Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have been told off by HR for this?

588 replies

Mhassy · 14/02/2024 16:17

I asked a member of the HR team if they had children, in the context of discussing a flexible working request. This was in the small talk/intro part of the conversation, it wasn’t said to make a point or anything, or to bolster my request for flexible working. It was literally a polite back and forth before the actual meeting began, she asked how things were going with DD, I mentioned some new teething and it was all very chatty and I just asked - I thought politely! - if she had children. She told me she didn’t and the time had passed for her to now. We then moved onto the meeting itself.

Anyway, a day later I have a called from someone high up in HR to say I shouldn’t ask people if they have children and this is not an appropriate question in the workplace.

I do get that pregnancy etc can be a sensitive topic. I lost a baby a few years ago and it was and incredibly painful time at work and I felt triggered by any small talk about babies. However I would never have made an issue and I didn’t make an issue when the topic was raised.

AIBU to think this is a step too far to be policing this sort of conversation? I am recently a single parent and wouldn’t launch into being offended if I was asked if I had a partner? Where does it end? I was only making conversation!

OP posts:
MikeRafone · 14/02/2024 20:13

she asked how things were going with DD

could be construed that you might not be coping with dd, otherwise why would she ask how is it going? It could be a personal triggering question

how far do we take this insulting talk

MoreDollies · 14/02/2024 20:12

MajorCleven · 14/02/2024 20:01

@MoreDollies I think I'm missing the relevance over why it matters, assuming the hr person told her manager truthfully why she was upset the result and my point is the same - it's not reasonable for the manager to go back to to OP and say she was in the wrong.

Ok, I'm just trying to find a rational reason why the senior HR manager might have spoken to OP directly. They have a colleague in their office in tears, because of something another colleague has said, however unintentional. Can they just do nothing? I dunno. Would it have been better if they had spoken to OP's manager to say that OP had upset a colleague can could OP's boss have a word about appropriate conversations in the workplace? That would have been way worse IMHO.

The alternative to finding a rational reason for it, we have HR managers behaving irrationally... Which is an even scarier thought to be honest.

MajorCleven · 14/02/2024 20:12

@StarlightLime thank you, as always with mumsnet I begin to wonder if I'm living in different world

Alwayswonderedwhy · 14/02/2024 20:12

She literally started the conversation about children by asking after your child? Absolutely ridiculous.

StarlightLime · 14/02/2024 20:11

KimberleyClark · 14/02/2024 20:05

If someone asks you about your children but doesn't volunteer anything in return you should be able to tell something from that.

That's ridiculous, frankly.
Op was asked a direct question about her children, but should have waited until her interrogator (as it were) volunteered information rather than asking a question in return?
That's not how normal social interaction works.

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 14/02/2024 20:11

I never ask this question because some people have had to bury one or more of their children. For the same reason, I never ask about spouses and siblings and I never ask what someone's relationship is like with their parents.

It's one of those questions that seems reasonable until you think it through, all the way through, considering all the possible things that can happen to someone's loved ones.

Eightfour · 14/02/2024 20:08

KimberleyClark · 14/02/2024 20:05

If someone asks you about your children but doesn't volunteer anything in return you should be able to tell something from that.

Thats not a conversation that’s an interrogation.

StarlightLime · 14/02/2024 20:07

HoneyButterPopcorn · 14/02/2024 20:01

FFS. A friend has training at work where they were told NOT to ask colleagues if they had anything nice planned for the weekend, or ask if they’d had a nice weekend/holiday/christmas. Just in case someone got upset.

when did people become such babies?

That's actually terrifying in it's complete absurdity. Jesus.

MajorCleven · 14/02/2024 20:07

@KimberleyClark so it's okay to start a conversation about a person's children when you don't know that person, but not okay for that person to ask if you have children?

Pootle40 · 14/02/2024 20:06

HoneyButterPopcorn · 14/02/2024 20:01

FFS. A friend has training at work where they were told NOT to ask colleagues if they had anything nice planned for the weekend, or ask if they’d had a nice weekend/holiday/christmas. Just in case someone got upset.

when did people become such babies?

Totally. I know someone who was told the word 'stakeholders' was discouraged as it could be insulting. Still trying to figure out why.....

KimberleyClark · 14/02/2024 20:05

MajorCleven · 14/02/2024 20:02

But if you ask someone else about their children, what are you expecting the response to be?

If someone asks you about your children but doesn't volunteer anything in return you should be able to tell something from that.

MajorCleven · 14/02/2024 20:02

KimberleyClark · 14/02/2024 20:00

I'm getting fed up of this kind of nonsense in the workplace. By all means deal with overt behaviors such as racism etc., but this was small talk which was completely in the range of normal.

What seems like small talk to you may be triggering and painful to others

Sometimes I think childless women can't win
They get criticized of they don't show enough interest in other people's children, and criticized if they are upset by questions about their own parental status.

But if you ask someone else about their children, what are you expecting the response to be?

Noideawwhatsoccuring · 14/02/2024 20:02

MoreDollies · 14/02/2024 19:54

Not when it comes to applying the law fairly, true, but what we don't have is context. I know I applied for flexible working just before I returned to work having had DD, being asked about my child in that context would be relevant/reasonable IMHO whether it affects their decision or not.

There is no context where bringing up someone’s children is relevant to their Flexible working request. Which is what I said.

In what way was asking about your child, relevant to your flexible working request? The fact that you were coming off maternity leave or had a child is irrelevant to a flexible working request process.

i think asking about a child in chit chat is fine. However, if you don’t want to talk about your personal life, don’t ask people about theirs.

Op could just as easily say ‘well I feel aggrieved she brought up my child. We were there to talk about a flexible working request, my child is irrelevant to a business meeting’.

Dont ask people, irrelevant, personal questions if you are touchy about people asking you, irrelevant, personal questions.

Eightfour · 14/02/2024 20:01

@KimberleyClark - then she shouldn’t be asking other people about their children!

MajorCleven · 14/02/2024 20:01

@MoreDollies I think I'm missing the relevance over why it matters, assuming the hr person told her manager truthfully why she was upset the result and my point is the same - it's not reasonable for the manager to go back to to OP and say she was in the wrong.

HoneyButterPopcorn · 14/02/2024 20:01

FFS. A friend has training at work where they were told NOT to ask colleagues if they had anything nice planned for the weekend, or ask if they’d had a nice weekend/holiday/christmas. Just in case someone got upset.

when did people become such babies?

KimberleyClark · 14/02/2024 20:00

I'm getting fed up of this kind of nonsense in the workplace. By all means deal with overt behaviors such as racism etc., but this was small talk which was completely in the range of normal.

What seems like small talk to you may be triggering and painful to others

Sometimes I think childless women can't win
They get criticized of they don't show enough interest in other people's children, and criticized if they are upset by questions about their own parental status.

MoreDollies · 14/02/2024 19:58

MajorCleven · 14/02/2024 19:51

Ok fair enough. She mentioned it to her manager to the extent that the manager felt she needed to talk sternly to OP. Depends how you define a complaint. But as I've said before either way the senior HR person should not have taken it further ( but it may be more on them than the person that 'complained.')

Again, we don't know she told her manager in a complaint kind of way. And OP won't know that either. The other person might have crumpled once they got back to the office and was asked why they were crying by her boss.

Which was why I raised my experience... Allegedly my boss just happened to go into the HR office to cry (rather than that of the business manager or CEO) rather than specifically crying to HR. Apparently. I don't personally believe that of my boss, but I do believe my HR lady wasn't telling me off.

MoreDollies · 14/02/2024 19:54

Noideawwhatsoccuring · 14/02/2024 19:48

You don’t have to be there.

The reason for your flexible working request holds no weight.

The reason given should not form part of the flexible working request. It’s entirely irrelevant In every flexible working request.

A person with children has no more right to have their flexible working request accepted, than a person who doesn’t have kids.

The decision should always be based on whether the business can accommodate. Not the reason for the request.

Not when it comes to applying the law fairly, true, but what we don't have is context. I know I applied for flexible working just before I returned to work having had DD, being asked about my child in that context would be relevant/reasonable IMHO whether it affects their decision or not.

ChampagneLassie · 14/02/2024 19:54

I remember a friend telling me years ago that upon hearing the HR woman’s Australian accent she asked her where she was from (my friends father was Australiian and she’d spent a lot of time there and she was intending on discussing Oz) and the woman told her you shouldn’t ask people this question as it could be perceived as discriminatory

MajorCleven · 14/02/2024 19:51

MajorCleven · 14/02/2024 19:46

@MoreDollies obviously we can only go by the OP which said the HR person complained and she was responded to sternly. So yeah I'm basing my replies on what the OP Said.

Thank goodness your HR department sounds more reasonable than the OP's though.

Ok fair enough. She mentioned it to her manager to the extent that the manager felt she needed to talk sternly to OP. Depends how you define a complaint. But as I've said before either way the senior HR person should not have taken it further ( but it may be more on them than the person that 'complained.')

Noideawwhatsoccuring · 14/02/2024 19:48

MoreDollies · 14/02/2024 19:45

Sorry, were you there? We haven't been told whether it is or wasn't. You have assumed it's not. In my case it was which is why I assumed it was. Either one of us could be wrong here.

You don’t have to be there.

The reason for your flexible working request holds no weight.

The reason given should not form part of the flexible working request. It’s entirely irrelevant In every flexible working request.

A person with children has no more right to have their flexible working request accepted, than a person who doesn’t have kids.

The decision should always be based on whether the business can accommodate. Not the reason for the request.

MoreDollies · 14/02/2024 19:48

MajorCleven · 14/02/2024 19:46

@MoreDollies obviously we can only go by the OP which said the HR person complained and she was responded to sternly. So yeah I'm basing my replies on what the OP Said.

Thank goodness your HR department sounds more reasonable than the OP's though.

It doesn't say the HR person complained in the OP... Unless that's been clarified since. Or I've misread that completely

Kerfuffleplunk · 14/02/2024 19:47

Have you when you started at the company been provided by HR with a list of topics you are not allowed to talk about?? I personally would be more worried about the mental health of the HR person who needed to flag this as an issue…in my workplace that would be an indication you perhaps weren’t well enough to be at work if you were upset at such a commonplace question .

RosePetals86 · 14/02/2024 19:47

Ridiculous from HR OP- bet they’ll want you doing team building/ being collaborative in the next breathe but no friendly chit chat ay. Must be like walking on egg shells!

Why can’t people take things in context anymore? You know when someone says something in malice and when not.