Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do you actually care about the environment?

441 replies

HamsterKebab · 13/02/2024 16:17

I think a lot of people say they care, but do you really? Have you adjusted your life with wildlife or the climate in mind? Or does convenience come first?

Im genuinely interested in how much the general public truly cares about biodiversity loss, climate change, pollution. Does it bother you or do you just think ‘someone else will deal with it’. I’m not judging, I genuinely want to know how people honestly feel rather than what they say out loud.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
herewegoroundthebastardbush · 14/02/2024 10:12

Jovacknockowitch · 14/02/2024 00:17

I care, so I vote for the Green Party at any and every opportunity where doing so won't let the fucking Tories in.
Due to our archaic electoral system, voting green may well let the fucking Tories in depending on the circumstances.

Yes, which is why I said 'unless'. I know how first past the post works.

Shade17 · 14/02/2024 10:04

Nope, couldn’t give a shit.

MrsBellsBoots · 14/02/2024 10:01

Floatlikeafeather2 · 14/02/2024 09:48

Not much these days. Most plastic trays are recyclable as are plastic fruit/veg bags, bread bags, orange nets, cheese packaging etc. Even a lot of the film used alongside plastic trays is now recyclable. It's a bugbear of mine that so many people make assumptions instead of reading the packaging. Things are constantly changing.

And equally, a lot of people don't read or understand the packaging, and try to recycle plastics that aren't recyclable. It's not straightforward.

weregonnagetrelagetedthistimeforsure · 14/02/2024 09:56

AskNotForWhomTheBellCurves · 14/02/2024 08:04

The people saying you don't care/it would be for the best if humans go extinct, do you celebrate every time a natural disaster like the flooding in Pakistan kills thousands of people then? Because presumably that's how human extinction through climate change would mostly look, just increasing frequency of events like that.

I never said I didn't care. I am a conservationist and I learnt a long, long, long time ago that the only problem on this planet is humans. Nothing else is as destructive and selfish as the human.

The quickest route to getting nature back to a natural state would be for humans to go virtually extinct. It is impossible for 7.8 billion humans to live on this planet without destroying the environment. A few million spread out and living in harmony with their surroundings could probably manage to be low impact.

Now you are bringing up human suffering. Millions, if not billions, of humans are suffering daily due to a variety of man-made situations (modern slavery, hunger, war, oppression, poverty, exploitation). I don't spend my time seeking out and celebrating human suffering. My emotional reaction to human suffering is not going to prevent, or increase, it happening. Only my actions will. I act to be as unselfish as I can without making my own life miserable, that as far as I'm prepared to go.

Floatlikeafeather2 · 14/02/2024 09:48

MrsBellsBoots · 14/02/2024 09:19

There is a lot of plastic that can't be recycled.

Not much these days. Most plastic trays are recyclable as are plastic fruit/veg bags, bread bags, orange nets, cheese packaging etc. Even a lot of the film used alongside plastic trays is now recyclable. It's a bugbear of mine that so many people make assumptions instead of reading the packaging. Things are constantly changing.

SideBob · 14/02/2024 09:47

Another friend reckons they will last one more year before they crack and book the Maldives.

😂😂

@Ouchmyarse

I hear you about not being fair, but it's about balance. I'm not one of those people who thinks you should forgo having children, meat and holidays forevermore - but you might choose a Eurostar over Australia.

If Andrew Tate wants to fly everywhere, own a tiger and burn plastic in his back garden to spite Greta, I won't be doing the same even though it's not fair.

MrsBellsBoots · 14/02/2024 09:46

I agree @Spendonsend

Spendonsend · 14/02/2024 09:41

The thing i find on these threads is the people who do care and the people who dont care often have the same carbon foot print anyway - or its not propotional to the level of care.. Like i dont think i care enough as i dont do anything thst would make me uncomfortable right now. But my friend feels she cares and does a lot, but they have more children, bigger house which costs more to heat and they fly for work and to see relatives. I think your carbon footprint relates more to your wealth than your caring, in very general terms.

Im not saying we all need to be perfect or that individuals cant make a difference but it seems a bigger more systematic issue.

Youcannotbeseriousreally · 14/02/2024 09:26

Honestly?no. I can’t really care when countries like China don’t and won’t.

I think there are many more important things to worry about so I focus on them

that said, I drive an electric car and I recycle…

Ouchmyarse · 14/02/2024 09:24

SideBob · 14/02/2024 09:17

Why did they post photos of themselves looking miserable? Or is it you would find it miserable?

I wouldn't want to pay to go on a damp UK holiday, but limiting flights or using other ways to travel is a fair middle ground.

If we all lived by 'I'm not doing it because other people don't' we'd all be terrible people. There's always someone who doesn't play by the rules. You still choose to do something if you're morally inclined that way.

They do all look miserable. They looked far happier in photos when they used to go to Disney or the Caribbean.

She and her husband are those sort of people though. They love posting about eco things and saying how life is harder now but LOOK AT HOW MUCH WE CARE.

Dh calls them the compo face family.

Another friend reckons they will last one more year before they crack and book the Maldives.

And no, I’d take a wet holiday in wales to be honest. I’ve not been able to afford any sort of holiday in a decade. But if I could, they would be ones I actually enjoyed, not ones to just prove the point of how selfless I am, because that’s just fucking madness.

It’s not about stomping feet and saying it’s not fair. it’s the bloody hypocrisy of it. It’s okay for the worthy, but not the little people? Nah. Sorry.

JennyBeanR · 14/02/2024 09:23

Jellykat · 13/02/2024 20:48

Slightly ridiculous to stop caring as much about the planet, because a bunch of people blocked a road once or interrupted a train journey. Hmm

But that's exactly why those activists are dangerous. Not to the corporations, but to the green agenda they claim to support. They turn people off. They are not winning hearts and minds by preventing an ambulance from getting to the hospital. Or making ordinary people late for work (or worse).
If they actually cared about the environment and not simply getting publicity, they would be pulling their stunts outside the offices of the FTSE 100 companies, or outside parliament.

MrsBellsBoots · 14/02/2024 09:19

Floatlikeafeather2 · 14/02/2024 08:43

Does your council not recycle plastic?

There is a lot of plastic that can't be recycled.

SideBob · 14/02/2024 09:17

Ouchmyarse · 14/02/2024 09:11

I know people who care so much that they never fly. I’ve got one friend who makes such a big deal out of it. Posting photos of damp holidays in Wales saying how they swapped their long haul holidays to save the planet. They all look bloody miserable.

If I had the money, I certainly wouldn’t be limiting my life experiences. Not when all you see are celebrities who lecture on the planet, jetting all round the world.

How come they get to do what they like while the rest of us have to stop flying to save the planet?

Why did they post photos of themselves looking miserable? Or is it you would find it miserable?

I wouldn't want to pay to go on a damp UK holiday, but limiting flights or using other ways to travel is a fair middle ground.

If we all lived by 'I'm not doing it because other people don't' we'd all be terrible people. There's always someone who doesn't play by the rules. You still choose to do something if you're morally inclined that way.

Ouchmyarse · 14/02/2024 09:11

I know people who care so much that they never fly. I’ve got one friend who makes such a big deal out of it. Posting photos of damp holidays in Wales saying how they swapped their long haul holidays to save the planet. They all look bloody miserable.

If I had the money, I certainly wouldn’t be limiting my life experiences. Not when all you see are celebrities who lecture on the planet, jetting all round the world.

How come they get to do what they like while the rest of us have to stop flying to save the planet?

Floatlikeafeather2 · 14/02/2024 08:43

Babyroobs · 13/02/2024 16:20

I do care but find it so hard. I try to cut down on plastic but so much supermarket stuff is in plastic trays. I try to recycle absolutely as much as possible, buy clothing second hand off ebay or charity shops, don't eat much red meat, in fact hardly any, haven't flown anywhere for years. I just feel a bit despondent about it as it feels like without everyone being on the same page it's not worth bothering. Every day I walk my dogs in a lovely local country park. There have been floods recently and the amount of absolute crap, plastic etc dumped in the river that has been washed up has horrified me. I just despair at how people can be such dirty thoughtless morons and care so little. It's just depressing to be honest.

Edited

Does your council not recycle plastic?

EmmaGrundyForPM · 14/02/2024 08:40

I do care but I'm also a hypocrite. We try to recycle as much as possible, we think about food miles when buying food, we installed an ASHP in our previous house (can't in our current house as it's too old).

But we still eat meat, we take one flight a year, we run two cars when we could probably manage with one.

I think part of the issue is that governments allow big corporations to get away with huge environmental damage, and we have people like King Charles lecturing us on climate change whilst owning multiple residences and taking helicopters and private jets.

I was a teenager in the 80s and was in dread of nuclear war. I was convinced we had no future. I think there's a part of me that thinks "yeah, had all this before, went through a stage of complete anxiety about nuclear war, all for nothing" and so this kind of feels the same.

MrsBellsBoots · 14/02/2024 08:28

AskNotForWhomTheBellCurves · 14/02/2024 08:04

The people saying you don't care/it would be for the best if humans go extinct, do you celebrate every time a natural disaster like the flooding in Pakistan kills thousands of people then? Because presumably that's how human extinction through climate change would mostly look, just increasing frequency of events like that.

No, it'll be shit for everyone, but I do still think it will happen. I don't think there is a lot that any of the posters on here can do about it though, however hard we try. And I do believe that the planet will heal once most/all of us have gone. I hope we don't take too many other soecies with us, but a lot have gone already due to human actions.

Most human inventions which were lauded at the time, are now seen to be very damaging in hindsight. Anyone else old enough to remember plastic being on Tomorrow's World? It was hailed as this great product that could be endlessly recycled. We can keep people living longer, but at great cost. We have all these forms of transport, and now most of us need to use it in order to keep our jobs. We are at a point, I believe, where this great big wheel is in motion and can't be stopped.

Things would fall to pieces very quickly if the things that poorly impact the environment were stopped. During lock down there were far fewer planes in the sky, which apparently (obviously) made the air cleaner very quickly, but it caused a lot of difficulties and so travel was actively pushed to help the economy.

Houses are being built miles from anywhere with little to no public transport so people have to drive. It goes on and on. The population are simply trying to live their lives around the changes that are happening whether or not they agree with them.

I think most people do care, but the small changes we are able to make just soothe our individual consciences and make us feel like we're doing something. But they're a drop in the ocean compared to what we're up against. So I care, but I'm not losing sleep over it.

AskNotForWhomTheBellCurves · 14/02/2024 08:04

The people saying you don't care/it would be for the best if humans go extinct, do you celebrate every time a natural disaster like the flooding in Pakistan kills thousands of people then? Because presumably that's how human extinction through climate change would mostly look, just increasing frequency of events like that.

IloveAslan · 14/02/2024 08:02

What really annoys me is the disposable age we now live in. When I was young things were made to last, and could be repaired - I get that things are now cheaper to buy, but they end up costing more due to having to constantly be replaced. Using something for a few years and then dumping it - or most of it - just doesn't make sense.

ZsaZsaTheCat · 14/02/2024 07:38

I care A LOT and do my best to reduce what I buy, reuse what I can and recycle as much as possible.
BUT it is tedious and time consuming! The easy option is not to bother.
When I’m faced with these dilemmas I think of my little grand daughter (2) and what world she will inherit-it helps me do my best.
My biggest gripe is supermarkets-SAINSBURYS- you know who you are- we don’t eat meat often but used to buy meat there. Now the meat counter is gone and the meat is shrink wrapped in the ghastly hard plastic you used to buy scissors in that need scissors to open 🤯 so now we buy meat from WAITROSE meat counter ( infrequently) or the butcher.
Last weekend I watched a Saturday chef individually wrap about 8 pieces of beetroot in foil to bake in the oven -MADNESS.
I hope no one reads this thread and thinks oh why bother then-there are thousands of us consciously making a difference-I believe en masse this does make our world a better place.

malificent7 · 14/02/2024 07:35

What people don't see is that this is making us suffer NOW. Floods, heatwaves, plastic on beaches, cost of living ( fossil fuel and grain = product of environment).
If we don't care that says we are not evolved or intelligent enough to survive.

malificent7 · 14/02/2024 07:32

I have a lot going on in my life atm and I care.
Perimenopausal, demanding, low paid nhs job, anxious teen.
I can only do so much though.
When I was a teen I cared more but oeople looked at me as though I had 3 heads as I didn't drive because of pollution.
Now I have to drive.

Ciri · 14/02/2024 06:19

The frustrating thing is that the government (whoever is in power) could do so much without spending anything. All they need to do is legislate and push the burden onto business.

neither the conservatives nor labour will do this though.

with relative ease they could make it compulsory for all new builds to be super insulated, triple glazed and have solar panels, rainwater catchment and sun shading and for estates to be wildlife friendly

with relative ease they could make it compulsory to super insulate your whole house and add other eco measures if you’re adding an extension.

with relative ease they could make large polluters pay additional taxes to be used directly to fund eco measures

with relative ease they could ban non recyclable food packaging and plastic shopping bags.

with relative ease they could turn off every other street lamp after 1am and require buildings to turn off lights used for advertising etc after 1am

with relative ease they could add an additional tax to imported fast fashion.

yes of course the cost of this would get passed on but then it stops people from buying as much shit. That’s a good thing and a win for the planet.

no political party has the balls though and they all suck up to either big business or the unions

IloveAslan · 14/02/2024 05:39

I do care, and like others try to do my bit, although I know I could do better. It is deheartening however as so much comes packaged in plastic, and because I can't always buy what I want/need in my small town I do buy online. I get a lot second hand, don't drive and have never flown, have never eaten a lot of meat, and try to recycle as much as possible, but sometimes it does seem futile. Also, doing the right thing is often also the expensive thing, and people do have to be mindful of costs. There seems to be so much waste in the western world and so many people who are only concerned about themselves and their pleasure.

I despair of those who genuinely don't care.

LuckyPeonies · 14/02/2024 04:50

Yes, i care about the environment very much. I don’t give a fig about human extinction, but i worry about all the other species who are suffering as a result of our unchecked destructiveness.

To that end, husband & I don’t eat meat, reject fast fashion and general mindless, needless consumerism, and last flight we took was 6 years ago, and short. Heat pump and keep heat down, live in smallish, well insulated house, rain water catchment & also conserve water whenever possible, buy local foods when possible, eat seasonal (no one needs flown-in grapes in summer or apples all year) recycle, no pesticides, native plants in the garden, habitat for birds and other species, etc. One person’s or family’s efforts multiplied many times can make a meaningful difference.

However, even with recycling initiatives, the mountains of plastic generated everywhere are staggering, and intermittent reports about new biodegradable plastics alternatives seem to fizzle out after initially looking promising. I am convinced companies could easily find a way to more sustainable packaging, but they don’t want to. We the consumers could apply pressure via our wallets, but too many people just do not care.

Swipe left for the next trending thread