Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have been told off by HR for this?

588 replies

Mhassy · 14/02/2024 16:17

I asked a member of the HR team if they had children, in the context of discussing a flexible working request. This was in the small talk/intro part of the conversation, it wasn’t said to make a point or anything, or to bolster my request for flexible working. It was literally a polite back and forth before the actual meeting began, she asked how things were going with DD, I mentioned some new teething and it was all very chatty and I just asked - I thought politely! - if she had children. She told me she didn’t and the time had passed for her to now. We then moved onto the meeting itself.

Anyway, a day later I have a called from someone high up in HR to say I shouldn’t ask people if they have children and this is not an appropriate question in the workplace.

I do get that pregnancy etc can be a sensitive topic. I lost a baby a few years ago and it was and incredibly painful time at work and I felt triggered by any small talk about babies. However I would never have made an issue and I didn’t make an issue when the topic was raised.

AIBU to think this is a step too far to be policing this sort of conversation? I am recently a single parent and wouldn’t launch into being offended if I was asked if I had a partner? Where does it end? I was only making conversation!

OP posts:
CountryShepherd · 17/02/2024 10:12

In our induction, its suggested that we are completely non specific re our domestic set up as use of the word 'husband' is heternormative and oppresses/excludes those who may be unwillingly single or in other types of relationships.

FFS.

Noideawwhatsoccuring · 17/02/2024 10:06

KimberleyClark · 17/02/2024 08:46

I am not sure it’s forward thinking at all, to assume that because a woman doesn’t have kids that it must be a painful situation for them. I have a few friends who don’t have kids and hate the assumption that it’s a sore point for them. It’s a choice they made.

I don’t assume anything about anyone’s reproductive status if I have only just met them. That’s why I don’t ask. I don’t think it’s really any of my business. Neither is it my business if they are single, married, dating or whatever.

By asking if someone has kids you aren’t asking about their reproductive status. the question is do you have kids. You have decided that’s the question. But it’s not.

Thats like saying if someone says ‘are you doing anything for mothers day’ they are actually asking ‘is your mum alive’

The Mother’s Day after my mum died was incredibly painful. More so than the Mother’s Day after my miscarriages. People asking if I had plans for Mother’s Day did illicit and emotional response because the truth was ‘no, my mum dropped dead out of the blue a few weeks ago I just want to pretend it’s not happening’.

However, to suggest people should never bring up Mother’s Day to people, just in case they are grieving or had miscarriage or have a bad relationship with their mother etc would be ridiculous. It’s really easy to say ‘no’ to these questions and leave it there.

If someone has kids do you think the question ‘how are the kids?’ Shouldn’t be asked. What if you ask someone and their kids are really sick. Would it be reasonable to interpret the question as ‘do you produce healthy children?’. That would be a massive and offensive interpretation. The fault wouldn’t be with the person asking.

As for not asking whether people are single or dating or married. If that person was participating in a conversation and asking other people questions about their relationship, they should expect to be asked questions about their own.

And again, they are classed as questions people don’t like to ask because of the social view that unmarried women are less than. The view is that if a woman isn’t married, she wants to be married but isn’t and it’s embarrassing.

KimberleyClark · 17/02/2024 08:46

I am not sure it’s forward thinking at all, to assume that because a woman doesn’t have kids that it must be a painful situation for them. I have a few friends who don’t have kids and hate the assumption that it’s a sore point for them. It’s a choice they made.

I don’t assume anything about anyone’s reproductive status if I have only just met them. That’s why I don’t ask. I don’t think it’s really any of my business. Neither is it my business if they are single, married, dating or whatever.

ChanelNo19EDT · 17/02/2024 08:28

This is su h a nonsense. Imagine if the question "are you married,?" was banned. I have children but when they were small, I was sensitive about being a single mum. People raced to corroborate what they suspected; that I was indeed a single parent. None of them feel they crossed any boundary im sure. Even if they used the information they got from their non-work related question to judge me/categorise me.
But I get it. Everybody is sensitive about something at some point in their life. That's not a reason to shut down all conversation.

Noideawwhatsoccuring · 17/02/2024 08:25

KimberleyClark · 17/02/2024 07:40

It may be a simple question to you, but to a person who had hopes of having a child and never did,for whatever reason, it can be a very painful one. Is that so difficult for you to understand?

By The same token, plenty of people have suffered very painful events related to their kids. And may not want people asking about their kids.

This is the point. Any question could be painful for somebody.

I am not sure it’s forward thinking at all, to assume that because a woman doesn’t have kids that it must be a painful situation for them. I have a few friends who don’t have kids and hate the assumption that it’s a sore point for them. It’s a choice they made.

It’s really not good for women, at all, for society to assume a woman who doesn’t have kids, must have wanted them but couldn’t.

If we are going to avoid any personal questions in case it relates to a painful experience for that person, there’s no conversations at all.

Don’t mention Mother’s Day, because my mother is dead.
Don’t mention Father’s Day as Bobs dad is dead

If you want to apply the rule to this specific subject and apply to only women, who haven’t mentioned children, you end up making it more awkward for the women.

KimberleyClark · 17/02/2024 07:40

Runnerinthenight · 16/02/2024 22:38

Aprilx · Today 11:43

I still do not expect to go into a formal work place meeting and have the other person, who I may not have even met me before, ask direct questions about my fertility and / or life choices. I am not sure what you are not getting about this.

But the OP was not asking about fertility or life choices. She asked a simple question, do you have a child? Answer, no!

It may be a simple question to you, but to a person who had hopes of having a child and never did,for whatever reason, it can be a very painful one. Is that so difficult for you to understand?

Platypuslover · 17/02/2024 01:42

Bat it back with she asked first about your child which is an even more inappropriate question then.

PoppyTries · 17/02/2024 00:39

Runnerinthenight · 14/02/2024 17:25

I think the HR person was a bit precious about running to complain. She should have had the balls and the nous to refute the question. All she needed to say was, "no, I don't" and leave it at that.

The OP doesn't care that time has run out for her. That was irrelevant and unprofessional.

Exactly. It doesn’t sound like OP asked her why she didn’t have kids, so she just volunteered that “it was too late” for her? What a weirdo.

yummumto3girls · 17/02/2024 00:07

I work in HR, clearly the HR manager hasn’t got more important things to worry about! I get it’s a sensitive subject but there was absolutely no intention to cause offence here.

Treesandsheepeverywhere · 16/02/2024 23:40

I know the person said it was "too late for her".... but people always assume childless people cnt have kids, yet it could be for different reasons.

There's a lady who lost all her 4 kids over a couple of years, and many more in similar situations.
Most wouldn't want to talk about it at work or be reminded of it.

It's a sensitive subject all round and better to err on the side of caution.

Empathy goes a long way.

Runnerinthenight · 16/02/2024 22:38

Aprilx · Today 11:43

I still do not expect to go into a formal work place meeting and have the other person, who I may not have even met me before, ask direct questions about my fertility and / or life choices. I am not sure what you are not getting about this.

But the OP was not asking about fertility or life choices. She asked a simple question, do you have a child? Answer, no!

SocksMcR · 16/02/2024 22:33

I'm really sorry.. I voted YABU because I misread the post and thought YOU were the HR person doing the flexitime request, and that it might have been viewed as discriminatory to base your decision on it.

Having removed my head from my backside and read it properly, I don't see that you did anything wrong whatsoever. YANBU. Sorry again for the incorrect vote.

MississippiAF · 16/02/2024 21:28

Insertcreativenamehere · 16/02/2024 20:22

The world has gone mad.

This. I wouldn’t be engaging with her ever again, tbh. Formal work chat only. Ignore her the rest of the time.

greenbeansnspinach · 16/02/2024 21:21

So many people are having problems conceiving these days that I would never ask whether they had them or not. It’s a sore point to be aware of generally.

Diddlyumptious · 16/02/2024 20:23

Everyone is way too precious you can't ask anyone anything without the fear of it upsetting someone or making a complaint. Conversation is dead

Insertcreativenamehere · 16/02/2024 20:22

The world has gone mad.

daliesque · 16/02/2024 19:17

Exactly. The HR person will have known OP has recently had a child. Asking about that child, acknowledging the existence of that child is miles different from the OP asking if the HR person has children.

If she hadn't then we'd have had the OP moaning on MN that she'd had a meeting with HR about flexible working for childcare and the person showed no interest in the child (I'm nit saying the op would do this it's just an example).

I too wonder if the actual conversation was slightly different to what we were told, but then everyone posting on here will do so with themselves in a favourable light.

The bottom line is what many other people have said and that is if you don't know someone has a child/children (and again HR lady knew OP had a child) don't ask. It's that simple. No need to accuse people of running off to complain or being childish.

I see we're now getting an invented scenario that HR was making the child a reason for justifying flexible working.

We all know anyone can apply for flexible working for whatever reason and don't have to give a reason. However, in my experience people do mention in conversation why they want this arrangement, even if it is to watch neighbours every day.

Noideawwhatsoccuring · 16/02/2024 18:52

Blablah1234 · 16/02/2024 16:27

Except we didn't actually get the HR persons question in the OP. OP said she asked after DD, giving us no context. If she asked after OP and OP said "oh I'm tired, DD isn't sleeping" asking "aw how is she doing?" Is not compatible to OPs question and is not a personal question, it's courtesy. It's not necessarily inappropriate for OP to talk about her daughter, especially as it sounds like she offers information unsolicited so there isn't a need for HR to divert the conversation. Some people are acting as if HR was quizzing OP on her daughter's private information. This was also a meeting about OP, not about HR person. Once again, OP didn't get disciplined she just got informed in case she isn't aware that it's a sensitive question and beat to avoid at work.

You are missing the point.

and no one said she was disciplined.

Personal questions aren’t appropriate for a work meeting. That’s what the Op was told.

if that’s the rule then HR should have been fully aware to not engage in personal chit chat. Whether op mentioned her child first or did not. And sound have diverted the conversation.

Again, even if someone else starts the conversation, don’t engage and ask questions if you don’t want people to reciprocate.

LightsCameraBloodyDoSomething · 16/02/2024 18:51

Duchydutch · 16/02/2024 18:27

I was interviewing for a senior position in a large multi-national company and was told by HR I could not ask any interviews about whether they had children.
That was 25 years ago.

Due to equality legislation and the risk of it being perceived as having an effect on whether or not the interviewee was offered the job or not.

In this scenario the power dynamic was that the HR woman was the equivalent of the senior interviewer and the OP the equivalent of the interviewee. Making the HR question more inappropriate than the OP's.

Duchydutch · 16/02/2024 18:27

I was interviewing for a senior position in a large multi-national company and was told by HR I could not ask any interviews about whether they had children.
That was 25 years ago.

LightsCameraBloodyDoSomething · 16/02/2024 18:14

JLou08 · 16/02/2024 18:12

YABU, not so much for asking as that seems to have been innocent but your reaction to it. Your post comes off as you being very defensive. If someone pulls you up on something being inappropriate in the work place just learn from it and move on. You have even acknowledged yourself how hard questions about children can be so there must be part of you that thinks you maybe shouldn't have asked but instead of just admitting that your looking for validation on the Internet.

I think it's the hypocrisy from HR woman that would stick in my craw. Rules for thee but not for me.

JLou08 · 16/02/2024 18:12

YABU, not so much for asking as that seems to have been innocent but your reaction to it. Your post comes off as you being very defensive. If someone pulls you up on something being inappropriate in the work place just learn from it and move on. You have even acknowledged yourself how hard questions about children can be so there must be part of you that thinks you maybe shouldn't have asked but instead of just admitting that your looking for validation on the Internet.

LightsCameraBloodyDoSomething · 16/02/2024 17:44

Blablah1234 · 16/02/2024 14:05

But we don't actually know she asked anything about OPs child other than how she is doing which may have been necessary to be polite if OP had mentioned her first. Whereas asking if she had children wasn't necessary to be polite and quite obviously an inappropriate thing to ask a colleague. Without knowing the whole conversation we can't assume HR was inappropriate whereas we know clearly OP question was, we don't need to make stuff up about HR person. It could have been entirely rude and complaint worthy if OP had mentioned her child and HR told her not to mention her children. OP clearly took no offense in being asked how her DD was doing whereas HR did take offense to being asked if she had children, probably because it's obvious that she haven't given anything in response to indicate that she does which is why OP asked. OP has learnt if they don't say, don't ask. She was disciplined for it, she was simply informed it's not appropriate.

Asking about something someone is happily talking about (as OP clearly was if she was telling her about teething) is obviously not the same as asking someone for info you don't know.

Edited

Don't be ridiculous. The info HR woman didn't know was "how is DD doing?" Thats the nature of a question. It would be extremely weird to only ask questions everyone knows you already know the answer to.

You seem determined not to acknowledge that the HR person was asking a personal question about OP's family. She was.

There is no difference in the nature of the question asked by OP and the question asked by HR except that you personally can easily envisage the latter touching a raw nerve but can't stretch your imagination into someone else's shoes to imagine how the former might touch a far nerve in someone else.

Any question outside of a strict robotic work context runs the risk of accidentally stepping into something because life and people are complex.

The options you have are to ban all non-work talk to ensure no-one is ever accidentally hurt or (and I really commend this to you as a mantra for life) expect adults to make an effort to take things in the spirit they were intended when it is abundantly clear no malice was intended.

You do not have the option to ban only your personal hobby horse questions (while absolving yourself for any questions you personally can't see any danger in for you), and certainly not to ban them in your own mind and then come down on unsuspecting colleagues like a tonne of bricks when they unknowingly transgress.

Such hypocrisy on this thread in places!

Incidentally, for those saying anyone with a child will pipe up about their own without being asked - no, they wouldn't. If you were talking about your children for some time and failed to ask me a reciprocal question I would think you were a bit self-involved and bad-mannered!

StarlightLime · 16/02/2024 16:40

Well yes but isn't it obvious when you have a meeting with someone at work who isn't a colleague that they're being polite and you politely answer "fine thanks" not dive into the ins and outs of what's currently going on with your child?
You're just arguing for the sake of it now 🤷🏻‍♀️
It's either inappropriate to ask personal questions relating to people's families or it isn't.

Now you're placing the blame back on op for not following your the script!

Blablah1234 · 16/02/2024 16:36

IHaveNeverLivedintheCastle · 16/02/2024 15:50

Such active imaginations, although it's surprising that can't extend to see how inaporopriate the OP's behaviour was.

No. I'm not. I do however find intrusive questions from people I have no connection with other than at work about my family, my holidays and what I do outside of work very irritating.

The OP was out of order asking if the HR person has children. We don't have enough information on the conversation before that to decide if HR was out order.

Basically this. I'm not sure why we need to know if HR was being unreasonable also, OP didn't ask that or suggest they were. She asked.if it's unreasonable to ask a colleague if they have kids even though she already had her answer from HR.

Swipe left for the next trending thread