Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

XL Bullies to be destroyed now!

494 replies

Babycatsarenice · 14/02/2024 11:12

Sick of these monsters still being on our streets (I never see them muzzled as their irresponsible owners don't comply) and worse still knowing that they are still in homes with children.

AIBU that they should be put to sleep NOW

OP posts:
Thread gallery
16
Imfreetofeelgood · 14/02/2024 14:54

I'm a dog lover, but something needs to be done about those not obeying the law. A man was killed by one 5 minutes walk away from my house, about 4 months ago. So pre legislation. Just walking his little dog on a housing estate. Devastating for witnesses. The police seized another, from the property it was let out of, and puppies.

Anametolove · 14/02/2024 14:53

Snowpatrolling · 14/02/2024 14:34

My friend has an XL bully, he is muzzle trained (muzzled every time they leave the house) crate trained, insured, has the exemption certificate, and has the correct harness.

so what type of person do you suggest she is???

I would think your friend is a decent person who did the mistake to pick this breed in the first place. I would be concerned about her long term safety and about the social limitations brought by her choice to her life (visitors at home, not being able to enjoy playing with her dog outside, etc.)

Lucytheloose · 14/02/2024 14:49

WiddlinDiddlin · 14/02/2024 12:48

Oh ok..

In real, practical terms, not 'give me the needle I'll do it' because you can't unless you're a vet...

How exactly would this work?

A team of vets going house to house killing dogs?

Where will they come from, vets go into veterinary medicine to save animals not kill them. They are independent businesses/employees, not government staff so, who is going to make them? Who will pay for this if they could be found? What would be in place to protect the MH of those vets?

How will you find them all, this would lead to many owners hiding dogs (which is a big part of the problem already, hidden dogs do not have their needs met, are untrained, unsocialised, suffering and far more likely to be dangerous should they escape or be exposed to situations they've no ability to cope with).

Do you suggest every home in the UK is searched for XL bullies?

Forcibly taking and killing peoples dogs in front of them is likely to be highly stressful for everyone and very high risk for all involved. Again, why should vets (who, unlike police officers, did not sign up for the risk of being punched/stabbed etc in the course of their everyday work) do this. What law is there in place that could be used to force them to do this?

Or do you mean for police to seize dogs and transport them to some killing facility - where is this facility (or facilities) please?

Killing dogs takes time and the legal methods require fairly close handling, or are you proposing to change our laws on euthanasia methods so that dogs can be gassed in large numbers as is done in some US states and parts of Japan?
Otherwise who is funding the seizure, transport, and housing of huge numbers of dogs, all of whom are liable to kill a person at the drop of a hat lets not forget, whilst they wait to be killed?

It was easy to add XL bullies to the existing breed specific laws, as all the work for that was done when pitbulls were banned.

I do not believe there is anything in place already that would allow any authority to destroy property simply because it exists (as opposed to where a crime was wilfully and with intent, committed), particularly property owners have just paid to meet the various conditions and exempt their property. I assume those people would be refunded and they'd have a good compensation case too for their expenses - who will pay for this?

Given the governments figures for how many XL bullies there are in the UK were WAY off... (they estimated around 10 thousand. It is more likely closer to 100'000) do you think this is a proportional response to less than 1% of the xl bully population being killers?

I think it would be a job for the police; specifically, for the firearms units.

DinoMummsy · 14/02/2024 14:42

SpudleyLass · 14/02/2024 12:01

Agreed. Euthanise them all AND bring in stricter dog ownership laws.

All dogs on a lead when outside, no exceptions. Bring back dog wardens, dog licenses.

Mandatory dog training courses - lose ownership and/or fine if no compliance.

The government has been too weak on this issue.

Yes, exactly this!

Flippingfruitflies · 14/02/2024 14:38

Never seen one in real life but agree they don’t belong in family homes or any home really. Decent owners will comply with the rules but it’s the ‘typical chavvy lowlifes’ who won’t and those are the ones most likely to have untrained or mistreated dogs who are dangerous.

HelloMiss · 14/02/2024 14:34

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Agree!!

Snowpatrolling · 14/02/2024 14:34

Shivermetimbers13 · 14/02/2024 11:35

I haven't seen one, but I'm horrified by the stories I'm reading about their attacks.

Yes they should all be put down. Telling owners to muzzle them doesn't work - the type of person who keeps a dog like that isn't the type of person who follows the rules.

My friend has an XL bully, he is muzzle trained (muzzled every time they leave the house) crate trained, insured, has the exemption certificate, and has the correct harness.

so what type of person do you suggest she is???

Anametolove · 14/02/2024 14:34

I guess one issue that transpires from this thread is the public seems divided on whether these dogs are inherently dangerous. Some PP seem to think that all the attacks we have seen are due to bad ownership.
My opinion (and I assume one not shared by many, esp owners) is that the issue lies in the genetic predisposition of this breed of dogs to attack and be violent (Kimbo lineage in the UK etc). The attacks themselves are then due to this predisposition and some basic safety not being respected (dogs around children, off lead, etc), which is bad ownership. But not 100% can be put on the owners, sometimes the dogs "turn" and attack their owners with no warning signs.
The ban does bring some peace of mind that responsible owners' dogs are going to be muzzled in public and on a lead, which is reassuring to some degree.

bastin · 14/02/2024 14:32

I've never seen one but if I did I'd cross the road

Porfirio · 14/02/2024 14:32

I'm more concerned with the huge amount of unwanted pets - dogs, cats and other unwanted animals that are filling animal rescue centres every day. Many are full to capacity.

The cost of owning a pet is rising, insurance, vet bills and food etc and animals are being dumped and abandoned. Relationship break ups and people going into rented accommodation where pets aren't allowed is another factor.

If you are a much loved pet of a responsible and caring owner you will have the happiest life possible. If you don't then you are destined to a life behind bars until the slight possible chance you may be adopted.

The U.K. is in a terrible state for these poor creatures who through no fault of their own have been bred and then abandoned.

Iheartmysmart · 14/02/2024 14:31

@TotalAbsenceOfImperialRaiment I’d be happy to be part of that. Aside from the whole XL bully situation, there are far too many people around who are totally incapable of being a responsible dog owner. I think prospective owners should be vetted, made to go to training classes and be licensed before they are even allowed to put their name down for a dog. This current system of any idiot being able to own one isn’t working.

Chocolatefreak · 14/02/2024 14:31

Using the 'it's the owners' argument is disingenuous and a little bit like the NRA's 'guns don't kill people, people kill people' argument. Yes, we need far better dog licensing and ownership laws. But we also need to stop people getting mauled. It's not the dogs' fault - but I'd rather these dogs were put down than people getting attacked/killed.

You could actually give a deadline for compliance and say that any dangerous dog breed found after x date without being castrated/muzzled/defanged etc after this time will be automatically put down.

HellsAngel81 · 14/02/2024 14:31

For those that are braying for blood, perhaps you might like to consider making a donation to Vetlife? This is a charity that supports the veterinary community, especially those suffering from mental health problems. I forsee this vital service becoming more needed in the near future. Not sure if I am allowed to include a link, so admin please remove if that is the case.
https://www.vetlife.org.uk/donate/

Gloriosaford · 14/02/2024 14:28

Keeping a dog is a hobby if you want to make analogies you should compare it to someone's knitting or their crafting \jigsaw puzzles.
Its a hobby, something you do for your own indulgence and amusement, stop subjecting the rest of us to your shitting irritating hobby

SomeCatFromJapan · 14/02/2024 14:27

I'd genuinely like to see them all euthanised at this point. I say this as someone who likes dogs and thinks that other breeds shouldn't be at risk of being mauled to death on a walk.

Gloriosaford · 14/02/2024 14:23

Fannyfiggs · 14/02/2024 14:06

Why the need to be so rude.

We wouldn't be rude if you posted about your daughters. Some of us love our animals and call them our girls, our boys etc. You don't know someone's situation as to why they may treat their animals like their kids so leave us to it like we leave you to your children.

And there you go drawing equivalence between dogs and children 🙄
Your dog is not equal to a child.

TotalAbsenceOfImperialRaiment · 14/02/2024 14:22

Unfortunately we are unlikely to ever be in a situation whereby it’s illegal to have a dog if you’re an irresponsible arsehole.

I'm coming round to the view that a committee of responsible citizens should decide whether an individual should be allowed to have a dog.

Trulyme · 14/02/2024 14:18

Fannyfiggs · 14/02/2024 12:16

Can someone explain to me why it's the XL Bullies attacking people now?

What happened to the 'devil dogs' of the 90s? Staffordshire bull terrier, bull mastiff, doberman German shepherd, rottweiler, Japanese akita? Have they now retired from mauling?

They stopped being the ‘cool’ breed and idiots stopped getting them simply to look hard and have them as status dogs.

It just goes to show how it is the owner and not the breed that’s the problem.

I’ve not once met an aggressive staffy but I remember every day seeing front page newspapers of how dangerous staffies were.

There are also a lot more dogs around in general now and so much easier to get one, so the number of dog attacks will keep going up as long as the number of dogs keep going up.

The reason I’m against PTS certain breeds is because in a couple of years a different breed will be the dangerous one.

Its not getting to the route of the problem.

Iheartmysmart · 14/02/2024 14:17

@Fishbones1 I’m not really missing the point. The way OP is hysterically frothing about this, everyone would believe there’s an XL bully on every street corner waiting to pounce on the unsuspecting general public. The truth is there are an awful lot of these dogs who are now being kept illegally by dreadful owners who shouldn’t be allowed to have a pot plant yet alone a living creature. But there are also responsible ones whose dog is highly unlikely to ever be a problem. Why should those dogs be destroyed.

Unfortunately we are unlikely to ever be in a situation whereby it’s illegal to have a dog if you’re an irresponsible arsehole.

AntonFeckoff · 14/02/2024 14:17

Fannyfiggs · 14/02/2024 14:06

Why the need to be so rude.

We wouldn't be rude if you posted about your daughters. Some of us love our animals and call them our girls, our boys etc. You don't know someone's situation as to why they may treat their animals like their kids so leave us to it like we leave you to your children.

Absolutely this.

I would be dead now if it weren't for my cat. I had a very difficult childhood, no family and was in a DV relationship. I'd never experienced pure, uncomplicated and unconditional love until I met my lovely boy. My life was turned around because of him. It's a shame some people can't accept the bond some people have with their animals and have to be so unpleasant about it.

mumto2teenagers · 14/02/2024 14:14

@ImNotReallySpartacus the vets are not too wimpy to euthanise them. Vets are dedicated to preserving the well-being of animals and they have every right to refuse to euthanise a healthy animal.

The ban is flawed, an XL bully who is owned by a responsible owner poses very little risk. The problem is the irresponsible owners who do not comply with the restrictions, knows nothing about training and uses the dog as a status symbol. Breed specific legislation does not work in reducing dog attacks. The government have no way of knowing how many XL Bully's there are and do not have the resources to enforce the ban.

Astrabees · 14/02/2024 14:11

So much hysteria on this thread. Over 30,000 XL bullies have been registered and granted exemption certificates, which goes to show only the tiniest of minorities cause problems. Some XL bullies are owned by the feckless but most of them have sensible responsible owners, as you can see from the updates on those that were fortunate enough to be rescued and rehomed by dog charities. I don’t like them and wouldn’t have one but I think we should bear in mind the figures for deaths caused by dogs around 10 a year in contrast with murder statistics of 500+ for humans killing other humans.

TheDowagerDoughnut · 14/02/2024 14:10

If we cannot enforce the muzzle requirement, there is no chance of enforcing an order to PTS.

At this rate we can make up as many laws as we like - and that'll just mean a greater number of laws ignored.

30,000 (ish) exempt dogs. Average lifespan of 10 years. Assuming an equal spread of age, that's 3000 less dogs per year through natural death. Within 5-10 years we will be talking about a different dog type. That new type will still have been created in a 'lab' (a scrappy kitchen with tools bought off the internet) by criminals looking to intimidate and launder money.

We need to enforce the laws we have, as a start. We then need to put real time and energy into reviewing those laws and coming up with something more effective at the end result we're aiming for: reduced harm and death from poorly bred, poorly raised, poorly trained and poorly kept dogs.

CactusMactus · 14/02/2024 14:10

Maybe put the owners and breeders down?

GPTec1 · 14/02/2024 14:10

Fannyfiggs · 14/02/2024 12:16

Can someone explain to me why it's the XL Bullies attacking people now?

What happened to the 'devil dogs' of the 90s? Staffordshire bull terrier, bull mastiff, doberman German shepherd, rottweiler, Japanese akita? Have they now retired from mauling?

All still around but they tend not to kill people in the numbers that XLs do.

A strong man could pull most of these types off you or i, he'd have no chance with a XL.

Swipe left for the next trending thread