP had her maternity leave with the current employer amongst the members of staff who legitimately are entitled to know, without asking, whether an employee has a new baby, are the HR team.

There's clearly a difference between HR's position and OP's so far as casual chat.

Blablah1234 · 16/02/2024 12:21

StarlightLime · 16/02/2024 11:55

Op's colleague did just that 😵‍💫

The meeting was about her though, it's expected that if you have a meeting about yourself that you will be asked about yourself as long as it isn't intrusive. It's something else to then ask the other person who the meeting isn't about. The OP hasn't specified that the HR person asked about her DD out of the blue or if OP mentioned her and put of politeness HR asked how she is doing. I doubt she would have brought up OPs daughter if she has no children herself but OP hasn't updated.

Abeona · 16/02/2024 12:18

Noideawwhatsoccuring · 16/02/2024 11:53

I don’t expect to go to a workplace meeting and have someone I barely know ask after my children.

It's sexist as hell, isn't it? Wonder whether the equivalent interview with a man applying for flexible working starts with questions about his children? What do they assume men want flexible working for — or don't they ask, because that would be invasive and potentially discomforting for him? Poor chap. Meanwhile the OP, being a woman and expected to be a super-sensitive mind-reader, gets a telling off.

Swipe left for the next trending thread