Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have been told off by HR for this?

588 replies

Mhassy · 14/02/2024 16:17

I asked a member of the HR team if they had children, in the context of discussing a flexible working request. This was in the small talk/intro part of the conversation, it wasn’t said to make a point or anything, or to bolster my request for flexible working. It was literally a polite back and forth before the actual meeting began, she asked how things were going with DD, I mentioned some new teething and it was all very chatty and I just asked - I thought politely! - if she had children. She told me she didn’t and the time had passed for her to now. We then moved onto the meeting itself.

Anyway, a day later I have a called from someone high up in HR to say I shouldn’t ask people if they have children and this is not an appropriate question in the workplace.

I do get that pregnancy etc can be a sensitive topic. I lost a baby a few years ago and it was and incredibly painful time at work and I felt triggered by any small talk about babies. However I would never have made an issue and I didn’t make an issue when the topic was raised.

AIBU to think this is a step too far to be policing this sort of conversation? I am recently a single parent and wouldn’t launch into being offended if I was asked if I had a partner? Where does it end? I was only making conversation!

OP posts:
Sceptical123 · 14/02/2024 23:07

I understand that it was probably a painful subject but she could have simply said “No I don’t” and moved the topic on. If you’d then said “Why is that?” I could understand the complaint.

I think it’s a very slippery slope introducing new policies regarding approved/banner topics of conversation in the workplace.

Surely that should be included in the work contract! How are you supposed to know what is and isn’t ok when it’s discussion of family life and isn’t racist, sexist, homophobic, ablist, political or about religion??! They cannot possibly have a go at you for talking about a subject you had no idea was off limits - in fact they would legally be in the wrong and you could probably build a very strong case if you were the sort to bother to go to a tribunal. It’s very thin ice for them anyway.

Runnerinthenight · 14/02/2024 23:06

MajorCleven · Today 21:21

@VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia it also sounds like you've had a really unfair experience with HR

With line management because HR's function is to advise.

MajorCleven · 14/02/2024 23:05

I'm asking the question did you have a nice Christmas the vast majority of people will not be putting a domestic violence victim in the position of saying what really happened over Christmas. That's my point.

StarlightLime · 14/02/2024 23:05

Eightfour · 14/02/2024 23:04

@HollyKnight - No Vito didn’t just share what works for them. They stated it as though it should be the norm for everyone and it’s bullying to ask someone how they Christmas was?! That poster obviously has a very specific situation which they’ve drip fed and then retrospectively gone back to posts before the drip feeds to make out the posters are targeting their autism and other life events were would need to be psychic to know. Their coping mechanisms are extreme and paranoid for people not In their very specific circumstances and to pretend otherwise is disingenuous as fuck.

Absolutely.

MorrisZapp · 14/02/2024 23:05

I ask people if they have kids because it's rude not to if I've been talking about mine. 'my kid my kid blah blah blah ok see you later' is one sided and poor communication.

If someone answers with no, OF COURSE I don't follow it up with intrusive or personal questions, or mad comments.

Eightfour · 14/02/2024 23:04

@HollyKnight - No Vito didn’t just share what works for them. They stated it as though it should be the norm for everyone and it’s bullying to ask someone how they Christmas was?! That poster obviously has a very specific situation which they’ve drip fed and then retrospectively gone back to posts before the drip feeds to make out the posters are targeting their autism and other life events were would need to be psychic to know. Their coping mechanisms are extreme and paranoid for people not In their very specific circumstances and to pretend otherwise is disingenuous as fuck.

MajorCleven · 14/02/2024 23:03

@VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia that's also assuming the person you are asking is actually a victim of domestic violence which generally will not be the case. Please be fair with what you are quoting.

Runnerinthenight · 14/02/2024 23:02

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · Today 22:13

If the question doesn't matter, and the answer doesn't matter:

  1. Communication is the transfer of information from one person to another. What information is actually conveyed in this interaction? It's not actually communication, is it, it's noise.
  2. Why worsen the office signal-to-noise ratio by asking and expecting an answer?
  3. Let's be honest here: amongst colleagues, this isn't genuine care for someone's wellbeing the way it would be if you were asking a friend. At work, it's virtue-signalling faux concern about someone who you don't care much about. Once you realise this, it becomes obvious that it's about the asker feeling good because "they bothered to ask". I object strongly to this kind of faux concern and find it very patronising. I'm not a supporting actor in the drama of anyone's life and I don't exist so that colleagues can pat themself on the back whilst pretending to care about me.

You are massively, massively overreacting here! It's a social convention, it's good manners!!

When someone comes back from annual leave, it's the done thing to ask if someone had a good break.

If someone comes back from a period of sick leave, you welcome them back and say you hope they are feeling better!

If someone has a bereavement, you acknowledge that on their return (if you haven't already interacted with them at the funeral for instance)

My team manager doesn't do any of this, and the team see it for what it is - fucking bad manners!! It's an acknowledgement, nothing more. But it shows a total lack of consideration not to do it!

Zone2NorthLondon · 14/02/2024 23:01

You were in the wrong. Perhaps inadvertently but nonetheless wrong. Potentially had a detrimental effect on the HR staff

chiwwy · 14/02/2024 23:00

she asked how things were going with DD, I mentioned some new teething and it was all very chatty and I just asked - I thought politely! - if she had children. She told me she didn’t and the time had passed for her to now. We then moved onto the meeting itself.

Anyway, a day later I have a called from someone high up in HR to say I shouldn’t ask people if they have children and this is not an appropriate question in the workplace.

I’d ask to have a meeting with HR and say it’s not appropriate for them to ask how my dd is.

MajorCleven · 14/02/2024 23:00

@VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia hairs are being split. do you think it's wrong, in a work environment, to ask that or not? I don't agree it's wrong.

MajorCleven · 14/02/2024 22:59

So to clarify:

It's not ill- advised (to the point of reporting to HR) to ask someone in a work environment if they had a nice Christmas

ChanelNo19EDT · 14/02/2024 22:58

If it happened as you reported, then I'd have pushed back on that. It was in context. Lots of people have reasons for working from home or working from the office, and you were just asking. I've no husband. Nobody's ever apologised for asking me ''are you married?'' and I just say ''no!'' and that's that. Imagine if I said nobody could ask anybody else if they were married.

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 14/02/2024 22:58

MajorCleven · 14/02/2024 22:29

@HollyKnight I haven't mocked or criticised anyone. I've disagreed with the premise of what they deem to be acceptable on the basis of the original post and in a work environment. They said it was unacceptable to ask if someone had a nice Christmas - I don't accept that is unacceptably in the workplace. Alongside many others.

What I said was: "Seriously, don't put a DV victim in a position where she has to choose between lying and disclosure."

When I say on a Relationships thread "LTB", am I saying that it is "unacceptable" for the OP of that thread to stay with their partner, or am I using the imperative form of the verb "leave" to advise the OP to leave their partner?

MajorCleven · 14/02/2024 22:57

@VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia no you said it was ill-advised but gave a (hypothetical?) emotive example of why. So I should have said ill-advised to be verbatim, I just processed and summarised it as 'unacceptable' because that was the vibe I got from your posts.

MyrtlethePurpleTurtle · 14/02/2024 22:56

Tahinii · 14/02/2024 18:49

Oh come on, it’s not appropriate to ask if someone has children in this setting. You didn’t get a warning or a bollocking, you got told it wasn’t appropriate and it isn’t. I don’t think it’s a big deal, but you clearly do!

I think that's pretty much it

Hocuspocusnonsense · 14/02/2024 22:55

KimberleyClark. I never felt any of the questioning was being asked with malice. I could see it was young women working out their own life choices and asking an ‘older’ woman about her life choices. I left a very long term relationship in my mid 30’s and didn’t have my first child until I was 42 so I did have a few years where I thought I probably wouldn’t have children. I also lost one at 40.

MajorCleven · 14/02/2024 22:51

Runnerinthenight · 14/02/2024 22:47

@Hocuspocusnonsense I wasn't quite grilled as much as that, but when I finally revealed at 5 months' pregnant that I was expecting a baby, a manager I barely knew stopped me in the corridor to ask, "Was it planned?"

I laughed!

Anyone on a senior position has had that, it's outrageous. I was asked in an interview when five months pregnant! (I did get the job.)

Gobimanchurian · 14/02/2024 22:50

It's not offensive to ask if someone has kids. When I had my first child people used to ask constantly if my mum lived close by.

My mum died when I was 9. It hurt being asked. At no point did I think it was an unreasonable question.

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 14/02/2024 22:49

MajorCleven · 14/02/2024 22:29

@HollyKnight I haven't mocked or criticised anyone. I've disagreed with the premise of what they deem to be acceptable on the basis of the original post and in a work environment. They said it was unacceptable to ask if someone had a nice Christmas - I don't accept that is unacceptably in the workplace. Alongside many others.

Did I actually say "unacceptable" or did I say something like "bad idea"?

Please wait whilst I re-read my own posts.

HollyKnight · 14/02/2024 22:49

The HR person did not ask the OP if she has children. The OP volunteered that information herself. One person volunteering personal information about herself does not obligate the other person to reveal personal information in return. And if that information isn't given freely, you do not ask for it.

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 14/02/2024 22:47

HollyKnight · 14/02/2024 22:26

You don't need to assume that. That is just the method @VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia has developed for herself, based on her past experience, to enable her to keep safe while navigating the workplace. And all people have done is mock and criticise her for sharing what works for her because it isn't "normal" from their point of view.

Thank you for understanding that my outlook is a tool to keep me safe.

And thank you for recognising that it's unfair to mock and criticise and brand "extreme and paranoid" an autistic woman who:

  • Is a rape victim who has had to face rape alarm jokes and the alarm being activated at work;
  • Has a current colleague who hates her and sabotaged her work for three years after I encouraged him to apply for the position (he was agency at first);
  • Has had management use rote learned "polite" answers against her to call her a liar and threaten her job because of what I now recognise was sensory overload and shutdown;
  • Has been branded rude more times than I can count for basically existing whilst autistic;
  • Has enough empathy to recognise that some questions are really hurtful for some people and cares enough to want to avoid upsetting someone at work, an environment that they can't just leave because they have to stay until shift end;
  • Has created strict boundaries and rules about my own behaviour (not other people's) to protect myself from falling foul of the hellscape of expectation traps that neurotypical people call "normal workplace social interaction";
  • Tries to explain and share those rules in the hope that they might help the OP who has fallen foul of an expectation trap.

And then people wonder why so few autistic people manage to have jobs...

Runnerinthenight · 14/02/2024 22:47

@Hocuspocusnonsense I wasn't quite grilled as much as that, but when I finally revealed at 5 months' pregnant that I was expecting a baby, a manager I barely knew stopped me in the corridor to ask, "Was it planned?"

I laughed!

KimberleyClark · 14/02/2024 22:46

@Hocuspocusnonsense how would you have felt being asked some of those questions if you’d never managed to conceive/had loads unsuccessful fertility treatment?

Runnerinthenight · 14/02/2024 22:45

That is shite.

You can always go and speak to HR in confidence. They will not divulge what you have told them if you ask them not do.

I've done that loads of times.

Swipe left for the next trending thread