Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

XL Bullies to be destroyed now!

494 replies

Babycatsarenice · 14/02/2024 11:12

Sick of these monsters still being on our streets (I never see them muzzled as their irresponsible owners don't comply) and worse still knowing that they are still in homes with children.

AIBU that they should be put to sleep NOW

OP posts:
Thread gallery
16
Winter2020 · 15/02/2024 02:40

Bingoballs · 14/02/2024 13:59

They have collectively decided to be absolute angels and give another breed the limelight.
They are no longer dangerous and are all angelic little fluff balls.

In reality there has been an increase in deaths relating to xl bullies but the other breeds haven't stopped attacking people but xl bullies is the breed the press want to publicise. Likely cause they have a certain look and posture.

Quote " Likely cause they have a certain look and posture."

... or perhaps it's because they make up less than 1% of dogs and 50% of fatal dog attacks?

Winter2020 · 15/02/2024 02:37

HappiestSleeping · 14/02/2024 12:19

This is a complicated issue, and it is irresponsible breeding that is responsible for the mess we find ourselves in. It is this that should be regulated, with additional restrictions for owners.

The breed itself started (allegedly) as a companion dog, although I humbly submit that there were better start points for this than pitbulls and staffies. Then you had the segment who bred the aggressive tendencies which led us to where we are. Couple this with the irresponsible owners and the lack of ability to enforce not only this law, but many others besides. Many dog owners do not know the requirements of the breeds they select as pets, and unfortunately this particular derivative has fairly disastrous potential consequences when it is not handled / looked after correctly. This is less of a risk with other breeds (you don't hear of many pomeranians attacking humans).

It is always the few that spoil it for the many, however we should bear in mind that dog attacks are still very rare, and there are things we can do to minimise the chances of it happening to us. If there is an owner not adhering to the law, report to the local authority, environmental health, and the police.

Quote re dog attacks: "there are things we can do to minimise the chances of it happening to us."

Yes so in the recent case of a child being attacked in the flats we can avoid and make our children avoid moving around near our own homes.

In the case of a child attacked by a dog on a play date - we can avoid our children going to homes with these dogs.

In the case of the dog going wild and attacking adults randomly near a petrol station - we can avoid getting out of our cars and moving around whenever possible.

In the case of the dogs that have got into their neighbours gardens and killed or savaged them - we can avoid using our own gardens - particularly if we know our neighbours or people nearby have these dogs.

In the case of the dog walker killed - businesses e.g. dog walkers/groomers/kennels can refuse to take these dogs.

In the case of owners being attacked and killed in the home or their children we can avoid owning these dogs.

Why should people have to change their perfectly normal behaviour moving around their homes and communities in order to avoid dangerous dogs? Get rid of them and allow people to move around feeling safe without having to "do things" to avoid a dog attack happening to them.

Winter2020 · 15/02/2024 02:23

Predictabilitypreferred · 14/02/2024 11:36

Are you going to do it? You are aware that veterinary professionals don't generally enter the profession to put healthy animals to sleep? And none of them have to put any animal to sleep if they don't agree with it. Indeed many practices are refusing which leaves one or two in any given area where they will oblige. How do you think that will affect the mental health of the staff? Spending all day putting healthy puppies to sleep? Would you like to spend your working day doing that?
The ban will do nothing. They will be replaced with another equally powerful breed. The answer isn't breed bans, it's ownership bans, much more restrictive breeding laws, import bans etc. Other countries manage these very well, it's just the UK government that is useless.

How do you think it affects the mental health of the nurses, surgeons and auxiliary staff at the hospitals nursing people that have been torn apart by these dogs and trying to put them back together?

How do you think it affects the mental health of the victims (those that live to tell the tale) and the victims families and friends? How about the general public that don't feel safe or that their children are safe in their communities? What about the mental health of people whose neighbours have these dogs?

It is right that no-one has to put an animal down - it is their choice to do it or not. I expect a lot of people would be willing to do it for the right price.

FabFebHalfTerm · 15/02/2024 01:20

Babycatsarenice · 14/02/2024 22:09

I hope this thread will give voice to all of us who are fed up with this ban that doesn't work as we are all still seeing these dogs out and about. Maybe Rishi will see it?!
Sure I can report an unmuzzled dog to the police- do you think the police have time to actually police this? They have said they don't have the resources.
Boo hoo nasty thread...what about the poor people who have been injured and killed?
As it stands this is going go go on 10 years unless further action is taken.
Of course it's not the dogs' fault but they should never have been bred in the first place.

@Babycatsarenice

the legislation has been put in place. It's been 14 days, on what planet did you think it would all have been sorted in 14 days.

you have the legislation in place, you have the channels to report it.

whinging it hasn't worked, not bothering to report dogs that have irresponsible owners.

what do you want? Specialist police to wander around your neighbourhood killing dogs you don't like the look of??

well it's not going to happen, so DO something (other than start goady threads on MN. Use the tools you've been given.

Treehugger22 · 15/02/2024 00:51

Gloriosaford · 15/02/2024 00:28

For every annoying dog I've ever known I have known many, many, more annoying kids
ANOTHER person who sees dogs as directly analogous with children!
I notice no one says "dogs can be annoying but trainspotters/pidgeon fanciers are worse". The comparison is always with children, implying that they [in the mind of dog a enthusiast} belong in the same category, or are competing for the same slot in society.

Children understand adults and can communicate with speech unlike dogs, yet a lot of people can't control their kids, yet its expected to control an animal that doesn't understand human language.

If someone's child kills another, should the parents go to jail? Me personally I think so, if the child is under a certain age.

Treehugger22 · 15/02/2024 00:45

Constant threads on this. This isnt aibu its spouting your stupid opinion and I can bet you're just another wannabe breed expert, that knows f all about dogs and just accuses people or having xl bullies when the dog is another breed.

Ever think maybe the dogs you allegedly see with no muzzle ARE NOT xl bullies? Hint why they have no muzzle.

Anytime I seen a xl bully, which is an xl bully they have been muzzled.

Time to stop curtain twitching and meet some friends if you have any

Thunderbird7 · 15/02/2024 00:41

Gloriosaford · 15/02/2024 00:28

For every annoying dog I've ever known I have known many, many, more annoying kids
ANOTHER person who sees dogs as directly analogous with children!
I notice no one says "dogs can be annoying but trainspotters/pidgeon fanciers are worse". The comparison is always with children, implying that they [in the mind of dog a enthusiast} belong in the same category, or are competing for the same slot in society.

I like dogs but… children are THE most vulnerable group in society and many of them can’t advocate for themselves, so I consider it a HUGE red flag when people prefer animals over children

Gloriosaford · 15/02/2024 00:28

For every annoying dog I've ever known I have known many, many, more annoying kids
ANOTHER person who sees dogs as directly analogous with children!
I notice no one says "dogs can be annoying but trainspotters/pidgeon fanciers are worse". The comparison is always with children, implying that they [in the mind of dog a enthusiast} belong in the same category, or are competing for the same slot in society.

IloveAslan · 15/02/2024 00:12

MrsMiddleMother · 14/02/2024 23:24

I think the government should go one step further and just ban dogs completely. No more dogs jumping up at strangers, no more attacks, no more dog shit all over the pavements, no more dogs in cafes. Just get rid of the lot.

For every annoying dog I've ever known I have known many, many, more annoying kids. Maybe the government should ban kids! Ridiculous, yes - but so is your suggestion.

I would cheerfully ban the majority of them from cafes (kids, not dogs).

IloveAslan · 15/02/2024 00:08

FreeZor · 14/02/2024 23:28

You don't know someone's situation as to why they may treat their animals like their kids so leave us to it like we leave you to your children.

Jesus Christ. Animals are not comparable to children. Whatever your "situation" this is just absurd. Get a grip.

No, animals are not comparable to children. That doesn't alter the fact that some us much prefer them to children (which doesn't mean we all treat them like children btw).

oakleaffy · 15/02/2024 00:03

FreeZor · 14/02/2024 23:28

You don't know someone's situation as to why they may treat their animals like their kids so leave us to it like we leave you to your children.

Jesus Christ. Animals are not comparable to children. Whatever your "situation" this is just absurd. Get a grip.

THIS is a huge part of the problem.
People treating dogs like children.

They are Dogs, they need 'discipline' like children do {Routine, regular exercise, training to be polite and nice to be around} but the whole nauseating ''Fur baby''
''Pet mom'' ''Pet parent'' thing is ridiculous.

I don't want someone 's 'furkid' leaping all over me in the park, mothers of toddlers don't want 'Pissfingers' the ''She's a rescyoo!'' snatching food out of their child's hand in a café..
Nor do we want our well behaved, quiet dogs pestered by your sex crazed Giant Poodle.

XL Bullies to be destroyed now!
itsalwaysthesame · 14/02/2024 23:53

MrsMiddleMother · 14/02/2024 23:24

I think the government should go one step further and just ban dogs completely. No more dogs jumping up at strangers, no more attacks, no more dog shit all over the pavements, no more dogs in cafes. Just get rid of the lot.

Same goes for therapy, PAT, police or guide dogs? What a silly comment 🙄

Icantbedoingwithit · 14/02/2024 23:31

Exterminate every single last one of them.

FreeZor · 14/02/2024 23:28

You don't know someone's situation as to why they may treat their animals like their kids so leave us to it like we leave you to your children.

Jesus Christ. Animals are not comparable to children. Whatever your "situation" this is just absurd. Get a grip.

FreeZor · 14/02/2024 23:25

Some people get them because they like them. They like how they look, they like the nature of the individual animal - so said a dog warden who once had two of them. Some get them for protection, because they live in a well dodgy area, and it makes them feel safer. Some get them to look tough and cool. Some get them to breed. Some get them to fight. Obviously a huge spectrum of reasons, raising from benign to worrying as hell and dodgy as all get out.

None of these "reasons" are an acceptable reason to put other people in danger. Being part of society means trade offs between the rights of others and your own freedoms. Sometimes the impingement on other people's freedom/ safety is too great dor you to just do whatever the hell you like, hence we have laws. The case for banning dogs like this when there is no compelling reason anybody needs to have one and the downsides of them doing so are so horrific isn't even finely balanced, it's a no brainer, to anybody with a brain, which I suppose highlights that fundamental explanation of why a specific subset of people still argue the contrary.

MrsMiddleMother · 14/02/2024 23:24

I think the government should go one step further and just ban dogs completely. No more dogs jumping up at strangers, no more attacks, no more dog shit all over the pavements, no more dogs in cafes. Just get rid of the lot.

FreeZor · 14/02/2024 23:19

They’re not monsters. Just like Rottweilers, German shepherds and staffies before them, they are the status symbol dog of shitheads, people who’ve got no clue how to care for a dog let alone be responsible for one. The difference with these is they are so big, muscular and strong, and their jaws are so large and strong, that the damage they can do is much more serious.

And nobody needs to own a fighting dog that can do that much damage when pretty much every dog owner admits that you can never trust a dog not to turn, even one that hasn't been bred to be more likely to do this, and lethal if it does.

FreeZor · 14/02/2024 23:17

If my children ran up to, in front of, around, strangers, sniffing at them, I'm quite sure a chuckle and an "it's ok, she won't bite, she just wants to play", would not be acceptable.

Don't forget jumping on them, wiping their muddy shoes on these strangers' clothes, spitting on them. Just being "friendly", of course! How adorable. 🤨 Growling at them if they object to this, or randomly running at them from 50 metres away and trying to bite them. Defecating in public areas.

Pretty sure nobody would be too pleased. It's completely bizarre that anybody thinks other people should have to tolerate any of that so that they can have a pet, before you even get into the dangerous ones.

FreeZor · 14/02/2024 23:10

I will be gobsmacked if he ever hurts anyone.

I am sure that will be a great comfort to his disfigured/ disabled/ dead victim.

oakleaffy · 14/02/2024 22:21

YuleDragon · 14/02/2024 20:09

I didn't say it was.

However, owners are responsible for being well aware of the genetic predisposition of the dogs that they own, and making sure they are owned and cared for in the appropriate manner.

Bull dog breeds are not house pets, and they shouldn't be, any more than Simon from flat 4 should be owning a Husky, or Wendy from apartment 7 on the 7th floor should have an Anatolian Shepherd.

People need to be taught responsible, breed appropriate dog ownership.

Go FFS at yourself.

It's absurd that XL Bull type apologists keep denying genetic input.

Working line Spaniels are different to 'Show' line.

Guide dogs breed for biddability and intelligence.

Police for boldness and intelligence

You can't 'Love' the fighting trait out of a Pitbull cross.

It's ridiculous that people are having to live in fear that their nice pet dog could be mauled or worse by one of these brutes - or that a small child, or old and vulnerable person might be randomly targeted by

''A big soft lump that wouldn't hurt a fly''
That Essex bloke whose MIL was slaughtered by his ''soft lumps'' is back-pedalling like mad saying he ''never knew they were vicious''..He really must be dense if we are going to believe that.

He's probably just trying to cut short any potential jail term.

Ol' dead -eye- Dick in the pic below is as far from a ''soft lump'' as you can imagine. An older person or toddler {and certainly no pet dog} would stand a chance.

XL Bullies to be destroyed now!
Babycatsarenice · 14/02/2024 22:09

FabFebHalfTerm · 14/02/2024 20:50

@Fionaville

but how do you think posting on here with 'must be DESTROYED' is going to help??

and she SAID they're never muzzled, so report the owners for that, there's a legal channel she can easily take, so why just post nasty threads on here?!

I hope this thread will give voice to all of us who are fed up with this ban that doesn't work as we are all still seeing these dogs out and about. Maybe Rishi will see it?!
Sure I can report an unmuzzled dog to the police- do you think the police have time to actually police this? They have said they don't have the resources.
Boo hoo nasty thread...what about the poor people who have been injured and killed?
As it stands this is going go go on 10 years unless further action is taken.
Of course it's not the dogs' fault but they should never have been bred in the first place.

OP posts:
tiredoftheBS · 14/02/2024 21:48

itsalwaysthesame · 14/02/2024 21:22

I've seen a few XL bullies and they have all had muzzles on, it actually encouraged me to stroke one! I probably wouldn't have if it wasn't wearing a muzzle, they are quite intimidating, I'm very much a dog lover but am wary of large powerful dogs.

I don't believe they should all be killed, I'd question why a person would want such a large powerful dog with a reputation.
What's wrong with a good ol mongrel

That’s just it—they are mostly mongrels, mixed breeds. I have a dog that I rescued as a baby. She was labeled as an unknown mixed breed, ‘we don’t know what she is.’ I’ve since had her DNA done, and she’s 90% Scott type American Bulldog. But Rishi doesn’t care—she’s to be categorised as an XL Bully because from floor to withers, she’s 29cm and has a head that is ‘large and broad.’ Those two defining features mean that our dog, which on her paperwork from the rehoming centre states she’s a dog of an unknown mixed breed, is now a banned dog in the UK.

itsalwaysthesame · 14/02/2024 21:22

I've seen a few XL bullies and they have all had muzzles on, it actually encouraged me to stroke one! I probably wouldn't have if it wasn't wearing a muzzle, they are quite intimidating, I'm very much a dog lover but am wary of large powerful dogs.

I don't believe they should all be killed, I'd question why a person would want such a large powerful dog with a reputation.
What's wrong with a good ol mongrel

Pickingmyselfup · 14/02/2024 21:17

I'm very much on the fence about this because I am very much that it's both owner and breed.

There is no denying that breeds have traits, I'm a cat owner and if I get any more pedigrees I will be looking at the more energetic outgoing breeds (Siamese, Bengals) as opposed to the quieter breeds (Birmans, Persians) because whilst there is never a guarantee there is a high chance your cat will conform to breed standard if you get them from a responsible breeder.

I'm also very much of the belief that ownership has a lot to do with it too. If you neglect a cat then there is a chance it could end up being aggressive even with proper breeding.

This is also where it goes hand in hand.

Let's say I'm looking for a first generation Bengal cat, only one step down from being half wild the chances are I will end up with a cat with wild tendencies who will need a lot more care than a Persian. I do my research, go to a proper breeder and take care of my cat correctly then there is a high chance I won't get my face ripped to shreds but with their breeding it's more likely than something like a Persian.

If I don't care where I get my cat from, choose any old breeder, don't look after it properly then the chances of it ripping my face to shreds is higher than the above scenario and again higher than a neglected Persian.

The problem with these dogs is that all of the above applies but the breeding is problematic. A bull breed was used to bait and fight bulls/bears/each other and so the breeders would breed the most successful ones and so the temperament would be passed on. A Staffordshire Bull Terrier also has terrier bred in, a fiesty temperament bred to dispatch rodents in a swift manner. So you have 2 breeds designed to kill mixed together so not ideal. I've no idea what am

The size again causes more problems, a dog the size of a pomeranian couldn't kill someone no matter how hard they tried but the size of these, their tenacity and willingness to fight is a terrible combination.

If Owner A chooses a reputable breeder, one who breeds for a friendly temperament and health then the risk of them attacking is low. If they do everything right, train them, don't let them be alone around kids/new people then the risk is lower still. Never zero because there is always that potential in any dog.

If Owner B chooses a dog which is bred by someone who doesn't care what the temperament of their dog is or they choose one for their aggression then the situation becomes high risk. If the owner never walks them, socialises them, trains them and neglects them then the risk is suddenly a lot higher.

Now I don't know enough about the breed/breeders to say if there are responsible ones but the stories coming out of the media suggest they are not because they are being sold to people with unsuitable circumstances and then a lot of the time passed from pillar to post. A responsible breeder should be willing to take their puppies back, help with rehoming, not sell to people they suspect will breed from them willy nilly. These dogs seem unsocialised, overcrowded, untrained and not exercised so it's a lethal combination and people are paying with their lives.

I agree with the ban and I don't agree with it. I agree with the premise of trying to reduce the risks and helping cull the irresponsible owners to an extent. There will always be those who don't listen just like there will always be murderers and thieves. I don't agree with it because ultimately it seems people are responsible for the outcome. Ban these, reduce deaths, great. Some other dodgy breeder will start to put the wheels in motion to create something else to sell to people who mostly want the dog to give off the "don't mess with me vibe" and so eventually the cycle begins again.

The only answer is to have a total crackdown on dog ownership. Dogs of all breeds bred properly and sold to homes of high standards with official paperwork. Vets to go through the paperwork of any new dog brought in and report and have the power to seize any that don't seem legit. Those found to not be need to be PTS, even a pomeranian and owners given a fine.

Obviously there are still massive flaws with this, one is money and time, there aren't the resources. Two it won't stop people from going underground, it would stop people seeking treatment if their "underground dog" was unwell and ultimately an innocent animals suffers. There are probably a ton more flaws as well, I'm thinking rescues, in breeding but I can't really articulate what I'm thinking.

So really since the "answer" won't happen I don't know what the solution is when we don't have the resouces. I do think the government despite my dislike of them are trying to mitigate damage and doing the right thing, it won't stop attacks but maybe it might reduce the numbers because they are harder to get hold of/harder to have unregistered and thus reduce the attacks.

I do question why anyone wants a breed known to have killed several people and also question the suitability of some breeds to owners. I wouldn't choose a large guardian breed in my small suburban home, I would go for a small companion breed but if I lived on a property with a large amount of acres and livestock to guard I would be more likely to consider a guarding breed.

tiredoftheBS · 14/02/2024 21:16

Keychangeoff · 14/02/2024 20:42

You lose the right to use the word responsible to describe yourself if you own an XL bully. I can think of a few other words you could use but we won't go there.

thanks for your input which I couldn't care less for but, i didn't go out and purchase an XL Bully which if you'd care to do your own research on, isn't in fact a breed, it's a 'type'. I rescued a dog that unfortunately falls into the category because despite her DNA proving she's 90% American Bulldog, she's categorised by this ridiculous ban. We didn't know what she was the day we rescued her, we didn't care. We chose her because she's an absolute darling. Shame it's her having to wear the muzzle....