Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

MIL wants to attend funeral but is supposed to be my childcare

889 replies

tinatsarina · 14/02/2024 08:32

So my MIL has the kids for me next Monday while I have 3 job interviews that afternoon. she's now told me she has to attend her sister in laws, brothers funeral. My parents both work so can't cover my childcare (half-term here). Told my partner to tell his mum she can't go but he said she's entitled to and people don't owe me anything. He's now potentially taking the day off even though she had already agreed to the childcare first AIBU to be annoyed that they are prioritising this funeral over the childcare?

OP posts:
AcrossthePond55 · 14/02/2024 23:47

puzzledout · 14/02/2024 23:40

@AcrossthePond55 I've read that, so as I said if OP is not happy why is she applying for a permanent position without adequate childcare?

Give it up, go bs k to being a SAHM, she only did it because MIL said whatever, so nothing ventured, nothing gained.

I think OP thought she did have reliable childcare, the MiL. As of right now, I kind of think it's still an unknown. MiL was apparently 'unreliable' in this one situation, the funeral. But that doesn't mean she would continue to be unreliable if she understood how important reliable childcare is. Or 'contrariwise', MiL may say "Nope, not signing up for that!".

It's an unknown as to why OP is returning to work. Maybe they're in need of the extra money. Maybe she just wants to get out of the house. If it's the former it's certainly worth talking to MiL, if it's the latter then maybe now is not the right time for OP to return to work.

puzzledout · 14/02/2024 23:40

@AcrossthePond55 I've read that, so as I said if OP is not happy why is she applying for a permanent position without adequate childcare?

Give it up, go bs k to being a SAHM, she only did it because MIL said whatever, so nothing ventured, nothing gained.

puzzledout · 14/02/2024 23:38

LadyBird1973 · 14/02/2024 23:33

I do actually think it would be better to have paid childcare. It is a big restriction on grandparents, if they aren't fully committed and want to do other things besides looking after dc. And I think for parents, to have free childcare that's unreliable, does more harm than good.
And free rarely means free anyway - parents usually end up paying for it in other ways. With a childminder or nursery, everyone knows where they stand, grandparents can enjoy just being grandparents and parents don't have to navigate the difficulties of childcare that's a favour.

But poor OP no other availability for nurseries (why would you need a nursery for school age children?) or after school clubs...... nothing in her area

So, no point in going to the interviews, so problem solved until OP can arrange adequate childcare that she's happy with and then she can get a job.

Or she job shares with her partner.

But all this because MIL wants to attend a funeral or take a weeks trip seems a little hasty....

AcrossthePond55 · 14/02/2024 23:38

puzzledout · 14/02/2024 23:29

@AcrossthePond55 the onus is on the parents to get reliable childcare, OP is unhappy yet applying for a permanent position without adequate childcare, why?

"I only went back as MIL suggested to us she would do childcare. I have looked at alternatives but nurseries and after schools are all full ATM if she hadn't agreed childcare I wouldn't have took my current position."

Presumably because MiL said she'd do it and it appears that right now there is no alternative. Again, this is why they need to have a meeting of the minds. And it may very well turn out that MiL would be so UNreliable that OP can't take the job.

Maybe MiL didn't understand how much childcare would tie her down. Maybe OP and her DH didn't understand what was in MiL's mind when she said she'd do it. But if I were OP I'd first want to make sure that MiL was unreliable before I shit canned any job.

LadyBird1973 · 14/02/2024 23:36

@DriftingDora you are missing that the grandmother offered. This was her idea!
Of course gps should have lives of their own. But you can't offer to be childcare, encourage the parents to rely on you, then not do what you agreed.
Fine not to do it, but don't promise and then let them down.

RadFs · 14/02/2024 23:34

Of course you’re being unreasonable. You seem entitled. It’s a funeral for goodness sake.

LadyBird1973 · 14/02/2024 23:33

I do actually think it would be better to have paid childcare. It is a big restriction on grandparents, if they aren't fully committed and want to do other things besides looking after dc. And I think for parents, to have free childcare that's unreliable, does more harm than good.
And free rarely means free anyway - parents usually end up paying for it in other ways. With a childminder or nursery, everyone knows where they stand, grandparents can enjoy just being grandparents and parents don't have to navigate the difficulties of childcare that's a favour.

DriftingDora · 14/02/2024 23:29

LadyBird1973 · 14/02/2024 23:18

"Are you on glue?" Yawn @DriftingDora

I don't think that everyone should think like me. But I do think people should honour their commitments, particularly if it was their idea in the first place.

Yeah, right, naughty MiL, daring to have a life of her own. Yawn. 😂

puzzledout · 14/02/2024 23:29

@AcrossthePond55 the onus is on the parents to get reliable childcare, OP is unhappy yet applying for a permanent position without adequate childcare, why?

AcrossthePond55 · 14/02/2024 23:23

CrazyHedgehogLover · 14/02/2024 19:41

@AcrossthePond55 seriously? A “serious sit down talk with her” umm no, they should find alternative childcare arrangements and be grateful for the help she offers!!

her partners work physically can’t refuse for him to have the day off if he’s actually said he hasn’t got anyone at home to look after the children… OP is actually being ridiculous.. not to mention rude and entitled.

The MiL has encouraged OP to return to work and said she wanted to do the childcare to help facilitate that. That being so, they need to be sure they're on the same page as far as being dependable. Yes, it's a privilege to have a relative do your childcare, but that doesn't mean they shouldn't be dependable. My MiL cared for DS2 as an infant and she was 100% committed to being there for us. If she hadn't been, we would have found paid care.

What I'm saying is that they need to be on the same page, and a serious discussion should find that out. By a 'serious discussion' I'm not saying to call her on the carpet or lecture her, just to get to the bottom of what MiL feels is 'providing childcare'. Does she understand that working parents need reliable childcare that they can depend on day in and day out, not one who cancels late in the day or is unwilling to forego another event or activity because they need to care for the child? If MiL doesn't want to commit to putting the childcare duty first, then yes, OP and her DH need to find alternative care.

DriftingDora · 14/02/2024 23:22

LadyBird1973 · 14/02/2024 23:13

'Warped' is a bit rude. Not all people think that funerals are a good thing or appropriate for anyone other than people who were close to the deceased.

It doesn't matter a tenpenny toss what other people think. A funeral is a private matter, and the family of the deceased are entitled to invite who they want. And that person can either accept or decline to attend - their choice. There's no 'criteria' or rulebook that has to be applied, and the opinion of others is completely immaterial.

Sparsely · 14/02/2024 23:22

It really helps the grieving to have a good turnout and feel the love. So it's not just for people who are really close. It's for anyone who cares. Which your MiL obviously does.

puzzledout · 14/02/2024 23:20

LadyBird1973 · 14/02/2024 23:18

"Are you on glue?" Yawn @DriftingDora

I don't think that everyone should think like me. But I do think people should honour their commitments, particularly if it was their idea in the first place.

And that commitment means that a person having the same cheek to die should be ignored GrinGrinGrin

I go to work, I commit to everyday 9-5, sometimes I can't do that because

Funerals
Sickness
Appointments medical I can't change

Etc etc..

It's an unpaid job not a vocation..

TiredMummma · 14/02/2024 23:19

Pay for it??

puzzledout · 14/02/2024 23:18

VaccineSticker · 14/02/2024 23:17

Funeral must have been arranged weeks ago but she’s only just decided to go.
She shouldn’t be dropping you like.

This had been covered numerous times, not all funerals are arranged weeks in advance.....

LadyBird1973 · 14/02/2024 23:18

"Are you on glue?" Yawn @DriftingDora

I don't think that everyone should think like me. But I do think people should honour their commitments, particularly if it was their idea in the first place.

VaccineSticker · 14/02/2024 23:17

Funeral must have been arranged weeks ago but she’s only just decided to go.
She shouldn’t be dropping you like.

BillieJ · 14/02/2024 23:16

LadyBird1973 · 14/02/2024 23:01

@Noglitterallowed the deceased isn't mil's relative - its sister in laws brother I think, so tenuous at best. Obviously if they were actual friends, I'd think differently but when people mean a lot to you, you tend to see them, I think.

Or maybe I just have an unusual view of funerals. I think they are for people who are actually grieving, not people who didn't care enough about you to see you for years. For example I didn't go to my uncle's funeral - I was sorry he died but honestly I would have felt it inappropriate to be there since we hadn't seen each other in years.

I'm not big on funerals either, but it's irrelevant whether I or anyone else would go. What's relevant is that OP's MIL does want to go, so she should. OP has children and needs to find childcare for them - it's how it is. If you have children, pets, a business or whatever and you need to be somewhere, you have to make arrangements. And have back ups.

I sympathise with the OP's situation, but the attitude is unreasonable.

Kitkat1523 · 14/02/2024 23:15

LadyBird1973 · 14/02/2024 23:01

@Noglitterallowed the deceased isn't mil's relative - its sister in laws brother I think, so tenuous at best. Obviously if they were actual friends, I'd think differently but when people mean a lot to you, you tend to see them, I think.

Or maybe I just have an unusual view of funerals. I think they are for people who are actually grieving, not people who didn't care enough about you to see you for years. For example I didn't go to my uncle's funeral - I was sorry he died but honestly I would have felt it inappropriate to be there since we hadn't seen each other in years.

Yes you have an unusual view of funerals…..a very weird one🙄

puzzledout · 14/02/2024 23:14

LadyBird1973 · 14/02/2024 23:13

'Warped' is a bit rude. Not all people think that funerals are a good thing or appropriate for anyone other than people who were close to the deceased.

Not all people......

Which clearly doesn't include the OPs MIL, it's warped that you think everyone should think like you!

puzzledout · 14/02/2024 23:13

Wanttobefree2 · 14/02/2024 23:08

It would depend on how well if she knew the deceased, it’s not immediate family. I’d be annoyed as it’s not as though you’ve asked her to babysit whilst you go to a girls lunch, it’s 3 interviews but it would depend on her relationship with the deceased.

We're all different, but I'd take the view that if someone I knew wanted to attend a funeral of someone they knew (however recently they'd seen them), that it was their prerogative and not for me to have the damn cheek to dictate if it was acceptable.

Others however think like you, that they've got the right to own their unpaid childminder and that they should acquiesce to your demands.

Strange old world isn't it!

LadyBird1973 · 14/02/2024 23:13

'Warped' is a bit rude. Not all people think that funerals are a good thing or appropriate for anyone other than people who were close to the deceased.

AcrossthePond55 · 14/02/2024 23:12

tinatsarina · 14/02/2024 19:33

I have been looking into alternatives as there's a few issues with her that I won't go into here, I do get on really well with MIL but recently theres been hiccups just as ive took on a new job on her insistence that she could do childcare. My current job means I can't just book days off so it's up to my partner but his job is also full on. I guess I'm frustrated that once again it's fallen through

But that's my point. The 'issues' need to be ironed out if she (and you) want her to do the childcare.

She wants you to work, that's fine. But if you and DH want to depend on her, then you and she need to come to an understanding of just what she means by 'do childcare'. Does she mean making that a priority over just about everything or does she mean 'unless there's something I want to do more'?

We used paid childcare with DS1 as both our mothers were still working. My low late MiL provided childcare (also at her insistence) for DS2 as an infant as she was retired by then. But she honoured her commitment and was there every day unless she was ill, and we bless her for it. You need to be sure you can depend on your MiL in the same way or find alternative care.

Noglitterallowed · 14/02/2024 23:10

LadyBird1973 · 14/02/2024 23:01

@Noglitterallowed the deceased isn't mil's relative - its sister in laws brother I think, so tenuous at best. Obviously if they were actual friends, I'd think differently but when people mean a lot to you, you tend to see them, I think.

Or maybe I just have an unusual view of funerals. I think they are for people who are actually grieving, not people who didn't care enough about you to see you for years. For example I didn't go to my uncle's funeral - I was sorry he died but honestly I would have felt it inappropriate to be there since we hadn't seen each other in years.

Yes I think you’re in the minority. Very strange view on it. My mother in law died recently for example and my husbands old school friends all made an effort to come to show respect - they hadn’t seen her for years but they wanted to support my husband and just show how sorry they are:
if my uncle died and I didn’t attend I’d imagine my family would all think what a heartless cow - even if I hadn’t seen him in a while

DriftingDora · 14/02/2024 23:10

LadyBird1973 · 14/02/2024 22:48

The OP is getting a kicking on this thread from people who sound far nastier than she does, frankly.

Since mil has offered to be the childcare, she isn't some put upon, exploited woman. The OP has made arrangements on the back of that offer and now mil thinks it's okay to drop out for the funeral of some random man she hadn't spoken to in years. I'd hazard a guess that her sister in law doesn't specifically need mil's support, and has other people at the funeral who could do this. OP otoh, only has one shot at these interviews - earning money and financially supporting her kids is a good thing.
Having made that commitment to the OP, I really do think mil should honour that commitment.

OP, in the long run, finding out now that mil cannot be relied upon, might be a good thing. In your shoes I'd sort out paid childcare so that you never have to rely on flaky relatives.

Are you on glue? How do you know (a) he's "some random man" and (b) that OP's MiL hasn't been specifically invited to the funeral? And as for other people sounding nastier than the OP does, that's an impossibility, as if her original post is genuine, she's obviously had an empathy bypass and is a strong contender for the Most Entitled Person of the Year award.

And for the benefit of the hard of thinking, the kids are the responsibility of OP and her partner.

Swipe left for the next trending thread