Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

XL Bullies to be destroyed now!

494 replies

Babycatsarenice · 14/02/2024 11:12

Sick of these monsters still being on our streets (I never see them muzzled as their irresponsible owners don't comply) and worse still knowing that they are still in homes with children.

AIBU that they should be put to sleep NOW

OP posts:
Thread gallery
16
Lavenderosemary · 22/02/2024 00:59

YouTube showed me a compilation of owners being interviewed after their pitbulls turned and did serious damage or killed. Dozens of brief 30 second interviews. All terribly shocked owners who's partners or children or relatives had been mauled or killed, or whose neighbours had been attacked. Without exception saying they would never have seen it coming. Their lovely, gentle, family friendly pet had never done anything before, not a sign. It seems like it's a common theme that these dogs really are great pets, wonderful family pets - until some sort of internal switch flips and they become hunter-killers in the blink of an eye. And after the event, revert back into the family pet.

My friend had a saying in her country that fits. "The dangerous dog is the one that sometimes bites. If it never bites, you're safe. If it always bites, you'll know and keep yourself safe. But if it sometimes bites - that's the one that will get you"

oakleaffy · 22/02/2024 00:36

@AUDHDVET

Having an incompetent owner lose control of it must have been alarming.
Hopefully that particular dog now has a strong, well fitting muzzle.

Their pumpkin 🎃 heads aren’t a great shape for muzzles.

Greyhounds locally wear well fitting Baskerville type muzzles when they are fresh off the ship from Eire- these gentle dogs can have a varying prey drive and the rescues keep them muzzled on walks til they have first hand knowledge of what the individual Greys are like.

Edit: Our vets also say XL types are far less likely to give any warning before being aggressive.

Most other dogs show their discomfort or fearfulness and give fair warning in their body language.

AUDHDVET · 21/02/2024 23:07

Honestly, is a difficult and convoluted situation where you can look at it from many angles. Lots of XLs are lovely and have amazing owners. However I had one that was lovely at first then turned on me when I did something it didn’t like, the owner panicked and let it go. Thankfully it just gave me a warning but I must admit I was frightened it was going to kill me. I’m pretty lax about muzzles and get through 99.9% of dog consults without one as I can read body language well and build up with positive reinforcement. This dog gave me no indication it was going to turn.

Vets are not the police and have been told we cannot type a dog. We do not get to decide what is and what is not an XL bully. There are so many lovely bull breed dogs that aren’t XLs that are now muzzled as owners exempted them as they were worried about the ban. Others roam free

HappiestSleeping · 21/02/2024 23:00

Gloriosaford · 21/02/2024 22:51

If bears are so clever why haven't they built zoos, put us all in them and are now running the world for their benefit?

They probably decided that their lives are simpler the way they are. Humans aren't exactly doing s great job of managing the planet, but that's a whole other thread.

Gloriosaford · 21/02/2024 22:51

If bears are so clever why haven't they built zoos, put us all in them and are now running the world for their benefit?

HappiestSleeping · 21/02/2024 19:19

I rest my case.

oakleaffy · 21/02/2024 18:46

whenlifegivesyoulemonssuckonthem · 21/02/2024 18:22

In Yosemite there are many signs explaining why the bins cannot be bear proof.

the general gist is…..

there is not much difference between the intelligence of a smart bear and an average human. And if we make bins bear proof at least half the population will dump their trash as they can’t work the bins!

Bears are very bright...Probably easily brighter than 50% of humans.
Son did a ''year out''working in Whistler, Canada, and saw mother bears showing their cubs how to open the 'bear proof' bins.
Maybe the bins weren't properly fastened , but they are the Canadian equivalent of Foxes here when it comes to bin raiding.
For a large 'pawed' animal, they are surprisingly dextrous.

whenlifegivesyoulemonssuckonthem · 21/02/2024 18:22

In Yosemite there are many signs explaining why the bins cannot be bear proof.

the general gist is…..

there is not much difference between the intelligence of a smart bear and an average human. And if we make bins bear proof at least half the population will dump their trash as they can’t work the bins!

HappiestSleeping · 21/02/2024 13:57

FreeZor · 21/02/2024 12:58

And no, I don't think what that parent did was ok. It was utterly stupid. The problem is that stupidity is incurable therefore we need appropriate laws that protect people from completely avoidable, dangerous things.

You cant legislate for stupidty though. The problem is, whenever you make something idiot proof, someone comes up with a much better idiot.

I don't think additional restrictions for owners will be enough either, despite the fact that many need it. It's the breeders that need more controls.

I think about it like guns. If you prevent access to guns, they can't be used. If you prevent access to potentially aggressive dogs, they can't be owned. There will always be outliers, and cases where something slips through, but those people then advertise themselves more obviously in the same way I would stand out if I walked down the high street carrying an Ouzi 9mm.

FreeZor · 21/02/2024 12:58

And no, I don't think what that parent did was ok. It was utterly stupid. The problem is that stupidity is incurable therefore we need appropriate laws that protect people from completely avoidable, dangerous things.

FreeZor · 21/02/2024 12:52

What is being discussed in the thread is that the current law is insufficient and doesn't strike the right balance between freedoms and protections. There should be much stricter licensing of dogs, which would enable these breeds to be eradicated. The licensing regime should impose sufficient fees on dog owners and breeders that the full cost to society of dog control and ownership is borne by dog owners and the licensing regime can be properly enforced, with stringent conditions placed on dog ownership and any dog whose owner cannot prove compliance confiscated and destroyed and the owner prosecuted.

I don't think there's any legitimate argument for people being allowed to own lions or tigers as pets. Aside from the dangers, they are wild animals and it is cruel.

HappiestSleeping · 21/02/2024 08:31

FreeZor · 21/02/2024 08:08

I notice you don't think that the relative of the child who asked for the XLB to be brought out to a child is unstable in any way? This is a completely avoidable instance.

If the dog is too dangerous to be near a child then it is too dangerous to be kept as a pet in a residential area.

It is legal in the UK (sadly) to keep lions and tigers as pets. They need to be licensed (as do XLBs now).

Can a child be introduced to those too?

As I have said repeatedly, I don't disagree about XLBs, they have become a problem for various reasons, however some accountability needs to be taken by the relatives, parents, etc. Whether you agree that the animal should / should not be kept as a pet, you surely can't then argue that because it is, that it was OK for the parent / relative to put the child potentially in harm's way?

FreeZor · 21/02/2024 08:08

I notice you don't think that the relative of the child who asked for the XLB to be brought out to a child is unstable in any way? This is a completely avoidable instance.

If the dog is too dangerous to be near a child then it is too dangerous to be kept as a pet in a residential area.

iloveeverykindofcat · 21/02/2024 04:52

TinkerTiger · 14/02/2024 13:41

This is like 'guns don't kill, people do'. You can't control people until it's too late unfortunately, so you have to cut the problem off at the source.

FYI I'm not for putting the dogs down, just pointing out that the 'it's an owner issue' argument is pointless.

I hear what you're saying, but are the dogs the source? What is the source? (I don't know, its a rhetorical question). Surely these people will just go on to the next designer "fighting" dog. Most large breeds dog could, theoretically, kill a human.

HappiestSleeping · 21/02/2024 04:08

Gloriosaford · 20/02/2024 23:54

Amy Legemah’s XL Bully, Hugo, bit a child’s leg on Attlee Road in Thamesmead on March 12 last year.
Then just 11 days later Hugo attacked a terrified student after he escaped while on a walk.
Amy's other dog, a Rottweiler named Luna, also joined in with the second attack.
On Tuesday (February 20) Legemah appeared at Woolwich Crown Court where she attempted to convince a judge that Hugo should not be put down because he isn’t dangerous.
But Judge Anya Lewis KC ruled that Hugo does present a risk to the public and should be destroyed.
Legemah cried out “please no, he’s my son” before booting a rubbish bin down the hall as she left the courtroom.
Legemah, 37, had pleaded guilty to two counts of being the owner of a dangerously out of control dog which caused injury.
Outlining the case against her, prosecutor Obi Mgbokwere said the first attack took place after the seven-year-old boy had been petting Luna near Legemah’s home.
When one of the boy’s relatives asked Legemah to bring Hugo out, she brought him out without a collar or leash.
“The boy was running and playing with another child when the XL Bully went to him without warning, grabbed his leg and bit it,” Mr Mgbokwere said.
When the boy began to cry Legemah pulled Hugo away and was very apologetic.
The young boy was taken to hospital for treatment for minor injuries to his leg.
The second incident took place on March 22 when Legemah tripped and dropped both Hugo and Luna’s leads as she left her flat to take them on a walk.
Hugo ran off first, followed by Luna.
An 18-year-old student who was passing the flat said the XL Bully stared at her before launching an attack.
He jumped at her, biting her elbow and right knee, before Luna joined in the attacked and bit the woman’s ankle.
The woman, who was knocked to the ground, said: “The incident made me fear for my life. I was very scared at the time and it has really shaken me up.”

The owner would appear to be unstable, the last person who should be in charge of dangerous dogs!

When one of the boy’s relatives asked Legemah to bring Hugo out,

I notice you don't think that the relative of the child who asked for the XLB to be brought out to a child is unstable in any way? This is a completely avoidable instance.

HappiestSleeping · 21/02/2024 04:04

Winter2020 · 21/02/2024 00:27

Quote "Anyone who is genuinely fearful does not have to just live like that, "

...but they do have to pive like that because as long as the dogs are registered/neutered/wear a muzzle on a walk they are legal. So for a neighbour frightened to use their garden there is no point in reporting to anybody - nobody will be interested in legal but frightening dogs next door.

Then we get back to the whole "responsible owner" debate and around we go again. Any unfortunate instance is far more likely from an owner who isn't following all those rules.

And I'm not saying I agree that they should have to, but there is always the option of a better barrier between them and the garden next door.

oakleaffy · 21/02/2024 01:15

Gloriosaford · 21/02/2024 00:40

Lets not forget 'he's my son' <boots rubbish bin down hall >
One's son would be charged with GBH if he launched a biting attack on a passer by!

Absolutely classic demographic of an XLB owner.

Allows it to hurt others then throws a mega strop in Court.

They aren’t great “ Breed type” ambassadors.

Gloriosaford · 21/02/2024 00:40

Lets not forget 'he's my son' <boots rubbish bin down hall >
One's son would be charged with GBH if he launched a biting attack on a passer by!

FreeZor · 21/02/2024 00:39

And that is extremely likely? And many such incidents? 🤔

Try reading my post again.

🏆 Comprehension fail award for you.

You (perhaps deliberately??) quoted half of my sentence. I said when someone is being attacked by one of these dogs it is extremely likely they will be maimed or killed.

I did not say that any given person is extremely likely to be attacked by a dog.

Winter2020 · 21/02/2024 00:32

...We have to wait for "Luna" to attack someone else before that dog is destroyed ....great. I bet her neighbours are delighted "Luna" who bit a passer by will be coming home. I bet their kids can't play out/use the garden. Why should an aggressive dog take priority over people's right to quiet enjoyment of their garden/street/neighbourhood.

Winter2020 · 21/02/2024 00:27

HappiestSleeping · 20/02/2024 22:47

Personally, I don't disagree that there is a disproportionate volume of attacks by this particular type of dog. One is too many. What I am saying, and I think the others are too, is that banning the breed won't stop this. Doing more to control breeding and sales outlets will.

Also, while there are people who are directly affected, the chances are still disproportionate to the reaction. I am not saying that it is not a very real fear. I would probably be uncomfortable if I had one living next to me. I don't think anybody here is saying that those people should have to live in fear either.

The government have done what they believe to be the right thing, whether we like it or not. Anyone who is genuinely fearful does not have to just live like that, they are able to report to the health and safety executive, the police and the local authority. Then we are at the mercy of how much funding those relevant bodies have to take action. If we want that changed, we should be lobbying for that too.

Quote "Anyone who is genuinely fearful does not have to just live like that, "

...but they do have to pive like that because as long as the dogs are registered/neutered/wear a muzzle on a walk they are legal. So for a neighbour frightened to use their garden there is no point in reporting to anybody - nobody will be interested in legal but frightening dogs next door.

Gloriosaford · 20/02/2024 23:54

Amy Legemah’s XL Bully, Hugo, bit a child’s leg on Attlee Road in Thamesmead on March 12 last year.
Then just 11 days later Hugo attacked a terrified student after he escaped while on a walk.
Amy's other dog, a Rottweiler named Luna, also joined in with the second attack.
On Tuesday (February 20) Legemah appeared at Woolwich Crown Court where she attempted to convince a judge that Hugo should not be put down because he isn’t dangerous.
But Judge Anya Lewis KC ruled that Hugo does present a risk to the public and should be destroyed.
Legemah cried out “please no, he’s my son” before booting a rubbish bin down the hall as she left the courtroom.
Legemah, 37, had pleaded guilty to two counts of being the owner of a dangerously out of control dog which caused injury.
Outlining the case against her, prosecutor Obi Mgbokwere said the first attack took place after the seven-year-old boy had been petting Luna near Legemah’s home.
When one of the boy’s relatives asked Legemah to bring Hugo out, she brought him out without a collar or leash.
“The boy was running and playing with another child when the XL Bully went to him without warning, grabbed his leg and bit it,” Mr Mgbokwere said.
When the boy began to cry Legemah pulled Hugo away and was very apologetic.
The young boy was taken to hospital for treatment for minor injuries to his leg.
The second incident took place on March 22 when Legemah tripped and dropped both Hugo and Luna’s leads as she left her flat to take them on a walk.
Hugo ran off first, followed by Luna.
An 18-year-old student who was passing the flat said the XL Bully stared at her before launching an attack.
He jumped at her, biting her elbow and right knee, before Luna joined in the attacked and bit the woman’s ankle.
The woman, who was knocked to the ground, said: “The incident made me fear for my life. I was very scared at the time and it has really shaken me up.”

The owner would appear to be unstable, the last person who should be in charge of dangerous dogs!

HappiestSleeping · 20/02/2024 22:47

Winter2020 · 20/02/2024 20:53

The "only 30,000" XL Bully dogs in the country so you are unlikely to be attacked by one doesn't hold water when they make up less than 1% of dogs but are responsible for 50% of fatal dog attacks - and although we don't have the statistics recorded as far as I know with that is mind it is reasonable to assume a very disproportionate amount of serious dog attacks also.

So if you want to argue that attacks are rare forget the 30,000 dogs - you need to look at the number of fatal and serious dog attacks and then consider about half of them are inflicted by these types of dogs.

So lets say 5 or 6 human fatalities in the last few years by Bully type dogs.... and you consider that rare... how many life changing attacks on people/visitors/neighbours/children? How many fatalities/ life changing injuries on other dogs and other animals? How many people living in fear going about their daily lives because they do have these dogs in the neighborhood. How many people no longer going for a walk or using the park, how many people that are scared to go in their gardens?

The number of attacks by Bully dogs will not show the number of people that dare not use their garden/ walk their streets/use their park because of these type of dogs being present. People avoiding living normally in order to avoid the dogs will reduce the number of attacks - but why should people not feel safe in their own garden because of their neighbours choice of dog?

Personally, I don't disagree that there is a disproportionate volume of attacks by this particular type of dog. One is too many. What I am saying, and I think the others are too, is that banning the breed won't stop this. Doing more to control breeding and sales outlets will.

Also, while there are people who are directly affected, the chances are still disproportionate to the reaction. I am not saying that it is not a very real fear. I would probably be uncomfortable if I had one living next to me. I don't think anybody here is saying that those people should have to live in fear either.

The government have done what they believe to be the right thing, whether we like it or not. Anyone who is genuinely fearful does not have to just live like that, they are able to report to the health and safety executive, the police and the local authority. Then we are at the mercy of how much funding those relevant bodies have to take action. If we want that changed, we should be lobbying for that too.

TheTimeIsNowMaybeNow · 20/02/2024 21:56

I'm sure it's unlikely that I'll ever be attacked by one but I can't get the 10 year old boy who was playing with his ball outside the front of his house and attacked by 2 who got out their garden when they saw him . We live in a rough area , I've only ever seen one here but I'm not going to say that it doesn't concern me that they are walking home on their own and they may come across one that decides to attack

Swipe left for the next trending thread