Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

XL Bullies to be destroyed now!

494 replies

Babycatsarenice · 14/02/2024 11:12

Sick of these monsters still being on our streets (I never see them muzzled as their irresponsible owners don't comply) and worse still knowing that they are still in homes with children.

AIBU that they should be put to sleep NOW

OP posts:
Thread gallery
16
Anametolove · 14/02/2024 14:07

I would rather be locked in a room with the agressive cavalier king charles of your grandparents than with the two lovely xl bully "girls" of the PP @YuleDragon

Luckyduc · 14/02/2024 14:06

Agree! tho I am completely anti dog and cats, if I had my way this would be a dog dog and cat free country. They just wouldn't exist. No idea why people want these big ugly dogs. They arnt cute.

Loobieloogold · 14/02/2024 14:06

If genuine, you sound hysterical. Or looking to stir feelings for an article.

mbosnz · 14/02/2024 14:06

I don't think it's particularly useful to make gross generalisations about the intellect and capabilities of those who choose to own these dogs. Personally, I know multiple owners of these dogs, and while there are those that live down to the stereoytype, there are others that most certainly do not.

It really doesn't do anything other than entrench peoples' positions, and make it easier for them to dismiss what is being said and not listen to more justifiable concerns and engage in debate, communication, compromise, and compliance.

Fannyfiggs · 14/02/2024 14:06

Mischance · 14/02/2024 13:30

"My girls" .... heaven help us. Sigh.

I thought you were going to tell us something about your daughters.

Why the need to be so rude.

We wouldn't be rude if you posted about your daughters. Some of us love our animals and call them our girls, our boys etc. You don't know someone's situation as to why they may treat their animals like their kids so leave us to it like we leave you to your children.

Fishbones1 · 14/02/2024 14:04

@Iheartmysmart

I met my first XL bully last week. He was muzzled, neutered, being walked on a lead and his owner had exempted him. I made a fuss of the dog and a nice chat with his owner then we both went on our way.

Sorry but you are completely missing the point. You encountered an XL bully for a few seconds with a responsible owner. Great. What about all those dogs that have irresponsible owners and live in bad conditions? The ones that snap and maul children/elderly grandmothers etc? People seem to conveniently forget that XL bullies are bred to be savage - the one you met had a muzzle on and was being walked. But even that dog has the genetic tendency towards violence as it’s part of their DNA.

ImNotReallySpartacus · 14/02/2024 14:02

I agree. There is no need or justification for these monsters existing. If the vets are too wimpy to euthanise them, I would volunteer.

mbosnz · 14/02/2024 14:02

I think they preferred not to find out @Gloriosaford !

Gloriosaford · 14/02/2024 14:01

Anyone who thinks it's a good idea to have one of these as a pet must by definition be lacking in critical thinking skills, not capable of making rational decisions and therefore entirely unsuited to be in charge of a dangerous animal.

mbosnz · 14/02/2024 14:00

Well, if I were to get a dog now, I'd get a golden retriever. Not because I aspire socially, but because they are good family dogs with a good nature, reasonably trainable, and good with people and animals. And I like how they look.

Some people get them because they like them. They like how they look, they like the nature of the individual animal - so said a dog warden who once had two of them. Some get them for protection, because they live in a well dodgy area, and it makes them feel safer. Some get them to look tough and cool. Some get them to breed. Some get them to fight. Obviously a huge spectrum of reasons, raising from benign to worrying as hell and dodgy as all get out.

Guess, on that spectrum of reasons, which are most likely to comply with the legislation, take good care of the animal, and train it well?

Bingoballs · 14/02/2024 13:59

Fannyfiggs · 14/02/2024 12:16

Can someone explain to me why it's the XL Bullies attacking people now?

What happened to the 'devil dogs' of the 90s? Staffordshire bull terrier, bull mastiff, doberman German shepherd, rottweiler, Japanese akita? Have they now retired from mauling?

They have collectively decided to be absolute angels and give another breed the limelight.
They are no longer dangerous and are all angelic little fluff balls.

In reality there has been an increase in deaths relating to xl bullies but the other breeds haven't stopped attacking people but xl bullies is the breed the press want to publicise. Likely cause they have a certain look and posture.

ttcat37 · 14/02/2024 13:57

They’re not monsters. Just like Rottweilers, German shepherds and staffies before them, they are the status symbol dog of shitheads, people who’ve got no clue how to care for a dog let alone be responsible for one. The difference with these is they are so big, muscular and strong, and their jaws are so large and strong, that the damage they can do is much more serious.

It’s never Mr and Mrs Smith from a nice area whose XL bully has attacked someone or Laura who spends hours a day training hers and has plenty of experience with big dogs. It’s some bellend who doesn’t know anything about dogs, let alone powerful ones, doesn’t use a lead because why should he, and lets his kids ride the dogs like a seaside donkey.

Nb to add that obviously there are lots of responsible owners of XL bullies, you’re not all shitheads and bellends.

YuleDragon · 14/02/2024 13:57

it absolutely is an owner issue, alongside a lack of police to enforce it.

Any dog has the potential to be vicious and aggressive. We've always kept King Charles Cavaliers, absolutely soft as shit, bred as lap dogs, glued to you, likely to lick you to death... still wouldn't leave with a child unsupervised.

My grandparents had one and whatever they did, they ended up with a nasty, food aggressive, resource guarding violent animal who only my mom or grandad could handle. He could and would have taken someone given the chance.

The responsible dog owners are the ones who are being punished by this stupid, rushed legislation, they've chipped, neutered, registered, insured and muzzled their dogs, the idiots haven't

Gloriosaford · 14/02/2024 13:57

I've actually been in a situation where the police were contacted by multiple parties concerning an XL bully situation. The police were doing all they could to keep the hell out of it!
Is it that they don't have the resources all skills requiredto deal with dangerous animals do you think@mbosnz

thegreenlight · 14/02/2024 13:54

It’s all very well people saying that they are beloved pets to responsible owners but why are people buying these dogs? Why choose this breed? People choose labradoodles because they are socially aspirational, spaniels because they want to appear more country than town. Unless it is a rescue dog, they have hundreds of breeds to choose from. What are owners trying to say about themselves when they choose these dogs?

Bleakmidwinter1977 · 14/02/2024 13:52

Mischance · 14/02/2024 13:30

"My girls" .... heaven help us. Sigh.

I thought you were going to tell us something about your daughters.

And this is part of the problem. Dogs are not humans, no matter how much some people want them to be regarded as such.
Nothing worse than someone's baby jumping around your children or sniffing your crotch when you are going about your day.
If my children ran up to, in front of, around, strangers, sniffing at them, I'm quite sure a chuckle and an "it's ok, she won't bite, she just wants to play", would not be acceptable.

mbosnz · 14/02/2024 13:50

Absolutely no point in legislating, if you haven't got the resources to enforce it. In fact, in this situation, personally, I think it will just make it worse, making breeding and owning go underground. Possibly we'll see a significant percentage abandoned. I'm sure no one wants abandoned XL bullies wandering around alone, hungry, confused, unloved, and fearful.

Currently our police forces seem to be having a spot of trouble keeping up with property crime, at something of an all time high, and crimes against the persons - particularly against women. When they are having to prioritise which call to attend, I'm thinking that unless an attack is in progress, a call that someone saw a dog that theythink might be an XL Bully out being walked unmuzzled is hardly likely to hit the attendance jackpot.

I've actually been in a situation where the police were contacted by multiple parties concerning an XL bully situation. The police were doing all they could to keep the hell out of it!

Trulyme · 14/02/2024 13:48

No it’s not fair that someone’s beloved pet should be PTS because of some twats.

We’d have barely any breeds left if we put down every ‘dangerous’ breed.

If this breed is eradicated, then it will be another breed that’s the problem.

Putting a plaster over this isn’t going to help.
The problem needs to be fixed and that means stricter dog ownership rules on all breeds.

TinkerTiger · 14/02/2024 13:41

YuleDragon · 14/02/2024 11:34

blame the owners, not the dogs.

the legislation is fundamentally flawed.

This is like 'guns don't kill, people do'. You can't control people until it's too late unfortunately, so you have to cut the problem off at the source.

FYI I'm not for putting the dogs down, just pointing out that the 'it's an owner issue' argument is pointless.

justteanbiscuits · 14/02/2024 13:40

whenlifegivesyoulemonssuckonthem · 14/02/2024 12:35

My next door neighbour has one.

They are perfectly responsible - registered, chipped, neutered and muzzled in public.

However they are not bringing him up to be a killer and so far is the softest oversized thing I've ever met.

I will be gobsmacked if he ever hurts anyone. Its the upbringing not the dog.

Not XL bullies, but bullies, lived next door to my Mum. Wouldn't hurt a fly, lovely family dogs etc etc One day they managed to make a gap in the fence big enough to break into her garden and rip her small dog to shreds. In front of her while she tried to grab a broom to hit them with. She has honestly never been the same since, it affected her enormously. As it was "only a dog" they attacked, and on private property, the owner got away with it completely and was only made to mend the fence.

SirenSays · 14/02/2024 13:36

Fannyfiggs · 14/02/2024 12:16

Can someone explain to me why it's the XL Bullies attacking people now?

What happened to the 'devil dogs' of the 90s? Staffordshire bull terrier, bull mastiff, doberman German shepherd, rottweiler, Japanese akita? Have they now retired from mauling?

Crazy isn't it /s. Its like we were right all along and it was the shitty violent and neglectful owners making dogs into monsters. Imagine that

AntonFeckoff · 14/02/2024 13:35

Gloriosaford · 14/02/2024 13:33

The thought of putting any healthy animal down, particularly one that hasn’t done anything wrong, is heartbreaking
You must be in floods of tears all day long then, all those animals euthanized, tens of thousands every day euthanized so that humans can eat them.

Of course the animal hasn't done anything wrong, animals have no concept of right or wrong, they are not capable of making moral choices and therefore cannot be innocent or guilty, this is something which applies to humans only.
Dogs are not human.

1: I don’t eat meat

2: My post was specifically from the perspective of a vet having to personally administer the euthanasia

HTH.

Gloriosaford · 14/02/2024 13:33

The thought of putting any healthy animal down, particularly one that hasn’t done anything wrong, is heartbreaking
You must be in floods of tears all day long then, all those animals euthanized, tens of thousands every day euthanized so that humans can eat them.

Of course the animal hasn't done anything wrong, animals have no concept of right or wrong, they are not capable of making moral choices and therefore cannot be innocent or guilty, this is something which applies to humans only.
Dogs are not human.

HappiestSleeping · 14/02/2024 13:30

Anametolove · 14/02/2024 12:31

While I applaud the intentions of your post @HappiestSleeping , I think the time for this has passed. Unfortunately, attacks are not rare, yes the media picks up on it, but not a week passes without the news of another attack. 3 days ago was a little boy in a communal area left with life changing injuries: https://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/home-news/bootle-xl-bully-boy-merseyside-wadham-road-b2494293.html

You are putting a lot of faith in owners training their dog properly, and the general public behaving in the right way to avoid attacks.

Personally, I don't think we should adapt our behaviour to suit the existence of these dangerous dogs; you will bever be able to fully control what events might lead to an XL bully attacking, the sheer strenghth and agressive tendencies of this particular breed making it impossible to control.
Ditto mental health of a few vets who might be opposed to putting them down.

I value human life above all, and it broke my heart to hear of this little boy, a mere week after two bullies killed a grandmother.

I think my point was to pass legislation that will actually stop the problem recurring. Backyard breeders are already working on replacements, so if we destroy all the XLB's now, they will just be replaced by some other Frankenbreed in a few years time. This has already started in fact as demand for other breeds to use has already become higher.

In this instance, I do think that stronger action needs to be taken against irresponsible owners, and uncontrolled specimens of this breed. Then again, I think that stronger action needs to be taken against racists, rapists, murderers, company directors who allow travesties such as the Post Office Scandal, various members of Parliament who are openly lining their own pockets.....the list is endless.

Hence the need to put legislation in place that minimises the need for ongoing management cost. If the government made it illegal to sell dogs on Facebook, gumtree etc, that would remove a good proportion of the outlets for these types of breeds. Of course there will be the subsection of society that will flout this, but they will be advertising who they are by possessing one.

Lastly, I maintain that attacks are rare. Whilst and instances of attacks are wholly unacceptable, there is statistically more chance of a wife being murdered by her husband than of being bitten by a dog, let alone killed by it. Or of a bit of space junk landing on our heads. Hence I can't see the government doing much more at this point as they have what they would consider to be bigger fish to fry.

It is a very sad state of affairs that so many dog owners don't have a clue about how to raise a dog. That can also be said of parents, car owners, computer owners and many other things. I concede that the consequences of not being able to operate a computer etc are significantly less serious though.

Mischance · 14/02/2024 13:30

mumofnations · 14/02/2024 12:30

My 2 girls are not monsters and this is the problem, many need to educated themselves!
I was walking mine the other day and told I had a lovely staffy 🤣
Most people have no idea what they even look like!
My girls are legal, muzzled and always have been on the lead they also sit and wait for walkers, children and other dogs to walk by when I am out with them they pay attention to me because I keep them safe not the other way round.

"My girls" .... heaven help us. Sigh.

I thought you were going to tell us something about your daughters.

Swipe left for the next trending thread