Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do you actually care about the environment?

441 replies

HamsterKebab · 13/02/2024 16:17

I think a lot of people say they care, but do you really? Have you adjusted your life with wildlife or the climate in mind? Or does convenience come first?

Im genuinely interested in how much the general public truly cares about biodiversity loss, climate change, pollution. Does it bother you or do you just think ‘someone else will deal with it’. I’m not judging, I genuinely want to know how people honestly feel rather than what they say out loud.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
Waitingfirthephone · 15/02/2024 21:02

Ohdeardddddeardear · 15/02/2024 19:18

It’s not the Government that want you to change your lifestyle. It’s that if we carry on as we are we will be fucked. We already are but we can lessen the degree of fuckedness.

Climate change means loss of biodiversity. It means huge swathes of the planet will become uninhabitable leading to mass migration and more wars over resources. Food will be harder to grow. Water a more scarce resource. Morality is a higher order human need. People will do unspeakable things when driven to it.

We are already seeing people flooded out of their homes. Higher mortality, more illness, food scarcity. In the UK. Much worse on other places. The poorest countries that produce the least carbon are being hit first and worst but even if you don’t care about the brown skinned people in other countries (and yes climate change is a race issue) you should care about your own safety and survival and that of any children you care about.

Don’t make changes for the Government. Make them for yourself.

Totally agree, hollow laugh at those refusing to do anything because they won't be told 😒 oh the irony....

Papyrophile · 15/02/2024 21:01

Silly previous post, but the question boils down to: more people or fewer? Quality or quantity?

Papyrophile · 15/02/2024 20:59

If the choice was between Chartres cathedral and a camel, which would you choose?

Curlewwoohoo · 15/02/2024 20:54

I work in the environment sector, I'm a paid up member of the green party, friends of the earth and a nature reserve trustee. But tbh after years of it I have been struggling to stay motivated as I see no change at all. However I had this conversation with my uncle, who can see big change since he started out in similar work etc so. Hoping my mojo comes back! I think the best thing someone can do is help other people to make changes.

Papyrophile · 15/02/2024 20:53

If there's a global environmental meltdown, I would hope that every survivor was Leonardo da Vinci, but it's equally likely that most would be near-Neanderthals.

Ohdeardddddeardear · 15/02/2024 20:48

CrimsonC · 15/02/2024 19:23

Basically, the government aren't stopping the super rich so I can't be bothered and won't change.

But also if the government tries to intervene and help the environment, I'll be fumin'.

If the Government ignored some know and preventable major threat to your life would you be ‘fuming’?

Ohdeardddddeardear · 15/02/2024 20:47

LovelyTheresa · 15/02/2024 19:29

I am 'brown skinned' myself, so no racism there. Speaking of other countries, though, it isn't the British who should be taking this on board. It is the Chinese.

Ah. The what about China argument. China are heavily investing in green energy. A lot if their carbon output is manufacturing unnecessary crap that we then buy. It’s not ok to say ‘I’m not going to stop slapping my wife until Joe Bloggs’ down the road stops punching his’. You just stop doing it because that’s the right thing to do.

I wasn’t suggesting you are racist. I’m saying that the more developed countries continuing to spew unnecessary carbon into the atmosphere even though it puts those living in less developed areas at higher risk, is racist. Because it’s largely white people spewing carbon and people if colour being effected negatively. It’s a new age of colonialism. Why should I care that some South Pacific Islander is going to lose their life when I want to fly to Spain again? It’s just not ok to have that attitude and there are simply no arguments that suggest it is ok. It’s simply people don’t care enough.

Papyrophile · 15/02/2024 20:47

In my personal opinion, humans and their curiousity, creativity and complexity are what makes life worth living. I'd rather look at a fabulous building than a polar bear on an iceberg. Which is not the same as saying I don't value an undespoiled environment; of course I want a safe clean environment as much as the next person. However, I don't think there's an easy, equitable balance in this, and so my vote is absolutely on the side of humans, art and culture.

I have little sympathy with all those suggesting the planet will be better off without people so that nature can prevail. If that happens, it won't stop volcanoes erupting, and another Krakatoa could happen in parts of the world tomorrow. Planetary activity could kill almost all of us in a few months, and there's not much to be done to avert such catastrophic events. And then, who will record the glorious magical balance that the Earth has sustained for 50,000 years?

To preserve this delicate balance, I am happy to compromise. I won't take a longhaul flight more than once a decade, but as I live in a very rural area I am not giving up my (fuel-efficient) 16 year old diesel car which is needed for everyday convenience. I already consciously choose to buy on the basis of food miles and low-input farming, and obviously I recycle fairly conscientiously. Having replaced inefficient windows with modern double glazing and insulated the house to the max, I am reluctant to splurge big time on solar because we want to downsize so we shall leave that win to the people who move in.

We had one child.

Ohdeardddddeardear · 15/02/2024 20:40

Paulrn · 15/02/2024 19:25

Yes but when I compare my values with those who are willing to disrupt, damage block ambulances and preach rather than discuss I believe that given the sort of people who are aligned with these movements it is probably not as bad as they would have us believe. You may not like it but they do more damage than good.

XR and their protests don’t change the facts. Whether you agree with their tactics or not is irrelevant to what is starting to happen. XR are acting on the work of hundreds of scientists, over decades, across the world. There are other campaign groups acting on it differently. Your views should be based on facts. You may or may not choose to give a toss but basing your opinions on the actions of a small group of protestors rather than the massive body of scientific data and theory seems bonkers to me.

ICanHearOwls · 15/02/2024 20:05

I do care, and have actively made changes to my life. I do feel fairly hopeless about it though. I don't believe that any meaningful actions will be taken before it's too late.

Comedycook · 15/02/2024 19:45

Honestly, no.

IloveAslan · 15/02/2024 19:44

Jellykat · 15/02/2024 17:05

Presumably not an animal or nature lover then @Pheasantsmate and no nephews, nieces, friends with kids?
Not so much a personal enquiry, i just find it bewildering that because someone doesnt have kids, they dont give a fuck for anyone elses or any other living thing..

I also dont do a 'im not as bad as X', because i think the comparison thing is an excuse, we are responsible for what we do or dont, regardless of what Fred next door is up to!

I agree with this. I don't have kids, or nieces/nephews, but it doesn't mean I don't care. Some people are just selfish and will come up with any old excuse to justify it. I simply can't understand people who think the only people who matter are their own family.

I also agree that comparisons are a lame excuse. Surely we can all do the best we can, we don't need to look around and see what others are doing, frankly it's not our business and it's certainly not a reason to simply give up. It's really not difficult to make an effort, and saying you won't because of what rich people do/don't is a cop out.

Honestly, I despair of some people.

Jellykat · 15/02/2024 19:38

Thats your interpretation @Haydenn , since when has MN been a tip toe around with phrasing kinda place? 'Presumably not' is a ?? not a WTF!!
I personally find it aggressive and unkind that Pheasants 'doesnt give a fuck' about the future of other peoples kids or other living things..
This thread is discussing Climate change in AIBU, not an individuals personal emotional problems, there are other topic categories for that...

LovelyTheresa · 15/02/2024 19:29

Ohdeardddddeardear · 15/02/2024 19:18

It’s not the Government that want you to change your lifestyle. It’s that if we carry on as we are we will be fucked. We already are but we can lessen the degree of fuckedness.

Climate change means loss of biodiversity. It means huge swathes of the planet will become uninhabitable leading to mass migration and more wars over resources. Food will be harder to grow. Water a more scarce resource. Morality is a higher order human need. People will do unspeakable things when driven to it.

We are already seeing people flooded out of their homes. Higher mortality, more illness, food scarcity. In the UK. Much worse on other places. The poorest countries that produce the least carbon are being hit first and worst but even if you don’t care about the brown skinned people in other countries (and yes climate change is a race issue) you should care about your own safety and survival and that of any children you care about.

Don’t make changes for the Government. Make them for yourself.

I am 'brown skinned' myself, so no racism there. Speaking of other countries, though, it isn't the British who should be taking this on board. It is the Chinese.

Paulrn · 15/02/2024 19:25

Ohdeardddddeardear · 15/02/2024 19:09

Either you care or you don’t. Your opinions about current science should be based on current science and nothing else. Your choices should be based on YOUR values rather than the behaviour of other people, surely?

Yes but when I compare my values with those who are willing to disrupt, damage block ambulances and preach rather than discuss I believe that given the sort of people who are aligned with these movements it is probably not as bad as they would have us believe. You may not like it but they do more damage than good.

CrimsonC · 15/02/2024 19:23

Basically, the government aren't stopping the super rich so I can't be bothered and won't change.

But also if the government tries to intervene and help the environment, I'll be fumin'.

Ohdeardddddeardear · 15/02/2024 19:18

LovelyTheresa · 15/02/2024 17:31

Except that with rich people using private jets, we might as well do what we want as well. Why should ordinary people scrimp and save and cut out meat and go 'zero waste' or whatever else when none of that makes the slightest difference? I will continue to enjoy my steak and my foreign holidays, which I will get to by plane. The government has no right to try to intervene in ordinary people's enjoyment of life, they are squeezing us enough as it is.

It’s not the Government that want you to change your lifestyle. It’s that if we carry on as we are we will be fucked. We already are but we can lessen the degree of fuckedness.

Climate change means loss of biodiversity. It means huge swathes of the planet will become uninhabitable leading to mass migration and more wars over resources. Food will be harder to grow. Water a more scarce resource. Morality is a higher order human need. People will do unspeakable things when driven to it.

We are already seeing people flooded out of their homes. Higher mortality, more illness, food scarcity. In the UK. Much worse on other places. The poorest countries that produce the least carbon are being hit first and worst but even if you don’t care about the brown skinned people in other countries (and yes climate change is a race issue) you should care about your own safety and survival and that of any children you care about.

Don’t make changes for the Government. Make them for yourself.

Haydenn · 15/02/2024 19:12

@Jellykat “Presumably not an animal or nature lover then @Pheasantsmate and no nephews, nieces, friends with kids?
Not so much a personal enquiry, i just find it bewildering that because someone doesnt have kids, they dont give a fuck for anyone elses or any other living thing.”

Personally I think starting your post with the phrasing “presumably not…” quite snide and aggressive. It’s also quite patronising to just suggest that she might have forgotten about nieces or nephews. I also am not the only one who read it in that way, so perhaps the issue is with your wording?

Ohdeardddddeardear · 15/02/2024 19:09

Paulrn · 15/02/2024 19:02

I started to but people like Extinction Rebellion etc have made me think twice so basically no.

Either you care or you don’t. Your opinions about current science should be based on current science and nothing else. Your choices should be based on YOUR values rather than the behaviour of other people, surely?

Jellykat · 15/02/2024 19:06

Where was i snidey or unkind or bad mannered @Haydenn? You dont know anything about my life, maybe im in a similar position to Pheasants in some ways, and thats why i'm trying to understand her perspective!?

Paulrn · 15/02/2024 19:02

I started to but people like Extinction Rebellion etc have made me think twice so basically no.

Haydenn · 15/02/2024 18:56

Jellykat · 15/02/2024 18:45

We obviously think very differently @Pheasantsmate , i dont have a pet but still donate to Battersea dogs home. I dont own a Polar bear, but still care that they are in danger, i've never been to certain countries but still care that they're being invaded etc etc..

And if Bono hires a private jet to collect his hat, that makes him a knobend, doesnt mean i've got to be one too.. but hey ho, no point in arguing, because some random on the internet isnt gonna change your outlook!

It’s an interesting one, because logic might not sway someone’s opinion on this. Because you both have your own logical reasoning for reaching your own valid conclusions. But manner and kindness might sway an opinion.

If someone says that they are lonely/isolated and that a sense of disconnect means that they no longer care- then a snide or unkind remark about not caring about nieces and nephews might just reaffirm that that person’s world view is correct and further entrench opinions? It costs little to be kind.

This post was about rather than the virtue signalling that many do in day to day life, do we actually practice things behind closed doors. I applaud anyone who has been genuinely honest about what they do or do not do and why. Only by understanding why people don’t do things, whether it is to much effort, feels like it won’t make a difference, or that they don’t feel a sense of connection to the future can others find ways to create change.

Jellykat · 15/02/2024 18:45

We obviously think very differently @Pheasantsmate , i dont have a pet but still donate to Battersea dogs home. I dont own a Polar bear, but still care that they are in danger, i've never been to certain countries but still care that they're being invaded etc etc..

And if Bono hires a private jet to collect his hat, that makes him a knobend, doesnt mean i've got to be one too.. but hey ho, no point in arguing, because some random on the internet isnt gonna change your outlook!

Pheasantsmate · 15/02/2024 18:29

SideBob · 15/02/2024 17:15

From the sound of it, Pheasant may be chinless not by choice ("missed the chance") and that's where that feeling stems from. Could be wrong?

Childless and as you guessed not by choice. And as @Jellykat “kindly” questioned, my friends with kids drifted away towards others in the family/with kids boat. They would say we have little in common and our lives have taken different directions.

So I do what makes me happy, I’d actually guess my environmental footprint is smaller than most. But I have no legacy, the world won’t miss me when I’m gone, and I don’t feel any concern for it when I am no longer here. Why would I?

DdraigGoch · 15/02/2024 17:57

the80sweregreat · 13/02/2024 20:45

If the government ever did impose a 'one child policy , ' you can bet your life it wouldn't apply to Royalty or those with oodles of money as they could pay their way out of any fines with the argument that they can afford to be ' green ' and have more than one child etc because they are far more important than everyone else.

It would be pointless doing so anyway. Our fertility rate (number of offspring per adult woman) is already below replacement level.

Swipe left for the next trending thread