Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do you actually care about the environment?

441 replies

HamsterKebab · 13/02/2024 16:17

I think a lot of people say they care, but do you really? Have you adjusted your life with wildlife or the climate in mind? Or does convenience come first?

Im genuinely interested in how much the general public truly cares about biodiversity loss, climate change, pollution. Does it bother you or do you just think ‘someone else will deal with it’. I’m not judging, I genuinely want to know how people honestly feel rather than what they say out loud.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
Eviebeans · 16/02/2024 05:38

I think I probably used to care much more and try a lot harder than I do now. For example I used to avoid bottled water whereas now I use it all the time as I wouldn’t risk drinking tap water. It feels as though people think more about the climate etc when they are feeling better off.

abominablesnowman · 16/02/2024 05:27

The idea of an individual 'carbon footprint' was originally pushed by BP, a major fossil fuel company. It was a very successful tactic of shifting the blame of climate change onto the average person. It's incredibly naiive to think that all these little things you're doing make the slightest bit of a difference. Yes, even if we all do it.

The vast majority of carbon emissions are out of our control. The majority of flights are taken by frequent flyers, so every single person deciding to forgo that one flight abroad a year (or even less regular) makes no difference. Industry uses plastic on a massive scale, and it's not like we have much of a choice how the food we buy is packaged, or how our electricity is produced.
A significant amount of 'recyclable' waste is just... not recycled, no matter how carefully we put it in the correct bin, make sure it's clean and all that.

It's out of our hands. As others have said, the UK is doing much better than many countries, but even that is a drop in the ocean compared the likes of China, India, and the USA. Nothing we can do as individuals, even collectively, will actually help. And we saw with COVID that we can't rely on the average person making 'the right choices' anyway.

Theonlylonely · 16/02/2024 04:05

Spendonsend · 14/02/2024 09:41

The thing i find on these threads is the people who do care and the people who dont care often have the same carbon foot print anyway - or its not propotional to the level of care.. Like i dont think i care enough as i dont do anything thst would make me uncomfortable right now. But my friend feels she cares and does a lot, but they have more children, bigger house which costs more to heat and they fly for work and to see relatives. I think your carbon footprint relates more to your wealth than your caring, in very general terms.

Im not saying we all need to be perfect or that individuals cant make a difference but it seems a bigger more systematic issue.

Yes! This is what I mean

Eco friendly types tend to be the more privileged middle class people - their carbon footprints are probably no lower than those living on council estates

Lets be honest- it’s about wealth and class and inequality

CraftyTaupeOtter · 16/02/2024 03:50

Honestly, no. Partly because I feel helpless to do anything meaningful to the big picture, so it seems like a waste of energy to worry about something I can't change. I feel acceptance. I do care about wildlife though. I have my garden set up to help wildlife and am involved in animal welfare. I think all the small differences we can make add up. I consider myself kind to nature overall.

CraftyTaupeOtter · 16/02/2024 03:47

Halftermhalf · 16/02/2024 02:36

Interesting thread OP.

For those of you saying you’re not, or just not interested, if you have DC how to you reconcile that? Do you just accept that you’ll do nothing now and they’ll almost certainly live in a very different world.

I'm not expecting to have GC, so that helps.

Theonlylonely · 16/02/2024 03:46

Why do environmentalists never address the class issue? I think it’s strange that this is not acknowledged.

Why assume people need to change? Lots of people already live a climate friendly, low carbon lifestyle just by being low income.

Theonlylonely · 16/02/2024 03:38

weregonnagetrelagetedthistimeforsure · 15/02/2024 14:03

I'm pretty sure he's trying to crack the launching of giant rockets capable of carrying people, food and water to set up shop on the moon once the shit hits the fan on earth.
He may not be liked but he is mathematically and scientifically astute and he can tell this planet is doomed - for the next 100 years at least. Once most of the people have perished and the fires and floods have settled down they can repopulate with mini Musk's.
I reckon that's his plan anyway.

God why would he want to?! What’s the bloody point. Sounds miserable. I’d rather be dead.

asdunno · 16/02/2024 03:22

Yes I recycle, try to minimise waste. We are meat free 4 days a week. I try to walk where I can.

There's probably loads more I could do though

Theonlylonely · 16/02/2024 03:18

Halftermhalf · 16/02/2024 02:36

Interesting thread OP.

For those of you saying you’re not, or just not interested, if you have DC how to you reconcile that? Do you just accept that you’ll do nothing now and they’ll almost certainly live in a very different world.

I do loads because it’s my lifestyle (see above) but don’t really think about the environment

I think your premise is wrong- lots of people live a low carbon lifestyle regardless of the environment. I think it’s very privileged of you not to realise a lot of people don’t have a choice or are just old fashioned resourceful types who like to live a simple life!

Theonlylonely · 16/02/2024 03:15

Oh and I forgot we recycle everything religiously. Would never throw something in the black bin that could be turned into something else- that’s a waste of good resources

Theonlylonely · 16/02/2024 03:07

Honestly no - I don’t really care. I do believe in climate change, I’ve accepted it will probably wipe us out, but I don’t think there’s anything I can do about it, so I simply don’t think about it. Can’t be bothered with the headspace. Same goes for world war- what’s the point wasting my life worrying about it until it’s happening in front of me? Then I’ll be worrying!

Ironically I have an extremely low carbon footprint because I only walk and cycle. Cook everything from scratch - fresh foods. Have been on 1 foreign holiday in 6 years, stay very local every weekend, wfh, eat cheaper in season foods. I live in a small city in the U.K so I can live this life with ease.

I don’t live this way for environmental reasons, it doesn’t really come into it as a factor. I don’t think the way I live will make a jot of difference to the environment. I have never believed the individual has any power over climate change. I think poor people have the lowest carbon footprints, but they don’t shout about being green, so why do middle class folk go on about it?

I don’t buy takeout with plastic containers. We buy all second hand uniform for kids. I hardly ever buy new clothes- I’m wearing the same coat daily since 2014!

We have a large biodiverse garden which attracts lots of different types of bees, birds and other wildlife.

I’d struggle to be any more green if I tried!

coxesorangepippin · 16/02/2024 02:51

We:

WFH most of the time
Have two cars, one of which is an old car, and basically knackered.
Walk where possible
Kids get packed lunches in Tupperwares
Eat at home mostly
Recycle
Buy local where possible

ChiefEverythingOfficer · 16/02/2024 02:38

I care a lot.

My company is B-CORP certified.
Travel only when essential.
Recycle and reuse - actively participate in a Buy Nothing community group.
Buy local (food).
Low red meat diet.
Just spent a whole year without buying anything new (except food, toiletries and toilet paper).
If I did need to buy something new, I would shop consciously.
We do not use pesticides or commercial cleaning products.

Will it do much to help - probably not. I work on the premise that if we all take responsibility for ourselves then collectively we might have a chancem

Halftermhalf · 16/02/2024 02:36

Interesting thread OP.

For those of you saying you’re not, or just not interested, if you have DC how to you reconcile that? Do you just accept that you’ll do nothing now and they’ll almost certainly live in a very different world.

AzureBlue99 · 16/02/2024 02:18

I care about the effects on wildlife, and what Man is doing to certain specious by grabbing their land, or the ice caps melting. But it is such a vast subject - all countries and individuals need to do their bit. And that just isn't happening and won't happen. People are greedy and selfish and just want stuff and to do what they like - they want the planet saved but other people to do it for them. People lecture about climate change and then hop on private jets like buses. Expecting families to feel guilty about their one plane trip a year isn't on.

Man is a destructive force and we are destroying our own planet. I am middle aged, no kids. I do feel sorry for those in future years who will see more and more effects of past bad behaviour by us. But individually there isn't a great deal I can do about it. So I don't think about it much. There is no point. I don't think about war either - me worrying about it won't change anything. So I don't.

DdraigGoch · 16/02/2024 02:14

MercanDede · 15/02/2024 13:26

I think one Falcon launch by Space X does as much as 200 cars in a year? So a lot.

His annual emissions are nearly 2,000 tonnes, and he's one of the better ones in that world!

Activists should glue themselves to private jets and superyachts. They'll actually have support from the public as well as making a real difference to emissions. I'd even buy the glue.

DdraigGoch · 16/02/2024 02:00

QueenBean22 · 14/02/2024 20:38

i think the natural rise of global temperatures is being exploited by governments for compliance. I don’t see the friends of rich politicians and royals doing much to decrease their ‘carbon footprint’

"Compliance" for what?

Jellykat · 15/02/2024 22:33

Absolutely agree with the above, its akin to moaning about whichever Government is in power, but not bothering to vote..

Purplebunnie · 15/02/2024 22:21

ArchetypalBusyMum · 15/02/2024 21:06

True.
I despair at those who do nothing, especially those whose impact is greatest or have power and influence.
I know my small effort is nothing against what else is going on... But I still don't want to be part of the problem. I know which side I'm on, even as I watch others (particularly world and business leaders) screw us over.
At the end of the day it's my conscience I'm answerable to.

You nailed it with the "it's my conscience I'm answerable to" I have been thinking about how to put into words how I feel all day.

My efforts may have minimal effect but at least I know that I have played a part

TheUsualChaos · 15/02/2024 21:24

We try. Make a conscious effort to reduce plastic. We don't waste energy or water. Our garden is very wildlife friendly. Haven't been abroad for years as can't afford it tbh but if we did travel it would only be occasionally.
BUT. We need our cars for work and there is no public transport option available that would work. Distances are too far for walking/cycling. I do always walk everywhere nearby though on my days off.

We do genuinely care about the environment and honestly, global warming is deeply concerning, but really, what difference can these small changes make when you have so many people making multiple flights abroad a year and other countries churning out greenhouse gases and plastics in such terrifying quantities.

I'm also highly sceptical of recycling as it seems that so much gets shipped overseas only to be dumped somewhere else. Id rather just bin it here than for that to happen as at least most of our waste is well managed. It's just depressing tbh.

CrimsonC · 15/02/2024 21:16

If the Government ignored some know and preventable major threat to your life would you be ‘fuming’?

Sarcasm, clearly.

Papyrophile · 15/02/2024 21:13

Why is the planet intrinsically worth saving, if there's no life form with the intellectual capacity to record what makes it wonderful? That is why humanity matters, in the absence of another equally intelligent life-form from an alternate universe.

Sellingbedtime · 15/02/2024 21:08

I do care. I'm scared for my children's futures.
I do what I can at an individual level but it feels like your paddling upstream sometimes against governments, world leaders and corporations.

My dad's not so reassuring words are, humans will end up killing themselves off and then the planet will sort itself out... Great 👍

ArchetypalBusyMum · 15/02/2024 21:06

True.
I despair at those who do nothing, especially those whose impact is greatest or have power and influence.
I know my small effort is nothing against what else is going on... But I still don't want to be part of the problem. I know which side I'm on, even as I watch others (particularly world and business leaders) screw us over.
At the end of the day it's my conscience I'm answerable to.

Paulrn · 15/02/2024 21:03

Ohdeardddddeardear · 15/02/2024 20:40

XR and their protests don’t change the facts. Whether you agree with their tactics or not is irrelevant to what is starting to happen. XR are acting on the work of hundreds of scientists, over decades, across the world. There are other campaign groups acting on it differently. Your views should be based on facts. You may or may not choose to give a toss but basing your opinions on the actions of a small group of protestors rather than the massive body of scientific data and theory seems bonkers to me.

To be honest I don’t care that you think it’s bonkers. I am not convinced by the “science” I remember when I was young the environmentalists were trying to convince us that we were headed for an ice age. And when diesel cars were good for the environment etc etc it’s just nature.