Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

XL Bullies to be destroyed now!

494 replies

Babycatsarenice · 14/02/2024 11:12

Sick of these monsters still being on our streets (I never see them muzzled as their irresponsible owners don't comply) and worse still knowing that they are still in homes with children.

AIBU that they should be put to sleep NOW

OP posts:
Thread gallery
16
HappiestSleeping · 14/02/2024 18:32

NoOrdinaryMorning · 14/02/2024 18:12

Highly qualified and experienced Veterinary professors have proven beyond any doubt using science that this behaviour is evident within the dna of these 'animals'. It is NOTHING to do with how they're raised ffs

It's amazing how some are blind to this. Every single dog breed has been bred over time to enhance certain characteristics that humans find beneficial. And yet, XL Bully supporters ignore the "donor" dna of fighting breeds. I do feel sorry for the dogs as they didn't have any choice in it, and as I've said before, it's the breeders that need to be shot. If anyone is going to try and create a nice companion breed, why does it need to have its roots in aggressive breeds?

That said, the way they are raised does have significant impact. Only to make the fuse shorter or longer, but if said fuse is sufficiently long, it may never go off. Depends on how much you want to stake on that word may though.

IsEveryUserNameBloodyTaken · 14/02/2024 18:32

whenlifegivesyoulemonssuckonthem · 14/02/2024 12:35

My next door neighbour has one.

They are perfectly responsible - registered, chipped, neutered and muzzled in public.

However they are not bringing him up to be a killer and so far is the softest oversized thing I've ever met.

I will be gobsmacked if he ever hurts anyone. Its the upbringing not the dog.

Do you know what every owner says after an attack “it’s never done that before”

AntonFeckoff · 14/02/2024 18:29

NoOrdinaryMorning · 14/02/2024 18:12

Highly qualified and experienced Veterinary professors have proven beyond any doubt using science that this behaviour is evident within the dna of these 'animals'. It is NOTHING to do with how they're raised ffs

Evident within the DNA? How does that work then? Did they look at it through an electron microscope and see little snarling faces in amongst the nucleotides?

Anametolove · 14/02/2024 18:29

Thank you for being open to debate @AddictedToBooks and I readily admit that if I knew someone with lovely XL, I wouldn't be so quick to demonise the breed. Unfortunately, everything I have been reading so far, from history of lineage to dog behaviourists biews, supports the view that these dogs are unpredictable and coupled with their sheer strength, I don't think we can take the risk. But for the moment, if the restrictions of the ban are being enforced, it is a good first step.

Ilovelurchers · 14/02/2024 18:28

funinthesun19 · 14/02/2024 17:46

Yanbu OP. Anyone who disagrees with you is delusional and part of the problem.

Loads of dog lovers have agreed these dogs are monsters and should be put to sleep. But some dog lovers are still too blinded by their love of dogs and feel too sentimental about them to finally back down, hold their hands up and accept that these dogs shouldn’t be alive.

This is the type of post I mean - it doesn't move anything forward just to dismiss those you don't agree with us as "delusional".

Some more constructive argument on this thread elsewhere tho, so that is positive.

Northernsouloldies · 14/02/2024 18:21

RedPony1 · 14/02/2024 11:32

I've never even seen one in real life,

I have and they're scary fuckers.

pinoco · 14/02/2024 18:19

RedPony1 · 14/02/2024 11:32

I've never even seen one in real life,

Where do you live? I live in a nice village near to a city and they're everywhere. Always being walked by some absolute tool with their knuckles scraping the ground. Of course, no muzzle and sometimes off the lead (post ban)

NoOrdinaryMorning · 14/02/2024 18:12

YuleDragon · 14/02/2024 11:34

blame the owners, not the dogs.

the legislation is fundamentally flawed.

Highly qualified and experienced Veterinary professors have proven beyond any doubt using science that this behaviour is evident within the dna of these 'animals'. It is NOTHING to do with how they're raised ffs

somekittenmittens · 14/02/2024 18:12

@WiddlinDiddlin "In every case to date, I can find housing, husbandry, training and health reasons for an increased potential for dangerously aggressive behaviour (vs defensively aggressive ie a dog warning folk to back off and trying to get away)."
Surely this tells you it's a breed problem? Rescued animal testing beagles and rescued puppy farming goldens aren't killing people or inflicting serious bites en masse, there are no retired greyhound deaths. Surely what you say supports a ban, when certain breeds will maul and kill people unless they're properly managed? Your argument against aversives is exactly why XLs should be demonised and banned - if they go wrong, they can cause a dog to kill people therefore they're not safe for anyone to own.

OOBetty · 14/02/2024 18:12

All the animal charities clearly state it’s not the dogs it’s the owners.
Its not one size fits all
Animals and humans can be aggressive if they are brought up to be.
The problem with xl bullies is their jaws are so strong they can do serious damage.

Id say jail the owners of all aggressive animals that aren’t or can’t be controlled

Should all xl bullies be destroyed now…..No. no more than the wrongs of a death sentence for murderers, rapists and drug dealers that all ruin lives
Should xl bullies owners be jailed……Yes. If their dogs cause death or serious injury they should receive the same sentence as if they caused it.

Should xl bullies that cause harm be destroyed. If they cannot be rehabilitated and only on the advice of those qualified to make that decision then yes.

superplumb · 14/02/2024 18:12

Yeah I'd have them all put down.
People who argue its the owners etc.. is the same arguments people in the US day about gun control. Get rid of all of them

Bring in dog licence for breeding

NoOrdinaryMorning · 14/02/2024 18:10

Babycatsarenice · 14/02/2024 11:12

Sick of these monsters still being on our streets (I never see them muzzled as their irresponsible owners don't comply) and worse still knowing that they are still in homes with children.

AIBU that they should be put to sleep NOW

100,000,000% agree! I'm sick of hearing about innocent people & kids being mauled to death.

I'm also sick of hearing about people thinking they know better than veterinary professors who've proven that tendencies of this violent behaviour is quite literally evident within the DNA of these animals. But yet Jeff on Facebook knows better! 🙄

WiddlinDiddlin · 14/02/2024 18:09

Please can we stop with the Kimbo bullshit?!

There is ZERO evidence that any of Kimbos genetics are actually here in the UK.

There is ZERO evidence that dogs related to Kimbo have killed anyone if they exist.

Twatty ego-boosting breeders claimed Kimbo lines to big up their crossbred mutts on pedigrees that are typically invented by the breeder and verified by absolutely no DNA proof at all.

One massively anti-dog outfit decided to jump on the Kimbo story and they refused to back it up with actual evidence (ie dna linking dogs to Kimbo).

XL Bullies in the UK are crossbreeds - mixtures of staffie, pitbull types, american bulldogs, olde tyme bulldogges, cane corsos and much much more.

Some of them will have been selectively bred for their willingness to lunge and yell and bark and grab stuff. Many of them won't and have simply been bred for their appearance with no thought whatsoever to their parents or grandparents.

In every case to date, I can find housing, husbandry, training and health reasons for an increased potential for dangerously aggressive behaviour (vs defensively aggressive ie a dog warning folk to back off and trying to get away).

In many cases, the reason was a total lack of appropriate training and a highly aroused dog 'playing' the way they had been taught to play - grabbing at limbs and not letting go (just visit tiktok to see people teaching other people how to teach their dogs to do this!).

The common denominator in dog attacks is people - failing to meet the needs of the dogs they choose to keep, choosing highly unsuitable dogs for their circumstances, using aversive training methods, training for 'protection work' (ie, to grab people by the arm or leg).

somekittenmittens · 14/02/2024 18:07

Fannyfiggs · 14/02/2024 12:16

Can someone explain to me why it's the XL Bullies attacking people now?

What happened to the 'devil dogs' of the 90s? Staffordshire bull terrier, bull mastiff, doberman German shepherd, rottweiler, Japanese akita? Have they now retired from mauling?

Dogs other than pitbulls have a low rate of mauling and killing in comparison, what you see in the media now isn't the hype that there was when we didn't have bloodsport dogs in family it's real, before it was media hype over a few incidences because it was so uncommon. Here is the wikipedia list of deaths by all dogs in the UK https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_fatal_dog_attacks_in_the_United_Kingdom , the unusual thing about the recent maulings is that they're regularly killing adults. In the stats before this, alot of the deaths are on infants which while unacceptable is telling that the aforementioned breeds very rarely succeeded in killing an adult that could defend themselves. It's almost exclusively bloodsport breeds (pitbulls, american bulldogs, bull terriers) that kill healthy adults with no medical conditions, oftentimes alone vs working in pairs which is common for dogs like rottweillers.

If anyone is interested in further breakdown, it isn't a UK source but gives a good breakdown of attacks by breed and age of victim.
https://www.dogsbite.org/dog-bite-statistics-multi-year-fatality-report-2005-2017.php

For none fatal dog attacks, here are some studies on dog bites, pitbulls also lead the way (an xl bully is a pitbull crossed with a molosser for size) https://www.dogsbite.org/dog-bite-statistics-studies-level-1-trauma-table-2011-present.php

iceskater1 · 14/02/2024 18:03

"Blame the owners, not the dogs"

It's not about blaming anyone, at the end of the day it's about keeping people safe and these dogs aren't safe.

moomoomoo27 · 14/02/2024 18:00

funinthesun19 · 14/02/2024 17:46

Yanbu OP. Anyone who disagrees with you is delusional and part of the problem.

Loads of dog lovers have agreed these dogs are monsters and should be put to sleep. But some dog lovers are still too blinded by their love of dogs and feel too sentimental about them to finally back down, hold their hands up and accept that these dogs shouldn’t be alive.

It's not going to help because then breeders create another breed that's similar but not illegal, and then that gets banned so they move on to the next one, etc. It's the same thing they do for drugs and legal highs.

moomoomoo27 · 14/02/2024 17:59

Flamme · 14/02/2024 17:54

What is your suggestion for legislation that will definitely prevent any more deaths?

You'd have to make human beings sterile and take away anything that could be used as a weapon for that.

Humans are the most dangerous thing on this planet, and they make everything non-dangerous dangerous.

Flamme · 14/02/2024 17:54

YuleDragon · 14/02/2024 11:34

blame the owners, not the dogs.

the legislation is fundamentally flawed.

What is your suggestion for legislation that will definitely prevent any more deaths?

funinthesun19 · 14/02/2024 17:46

Yanbu OP. Anyone who disagrees with you is delusional and part of the problem.

Loads of dog lovers have agreed these dogs are monsters and should be put to sleep. But some dog lovers are still too blinded by their love of dogs and feel too sentimental about them to finally back down, hold their hands up and accept that these dogs shouldn’t be alive.

HelpMeGetThrough · 14/02/2024 17:44

I bet what you've seen aren't even xls, because you would have to go over with a tape measure to find this out and I'm assuming you haven't done that

Well, we could add them to the list as well then.

AddictedToBooks · 14/02/2024 17:41

Anametolove · 14/02/2024 17:15

But @AddictedToBooks the media doesn't invent these attacks, they exist. People are being killed by XL bullies. Ive read 6 attacks over 10 were of xl in 2022. And the outcome with such a powerful breed is often catastrophic. Your dog was almost attacked! So why not demonise the breed? It is the breed that is the issue, on top of shit owners. I actually do not understand the side that says there is nothing wrong with these dogs, I really don't. And I say this as someone who really loves dogs.

Yes any dog can turn as you say, but a mini goldendoodle cannot maul a grown man to death even if it was animated with the most lethal intentions.

Thanks for being polite unlike the person below you, who I choose to ignore apart from to say "no need for swearing and insults to get a view across".

Your points are valid, and yes if that dog had actually managed to attack my Border Collie, then I would probably have had a different view.
The only reason I don't demonise the entire breed is because I have a neighbour who has two XLBs and they have always been really well behaved and lovely and to be frank, I wouldn't like to see them taken off to a vet and euthanised just because of what they are, because I know them and see them daily.
I will say though, as other PPs have wondered why people have chosen XLBs (good question to be fair) as pets, that my neighbour rescued hers as they were dumped as young puppies on a foothpath in our local countrypark that was flanked by a deep river on one side and one of the busiest motorways on the other.

I also really get what you're saying over the statistics and yes, you've made me think, but I still can't find it in myself to demonise the entire breed - I hold my hands up and admit I may well be biased because of the two I know.

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 14/02/2024 17:40

SweetBirdsong · 14/02/2024 17:04

@Babycatsarenice

I agree. It's kinda sad as it's not their fault, but when it's come to the point where GROWN MEN are being killed (and grown women!) something HAS to be done. The 'vicious dogs' of yesteryear like Rottweilers and pitbulls and the like, used to attack and maim children, and occasionally kill a child, but this XL Bully dog has gravitated to adults.

They all need annihilating. I had never even heard of the fucking things until last year. Where on earth are they even from?!

I would argue that "something has to be done" when a dog attacks a child. Children aren't less valuable than adults.

I think there should be a competence test and licence needed to have a dog over a certain height or weight (basically one big enough that a typical adult female couldn't reliably stop it from pulling free when leashed) and part of the condition of the licence is that the dog must be muzzled in public, can only be taken outside by an adult, and can't live in a home with children below a certain age.

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 14/02/2024 17:34

@ImNotReallySpartacus hold a driving licence

We already have driving tests for that.

perhaps the same committees should make decisions about who is allowed to reproduce,

Eugenics isn't acceptable in a democratic society.

or move in with a single mum who has young children.

Now this, I can get behind.

AntonFeckoff · 14/02/2024 17:32

RamblingAroundTheInternet · 14/02/2024 16:50

The thought of putting any healthy animal down, particularly one that hasn’t done anything wrong, is heartbreaking.

Do you feel the same about cows, bison, sheep, pigs, deer, horses, chickens, ducks etc @AntonFeckoff? These are healthy animals that haven’t done anything wrong that are slaughtered daily in their thousands for humans to eat. They are bred by humans for meat (except deer and horses which are still killed and eaten), like dogs are bred as pets. None would exist in the numbers they do if they weren’t. XL bullies wouldn’t exist naturally at all.

The cognitive dissonance about certain animals because we regard them as pets is hilarious and pathetic in equal measure.

Any animal that has the strength and ability to kill a man, let alone a child, should not be wandering the streets or being kept in private homes.

I have already addressed this in response to another poster who was equally passive aggressive and keen to come across as oh so very clever. 1. I don't eat meat. 2. My post was addressing suicide rates in veterinary medicine, and the quoted text was specifically from the perspective of a vet having to personally euthanise healthy animals.

Any animal that has the strength and ability to kill a man, let alone a child, should not be wandering the streets or being kept in private homes.

Best not venture too far from the UK then, since many countries have animals with these qualities wandering into human habitats on a regular basis. Unless you think they should all be culled for your convenience?

SweetBirdsong · 14/02/2024 17:28

@LakeTiticaca Harsh! Shock