Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Comments from SIL about daughter’s school

192 replies

BellamellaB · 14/02/2024 12:20

My daughter is in year 6 in a private school where they offer part time boarding so once or twice a week she boards (her choice - she loves it).
My dh is close with his brother so we spend quite a lot of time with him and his wife (SIL).
They have a daughter a year younger than our daughter.
Always got on super well with SIL but as our daughters have started getting older I’m feeling some animosity from her. All centred around my daughter’s school.
I could take the odd dig here and there but now my daughter has said about a few remarks that were made to her by SIL and cousin at a sleepover last weekend.
School referred to as ‘snobby school’
by SIL.
Cousin said children only board at school
if their parents don’t want them!
And a couple of other things.

It does feel like it’s escalating.
The cousins are close and I don’t want this to come between them.
Not quite sure how to handle it.

Any experience of this kind of thing?

Thank you for reading :)

OP posts:
ttcat37 · 14/02/2024 19:09

Lol at all the posters clearly getting boarding school mixed up with a 1980s eastern bloc orphanage

Dibblydoodahdah · 14/02/2024 18:50

incognitothismorning · 14/02/2024 16:13

not convinced! maybe she was just being polite- so many of these responses are based on the assumption that everybody will be in agreement that the private school is a better option. In my experience it isn't necessarily a better option and not only that, private schools are often not seen s the better option either. Plenty of people dislike them and dislike the outcomes for children, and plenty of children are less happy and do worse there. Some are fine, many are not, and boarders in particular often are not.

I suspect the comments are because the school is disliked, and the effect on the children who go there is disliked. I dont see why it is likely to be envy or bitterness, rather than dislike.

I do think you should distance yourself and your child a bit more, as your DD is likely to be alienated from state school children and non boarders, and can't see either child is going to benefit from continuing the friendship.

When I sent my children to a private school a “friend” made scathing remarks about the school. She sent her DC to the local state school….but guess where I bumped into her a few years later…at my DCs private school because she had decided to move hers there. By that time my oldest had moved on to a very very difficult to get into state grammar. She had got wind of that and then proceeded to criticise the grammar (whilst gushing about the private school). Do you see a pattern?!!

The OP’s SIL was definitely coming from a place of bitterness and envy. Even if you have an issue was a particular type of school, you don’t pass on that dislike to your children running the risk that they make offensive comments to a friend or family member who attends that school. You teach your children to be respectful.

BellamellaB · 14/02/2024 18:48

Suchagroovyguy · 14/02/2024 18:41

That poster…. 😂

🤯

OP posts:
WarningOfGails · 14/02/2024 18:47

incognitothismorning · 14/02/2024 18:33

If cousins are educated in these different cultures, there will be wedges driven between them. That is inevitable. They are growing up in different worlds.

I don’t agree it’s inevitable. I was privately educated - as were my siblings - and my cousins weren’t, but it was never an issue or a topic between us.

Suchagroovyguy · 14/02/2024 18:41

BellamellaB · 14/02/2024 15:34

I think boarding may have changed a little
in the last 60 years

That poster…. 😂

StaunchMomma · 14/02/2024 18:35

BellamellaB · 14/02/2024 13:13

I am thinking of having a chat. But I think she will say she’s just joking 🙃
It has got to the point where we never mention anything about the school in case it comes across wrong. Which is a shame.

If she says she was joking you need to tell her her jokes have upset your DD and she needs to rectify that!

You really do need to stand up for your child, here - she's essentially being bullied by an adult.

I do understand where you're coming from, we've had a few 'friends' of both DS and myself become a bit bitchy and hostile since he passed his 11+. People don't like being in a position where they feel inferior, even if THEY are the ones making themselves feel that way.

It's really sad that this woman, who is essentially an Auntie to DD, can't be happy for her that she is at a school she enjoys. It's your job to make that clear to SIL.

incognitothismorning · 14/02/2024 18:33

WarningOfGails · 14/02/2024 18:08

We have the opposite situation! SIL (DH’s sister) is really rude about state schools (her DC are privately educated) - my DC have picked up on it and it’s definitely damaged their relationship. They don’t know what to make of being told their cousins have to go to private school to be kept away from the type of girls you find at state school etc. We used to be really close but this has really put a wedge between us.

If cousins are educated in these different cultures, there will be wedges driven between them. That is inevitable. They are growing up in different worlds.

saraclara · 14/02/2024 18:20

Tell her aunt and cousin are envious

That's terrible advice. Rubbishing them both to the daughter is as bad as what SIL appears to be doing.

WarningOfGails · 14/02/2024 18:08

We have the opposite situation! SIL (DH’s sister) is really rude about state schools (her DC are privately educated) - my DC have picked up on it and it’s definitely damaged their relationship. They don’t know what to make of being told their cousins have to go to private school to be kept away from the type of girls you find at state school etc. We used to be really close but this has really put a wedge between us.

Corgiowner · 14/02/2024 18:05

Newbalancebeam · 14/02/2024 13:45

Interesting that so many put this down to jealousy. Where we live, private schools are ten a penny. Most of them are not Eton standard, rather somewhere where those not able to cope with academic rigour are sent to become ‘well rounded’ individuals. Personally I’d rather mine went to the local grammar than any of these establishments! Private doesn’t always equal better, hence often very little to be jealous of…

My DCs went to “Eton standard” but I agree private or I prefer independent doesn’t necessary mean better for your child even at the top schools. It’s all about fit every school has a box/ethos that they want their pupils to fit into, if your child fits the box/ethos then it’s a good choice and its likely they will thrive be it state or independent.
@User19798 choosing to board your children does bewilder others but that doesn’t necessarily make it a bad choice for the individual family/child. It’s all about what works for the individual child.

AmytheDancingBrick · 14/02/2024 18:03

@incognitothismorning
I’m not sure why you think we are in agreement. I’m not sure I’ve read anything that you’ve written that I agree with.

I don’t believe the SIL has a poor opinion of the school. I don’t believe the OPs daughter will have her soul damaged by choosing to spend a couple of nights boarding with her friends, and I don’t believe the OPs daughter is projecting any concerns.

And I said supervise not distance.

BananaSpanner · 14/02/2024 17:52

BellamellaB · 14/02/2024 15:01

That solution sounds perfect!

Thank you 🙏

I would not give your DC digs to aim at the other child. By all means increase your dc confidence but not at the expense of your niece’s confidence because although she may have said some unpleasant things, she will have been influenced by her mum so time to take the moral high ground.

Just tackle it head on with SIL and leave the kids out of it.

Sammysquiz · 14/02/2024 17:48

Mine are at a fantastic private school and I get similar comments from my sister. Whenever my DC mention their school, even in the most innocuous way, she says ‘oooh must be lovely to be rich’ or similar, in a sarcastic voice. I just let it flow over me now - it’s her chip on her shoulder, not my issue.

MrFlippersPancake · 14/02/2024 17:47

She's jealous, we had similar when our DDs went to grammar rather than the local school, it affected some friendships including with SIL. We just don't talk about it now several years in but things have never been quite the same ifykwim

BellamellaB · 14/02/2024 17:47

DH is going to speak to his bro. I’ve said I’m happy to go straight to her but he wants to sort it with bro.
There will be a couple of weeks with no sleepovers (prearranged stuff going on) so that will be a nice break.
Then we shall see….

OP posts:
SheerLucks · 14/02/2024 17:43

PollyPeep · 14/02/2024 12:24

She's jealous that you can afford private school. This might not change unfortunately.

This.

I would just rise above it and encourage your DD to do the same, and it will hopefully pass.

Mimami · 14/02/2024 17:42

MILTOBE · 14/02/2024 13:21

I think it would be great if schools had somewhere that children could stay overnight if the parents needed that or if the children wanted to be with their friends. I would have been all over that as a child! I could see my children preferring that to having a babysitter and I would've felt safer with that than leaving them on their own when they were older, too.

That exists in some independent schools, it's called flexi-boarding but you would have to pay for the day part of the school too

incognitothismorning · 14/02/2024 17:36

AmytheDancingBrick · 14/02/2024 17:16

You don’t need to be convinced about the SILs motives - it’s irrelevant.

The OP has asked about how to deal with comments directly to her daughter.

OP it sounds like your daughter is happy at her school and enjoying a day or two boarding each week. It a shame that some posters have such poor comprehension and can’t understand that this is her choice.

I would probably stop the sleepovers and supervise more closely when they are together.

well, we are in agreement then, aren't we. I think the sleepovers need to stop and the children distanced. they are no longer compatible

houseydnc · 14/02/2024 17:34

So what's your plan?

Sounds like your DH doesn't care enough to advocate for his daughter. It's something that weighing on her mind, too. Why can't he prioritise her emotionally?

SeulementUneFois · 14/02/2024 17:32

Tell your daughter the fable of the fox and the "sour" grapes.

IsthisthereallifeIsthisjustfantasy · 14/02/2024 17:26

Of course, you could just also go all out megabitch. "I've been meaning to say, I really appreciate these comments you and Emmeline have been making about Clementine's school. It's such a sweet, caring, unique environment that I worry sometimes she won't get enough experience of the sort of mean jokey comments you get at normal schools."

caoixr · 14/02/2024 17:17

OP you are much nicer than me. I would really go to town on how good the school is as I would know it would wind her up. And generally avoid as they have a jealous nature so no good will come out of the relationship.

AmytheDancingBrick · 14/02/2024 17:16

incognitothismorning · 14/02/2024 16:13

not convinced! maybe she was just being polite- so many of these responses are based on the assumption that everybody will be in agreement that the private school is a better option. In my experience it isn't necessarily a better option and not only that, private schools are often not seen s the better option either. Plenty of people dislike them and dislike the outcomes for children, and plenty of children are less happy and do worse there. Some are fine, many are not, and boarders in particular often are not.

I suspect the comments are because the school is disliked, and the effect on the children who go there is disliked. I dont see why it is likely to be envy or bitterness, rather than dislike.

I do think you should distance yourself and your child a bit more, as your DD is likely to be alienated from state school children and non boarders, and can't see either child is going to benefit from continuing the friendship.

You don’t need to be convinced about the SILs motives - it’s irrelevant.

The OP has asked about how to deal with comments directly to her daughter.

OP it sounds like your daughter is happy at her school and enjoying a day or two boarding each week. It a shame that some posters have such poor comprehension and can’t understand that this is her choice.

I would probably stop the sleepovers and supervise more closely when they are together.

BellamellaB · 14/02/2024 17:11

RandomPoster456 · 14/02/2024 17:05

I will never understand posters who take what the OP is saying and embellish and add bits in at will when they have no other information to back up their nonsense statement. If BIL has said they’d have sent their child there if they had the funds, who are you to imagine otherwise based on your own opinion? Regardless, if it’s not your child’s education, it’s not your business and it really is as simple as that. There is absolutely no excuse on earth to bully a child and make them feel like they’re not loved or cared about. Disgusting, inexcusable behaviour. Making rude and nasty comments to children do not indicate polite behaviour to me. In fact, quite the opposite.

Edited

I know! I keep having remind myself this is Mumsnet 😂

And I agree, no need ever to make shitty comments to my child.
It’s pathetic.

OP posts:
RandomPoster456 · 14/02/2024 17:05

incognitothismorning · 14/02/2024 16:13

not convinced! maybe she was just being polite- so many of these responses are based on the assumption that everybody will be in agreement that the private school is a better option. In my experience it isn't necessarily a better option and not only that, private schools are often not seen s the better option either. Plenty of people dislike them and dislike the outcomes for children, and plenty of children are less happy and do worse there. Some are fine, many are not, and boarders in particular often are not.

I suspect the comments are because the school is disliked, and the effect on the children who go there is disliked. I dont see why it is likely to be envy or bitterness, rather than dislike.

I do think you should distance yourself and your child a bit more, as your DD is likely to be alienated from state school children and non boarders, and can't see either child is going to benefit from continuing the friendship.

I will never understand posters who take what the OP is saying and embellish and add bits in at will when they have no other information to back up their nonsense statement. If BIL has said they’d have sent their child there if they had the funds, who are you to imagine otherwise based on your own opinion? Regardless, if it’s not your child’s education, it’s not your business and it really is as simple as that. There is absolutely no excuse on earth to bully a child and make them feel like they’re not loved or cared about. Disgusting, inexcusable behaviour. Making rude and nasty comments to children do not indicate polite behaviour to me. In fact, quite the opposite.