Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Comments from SIL about daughter’s school

192 replies

BellamellaB · 14/02/2024 12:20

My daughter is in year 6 in a private school where they offer part time boarding so once or twice a week she boards (her choice - she loves it).
My dh is close with his brother so we spend quite a lot of time with him and his wife (SIL).
They have a daughter a year younger than our daughter.
Always got on super well with SIL but as our daughters have started getting older I’m feeling some animosity from her. All centred around my daughter’s school.
I could take the odd dig here and there but now my daughter has said about a few remarks that were made to her by SIL and cousin at a sleepover last weekend.
School referred to as ‘snobby school’
by SIL.
Cousin said children only board at school
if their parents don’t want them!
And a couple of other things.

It does feel like it’s escalating.
The cousins are close and I don’t want this to come between them.
Not quite sure how to handle it.

Any experience of this kind of thing?

Thank you for reading :)

OP posts:
EffYouSeeKaye · 14/02/2024 16:58

incognitothismorning · 14/02/2024 16:13

not convinced! maybe she was just being polite- so many of these responses are based on the assumption that everybody will be in agreement that the private school is a better option. In my experience it isn't necessarily a better option and not only that, private schools are often not seen s the better option either. Plenty of people dislike them and dislike the outcomes for children, and plenty of children are less happy and do worse there. Some are fine, many are not, and boarders in particular often are not.

I suspect the comments are because the school is disliked, and the effect on the children who go there is disliked. I dont see why it is likely to be envy or bitterness, rather than dislike.

I do think you should distance yourself and your child a bit more, as your DD is likely to be alienated from state school children and non boarders, and can't see either child is going to benefit from continuing the friendship.

But they are cousins, which is different to a usual friendship. Besides, running away from difficult situations or a difference of opinion is a poor answer to this problem.

I think @Lancia72 gives an excellent perspective here, actually. Be direct with your sil. She is behaving badly here, by making rude comments directly to your young daughter about her school and allowing her child to do the same. You don’t have to defend your choices, just ask that they be respected.

RandomPoster456 · 14/02/2024 16:58

Whether they agree with your DDs school or not (I have RTFT so I know that they do) it’s not their place to have an opinion. I’d go straight in and say that your DD told you that they’ve been making digs about her being semi-board and you don’t appreciate any insinuation that you do not care about your DD as it’s spiteful and cowardly to upset a child like that. There’s absolutely no way that can be misconstrued as a joke, nothing about that is funny in the slightest. I’d also say that you’re surprised because BIL mentioned how funds permitting they’d have sent their DD there, so with that being the case that she can keep her unsolicited, hypocritical opinions to herself. I’d also tell her if she has any welfare concerns she’s perfectly capable of taking them up with you directly. Bitch.

Lancia72 · 14/02/2024 16:46

This is a classic example of what seems to be the problem not being the actual problem.

The big picture is that you don't feel you can be direct with your SIL for fear of her making a scene or sulking etc. This means whether you acknowledge it or not, she's dominating you. You have her psychologically higher up the 'pecking order'.

If she's making you/your daughter uncomfortable you're well within your rights to fire back with whatever (working hard to pay for it, pragmatism re. quality of state schools etc.). Doesn't have to be a shouting match, just a well-matched response.

If she takes offense, she takes offense. Don't walk on eggshells for her. A taste of her own medicine won't kill her.

Poltershighclimb99 · 14/02/2024 16:21

I’d think you could bring it up with SIL in a casual way. Such as ‘I know kids say funny things but dn said something to my dd about her boarding school and how it means your parents don’t want you, Obviously it’s just kids being kids but it upset my dd. I don’t want to upset dn by addressing it with her but I just thought maybe you could check in as obviously as you know that’s not at all accurate. Thanks SIL.

IgglePiggledidawiggle · 14/02/2024 16:21

Just seen some of your other posts. The fact that you have been told regularly they wish their child could go there tells me they will see if you can help out soon enough. And they are hoping you will say yes to show them what it’s really like and that it’s not snobbish/cold or whatever to send the kids to send there.

maudelovesharold · 14/02/2024 16:17

She’s 11 and at boarding schools. Regardless of how much she loves it, it’s not an uncontroversial choice…

The op said she boards 2 or 3 times a week at age 10! How is that any more controversial than sending your 2 yr old (and younger) to nursery or a childminder 8-5 or later five days a week?

IgglePiggledidawiggle · 14/02/2024 16:15

At that point I was pretty direct and said that sorry, that these were not expectations she should ever have.

IgglePiggledidawiggle · 14/02/2024 16:13

Yeah I know that one. Least they haven’t indicated you should pay for theirs to join yours. My MIL indicated that fir a while as apparently family members ie: us that had spare they should use it to provide the same advantages for SILs kids. Oh and that my children had a duty to help their cousins when they were older to ensure they were all equal.

incognitothismorning · 14/02/2024 16:13

BellamellaB · 14/02/2024 16:07

SIL wants to send her daughter there but funds don’t allow unfortunately

not convinced! maybe she was just being polite- so many of these responses are based on the assumption that everybody will be in agreement that the private school is a better option. In my experience it isn't necessarily a better option and not only that, private schools are often not seen s the better option either. Plenty of people dislike them and dislike the outcomes for children, and plenty of children are less happy and do worse there. Some are fine, many are not, and boarders in particular often are not.

I suspect the comments are because the school is disliked, and the effect on the children who go there is disliked. I dont see why it is likely to be envy or bitterness, rather than dislike.

I do think you should distance yourself and your child a bit more, as your DD is likely to be alienated from state school children and non boarders, and can't see either child is going to benefit from continuing the friendship.

BellamellaB · 14/02/2024 16:07

incognitothismorning · 14/02/2024 16:01

Or they may not be sad or bitter or jealous, just have a very low opinion of your DDs school

SIL wants to send her daughter there but funds don’t allow unfortunately

OP posts:
JudgeJ · 14/02/2024 16:06

Coldupnorth7 · 14/02/2024 12:26

This is your DH's problem to deal with. Give your DD some stock phrases and reassure her but get your DH to tackle it with his bro.

Stock phrases like 'my school's better than your scruff joint', that should get up your SIL's nose.

BellamellaB · 14/02/2024 16:06

makeanddo · 14/02/2024 15:58

The problem I had, and maybe you will have, is that I stopped talking about what my children were doing/had done. Everytime I mentioned something it was sneered at or there was a bit of a silence however I noticed everytime this person mentioned something their children had done it was met with enthusiasm etc. Believe me I am not a showy off person, we're talking just general chit chat about what they had been doing.

It will not stop and will almost certainly get worse when they start secondly assuming your DD will be at private school. For me it has caused long term damage and was so unnecessary and hurtful. Your SIL sounds sad and bitter.

Definitely this is happening.
I’m finding myself holding back on saying just normal stuff.
It’s a sad situation.

OP posts:
incognitothismorning · 14/02/2024 16:01

Or they may not be sad or bitter or jealous, just have a very low opinion of your DDs school

makeanddo · 14/02/2024 15:58

The problem I had, and maybe you will have, is that I stopped talking about what my children were doing/had done. Everytime I mentioned something it was sneered at or there was a bit of a silence however I noticed everytime this person mentioned something their children had done it was met with enthusiasm etc. Believe me I am not a showy off person, we're talking just general chit chat about what they had been doing.

It will not stop and will almost certainly get worse when they start secondly assuming your DD will be at private school. For me it has caused long term damage and was so unnecessary and hurtful. Your SIL sounds sad and bitter.

BellamellaB · 14/02/2024 15:44

User19798 · 14/02/2024 15:16

I don't think she is jealous, and I think the constant "she's jealous" from MN when anyone disagrees with private schools etc is childish and absurd. A LOT of people disapprove of private schools. A lot of private schools foster very snobbish attitudes. I work with children at independent schools and some of them do teach children to look down on others. A LOT of people also find boarding weird and confusing. Having worked in the schools I find it very odd personally and it makes me feel very distant to anyone who chooses this (including DB and SIL) because I find their choices so bewildering.

I realise you are happy with your decision and think it is right for your child, but I and many many others cannot wrap their heads around it.

It’s not about her disagreeing with private schools.
My BIL has discussed with DH the fact that SIL wants to send her daughter to my daughter’s school but funds don’t allow unfortunately.

OP posts:
BellamellaB · 14/02/2024 15:34

incognitothismorning · 14/02/2024 15:21

I hope you are right. I have friends who still carry that question mark on their soul 60 years later.

I think boarding may have changed a little
in the last 60 years

OP posts:
incognitothismorning · 14/02/2024 15:21

BellamellaB · 14/02/2024 14:57

She boards one or 2 nights a week. Entirely her choice.
I don’t think there’s any question marks on her soul 😉

I hope you are right. I have friends who still carry that question mark on their soul 60 years later.

User19798 · 14/02/2024 15:16

I don't think she is jealous, and I think the constant "she's jealous" from MN when anyone disagrees with private schools etc is childish and absurd. A LOT of people disapprove of private schools. A lot of private schools foster very snobbish attitudes. I work with children at independent schools and some of them do teach children to look down on others. A LOT of people also find boarding weird and confusing. Having worked in the schools I find it very odd personally and it makes me feel very distant to anyone who chooses this (including DB and SIL) because I find their choices so bewildering.

I realise you are happy with your decision and think it is right for your child, but I and many many others cannot wrap their heads around it.

muggart · 14/02/2024 15:10

Equally, they are comments she will have to deal with in life. She’s 11 and at boarding schools. Regardless of how much she loves it, it’s not an uncontroversial choice…

I agree with this. Your DD will experience these attitudes from other people too, it's life. She will have to get used to it.

muggart · 14/02/2024 15:09

Teentaxidriver · 14/02/2024 15:05

Amused by the pp that she’ll have to learn to deal with such comments “for life”. I went to a household name school. Learnt early to be very discreet about my background. It really doesn’t have to be an issue.

Aren't you proving their point here? The fact that you learnt to be discreet shows you knew from an early age you'd be negatively judged for it. It's only not an issue so long as you hide a huge part of your upbringing.

Safxxx · 14/02/2024 15:07

BellamellaB · 14/02/2024 13:13

I am thinking of having a chat. But I think she will say she’s just joking 🙃
It has got to the point where we never mention anything about the school in case it comes across wrong. Which is a shame.

Have the chat anyway as it's necessary..even if she denies it or puts it down to humour..say it's not funny...it needs to be said, so she knows your not having any of it. If after that she continues to say these things then slowly back away from them...like no sleep overs as they are finding that opportunity to tease her.

Teentaxidriver · 14/02/2024 15:05

Amused by the pp that she’ll have to learn to deal with such comments “for life”. I went to a household name school. Learnt early to be very discreet about my background. It really doesn’t have to be an issue.

DuckbilledSplatterPuff · 14/02/2024 15:02

Iloveacurry · 14/02/2024 13:32

is your DH aware of what SIL and her cousin said to your daughter? He definitely needs to speak to his brother about this. I think if you speak to SIL about it she might play it down or say she’s joking.

This is true, and its probably what I would have done in the past
But I think you might have to wait around for your DH to talk to his DB (and he may not phrase it the way you want him to) and for the DB to talk to the SIL (who knows how he will convey it?)and for the SIL to talk to her DD etc...
it will get lost in the translation and could cause a bigger blow up.

Talk to her in a friendly non-confrontational way, not using emotive/accusatory language etc.. and at least you'll have had your daughters back. If SIL takes offence, well you know where you stand. Even if SIL says she is joking - you have raised the issue with her and told her that the comments are upsetting her daughter. You've put her on notice that you will approach her directly again if there are future occurrences.

A PP mentioned having a chat with your DD to help her find ways of dealing with comments like this and also considering things that might spark comments.

Ggttl · 14/02/2024 15:02

Having a word with her will only make it worse. You just have to rise above it or distance yourself. If her daughter gets better GCSE/ A level grades or ends up earning more than yours, brace yourself for the comments about it. Very few people can resist gloating over that one.

BellamellaB · 14/02/2024 15:01

TimetoPour · 14/02/2024 14:59

Your daughter sounds like a great kid and good for her for calling her out.

First thing, I would reinforce the confidence in your daughter. Tell her aunt and cousin are envious and there is nothing wrong with boarding if she enjoys it. What kid wouldn’t love a weekly sleepover with their friends?

As for the adults, I would get DH to message the brother about catching up soon but could they stay off the subject of school. Your daughter heard some of the things the SIL and cousin say and whilst it may be in jest it hurt her feelings.

That solution sounds perfect!

Thank you 🙏

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread