Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

XL Bullies to be destroyed now!

494 replies

Babycatsarenice · 14/02/2024 11:12

Sick of these monsters still being on our streets (I never see them muzzled as their irresponsible owners don't comply) and worse still knowing that they are still in homes with children.

AIBU that they should be put to sleep NOW

OP posts:
Thread gallery
16
ejsmith99 · 16/02/2024 14:17

I'm glad of the ban because with the breed increasing exponentially, more so than any other because so many got them to breed and make them easy money, the thought of where we would be in 5 years time was horrifying.

Now we are left with the same old problem of what we do about anti social behaviour and how we stop the next breed being adopted/created by the lowlife. It is a problem the world over and nobody has found a solution. What seems like smart legislation soon falls apart because it is never enforced.

The Calgary model is mentioned all the time. They don't even use it themselves nowadays because it was resource heavy and Hurricane Katrina bought in an influx of pitbulls.

Any breeding legislation favours large businesses. Especially with a young family you want a puppy brought up in a home, surrounded by all the normal sounds of the home, handled by people of both sexes and all ages. Not in purpose built kennels out the back.

I do understand the stress put on staff having to put healthy dogs down. But vets also have a duty to public health. Unsurprisingly, from those I've spoken to, the vets who've had to try and put cats and dogs back together again after being mauled by an xl lean towards the ban, imperfect as it is.

And please stop insulting the public with the chihuahua/small dog argument. Whatever their temperament xls cannot be stopped by strong adult humans. They certainly can't be pulled off whatever they are attacking in most circumstances. Clearly by the laws of physics they are potentially more dangerous than the majority of breeds popular in the UK.

hookiewookie29 · 16/02/2024 13:11

Shivermetimbers13 · 14/02/2024 11:35

I haven't seen one, but I'm horrified by the stories I'm reading about their attacks.

Yes they should all be put down. Telling owners to muzzle them doesn't work - the type of person who keeps a dog like that isn't the type of person who follows the rules.

Not true. I know 3 people who have XL Bullies and they have followed the rules to the letter. Don't tar them all with the same brush.

FreeZor · 16/02/2024 12:33

I see. Making "observations" about someone (whom you have never observed) which involve personal insults about their character is quite obviously far ruder than commenting on someone's opinions indicating they have skewed views of reality. That is why personal insults are against the Talk Guidelines whereas telling someone to "get a grip" is not. The irony of you insulting people then telling them you believe they are rude seems entirely lost on you. But, whatever. 🥱

Fannyfiggs · 16/02/2024 11:48

FreeZor · 16/02/2024 03:18

@Fannyfiggs you cannot quote a quite on the app. I did quote you, in bold, and self-evidently you were perfectly able to find the post and respond in person.

As for your personal insults followed by accusations of others being rude, I shall leave you to your cognitive dissonance.

I did say you sounded like... not that you were. I don't think that's rude, it's an observation.

Telling someone to 'get a grip' because you don't agree with them is rude.

Just my opinion though, do what you want with it.

FreeZor · 16/02/2024 03:18

@Fannyfiggs you cannot quote a quite on the app. I did quote you, in bold, and self-evidently you were perfectly able to find the post and respond in person.

As for your personal insults followed by accusations of others being rude, I shall leave you to your cognitive dissonance.

Infinity234 · 15/02/2024 20:53

I’m vegetarian and dislike any sort of cruelty to animals….but children/innocent people are far more important in this case. It’s terrifying and everyone who thinks their XL could never turn is either incredibly naive or just stupid.

oakleaffy · 15/02/2024 20:09

Fannyfiggs · 15/02/2024 20:02

Ah no, I was right. You have no empathy whatsoever.

The point of the post was that she has a bond with her cat that has kept her alive but I see you skipped right over that bit just to make your point.

That's really sad.

The point being that a pet domestic cat will not maul someone to death.

A mauler dog can and will kill people, cats, and smaller dogs.

No one NEEDS a mauler dog type, bred to fight , there are plenty of perfectly nice dogs around that don't destroy other people's {or animal's } lives.

That was the point.

Fannyfiggs · 15/02/2024 20:02

FreeZor · 15/02/2024 04:00

I would be dead now if it weren't for my cat. I had a very difficult childhood, no family and was in a DV relationship. I'd never experienced pure, uncomplicated and unconditional love until I met my lovely boy. My life was turned around because of him. It's a shame some people can't accept the bond some people have with their animals and have to be so unpleasant about it.

Pretty sure nobody objected to you having a cat. Cats don't generally maul and kill random strangers. There are plenty of pets available that people can choose the keep that don't negatively impact other people's lives.

Ah no, I was right. You have no empathy whatsoever.

The point of the post was that she has a bond with her cat that has kept her alive but I see you skipped right over that bit just to make your point.

That's really sad.

Fannyfiggs · 15/02/2024 19:57

FreeZor · 14/02/2024 23:28

You don't know someone's situation as to why they may treat their animals like their kids so leave us to it like we leave you to your children.

Jesus Christ. Animals are not comparable to children. Whatever your "situation" this is just absurd. Get a grip.

Why didn't you quote me so I could reply personally? Did you just want a wee rant in peace?

You are entitled to your opinion and as I said, leave us to our animals and we'll leave you with your children or whatever brings you joy.

However, there is no need to be rude and what you said makes you sound like you lack empathy and are incapable of understanding your fellow human.

I hope I'm wrong because going through life like that must be hard.

HappiestSleeping · 15/02/2024 19:00

Winter2020 · 15/02/2024 02:37

Quote re dog attacks: "there are things we can do to minimise the chances of it happening to us."

Yes so in the recent case of a child being attacked in the flats we can avoid and make our children avoid moving around near our own homes.

In the case of a child attacked by a dog on a play date - we can avoid our children going to homes with these dogs.

In the case of the dog going wild and attacking adults randomly near a petrol station - we can avoid getting out of our cars and moving around whenever possible.

In the case of the dogs that have got into their neighbours gardens and killed or savaged them - we can avoid using our own gardens - particularly if we know our neighbours or people nearby have these dogs.

In the case of the dog walker killed - businesses e.g. dog walkers/groomers/kennels can refuse to take these dogs.

In the case of owners being attacked and killed in the home or their children we can avoid owning these dogs.

Why should people have to change their perfectly normal behaviour moving around their homes and communities in order to avoid dangerous dogs? Get rid of them and allow people to move around feeling safe without having to "do things" to avoid a dog attack happening to them.

Well, I would say this:
the recent case of a child being attacked in the flats we can avoid and make our children avoid moving around near our own homes.

  • don't go out with someone who owns a dangerous breed.

In the case of a child attacked by a dog on a play date - we can avoid our children going to homes with these dogs.

  • yes, exactly - don't send your child somewhere with a dangerous dog

In the case of the dogs that have got into their neighbours gardens and killed or savaged them - we can avoid using our own gardens - particularly if we know our neighbours or people nearby have these dogs.

  • if you know your neighbour has a dangerous dog, I would probably be tempted to make sure the fence was secure.

In the case of owners being attacked and killed in the home or their children we can avoid owning these dogs.

  • yes, exactly right. You can't complain about the dogs attacking people and also defend their right to own this type of dog.

Of course, there are completely unavoidable situations, such as the dog walker, and the petrol station, however, you know you are being extreme.

What I mean is for the people who say "there's always an un-muzzled XL Bully in the place I go to do xxx" - go somewhere else. I know you shouldn't have to, but there are a lot of things you shouldn't have to do in this life.

Personally, I haven't had to change my habits one bit as dog attacks such as these are infinitesimally unlikely.

Rather than bleating on about it on this and other forums, we should be lobbying our MPs to pass legislation to control the breeders. That would be a much more sensible step forward.

SomeCatFromJapan · 15/02/2024 17:44

The euthanisia of individuals belonging to this breed-that-apparently-isn't-a-breed is far, far less tragic than the humans killed in dog attacks, a large percentage which are now being carried out by this - what should I call it if it isn't a breed? Type?

It's also far more tragic for people to have their pet dogs mauled to death on a walk than for any dog to be humanely put down.

Predictabilitypreferred · 15/02/2024 17:34

@VeryHungrySeaCucumber

veterinary professionals don't generally enter the profession to put healthy animals to sleep

One could argue that the breed is inherently psychologically unwell and that there is no ethical issue here.

One could, if they were a breed which they are not.

Have you any statistics on what veterinarians actually think about the ethics of putting dangerous dogs, potentially the (most) dangerous breeds, and/or dogs bred to have major spinal or breathing difficulties, for example, to sleep?

A dog with spinal or brachycephalic issues would not be considered healthy so a different argument. As far as healthy XL bullies go a vet times survey found three quarter of vets and nurses objected.

https://www.vettimes.co.uk/news/euthanasia-of-xl-bully-dogs-tragic-and-pointless-endeavour/

Euthanasia of XL bully dogs ‘tragic and pointless endeavour’

Concerns mount over moral injury impact on vet professionals of being asked to perform or assist in procedure – amid signs owners are already acting ahead of

https://www.vettimes.co.uk/news/euthanasia-of-xl-bully-dogs-tragic-and-pointless-endeavour

oakleaffy · 15/02/2024 17:06

Xoxoxoxoxoxox · 15/02/2024 16:57

My dad’s neighbour has a dog I believe is one and it got into his garden the other day.
My dad is 82 I am so worried about it.

These XL's are incredibly powerful and can and do crash through fencing/hedges like tanks to get to where they want to be.

They are often escaping and that is how the poor chap in Sheffield was killed , when two maulers got out of a window and into his elderly mother's garden.

Definitely check your father's boundaries.

Report if you feel your father could be in danger from a potentially dangerous dog.

These have an attraction to attacking vulnerable people, people who are zero threat to them.

Your Dad deserves to be safe in his home and garden.

Xoxoxoxoxoxox · 15/02/2024 16:57

My dad’s neighbour has a dog I believe is one and it got into his garden the other day.
My dad is 82 I am so worried about it.

VeryHungrySeaCucumber · 15/02/2024 16:54

veterinary professionals don't generally enter the profession to put healthy animals to sleep

One could argue that the breed is inherently psychologically unwell and that there is no ethical issue here.

Have you any statistics on what veterinarians actually think about the ethics of putting dangerous dogs, potentially the (most) dangerous breeds, and/or dogs bred to have major spinal or breathing difficulties, for example, to sleep?

oakleaffy · 15/02/2024 09:23

marshmallowburn · 15/02/2024 05:24

Australia banned the importation of pit bulls 15 years ago. AND heavily regulated other bully types. No Idea what's happened in the UK .It's like nobody was watching!
Edit for typos

Edited

There was a woman severely mauled by what looks to be a pitbull type in Australia recently..

They are now trying to say it’s a French Mastiff, but they have a very different look.

Probably the rescue centre that rehomed the Pit called it that. ( Happens so often when breed types are deliberately mislabelled)

Just because it’s reddish I’m surprised the rescue centre didn’t try labelling the violent brute as an Irish setter.

VeterinaryCareAssistant · 15/02/2024 05:56

whatsitcalledwhen · 14/02/2024 19:14

Does he live in a house with children do you know?

No idea and not my business.

marshmallowburn · 15/02/2024 05:24

Keychangeoff · 14/02/2024 20:09

Where do you live that you've never had the misfortune of meeting these awful creatures? Asking for a friend .....

Australia banned the importation of pit bulls 15 years ago. AND heavily regulated other bully types. No Idea what's happened in the UK .It's like nobody was watching!
Edit for typos

FreeZor · 15/02/2024 04:01

CactusMactus · 14/02/2024 14:10

Maybe put the owners and breeders down?

Might be the kindest thing to do. And good for the human gene pool.

FreeZor · 15/02/2024 04:00

I would be dead now if it weren't for my cat. I had a very difficult childhood, no family and was in a DV relationship. I'd never experienced pure, uncomplicated and unconditional love until I met my lovely boy. My life was turned around because of him. It's a shame some people can't accept the bond some people have with their animals and have to be so unpleasant about it.

Pretty sure nobody objected to you having a cat. Cats don't generally maul and kill random strangers. There are plenty of pets available that people can choose the keep that don't negatively impact other people's lives.

FreeZor · 15/02/2024 03:58

So much hysteria on this thread. Over 30,000 XL bullies have been registered and granted exemption certificates, which goes to show only the tiniest of minorities cause problems.

No. It "just goes to show" that:

a) there will be many more maulings and deaths because of shitty people who still keep these dogs as "pets"; and

b) there are a very large number of utterly stupid people in the UK who will never be decent members of society.

FreeZor · 15/02/2024 03:46

the legislation has been put in place. It's been 14 days, on what planet did you think it would all have been sorted in 14 days.

It would have been sorted out in not much longer than that if the legislation had been drafted properly, i.e. that all of these unnatural abominations should be put to sleep, no exemptions. Any of them reported should be PTS and owners who still have them after the ban prosecuted. All owners of any dog subject to strict licences and all non-compliance means dog confiscated, PTS and prosecution. Licences costing a lot so that they cover the actual cost, collectively, to society of people owning dogs.

FreeZor · 15/02/2024 03:41

For every annoying dog I've ever known I have known many, many, more annoying kids. Maybe the government should ban kids! Ridiculous, yes - but so is your suggestion.

I would cheerfully ban the majority of them from cafes (kids, not dogs).

Children are necessary for the continuation of the society that you purportedly belong to, whether you have a bizarre distaste for them or not. You will have no food, electricity, healthcare, or anything else if children are not produced, who then grow into adults so out of basic self-interest you should be happy people have children and go to all of that effort to raise them when clearly you think they shouldn't exist. 😵‍💫🙄 Dogs serve no such purpose. The rest of society gains nothing from you having a dog. They should not be subjected to any danger, cost, or even inconvenience as a result of your choice of pet. And aside from all of that, you are very messed up if you do not understand the difference between an animal and a human and why protecting kids from being mauled is more important than how attached you may be to your "fur babies" 🤢

FreeZor · 15/02/2024 03:34

Gloriosaford · 15/02/2024 00:28

For every annoying dog I've ever known I have known many, many, more annoying kids
ANOTHER person who sees dogs as directly analogous with children!
I notice no one says "dogs can be annoying but trainspotters/pidgeon fanciers are worse". The comparison is always with children, implying that they [in the mind of dog a enthusiast} belong in the same category, or are competing for the same slot in society.

And note how many incidences there have been of annoying children mauling random strangers to death in public...

Zero.

Winter2020 · 15/02/2024 02:47

Astrabees · 14/02/2024 14:11

So much hysteria on this thread. Over 30,000 XL bullies have been registered and granted exemption certificates, which goes to show only the tiniest of minorities cause problems. Some XL bullies are owned by the feckless but most of them have sensible responsible owners, as you can see from the updates on those that were fortunate enough to be rescued and rehomed by dog charities. I don’t like them and wouldn’t have one but I think we should bear in mind the figures for deaths caused by dogs around 10 a year in contrast with murder statistics of 500+ for humans killing other humans.

I don't think you would have the same thoughts on the acceptable level of fatal dog attacks if it was your child that had just been mauled or killed.

The acceptable level of fatal dog attacks is zero. The number of fatal dog attacks has been rising with 50% of them attributed to these Bully breeds that make up only 1% of dogs. That is why action has to be taken.

Swipe left for the next trending thread